Insurance Tomorrow podcast From conflict and trade tensions to cyber attacks, climate change and economic uncertainty, today's risks are more connected than ever. For businesses and brokers, understanding how these threats interact is becoming increasingly important. In this episode of Insurance Tomorrow, host Georgie Frost is joined by Hanna Kam, Chief Risk Officer at Allianz UK, and David Abbott, Managing Partner of Insurance Services and Head of Global Risks at DWF. Together they discuss: How geopolitical instability is changing the global risk landscape The growing impact of supply chain disruption on businesses The links between war, political violence, cyber threats and AI driven risks How insurers are responding to increasingly complex and interconnected threats Why underinsurance remains a major challenge for businesses How brokers can help clients build resilience in an uncertain world 🔔Make sure to subscribe so you don’t miss future episodes.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This discussion examines how global instability and geopolitical shifts are transforming the insurance industry. It highlights the move from traditional risk prediction to strategic resilience, emphasizing the need for scenario testing, supply chain diversification, and the evolving role of insurance brokers as strategic partners in an era of \"grey zone\" warfare and AI-driven threats.
We are all chief geopolitical officers, like you know in reality. I think if you look at the last
five to ten years, you can't operate your own business, or whether it's a large organisation
or small SME business, without thinking about the environment you work in.
The extreme nature of wars and conflicts is changing in front of us and the fundamentals
of what a conflict looks like, bringing in AI and cyber, sort of grey actions,
those sorts of things around the edges is changing as well.
Uncertainty has become a defining feature of today's world, from conflict and trade tensions
to cyber attacks and climate change. Organisations are having to think differently about risk.
Today we're looking at how those geopolitical and economic shifts are reshaping insurance,
what this means in practice for businesses, and how brokers can help clients prepare
for whatever comes next. And as a note, we recorded this conversation in the summer of 2026.
Hello, I'm Georgie Frost. Welcome to Insurance Tomorrow, brought to you by Allianz.
Joining me today are Hannah Camp, Chief Risk Officer at Allianz UK, and David Abbott,
Managing Partner of Insurance Services and Head of Global Risks at DEWF,
a global legal and business services provider. Welcome to you both.
Thank you.
Hannah, I just mentioned there at the start some of the big challenges facing UK businesses today,
but what has the recent global instability that we've seen meant for the insurance industry?
The global kind of instability has meant that it's less about isolated kind of incidents.
It's actually reminding us all that one event could ripple through lots of different areas
and actually affect businesses' operating model. You look at lessons we've learned from the Ukraine,
Middle East conflict, disruption in the Red Sea, US tariffs, cyber events,
these all kind of remind us that actually you're not immune to any of these issues.
And I think one of the biggest changes the industry has to think about is that history
is no longer a really reliable guide to what's going to happen in the future.
I think we've seen kind of de-globalization or interventionist approaches where I think
countries or governments, bodies are not going to react in the same way.
So we can't really see how things are going to pan out from there.
So the industry and the insurance industry have had to take a different lens, a broader lens,
and actually think about, well, what can that mean for businesses rather than just
an isolated kind of event?
David, it feels looking to the future at the moment is particularly a hard thing to do.
There are so many uncertainties. We know that, for example, AI will play a role,
but what that role will be, who can predict?
But saying that, I'm going to ask you anyway, what geopolitical and economic factors do you
think will have the biggest impact on insurance over the next decade?
Well, insurance exists in a context, in a paradigm, and it responds to the context it's in.
So I guess just to also agree with what Hannah was saying, I mean, we are right now,
we are actually at an inflection point for insurance in the same way,
because it just reflects the world, that we are an inflection point for the world.
So, you know, the predictability of Western alliances, of Western trade,
of Western diplomacy and politics are going or have gone.
War being contained in certain areas that we thought it would be somewhere over there,
that's changed. It's on our doorstep.
The extreme nature of wars and conflicts is changing in front of us.
The fundamentals of what a conflict looks like, bringing in AI and cyber, sort of grey actions,
those sorts of things around the edges is changing as well.
Those things are going to carry on.
So over the next 10 years, at least, that is what we're seeing.
I can't predict 10 years, obviously, especially with things like AI.
But over the next 10 years, that fundamental change in the world order,
I don't think that's going to change for a while.
And that's what insurance is dealing with.
And unfortunately, it's set against the background of the issue of climate risk
and the speeding up of climate risk and resource nationalism, all the things that will lead to.
Talking about prediction, and I suppose climate risk as well,
something like climate change to a degree can be modelled.
But human driven risks, like you spoke about there, such as conflict,
are much harder, I guess, to predict.
