Acquired Minds Podcast The personal guarantee is one of the biggest deterrents to buying a business with an SBA loan. If the business fails, the bank can come after your personal assets. But a new product called personal guarantee insurance (PGI) aims to reduce that risk. Today’s guest, Jason Hunt, founded Ink, a PGI provider. After a career in restructuring and buying and selling a business himself, Jason decided against a second acquisition because of the personal guarantee risk. Listen as we break down how PGI works, what it costs and covers, how lenders view it, and how it applies to buyers, serial acquirers, and sellers rolling equity.Jason is also joining us for an Acquiring Minds webinar Tuesday, November 17, at noon Eastern. Find the registration link in the show notes.
00:00 Introduction to Inc. 01:02 Jason's background in turnaround finance 07:59 Defining the personal guarantee 10:23 Napkin math walkthrough 17:08 Additional customer profiles 19:24 Lender community reactions to PGI 27:30 Policy structure 31:23 Claims process mechanics
AI Generated·May contain errors
Jason Hunt, welcome to Acquiring Minds.
Will, thanks for having me. It's great to be here.
Jason, you're the founder of Inc.,
a new company providing personal guarantee insurance
to the SBA business buyer market.
Not surprisingly, there is a lot of interest
in this concept, in the product.
For some people, the personal guarantee represents
so much downside that it keeps them from pursuing this path at all.
So if personal guarantee insurance, PGI, takes off,
it could open this path for more people.
And then, of course, the people who would have bought
a business with an SBA loan anyway
are going to have a new opportunity
to protect themselves from the nightmare scenario.
So it's very intriguing.
There's a lot of buzz around PGI.
We're going to learn about the concept
and Ink's own solution in our conversation now.
Great to have you, Jason.
Let's begin with some background on you, please.
Happy to.
So my background is a little bit eclectic,
but I feel like all these pieces brought together
the right foundation for building this product.
So I started my career in 2008,
and I went into finance, and it was the height of the
global financial crisis.
So I went into turnaround and restructuring.
We typically help larger companies that had taken on too much debt.
figure out what they were going to do next.
A lot of times that was restructuring the debt
with their lenders. We could be operationally trying
to turn around the business. We could
be raising fresh capital.
Or if none of that worked out in the best path, we would sometimes
liquidate the business. So really kind
of foundational experience for understanding
what happens when you take on too much debt
and that doesn't work out. Helpful for PGI.
And after that, I wanted to be an entrepreneur.
And I went and bought a small business in 2013.
Back then, I don't think the word ETA existed.
It was really early days in the ecosystem.
And we bought an education company. So we'd have contracts
with local schools and a private lesson business.
And we really focused on the private lesson business
is the way that we can scale this to multiple cities.
So, yeah.
Kind of thinking back to those days, a lot of people talk about AI.
Back then, it was like, hey, let's build a website
and find some customers online.
And that's basically what we did.
We built an online marketplace.
We grew it city by city, and we ended up selling the company.
We did that.
That got me into tech.
I worked for the choir for a bit.
They were called Reverb.
Then I worked at Amazon.
Then I worked at a company called QuickNode, really in growth roles.
So I learned a lot about building products,
iterating quickly, and driving revenue growth.
And so...
After I went back and got more experience,
I wanted to go be an entrepreneur again.
And I started looking at buying a business.
And as I got into that, my financial profile changed.
You would think a lot of that was good
because it was like, hey, we have more assets and
I have more experience.
And frankly, I was way better equipped
to go run a company than I was at 25.
But, you know, that's where
the personal guarantee became a lot harder for us.
We had some real estate assets and not only that.
My wife managed those and would do renovations and things like that.
So if things didn't work out with going to buy a business,
it wouldn't just wipe out
the assets, it would wipe out her nine to five.
And so we decided not to do that as a family.
Right, Mike.
As I was going through that process,
I chatted with a lot of searchers and got their feedback
on how they handled the personal guarantee.
And I just got this feeling that there needed
to be a product out there to help folks.
And there was just that really strong demand signal from the market.
So I teamed up with my partner, Devin.
We started building this product.
It's taking a bit to get live,
but we just got it in the hands of customers
and we're super excited about it.
Did you have the awareness
that PGI, personal guarantee insurance,
exists in other places?
So namely, there's a big provider
of personal guarantee insurance in the UK.
And I've heard that cited as sort of a precedent
for what could happen here.
And the reason I ask that is because
I'm not sure that I would have had the insight
Otherwise, or the insight that you did, I just took sort
of a personal guarantee as a law of physics in SBA land,
in lender land, and that it's there precisely to not,
and there are no workarounds, and that's the way the banks like it.
Well, I would say some of this came
from building software products over the last 10 years is like
you really listen closely to demand signals from customers.
