When Kepler failed, why didn't we just build another one? Do we know about all the potentially dangerous asteroids? Could one just come out of nowhere? And in Q&A+, which planets are more difficult to visit (the answer will surprise you)?
00:00 Intro 00:22 [@paulcockerill4260] Why didn't NASA build another Kepler? 05:16 [@SeanMann-o6v] Are the near earth asteroids all known? 10:04 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video addresses viewer questions regarding space exploration and planetary defense. The host discusses why NASA prioritizes \"flagship\" telescopes over rebuilding older missions like Kepler, the current state of tracking dangerous near-Earth asteroids, and shares personal travel tips for visiting Iceland.
When Kepler failed, why didn't we just build another one?
Do we know all about potentially dangerous asteroids?
Could one just come out of nowhere?
And in Q&A Plus, which planets are more difficult to visit?
The answer may surprise you.
It's time for the question show, your questions, my answers.
As always, wherever you are across my channel, if a question pops in your brain,
just write it down.
I'll gather them up and I will answer them here.
All right, let's get to the questions.
Paul Cockerell.
Why don't they build another Kepler?
Sure, in the big scheme of space missions, it wouldn't be that expensive.
It wouldn't be that expensive.
Kepler was a flagship mission, so not the $300 million type mission that you get with,
say, something like the TESS mission, the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite.
The Kepler mission cost about $700 million US dollars at the time, and that was like,
say, 20 years ago.
So, you know, inflation adjusted, maybe it's a billion dollar mission.
So that's not small, and it's not, say, $10 billion for another James Webb or whatever
the Habitable Worlds Observatory is going to cost.
So you could justify building another Kepler right now, for sure.
Instead of building the Habitable Worlds Observatory in the 2040s, you dust off the
old plans for Kepler and you build another one, but this time you put in much better
reaction wheels and you minimize the chance that it's going to fail.
If I was running NASA, I might do that.
And the reason I think that's a good idea is because, come on, do we really think that
NASA is going to pull together over the 20 years that it's going to take to pull the
Habitable Worlds Observatory together, that we're going to see a mega flagship mission
that's going to launch in that time frame, with all of the technology, all the changes,
all the things that are happening?
I mean, maybe it would be amazing, like that would be the telescope that would
truly find an Earth-sized world orbiting around a Sun-like star and measure the atmosphere
of that planet.
That would be incredible.
But to just find that planet, I think you could do that on more of a shoestring budget.
And TESS isn't powerful enough.
TESS can't find it.
PLATO is a more powerful version of TESS.
It's going to be looking for transiting planets.
It could maybe do the trick.
So maybe PLATO gets us what we could have had with Kepler.
But if not, maybe we launch another Kepler.
But this is not what's happening.
And this is because space science is chronically underfunded, that the astronomers are asked
what they want.
And they say, well, what we want is we want the telescope that can find and analyze the
atmospheres of Earth-sized worlds orbiting around Sun-like stars in the habitable zone.
And, and then the year after that, you know, Congress goes back and is like, are you sure?
You know, if we took more money away from you, now what would you say?
And the astronomers are like, we want the spacecraft, we want the telescope that can
find us Earth-sized worlds.
They stick to their guns.
This is the thing they want.
This is the thing they want next.
And if you're going to take away their money, then they're just going to have to wait longer.
But that is, that is what gives them the next big science task.
And so you always have this balance, right?
We have been reporting nonstop on what's happened with James Webb.
It's a 6.5 meter telescope at the Earth-Sun L2 Lagrange point, cooled down to, you know,
a few dozens of degrees above absolute zero.
It is the most pristine space telescope ever made, designed to push our vision way beyond
anything that has ever existed before.
You know, when it comes to infrared astronomy, Hubble does not hold a candle to James Webb.
It is a order of magnitude leap forward in terms of astronomical capability.
And that is what is required to find new things, the new things at the beginning of the universe.
And so you always have this balance, like, do you do you just try to
fill in all the nooks and crannies with little CubeSats and small explorer missions that
get you incremental improvements into what you already know?
Or do you swing for the fences to get something that is very powerful,
that is a order of magnitude leap in your capabilities.
And generally, the astronomical community kind of does both.
They have the big flagship that they want, and then that clears the way.
So you're building the Hubble World Observatory.
So you then don't want to build the thing that will analyze atmospheres,
the thing that will find transiting planets and the thing that will examine, right,
you just stick to your guns.
I probably, but like, what do I know, right?
Just a journalist.
So this is the plan right now.
We'll see what happens.
It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above.
Jerry Kukler, Greg LPSF, Greg Tatum, Jay Money, Katie B, Local Verse, Scotty Mac, Christopher See,
Aaron Music, and Bill Prisbeck.
Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Sean Mann.
Fraser, are the near-Earth asteroids all known?
Could a big one just hit us without us knowing?
The near-Earth asteroids are not known.
Now there are a couple of classifications.
So astronomers know of essentially all the near-Earth objects that are bigger than a
kilometer across.
And when you think about the Chicxulub, the dinosaur killer, that was a 10 kilometer object.
And so astronomers have mapped out and know the locations of pretty much all of the ones
that are one kilometer across.
And those are global destructive, that if one of those asteroids hits the planet, it
doesn't matter where you live, you're going to have a very bad time.
But there are now, they're estimated, I think we know 35,000 near-Earth objects at this
point.
And so you get this distribution, right?