So how do insurers account for that uncertainty in modelling and pricing?
So you're right, like there are certain areas that, you know,
modelling is a well accepted approach.
But the long term impact of modelling is to quite nascent kind of area.
So some of it's about using other techniques rather than just modelling.
I mean, you know, David mentioned AI.
Yes, AI can get you lots of data.
But you need to think about context.
You know, what about, what are the scenarios?
What are the range of outcomes?
You know, what are the data?
What are assumptions you can make?
And what's the expert judgment overlaid on there?
So AI might be able to bring you lots of data to help you do modelling.
But actually, interpretation is key and expertise is vital.
And earlier, you know, David mentioned,
there's so many different things going on.
How do you layer up different impact?
And I mentioned like, you know, one event could ripple all the way through.
And we've seen that through, like I said, the different events in recent years,
that how do you know, you know, something is actually going to change?
And actually, your energy prices have gone up, inflation have hit,
cost of living is going up.
There's more cyber attacks, you know, from there.
So how do you deal with almost like that next stage
or implication of these kind of areas?
And I think when you look at the modelling,
how can you, you know, navigate through all that?
I think the biggest mistake is to believe that uncertainty can be eliminated.
You know, the real challenge is about how do we understand that uncertainty
and how we can actually be readily, you know, be ready to respond to that.
David, you spoke about things coming onto our own doorstep
and something like wildfires is a really good example.
I mean, I've been in Toronto, wildfires there,
in the UK, across Europe, across the world, we've been seeing those.
How do events like those challenge traditional catastrophe modelling?
Things have become less predictable.
In the past, you could, with Nat Cat,
you could say, model what happens if a hurricane hits a Gulf town.
What happens if a wildfire takes out a Canadian mining town
or something to use sort of real examples.
Where the wildfires are spreading and changing,
they're going into urban areas.
Nobody necessarily thought about a wildfire
coming through Malibu and hitting the sea.
That immediately has a much wider economic impact.
It brings in all sorts of other interconnected losses.
And so we're back on the theme of everything is more interconnected.
Everything's more complex.
Once you start taking out economic centres, the ripple effect is huge.
And it's extremely hard to model that because it's hard.
There are so many different ways in which the loss could go.
The variability is just increasing.
It's magnified more than anything else.
And I think people mistake that the objective
isn't to predict future exactly the way it's going to be.
It's actually understanding it.
Insurers use a lot of different techniques like scenario testing.
If you think of a scenario,
you think of what's the range of outcomes,
you may not have the solutions that are readily available to a model,
but at least you've thought about what-ifs.
And I think that is becoming more complex
because as you said,
the interconnectivity of different risks and different events
is like how do you interpret
and how do you make sense of what's actually going on
rather than drop on a pin.
This is the exact answer we're looking for.
I want to focus on another, I suppose, risk,
supply chain disruption.
This year's Allianz risk barometer, Hannah,
shows that that is still a major concern for businesses.
So where are you seeing companies make real progress here
on building resilience?
Well, we've looked at UK kind of SME mid-market businesses.
What we've heard from some pulse results
is that seven in 10 businesses think
that they are very vulnerable to their supply chain.
And probably four in five businesses think that
if there was a disruption to an internet to them
for over 48 hours,
it would be a major disruption to the operating model.
So what it's actually telling us also
is that businesses are starting to stop thinking about,
it's like a matter of if or when, you know.
They're kind of saying,
no, actually this will be a permanent feature
of how we operate.
There will be a disruption to our business
through supply chains.
So how do you deal with that?
There's a few things you can do.
Firstly, identify your supply chain.
Look at your direct, indirect suppliers.
It's quite complex,
but if you think about, you know,
what am I dependent on?
What would happen if something is disrupted?
I think the second thing you could look at
is diversifying your supply chain
and having better visibility
of where you're actually vulnerable.
How do they interconnect?
What would really stop my business
be able to bounce back,
even if I had disruption?
And then you might think about
the diversifying supply chain,
looking at geography.
Lots of people, especially like David said,
with the global geopolitical disruptions
and conflict,
you have to start thinking in the tariffs,
not to mention that.
You have to think about
how you're going to diversify geographically.
So you might move to more domestic suppliers.
One element I've noticed is
some people start to think about
what about common ownership?
Sometimes it's not the geographical part of it.
What if your supply chain has a common ownership?
Does that have an impact?
David?
We've learned lessons steadily on supply chain,
as I think Hannah was alluding to.
I mean, if you go back to something like Fukushima,
that was probably the first event
which really made people sit up
and think about supply chain.
A lot of that, though,
was about diversifying your chain
and stockpiling,
which people must do.