And I was fortunate. I had a WhatsApp
group of searchers. And anytime you mentioned
something about the personal guarantee,
there was just a lot of demand signals.
And I said, okay, there's something really here.
And then I did start doing
the research about what has existed in the past.
So there was actually a company
in 2010 called Asterix Financial that did it in the US.
They ran for a couple of years.
They ended up selling the business to a company in the UK.
I'm not totally sure if that's the same one
that's existed in the UK for the last 15 years,
but the one that you're talking about has been around for a while.
Um, and has a lot of history in the product works.
And I think one of the main things is in the UK,
they have higher PG prevalence.
So most, most business loans actually have a PG.
So even though their debt market is a lot smaller, um, you know,
it's more kind of in your face, like it is with SBA, you know,
and you see it every day and everyone's talking about it.
And so I think that's one of the reasons
that it got started up there first.
You're actually not the only.
provider or really startup
who is pursuing this solution for the market. I've had another on
and there's chatter of even others.
So maybe there's two of you definitely who are going
to market and there may be others. Is that a coincidence or is there...
Something in the air or what's that about that all
of a sudden there appear to be a number of
competitors in this space?
Man, I like to joke that ChatGPT is responsible. Everyone kind of
typed in and said, hey, is this a good business?
And it's like, it's a huge TAM. You should totally
go after it and build that business.
I don't know if that's actually true.
So, you know, my...
My experience was so personal.
I had bought businesses and signed the personal guarantee
and my assets were in the exact wrong places
and we had no homestead protection. It was like
I had been through it.
So that was kind of my experience and it was really built from the
bottoms up. I do think that the growth of the SBA ecosystem
and ETA is a big deal because
think about your podcast, Will. You've had...
Maybe 15 horror stories on there, right?
And most of them are success stories.
But word is getting out that, hey,
if you buy an asset-light business, the PG, to the
tune of $2 to $3 million, there's a lot of risk there.
And so as that ecosystem has grown,
I think the need for this product has also grown and
the awareness has too.
Yeah.
I'll just cite, I think,
my most recent guest who had the courage to come on here and tell
her horror story, Morley Desai,
an e-commerce business that very quickly went to zero after
her acquisition, but it was a $4 million enterprise value acquisition,
so a sizable business.
And she now is, if I recall, it's $200,000 a year.
For a number of years, she's under this burden,
not to mention destroyed credit.
So it is a nightmare scenario.
Now, she has emerged on the other side
and is philosophical about it, is moving on with
her life and has landed on her feet.
And she didn't lose her house.
So there is a silver lining there.
But this can be seriously devastating.
And that's only the most recent example on Acquiring Minds.
People should go back and listen to that.
I've, I've, um...
I've teased it, gotten us a little bit ahead here,
Jason, but let's talk directly about
the problem that it solves.
Kind of define the personal guarantee
and then personal guarantee insurance.
Yeah, I think at a high level, what the personal guarantee is saying
is that, hey, if the business, the business takes out the loan,
and if the business can't repay the loan,
then I'm personally going to backstop that.
So if you think about that a little bit,
you're kind of repealing the concept of limited liability.
Capitalism was built on the concept of limited liability, where it's
like, hey, what happens with this business won't come home with you.
Now, it serves a real purpose.
Otherwise, lenders might not lend in this ecosystem.
That's what the SBA is doing. That's what
the personal guarantees they're helping with
is that the lenders know that there's enough collateral
that they can go after and make
this loan. So it's helpful,
but the downside risk that you talked about is real.
As we think about what we do,
we really focus on trying to figure out what that personal
guarantee amount is.
We size that and we cover it.
So in different businesses, it really depends.
You might have a lot of business collateral
or a little business collateral, and we'll
help you size that and then figure out coverage for it.
So think about if you're buying a services company,
you might just have computers and
people, right?
So your PG amount, you're basically on the hook for the entire loan.
And so you took out $2 million.
Sell the computers for a couple thousand,
maybe you have some AR, but there's not really a lot
of business collateral. Now there's other
companies where maybe you buy the real estate,
you buy, you have a ton of inventory and you can sell that off.
You take out a $2 million loan,
the PG amount could be 500,000 or a million
because you have a million in collateral.
So that's step number one is trying to figure out, put a number on,
hey, how much is this PG that I'm signing up for?
Then we cover that amount.
And we are there for you if the personal guarantee gets called.
So I think it's an important distinction.
We don't cover the business assets.
We cover if the personal guarantee was called.
And we step in before you have to pay out those personal assets.
So we help protect you with that.
We do have some shared coverage.
We typically target about 80% coverage.
We can go higher and lower than that.
We have a lot of flexibility on it.
But that's generally what it's focused on is like
if your personal guarantee gets called.