There's like 1,300 that are the one kilometer across, and then many, many more of them that
are smaller.
And the sort of the scary size, the one that astronomers are most worried about is at about
140 meters across.
If one of those hits the planet, it is a city killer.
It is going to rain down debris across a chunk of the globe.
And that we want to make sure that we prevent every one of those from hitting.
We think about the Chelyabinsk one that hit Russia, that was like 20-ish meters across.
So 30 meters across, 40 meters across, like those are probably airbursters.
And then when you get above 50, up to, you know, from that point on, you start getting
actual impact with the ground.
So we don't know where all of those are.
We know where a lot of them are, but we don't know where they all are.
And so one big mandate that was provided by the US government like 10 years ago was
let's find the rest, let's find all the scary ones.
And that's one of the reasons why the Vera Rubin Observatory was built, is that it is
an asteroid hunter, and specifically it is a near-Earth object hunter.
And so it is doing a comprehensive scan, and it should find us most of the dangerous near-Earth
objects at the end of its 10-year run.
Of course, it's going to go much longer than 10 years.
It's a ground-based observatory, you can just keep upgrading it, it'll just keep working,
just keep turning up asteroids.
But there's like a class of objects that it's going to be really tricky for us to
see, and those are ones that can be inside the orbit of the Earth.
So the ones that are outside the orbit of the Earth, you're looking off into space,
into the darkness.
But the ones that are closer to the Sun than we are, you have to be looking kind of towards
the Sun.
And that's really hard for ground-based telescopes to do.
So NASA is working on a space telescope called NEO Surveyor.
And this is going to be an infrared telescope, it'll fly in formation with the Earth, but
not with the Earth.
And so it will be able to view the sky from a different position than the astronomers
on Earth are able to see it.
And that will allow them to find the ones, the sneaky ones, that Earth can't see.
And so between the NEO Surveyor and the, you know, ground-based observatories like Vir
Rubin, within the next decade or so, pretty much every single dangerous asteroid will
have been found.
And then we will know, is there an asteroid that has the potential of hitting the Earth
in the next century?
Or are we totally in the clear?
Which will be quite good to know.
Now those are the big ones, right?
You could still get hit by a 50 meter asteroid, and that would be a very bad day.
But, you know, that's a Tunguska.
But the ones that will wipe out cities, the ones that will rain down debris across a thousand
kilometers, those ones we will be able to know whether or not they're a problem for
us.
Do you know you can watch the same video with no ads and get a bonus question over on Patreon
completely for free?
We call it Q&A Plus.
This week's bonus question, which planets are more difficult to visit?
The answer may surprise you.
And I'll put a link in the show notes.
All right.
Those are the questions that we had this episode.
Thank you, everyone who asked your questions into the YouTube comments, everybody who joined
me for the live show.
I'm going to chat about my recent time in Iceland.
But first, I'd like to thank our patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pedretti, Baldazar Galactic Invader, Brian Bowdoin,
Kerwin, Chuck Hawkins, Grander Bailick, David Guildsden, David Matts, Evan Dot Pro, James
Clark, Jeremy Madden, Jim Burke, Marcel Smith, Mike Purcell, NASA Ocean Guide, NorthSpace,
OneStepAnimals.org.
Plan your next trip with Whale of Travel.
Please follow my nephew at vbrick6994, Renkaidu, Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Team49, Telescopes
Canada, Vlad Tepelin, Wolfgang Klotz, Zelda, Baldazar, I knew this day would come, who
support us at the Master of the Universe level, and all our patrons.
All your support means the universe to us.
So Thomas Freyr asks, did you see the Aurora Borealis in Iceland?
So this time I did not.
But this is not the first time that I've been to Iceland.
This is the third time that I've been to Iceland.
And there's kind of like a secret hack, which is that if you fly on Iceland air, this is
not a sponsored message, but if you fly in Iceland air, then you can, as part of your
trip, you can book a multi-day layover in Reykjavik, essentially in Iceland, and at
no additional cost.
So say you're going to fly from, say, Vancouver to England, you can fly through Reykjavik
and then you can do up to a seven-day stayover in Reykjavik, you know, book a hotel, and
then continue on on your journey.
And it breaks up the journeys.
If you don't like really long flights, like eight-hour-plus flights to go to Europe, then
doing that stopover in Reykjavik is sort of a nice way to break it up.
And Reykjavik, like, Iceland is absolutely incredible.
If you've never been there, you owe it to yourself to go to Iceland at least once in
your life.
Obviously, there's a fox.
Holy moly.
If you've never been to Iceland, it's incredible.
You know, like, the city is fairly small.
It's kind of expensive.
But the trick is that they have these incredible tours.
Like, the whole island is just organized around these incredible tours.
And there's these four-hour tours where you do this thing called the Golden Circle, and
you see this incredible waterfall and all this other stuff.
And then they have these longer tours.
One will take you all the way down the south coast, and you can see just waterfall after
waterfall, glacier, volcano.
And you end up at this place called Diamond Beach, where chunks of ice sort of float up
on shore.
And it's an incredible place.
And so, you know, if you're looking for a way to add a little bit more adventure to
your trip, consider stopping at Iceland.
This time, I didn't get any northern lights.
We had clouds and rain, which is very common in Iceland, especially in September, October.
But the previous time I did, I was there in October two years ago, and we got northern
lights, and they were fantastic.
So if you've ever, like, wanted to see the northern lights, try this layover idea through
Iceland.
All right, we'll see you next time.