So the just-in-time world,
I think, is probably quite a long way behind, right?
That was a little while ago.
But even so, what we're seeing now is
people must look at diversifying suppliers
and diversifying routes.
And that's the critical thing
that we've seen most recently.
If you looked at the supply routes
for oil around the world
and how they're changing,
avoiding the Straits of Hormuz, for example,
is remarkable.
But the other thing that's remarkable is the cost.
The increased cost of changing your supply route,
especially with regards to shipping,
because the difference between going
through the Suez Canal, for example,
or up the Red Sea
and going around the bottom of Africa is huge.
So really, it's looking at diversity of route,
diversity of supplier,
but also the loss, the cost,
having a realistic analysis of that.
I want to ask you,
because I suppose one concern
that continues to evolve
and everything's interconnected now, isn't it,
is the risk from war and political violence.
As conflicts increasingly combine
physical and digital threats,
how is that changing what clients need
and how insurers respond to those needs?
It creates a very difficult situation
because it makes it hard
to predict where your loss is going to come from
and whether you have bought the right cover
to fit that loss.
So in a traditional situation,
you might say you have a self-contained war
in this particular area
and you've bought cover
because you're doing business in that area
and you know that might happen
because it's happened before.
Now you're in a situation
where you may not have bought war cover
in a particular area
and now it's happened.
It may have been somewhere
you thought was very safe
and suddenly it's getting hit by drones.
You may have supply chain trouble
from something which isn't directly
where the war is happening
but is somewhere related
and contingent upon that war.
So for example,
a very good example of that
is the destruction of the Nord Stream Pipeline.
The destruction of the Nord Stream Pipeline.
There's just been a whole case
in the High Court about whether,
despite the fact that they couldn't prove
who that was,
does that count as a war for insurance losses
or doesn't it?
So it's just coming from so many different angles
and using different methods.
You might call it grey kind of war.
It's not cold war
but it's somewhere between cold and hot war
disrupting your business
which you don't expect
and that is also linked to
how are we describing war
when we're taking insurance policies out.
I would agree, David.
I think one of the things that as an insurer
we think about this
and we talk to our clients about
is it's not coming from
a necessary product lens as well
because it's more about resilience.
I think sometimes you go
how much of a loss is insurance policy for indemnity?
The value sometimes
especially from our broken community
is about that advice.
It's about that dialogue to have.
It's having that conversation to say
what are you willing to lose
or what are you having on there?
One of the examples I always use
is if you take cyber,
if you have a cyber event
sometimes an insurer will say
oh okay, here is a pot of money to help you solve.
That doesn't solve your problem right there.
Actually what you need is that expertise,
that advice to go
how do I navigate through the disruption?
So I think your point about
you've got lots of complexity of wars
turning out differently.
On my advice to our broken communities
is always say ask the client
don't think about what caused the disruption.
Think about what happens
when you've got the disruption
and how would you navigate through it?
Because when we do scenario testing
in an insurance company
we always think about
my advice to people is
it doesn't matter how it started
if the impact is a certain way
if we can find a solution
to help manage or mitigate
or minimise that impact
that's actually the solution
as opposed to being exact from there.
But there are certain things
that needs to be
like you said in the wordings
how it's being covered.
Well I think there are two parts to that
and I completely agree with what you say.
The first and by a long way
the biggest part is
have we predicted
where problems might come for the business
and have we got ways of mitigating that risk?
And one of those ways is insurance
but there are other ways of being resilient
and I think if we're going back to the broker
the broker is absolutely critical in helping
particularly an SME
that can't afford like
an army of analysts in-house
to look at all those scenarios
and where things might arise
and just how they deal with them
insurance being one of those aspects.
So I think that's absolutely critical
and to avoid gaps
is really a critical piece.
When it comes to
that does the policy do the job
I completely agree
that is a smaller percentage of what's going on.
What we have seen in the courts
is if the policy hasn't caught up
with what's going on
you can end up in a fight.
Well this isn't the first time
that Insurance Tomorrow
has examined the topic of geopolitics
and its impact on the industry.
We did so back in 2018.
Just from our perspective
you know three things
is appoint a geopolitical officer
it could be the chief exec himself or herself
or it could be someone
at the other CC level
but certainly towards the top
conducting a geopolitical stress test
something that's beyond
just horizon scanning
and then thirdly is around
implementing a geopolitical
forecasting monitoring solution
so that it's not just about
monitoring the news
but actually having plans in place
that are looking at what might happen
and then what's your one day plan
that you need to do
on the first day after an incident changes.
That was Andrew Mantilia
geopolitics lead at KPMG
speaking there on Insurance Tomorrow in 2018
on the importance of forecasting and planning.