We can help you pay that off
so you don't face personal wipeout with this deal.
Can we walk through just some napkin math
of an example business acquisition?
Call it a $3 million business acquisition with an SBA loan.
Just walk us through some very loose numbers on that.
Yeah, I would say at a high level,
there's probably a couple numbers you need to know.
What's the loan amount? How much business assets you have? And then you
also want to know how much personal assets you have exposed.
But if we take that $3 million example and we say,
hey, the business has...
A million in assets, you would get coverage for the 2 million,
which is what you're backstopping
on the personal guarantee side.
So in that scenario, let's say we cover 80% and we have
some flexibility on that number,
we'd be covering 1.6 and you would retain 400,000 on your side of
risk.
Our whole goal is that people can afford that deductible,
but it doesn't wipe them out.
Hopefully, they don't have to sell their house.
They don't have to sign up for a payment plan
of $200,000 a year for five to 10 years.
And they can really pay off the loan in full.
And that's what we're hoping for.
So in that scenario, the business assets would go first.
That would be the first million that would go pay back the loan.
We would pay next for our 80%.
And then the person would also pay their deductible.
And so when you talk about 80% coverage,
the remaining 20% is what we'll call the deductible.
Okay, so in this example, as you said, it was $400,000.
And so what your customer is asking themselves,
the business buyer, as they set out to consider
a policy is, will the deductible,
the deductible might be so large that it wipes them out anyway.
If I'm somebody with less than $400,000 in assets,
in that example, I'm going to be wiped out anyway.
Am I thinking about this the right way?
Well, I would say high level,
a lot of times people's assets exposed
are related to the loan value.
So I don't see a ton of scenarios
where someone with maybe $50,000 assets exposed
takes out a $5 million loan,
generally, if they're a self-funded searcher.
So I would say those things are pretty proportional.
Um, typically the loan value is a little higher than the assets,
but we check to make sure that
the deductible makes sense for this particular individual.
And if it doesn't, that could be a
reason that we could go higher than 80% on the coverage.
Cause when you think about what people,
what we're trying to optimize for is we still want some skin
in the game. The lender still
I still want some skin in the game and
That is not really as a percentage of the coverage,
it's as a percentage of their assets exposed.
So we take that into account when we size the deal
of like, okay, this person has a million dollars
assets exposed, maybe it's home equity, whatever it is.
What is the percent?
What is the deductibles percentage of their assets exposed?
And does that make sense from a risk transfer perspective
and also skin in the game?
And we look at both of those things.
The key variables are going to be my own assets,
then basically all the characteristics of the
business, the size of the business that I'm buying
and the cashflow that it has and the
multiple that I'm paying, basically all the typical factors.
But the one other that you
look at closely is my own post-transaction liquidity,
the assets that I'm looking to
protect. And that's a key question
because obviously that's what, when the PG hits,
that's what it comes down to, how much of my assets are really at risk.
Right.
And I would say a lot of people probably don't spend enough time
on what collateral is in the
business and what could you actually sell that for.
Granted, a lot of SBA deals tend to be asset
light acquisitions, but some aren't.
Some have inventory that they could sell. Some have the
option to buy the real estate
and kind of putting a fine number on that helps you size the personal
guarantee. And that part is really important too.
It is kind of an interesting point, isn't it,
that asset light businesses are.
What are preferred in our world.
Mm-hmm.
And yet, it's precisely those that leave you most exposed
in a bad situation because there's
nothing, there's that much less to liquidate
and to pay the bank back with.
And in fact, there has been a searcher or two,
a business buyer or two on the podcast
who said, I actually wanted a business.
I wanted to buy a manufacturing business
because I wanted it to have assets because I wanted,
I saw that as some downside protection in the event of.
Uh, the underperformance where I could,
I would have something to liquidate and it
wouldn't be a so-called air ball.
The business isn't just good, all good, almost all goodwill.
That is totally true. And I wouldn't say it's the norm,
but I have chatted with some customers
who intentionally tried to buy the real estate,
you know, make sure that they had a ton of assets
so that they were mostly covered.
And, you know, there's a lot of things to think about when buying
a business. It's not just that,
but I think you got to look at both. You got to say, okay,
what's the upside here? Can I run this business?
Do I like the seller? Is there growth? Can I keep
Keep this stable.
But then in a downside scenario, what does that look like?
And you got to run that scenario too and really take a hard look at it.
And we help people do that.
It's very easy to focus in the downside scenario on the money piece,
how much money somebody is going to, their assets at risk.
But there's also the destruction of their credit,
at least for what, seven years?
Talk about the sort of qualitative damage that can be done.
Yeah.
Well, at a high level, if we can help you avoid personal bankruptcy,
we want to, right? Like that's typically what would happen
if you don't have enough money to pay it back.