David what did you make of those points?
I would agree that it's critical
in your business
to have somebody who is responsible
for the way in which geopolitics
might affect your business.
I think having a geopolitics officer
sounds like quite a grand project
probably only achievable by people
with very large balance sheets
or a geopolitics team
I mean that's a great thing to have
but where I agree with what he was saying
is that you have to have somebody
who's looking after this
who's going to ask the right questions about this
that's critical
and for most businesses
the critical thing is that
you're asking the right questions
so you're going to your broker and saying
have I got
do you think I am exposed here?
What are the exposures
we should expect in this business?
And I'm not talking about people
that kind of like shipping wheat out of Odessa
I mean that's obvious
that you need to be aware of your
global political threats
but all businesses
which have got these supply chain issues
that don't think they're involved in geopolitics
yes they ought to have somebody
who is running point on geopolitics.
I think we are all chief geopolitical officers
in reality
I think if you look at the last five to ten years
you can't operate your own business
or whether it's a large organisation
or small SME business
without thinking about the environment you work in
so in some ways I smile
when that little clip comes back
because nowadays we all have to be
we all have to have a view of
what environment are we operating
what are our interpretation
of what the geopolitical landscape looks like
yes I agree with David
there'll be some companies like Allianz
where we have people dedicated to that
but then it's also how we share that knowledge
to our clients to our customers
like through the podcast
and say this is what we're thinking about
here's something you can think about
on a smaller scale
so I think you know
from a mindset point of view
we've all had to switch
and maybe we didn't realise we have
but I think we have all had to change our mindset
Hannah as businesses
have to navigate increasingly this uncertainty
particularly economic uncertainty
also geopolitical
how do you think the broker of the future
might look different to the broker of today?
The broker of the future
I think there'll be more advisors
rather than an intermediary only
they are going to be interpreters
rather than information providers
and I think they are going to be
kind of like your resilience partner
as opposed to just a policy seller
I think with the information that is available
and David and I
you know we talked about the technology AI coming in
you can punch the data through an AI machine
it might help you connect the dots
but it won't be able to really connect
and tell you okay
what are the secondary and tertiary impact from there
they wouldn't be able to replace
the wealth of knowledge from a broker
who's had years of actually working with clients
alongside them to go
well here's what happened when it went wrong
here's how you recover from that
so that human element
especially with complex risk
does need that kind of interaction with the broker
and almost like the insights from it
I think the independent viewpoint from a broker
is really important for a business
because you can use them as a strategic sounding board
like are these my vulnerabilities
have I made the right assumptions
how interconnected is my things going on
the broker of the future
is less going to be just about risk transfer
you know the value of them will be coming from
how do you help the client
anticipate some of the losses they have
understand how much they're willing to withstand
and then how you kind of build contingency funds around it
David how they spoke about AI
a topic understandably
that we've spoken a lot about on insurance tomorrow
but as AI and geopolitics increasingly collide
through cyber attacks social engineering and the like
where do you see those risks headed
I think it is very hard to say
where we see AI risks headed with any accuracy
because it's changing exponentially quickly
I think right now we can see an increase
in things like fraud
spoofing in sending transport down the wrong route
in ransomware that sort of thing
I think as AI gets more and more agentic
and has more and more control
then we I think we're seeing probably a new kind of risk
where we look at sort of threat actors potentially being AI
and we will have to change and pivot
to work out how the risk world responds to that sort of risk
that's a different sort of risk in the future
but probably near future risk
is what happens if AI becomes the bad actor
that's a different sort of risk entirely
I would add to that I think I tend to think of in two ways
AI can be a threat but it's also an opportunity
I think you mentioned you know it could be a threat actor
we're already seeing that actually in cyber
so in cyber security and resilience
you see it both ways
you see the bad actors using AI to get quicker
so you've seen a lot of prior news on the news
issues about frontier AI
how that could be a quite a big threat
so you see that but at the same time
a business can use AI as part of their defence
to learn faster as well from there
so I think there's a little bit of a balance of you know
as well as it could be a threat to you
how do we leverage what we know
and how do we leverage that tool to do it
and yes there'll be issues around ethical use
you're thinking through it
so it is a new area everyone's exploring how that is
but I think the opportunity is also there about with AI
I think yeah absolutely
if you're looking purely at the sort of political risk war
that sort of thing and where that could go wrong
then that's going to be a developing situation
if you look at AI overall
I would say that actually the majority of AI
is going to be positive
because AI is going to have a positive influence
on your resilience on your risk analysis
and your ability to respond to situations
because it can help you quickly