And so if you kind of step back to that example,
we were talking about where we covered 1.6 million,
big number, and then they covered 400,000.
Our hope is that you'd be able to pay off this loan in full.
Even if you have a default, but you're able to pay off the loan
in full, you actually might be able to go get another SBA loan
and go do it again. You didn't have a charge off.
You paid off everything to the penny, and that is helpful
for your credit, and it's also helpful for your future too.
That's really what we're going for with insurance
is to help people not be wiped out.
Obviously, there's still some pain there on the deductible, but they
can still get a fresh start after going through this whole situation.
We're talking a lot about the SBA business buyer as the kind
of core ICP, the core persona here for Inc. and for PGI in general.
But there are a couple of other profiles that you think about,
other potential customers of this product.
This
Let's talk about those.
What you call the stackers, multiple acquisitions.
Let's hear about that.
And then second, sellers, which is an interesting one.
First, the stackers, please.
Yeah, at a high level, there's a sub cohort of people that are trying
to buy multiple businesses. Some will call them the roll ups,
you.
but they're going to buy one, they're going to get in the industry
and they're going to go buy another one.
Because the insurance wasn't around for that first one,
they might have gotten really comfortable with that first one.
Maybe they paid off a lot of the loan. It's done well.
It has enough earnings.
They're not super worried about that first one,
but they're going to go buy another business.
And if you buy another business,
you can actually use more leverage.
You could use 100% leverage on that deal.
So suddenly they've gone from very comfortable
with their debt structure
to taking on a lot more leverage.
And for that new deal,
they want to get the personal guarantee insurance.
So that's one persona.
And then this is another one
that we didn't build this with it in mind,
but it's kind of come to us is that
With the rule changes in the SOP,
if the seller stays on and rolls their equity,
they have to sign the PG for two years.
And that is a really hard thing to get sellers
comfortable with, like very hard.
Because they're like, okay, this new person's coming to run my
company. I have to sign the personal guarantee
to the tune of $2 million based off how they run it,
even though I'm going to help them.
But it is common in the trades or anything with a license,
Think medical field, things like that.
So I would say.
By and large, a lot of sellers still don't want to do that.
But personal guarantee can be a solution for them
where they know they have downside protection for the deal
and that could help them get comfortable with it.
So I've been chatting with brokers and folks
that really specialize in those categories
and they're really excited about it.
It's a pretty interesting use case.
We'll see if it takes because that SOP change really...
Kind of just eliminated the ability for sell SBAs
in an SBA business loan context for sellers to roll equity,
which, as you said, in the trades and license scenarios
was it was an important feature of many deals.
And this kind of killed it.
So that would be that's pretty interesting.
You mentioned lenders earlier.
You've been very, very in touch with the lender community.
One
Obvious question about PGI to ask is how do lenders like it?
Or do lenders feel like it's kind of a workaround?
you
You know, they want that personal guarantee there.
very
Those teeth is what make sure that they get paid.
So how has the lender community reacted to this?
much.
Well, I would say it's early days,
but generally the feedback has been really positive.
We've got to build this product, make sure that people
are happy with it and build that trust over time with lenders.
But if you think about it from first principles,
from their perspective, I would say on the front end,
we could bring new, really qualified buyers to market.
I was held back. There's folks that are held back
and they tend to be mid-career.
They tend to have more assets. They tend to have more experience.
They could be really good people to go run.
a small business and grow it and create jobs.
And those tend to be the folks that we see really
interested in personal guarantee insurance.
So from a high level, it could bring new folks into
the market for the lender that could be really good risks
and customers for the lender.
On the downside scenario, if you go through the whole process,
it could help them get paid back
faster and more whole.
And the truth is, no lender that I've ever met loves seizing your
personal assets. It's just like it's not a great experience
for their customer. Sometimes you sign
confidentiality stuff because it's not a great look.
And so if there's a solution that can
And, um,
be cleaner for them to recoup their money,
which is really what they're looking to do.
I think that's an exciting solution for them.
When it gets to skin in the game,
we really designed the product around that shared retention
because we want people to have skin in
the game. And so when I think about that right now,
our system is like, hey, for you to act
the right way, we have to take 100%
of what you own unlimited until it goes.
And I think you and I know running businesses that that's not true.
Like you are going to try and run your business really well,
even if there wasn't that most
people do, right?
When you have a venture-backed startup, people are trying to run it.
They don't have debt on the company, all that kind of stuff.
But, you know, it's really kind of like,
I like to call it fight when distress, you know,
what people really want is to know
that this business owner will fight to save the business
when it's not doing great.
And so we think we have the right balance of that,
where the first deductible really
is their down payment.
It is running this business for multiple years.
It is taking an under-market salary.