and it has a global internet wide view
so I think overall actually I'm still of the view
that AI is positive
even you know we can all read dystopian articles
about how we're all going to be the pets of robots
in 10 years time
but overall I see it as positive
but obviously there is a sort of darker element
I'm not sure the risk world is set up for that element yet
and nor should it have been
that's not a criticism
but that's what's in front of us
yeah I think it's the pace isn't it
AI has just increased that pace
so David's right
like with geopolitical
the AI could be turned into a tool a weapon
but it's also the pace that it can move faster
and it's about how do we use the same tools
to respond faster as well
we could talk about AI all day
but there are other issues and risks I do want to cover
one of them particularly under insurance and protection gaps
already a challenge for many businesses
so Hannah looking ahead
where do you see the biggest gaps emerging
particularly for SMEs
I think the protection gap is
maybe not going to come from risks
that we think we haven't seen
it's going to be risks that we already know about
but it's how they actually magnified and amplified
so we talked about earlier
the interconnectivity of risks
I think it's about how it's layering up
so as risks change and evolve
I think it's not easy for businesses
to work out how much they're exposed to
you know what happens
when it's not just one incident
it's multiple incidents
you know we talked about
with a lot of events
you know in recent years in the world
there's a spike of energy prices
the cost of living
the inflation
the impact of an economy
how consumer sentiments and spending is less
business cost is going up
it's a layering those parts
is where probably
where it could lead to under insurance
or inadequate contingency planning
that's actually the challenge for businesses
I agree absolutely with that
I think that it's a multi-layered environment
when you're looking at a protection gap
or insurance gap
because there are so many influences
and one is in today's world
one is that you don't realise where the risk was
and as something has come up from a new angle
that produces gaps
another is which is increasingly the case
moving back to sort of tech
that you simply can't get enough insurance
to cover something
a very good example of that is huge data centres
in fact an article in the FT recently
huge data centres
one in particular in Texas
where they can't get the insurance
to cover the cost of the data centre being destroyed
and I think that's where the broken community
really plays a role
because I think you know
you're having a real conversation with a client
to say what are you willing to lose
what are you able to withstand on here
I think that's when you
for me you know it's about risk appetite
what's your own risk appetite for your business
what are the things that you kind of go
look I can't do without this for five days
I can't do it in seven days
I think what you're right
you can't buy everything
you can't protect everything
so it's about prioritisation
so I think the future of the broker
is if they can help a client
think about how you prioritise the risk
understand the uncertainty better
so they can make informed decisions
and help them kind of set up themselves
to go what is your resilient plan on there
that knowledge will make the future broker
even more important
I think the critical thing to it
is that the broker there
the really important job is to do
actually what the broker's always done
which is to produce the communication
with the client
to make sure they understand what they need
what they want to buy
what they don't want to buy
and what they are buying is doing
and how it operates
and that communication is critical
and when that breaks down
from a sort of legal perspective
and you see disputes
it's often just because that's broken down
so that broker role has always been critical
and will continue to be absolutely central
David Hannah spoke about the conversations
between clients and businesses
what conversations do you think are not happening
that should be happening
I don't have insight into
what's happening on the ground
because things come to me afterwards
because I'm a lawyer
but I do wonder sometimes
whether there is a full conversation
a transparent conversation
about the whole business
and the whole business's needs
maybe a painful conversation
painful for the client
maybe it's something they don't want to reveal
but I just wonder sometimes
whether everything's revealed
so the broker can fully interact
with their risk profile
and give them the solution they need
Hannah, your views?
It's probably making sure they understand
what's the impact to their businesses
because I think geopolitical events are so big
you can read on the news all the time
but the connection or that linkage between
what does that mean to my business
to my staff
to my people
my customers
I think that is really key
it's very easy to get caught up with
the big bang or the issues on there
but sometimes it's the small things
like the logistics operational events
that actually will help a business
survive the disruption
David, Hannah, thank you so much for your time
fascinating discussion
Thanks for having me
Thank you very much
That's it for today
next time on Insurance Tomorrow
we'll be looking at the future of insurance
and how technology,
changing customer expectations
and emerging risks
could reshape the industry
over the coming decades
If you've enjoyed this episode
please subscribe
so you don't miss future discussions
as soon as they're released
and you can catch up with all our episodes
on Spotify, LinkedIn, YouTube and Apple Podcasts
and as always we'd love to hear from you
What are the issues you're discussing
with your colleagues or your clients?
Is there a question you'd like us to put to our experts?
Just drop us a message via the link in the show notes
Insurance Tomorrow is brought to you by Allianz
I'm Georgie Frost
Thanks for joining us
and we'll see you next time