And then we have a second deductible,
which is just one deductible for our product, but
it's sort of a second deductible, which is their 20% that they retain.
And we think that's enough to get the incentive
that we want for someone to run this business
to the best of their ability.
It's an interesting point.
Jason, we talk so much about personal guarantee
as being skin in the game, but it does.
And it's a great question to ask.
Well, maybe it's more skin in the game than necessary.
It's so onerous.
You know,
Maybe we can get a business buyer, an SBA business buyer,
who hits upon a rough patch just as motivated
without holding a knife to their throat.
These are generally motivated people anyway.
And so it's...
It's a good question.
Is the PG almost outsized
in how devastating it can be?
And so you're arguing that you don't need that much.
It doesn't need to be that onerous to still have these entrepreneurs
perform to the best of their abilities.
Would losing an additional 20% of your net worth
make you still want to fight to save the business?
And everything you put in so far, it's still...
A lot of incentive to try and make things work if it's possible.
The other thing that I want to react
to is this point that there's a correlation between
someone's assets and how experienced they are.
Obviously, the further they get in their career,
the more kind of mid-career experience they've
accumulated, probably the more assets they've accumulated.
And, yeah.
And yet, and therefore,
what they have exposed in the case of a downside is that much more.
And so...
In some, there's sort of this perverse dynamic where,
as you kind of said, the very people who
might be best qualified to go buy
and operate a small business are the ones who have the most
on the line and are therefore disincentivized to do it.
Because the personal guarantee is most
threatening to the guy or gal with a family
and three kids and a mortgage. And yet that person
has all of that.
is probably 20 years into their career and is really quite experienced.
Anyway, so in some ways,
the personal guarantee incentivizes the youngest.
25-year-old who's really got nothing on the line
to go out to take the biggest swing they can.
And yet they're also the least experienced of the cohort.
So I say that from personal experience
because that was me when I bought a business the first time
I used my 401k, I rented, I didn't have a family.
You know, I was not worried about it.
And the second time around, I was almost 40.
And, you know, we had rental properties.
We had my wife's business
and we had built up assets over time.
But I was way better equipped to run a business.
I mean, like I had no idea what I was doing.
I mean, I was excited about it and I worked really, really hard.
And, you know, we made it a success.
But the second time around, there's no question about it.
At least speaking for me personally,
I was way better equipped to run a business.
This 80% number, Jason,
so some of the other products in the market have different coverages
that they're talking about.
50% is a number that you'll hear. How did you decide on...
80%, is that a magic number?
Just talk about the differentiation in your product
based on that particular number,
that coverage percentage that you've landed on.
Well, at a high level,
it kind of steps back to a lot of the stuff
we've already talked about where it's like,
okay, how many people does this provide
enough risk transfer for?
And so we actually did research with our customers
or before we had the product,
it was like early interest people to be like,
How much assets do you have?
And how much coverage are you going to get at 50, 60, 70, 80, 90?
And will this product work for you?
Because if you think about the example,
let's say that you have 50% coverage, you have a million assets,
it's still a lot, but you took out a $2 million loan,
and you only get 50% coverage, you're still wiped out in that scenario.
So that's not everybody.
There are some people that have a ton of assets.
Let's say you have $4 million, you take out a $2 million loan,
50% is truly helpful in that scenario.
And so we just wanted to talk with customers,
collect that data, and then make an informed
decision. And what we found is that most people get
a loan that's around double the size of their
assets exposed. So we had to think about, okay,
how does that deductible fit with their assets
exposed? Is that enough skin in the game?
And does it still make sense to purchase this product?
And that's where we landed on that. And I will say, it's not...
Just 80%. We don't do the same for everybody.
Each situation is different and we have some flexibility.
So we've had people say, hey, I want 60%.
And some other people say, I want 85%. And we've been able to work
with both of those folks to help them get the coverage they need.
Great. And on the actual policies,
can we hear more about how they're structured and priced?
So how to think about this as a potential customer of PGI?
Yeah. At a high level, they are typically annual policies.
And when we think about that,
we have a couple of different options.
So this is one of the recent changes that we
had to the product that I think is really exciting
for folks, is you can do a one-year
option, a two-year option, and a three-year option.
And for each of those, really what
you're buying is a guaranteed renewal
for the next year and a rate lock.
So one of the concerns we heard early on is that, hey,
if I do the one year, what happens at the end of that one year
if things go bad with the company or the economy or anything like that?
And people are really buying peace of mind.
And so we went back and we made an update to the product
to allow people to go up to three years where they really,
truly do have that peace of mind.
Now, it does cost a little bit more in premium
to lock it in for a second or third year.
But really, the headline for us is we wanted to give customers choice.
I think the one-year product is great for things that...
Could happen within the year
that could be totally beyond your control.
Like talk about customer concentration
or like the team walking out
and starting a competitor
that can certainly happen in the first year.
There are defaults in the first year
where that happens.
But if you're having kind of more
of a slow decline and you're like,
hey, I want to protect against that.
That is for sure more
the three-year product, right?
And you're going to lock in that rate.
So for us, we...
We have what we call our base rate, which is kind of,
I guess I would say our starting average
price at about 1.5%. So if you kind of take,
we'll just use an easy example. Let's say you've
got a million in coverage, assume no business assets,
we're covering 800,000. That would be
about 12,000 in the first year, one and a half percent.
Now it could be higher and lower than
And it does vary a lot.
I would encourage folks, if they're listening,
to get estimates from us because it really
depends on the deal.
It could be a lot cheaper.
It could be a lot more expensive.
And then typically, as you go longer out
and lock in that coverage, it does go a little
bit up each year that you lock in.
Great.
And just to be clear on the one-year option versus
the three-year option, the concern
that you were reacting to in the market was that I buy a business
and I get PGI and it's
It's an annual policy.
And I'm worried that if things aren't going well in month 11
or 12 of my ownership,
you're simply going to drop me as a customer, as an insured.
And so this is a reaction to that concern.
And essentially, I can sign up for three years out of the gate.
And so I don't have to worry that I'm going
to be dropped anytime during those three years,
no matter how bad things get.
I would say it's not our intent to cancel people.
There's part around the business,
but it's really also about the economy and things like that.
When you think about these big macro
events, insurers can get a little bit more guarded in those times.
That's exactly when you want the
coverage. This, within the policy,
locks you in for those years where you know what your rate's
going to be and you know you're going to get renewed.
That's a really big thing for folks.
And one of the cool parts about it is we kept
the annual policy, even though we have those
guaranteed renewals and rate locks.
And so the insured actually has a lot of flexibility. They
don't even have to go to year two or three if they don't want to.
They can stop the coverage
when they feel comfortable with the business,
which is really nice. And then we also take
into account the benefit of amortization.
So in year two, you've maybe paid down a little bit of
the principal on your loan.
We locked the percentage rate. So let's say that's 1.5.
And in year two, you only need $900,000 in coverage versus a million.
We will apply that percentage to that.
So your premiums will actually come down over time.
It's pretty unique.
You know, I really don't know a lot
of insurance products where your premiums could get cheaper,
but it makes sense.
You know, as you de-risk the business and you pay off the loan,
that will happen with
that multi-year coverage here.
And so walk us through the mechanics of getting PGI.
Here, Jason, what would it look like?
Where does it fit into the whole long transaction process?
Yeah.
At a high level, we're happy to chat with folks at any time.
It's a brand new product.
We want to get education out there and just kind of share how it works.
Where we can start to give you pricing is typically
when you get a term sheet from your lender and you're under LOI.
We have enough of kind of like the core ingredients.
What's the business?
What does the loan look like?
All that kind of stuff where we can give you,
just basically let you know, are you likely to
be approved and what's your rate going to be?
And then we just follow along through closing
and typically close with you or within 30 days.
So we're really kind of focused on originations
for loans. We can go outside of that.
We can go up to six months, but those are kind of more
exceptions than our core rule.
We really like to close with you. I think it's easier.
Thank
For the borrower, they have all their docs ready
to go with their acquisition and it
makes it really easy for underwriting too.
And then in the downside case that this is meant to protect against,
what does the sequence
look like then?
When do they start interacting with you,
a borrower who's had hard times?
you.
Yeah, I would say at the highest level,
hopefully you don't need the insurance and the business
goes great.
If it doesn't, there could be a turnaround scenario.
So let's say, you know.
Revenue or profits came down a little bit
and you have too much debt on the business,
but it's really a good underlying
business and you want to hold on to it.
That would be probably something that you would
work out with your lender where you're like,
hey, we need to extend the terms
or we need to adjust the rate or whatever it is.
Help me try and keep the business.
That's what I used to do in turnaround and restructuring.
Those are, if you can make that happen,
that's great because you can hold on to the business.
Where we really come in is where there's really
not those moves to make anymore.
You're kind of like, hey,
I've done all those moves where we can't make this a going concern
anymore.
And so when you had a default notice with your lender,
that's part one of our claims
trigger.
That gets your claim in on time.
And then we follow along with you
and the lender as they liquidate those business assets.
So back to that conversation we were having before where it's like...
What amount are you going to get for that?
We want to try and size that and know ahead of time.
That goes back to pay the loan.
And then the lender tells us, hey, they had a million outstanding.
They got $200,000 in business recoveries
and there's $800,000 in the gap.
And that tells us the number that we need to go pay for the claim.
So we allow for time to happen with that.
Automatically, you get 24 months of like, hey,
we got to go through the business recoveries
and figure out that amount.
You can extend that over time.
We know that some liquidations can take time.
Some don't take a lot of time.
Some are just like laptops and not much.
So we try to build the process so that it's flexible
based off all those different scenarios.
And tell us where Inc. itself is in terms
of availability of the product,
where it's available.
There are certain states that I know you're not available in.
So talk to us about actual contact with the marketplace here.
Where are you?
Yeah. So a lot of insurance is state by state.
We are live in 43 states plus DC.
Some big ones that we're not live in now are California, Florida,
and New York. I think we have about 71% coverage of SBA volume.
In those other states, we do plan to get to them.
I originally grew up in California.
I've lived in New York. They're great ecosystems.
They're high volume, but they have a different.
way that they treat this line of business
and we have to file to get admitted in that state.
That process does take a bit of time.
So we're probably estimating about 12 months to be in
those markets. And in the meantime,
we're serving customers in other 43 states.
But you predict having 100% coverage across the U.S.?
Oh, yeah. Yes. Over time.
And are you actually writing policies? Is the product available today?
Yeah, we have our first cohort of customers,
which has been really exciting,
really across industries, some accounting, some excavation,
some home services, businesses, medical, things like that.
So it really does kind of fit.
Probably the same types of business
that you're seeing through your podcast.
And we just got this new product live two weeks ago
with the guaranteed renewal and
the rate lock and the demand for that has been really strong.
It sounds like that.
So that was one adjustment to the product offering that you made.
Were there any other things that you built into the product?
Then learned quickly from the market that needed tweaking?
Yeah, I would say that there was two.
One was just the whole customer experience.
We built kind of our flow from application
to quote to bind from scratch.
So we really tried to make that a forward thinking, easy to use, great
UX customer experience for people so that they're excited about this.
It's easy to do.
It's a lot of work going through a closing
and SBA packages a crazy amount of documents if you've seen it.
So the more that we can just kind of hook into that process,
we have the ability to extract those documents,
pre-fill your application, things like that.
That's been one of them. And then we built
a lot of tooling on our site.
You know, when I think about our goal in the ecosystem, we want
to help people buy businesses that are successful and don't fail.
We're really aligned on that with this individual, right?
Like if they don't fail, that's great.
For us, it's great for them
and they can continue growing this business and drop the
coverage when they need it.
And so we built some tooling on our site to help people do that.
We launched a default rate tool where we
are sharing some of the information that we have
on different industries and how they default over time.
And that data is pretty insightful.
And it's something that you won't know.
You might see a home services category that's really hot,
that's like spiking this year
and be like, okay, what?
What's going on there?
And so we want to get that out to our customers
so that they have the information
on what we're seeing on our side.
If it's early enough,
maybe that can help them pick a different type of business
that has really low default rates.
And if not, at least they know
and they can think about
what are some of the risks
that happen with other businesses
and how can I mitigate against that?
Yeah.
Well, maybe not your intention and what you shared with us,
but I can't let you tease
that you have some special market intelligence about
which business categories are seeing
a spike in defaults and not tell us what those are.
What categories are having a hard time right now?
Yeah, I would say on one of them that's having a hard time right now.
Well, one, overall defaults are up in general.
If you look at the chart, you know, and I don't think
that would surprise anyone, but things got kind of looser and,
you know, 21, 22, 23, and you're seeing that default rate go up.
So almost all categories are up.
One that is spiking that is a popular category is roofing.
Um, and I didn't know that until, you know,
we had a customer apply and I was like, why
did this not go through?
And I looked at the data
and that was part of the reason great person, um, look like
great on paper.
And I didn't know that about
this particular category and it was true in the data.
So we wanted to open source that, get that information out to people.
So there's no surprises on that kind of stuff.
Um, and then on the good businesses,
I think this is really interesting too, that clinics
I think that the lowest default rate of categories that have volume,
car washes with convenience stores, another one,
really kind of the whole dental medical has been really strong.
So that's on there, too.
And you can kind of go pick your targets.
Great.
And so that's available on the website.
Yeah.
What's the URL?
What's the URL?
Incinsurance.com.
And then it's slash default dash rates.
But there's a button on the top menu.
Yeah.
Yeah.
How many of these policies do you have to write, Jason,
for your own business, for this startup of yours to become viable?
I know nothing about insurance, but there's obviously kind
of a threshold number, a critical mass number, roughly.
I mean, do you have to underwrite thousands
of policies or less or what?
Give us a direction.
I think for things to be viable, we'll be in the low hundreds,
and I think we can get there pretty easily.
As you get larger, it's better, though, because what they call it
in insurance is the law of large numbers, right?
Like the more policies you have.
You can rely more on the statistics, right?
So you can say, okay,
the data that we pulled from overall with the SBA is actually true.
The more that you have smaller, the more random it gets.
And so that's something to think about.
With this category, though, I really think that over time,
this will become pretty standard.
It'll be looked at as a little crazy that back in the day you could...
You know, buy a business for $3 million with no business collateral
and PG the entire thing.
I think insurance will kind of be built into that.
If you think about...
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And that you even have the collateral,
at least you have the house, you know,
like you have the house, you have something that you can sell.
Here, we're saying no collateral, I'm backstopping the whole thing.
And I think it'll make sense. And so as this gets bigger,
we'll fine tune the pricing, we'll get that.
Nailed in over time, and I think it'll really
be built into the ecosystem and helpful for folks.
Circling back to this point that you're not the only one doing this,
there's been another provider on the pod,
and there's talk of other providers still.
How do you react to that?
Is it like, hey, I don't want competition?
Or is it like a more experienced entrepreneur?
You recognize that actually having some competition
validates the entire category.
Yeah.
In some...
It's a strong signal to the consumers
that this product concept is here to stay.
Yeah.
I do think it's helpful for the consumers.
Like if we were the only person in the category,
I think that would be a little bit scary
and more people coming to the market.
It is a positive thing for validating the industry overall.
So I think that's positive.
And then on the particular competitors,
I have a lot of respect for them.
I know how hard it is to build this product
and how long it's taken to get to market that
anyone that actually has a product live.
Huge hats off to them, for sure.
So I think that's true.
And then for us, we just try
and focus on differentiation, like any business.
And what are we doing that is unique to us?
And how can we stand out?
And how can we iterate on the product quickly?
And what can we offer customers that they don't get elsewhere
so that people pick us?
And so we're really focused on that.
It is kind of funny because it does feel like
a lot of competitors came quickly.
But at the same time...
Any business category that is large or growing or is nascent,
but is growing really fast,
they're going to have multiple entrants.
So it's pretty expected, I think.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah.
Well, as you put it at the top,
the pain point here is just screaming. I mean,
the PG gets so much attention, justifiably,
in our world that if you had the insight that
there could be a product that could address that.
Once you have that insight, it's like, yeah, there will be demand here.
No question.
The demand signals, as you put it.
Yeah.
Okay, Jason.
Well, if the listener is interested in learning yet more
or asking you questions directly,
you'll be hosting a webinar
with Acquiring Minds on Tuesday, November 17th.
So we're going to get more into the weeds there.
You will deliver a presentation.
And then, of course, there will be Q&A.
So people, any questions that somebody's listening now and...
And screaming at me to ask that I'm forgetting to ask.
They can come to that webinar and ask.
And there will be a link in the show notes
of this episode to register for that.
And of course, we'll promote it in all of our usual channels.
Thank
And people can go to inkinsurance.com.
You mentioned the digital tool, the tooling that you've provided.
Mm-hmm.
There's a lot of tooling on the website, right?
you
Not just the one thing you mentioned.
To tell people what they can find at your URL.
very
Yeah.
Yeah. Check out our website at inkinsurance.com.
We have the defaults rate tool,
which has been really popular.
You can see that about your industry. We also help you
much.
size the personal guarantee.
So you can put in the type of deal, the business collateral,
what state you're in, your personal assets,
and it'll help you figure out how much of that is
exposed. We have a quick estimator.
So if you don't want to go through the application yet,
you can put in a couple of pieces of information about the deal,
and then we'll get back to you quickly
on whether it's likely to be approved.
And what the pricing is going to be.
So we're building new tools all the time
and definitely go to our website to check it out.
Super.
That was inkinsurance.com.
And again, everyone come to the webinar
on November 17th, Tuesday, noon Eastern, our usual time.
And to learn more about Inc.
and personal guarantee insurance.
It's an exciting moment for the SBA business buyer world
because of this product and this whole category,
which seems to have kind of sprung up
in the last, call it 12 months or less.
So we appreciate all of your entrepreneurial, you know.
energy that you're putting into this, Jason.
And we all hope that it, as you know, that your
vision comes to fruition, that this basically just becomes
a standard in our world. That would be a
helpful thing for buyers. So thank you. Awesome. Thank you, Will.
Hope you enjoyed that interview.
Don't forget to subscribe to the Acquiring Minds newsletter.
We send an email for every episode
with an introduction to the interview,
a link to the video version on YouTube,
and soon, key takeaways, numbers,
and more essentials from the interview
for those of you who don't have time to listen or watch it.
Subscribe at acquiringminds.co.
You'll also find all our webinars there on the website,
both those we have coming up
and recordings of past webinars.
At this point, there are over 30 webinar recordings,
a wealth of information
on all the technical nitty gritty of buying a business.
Acquiringminds.co.