Cyber insurance outlook: Soft conditions continue as risk exposure and uncertainty grow

Business Insurance
4 followers
13 Video Views·May 15, 2026
New Zealand’s top cyber insurance experts break down the 2026 market outlook, warning that business interruption remains one of the most underestimated cyber risks facing clients today. In this Insurance Business TV power panel, Damien Schade, Decklyn Thomson and Tom Arnott discuss soft market conditions, tightening underwriting, ransomware exposure and whether the US-Iran conflict could reshape cyber risk and pricing.
AI Generated·May contain errors
I think it absolutely has to have an impact at some stage,
but at this stage I don't think we have seen any changes.
Most businesses still see cyber as an IT risk as opposed to like a possible financial risk.
It's the old saying is, it's not if but when. Couldn't be more real at the moment.
Hello and welcome to Insurance Business TV for our first cyber insurance power panel of the year
for New Zealand. We're going to look at what brokers should know about the current market
trends, where the main exposures are and the impact of the US-Iran conflict.
We've assembled our panel of experts. Damien Shade is Client Director Financial Lines at Lockton.
Declan Thompson is Associate Director with GSI Insurance Partners. And we have a new panelist.
Tom Arnott is Cyber Specialist with Marsh. A special welcome to you, Tom.
Thanks, Danny. Excited to be here.
Yeah, great to have you. And of course, welcome to our two regulars as well.
Let's start with you, Damien. How is the cyber market looking right now?
Is it still soft? And what's standing out for you in terms of market trends, if anything?
Yeah, nice to be back, Danny. Thanks for having me again. Yeah, look, 2026 is a little bit status
quo. To kick the year off, the market still remains relatively competitive. Still insurers
are being relatively aggressive at trying to retain their business. We haven't seen sort of
significant number of large claims within the last few months. Just continue to see a lot of
the social engineering, the smaller type traditional clients. So the market still
remains relatively buoyant in this capacity and options for our clients at the moment.
And Declan, turning to you, what are you seeing that's new and trending, if anything?
Yeah, thanks again for having me, Danny. I do agree that we're still in a relatively soft
market. I know that insurers are still looking to improve on their underwriting discipline in
terms of tightening cybersecurity requirements. I'm liking that we're seeing a lot of insurers
be proactive with some of their cybersecurity reporting and assessments that they're doing
even ahead of remittals or when we're seeing submissions through. So I think that there is
tightening up happening around underwriting criteria and that kind of thing. But in terms
of pricing, I would say that we're definitely still relatively in a relatively soft market.
Thanks, Declan. And Tom, coming to you in third place there, what are you seeing that's trending?
Yeah, Danny, I'm going to sound a bit like a broken record here, but I agree with the other guys.
Definitely still a soft market. I think we're going to see the market conditions remain
relatively stable throughout 2026. I don't envision any major changes.
From a pricing perspective, we're seeing anywhere from minus five to plus five percent at max,
but as a whole, it's relatively consistent and I think it will remain that way.
But yeah, we will monitor it. And Tom, sticking with you, if you guys are
sort of seeing the market as relatively soft at the moment, what should brokers be doing now?
Because presumably there'll be an upturn at some stage. Are you making sure everyone's getting
ready for things or is it too early to do that at this point?
Yeah, it's more of a constant process, continuing to ensure that clients are maintaining insurability
and just taking them through that journey is key. We've been doing that for years,
we'll continue to do that. For when the market does inevitably turn, you want your clients to
be in the best shape possible. And we're doing things like encouraging onboarding calls with
incident response vendors, familiarising clients with their hotline numbers,
just little immediate things that they can be doing to increase their
resilience and awareness for when that market does turn inevitably.
Yeah. And Damian, what about you? Are you
doing the little tweaks or what are you watching at the moment if the market ends up turning?
Yeah, I think so. I think you've got to take advantage when the market is like it is to
squeeze as much coverage as you can out of insurers because there's opportunities to be
able to get those extra limits, to get those extra sub-limits and drive the coverage position.
But I agree with Tom's point around making sure that the cyber resilience piece is in line as
well. So you've really got to sort of, it's almost preparing for the inevitable, whether
that be in sort of six months, 12 months or two years, making sure the programme is as
robust as possible and also the risk management aligns to that from a cyber perspective.
And Declan, are you preparing for the inevitable?
I guess so in a way. I think these conversations with clients can sometimes be like you may as
well sort of take advantage of the pricing now and bank some of that while you can. But
at the same time, it's having conversations with them around implementing better cyber
risk management, better IT security so that things like MFA, patching, backups, EDR,
those kinds of things, insurers are going to be caring about either later this year
or in a few years' time. So it's just making sure that when the insurers do tighten up,
they're still in a favourable position to kind of achieve some favourable pricing, really.
And Declan, sticking with you in terms of achieving favourable pricing, that's everything
to do with exposures. What exposures are you most worried about now that your clients might
be underestimating? Well, it's a good question, Danny. I think
in terms of exposures, I mean, there's always the classics kind of social engineering,
like invoice fraud, those kinds of always maybe star risks. But I think one thing that I guess
we're finding is the business interruption sort of business interruption loss following cyber
events can be a thing that a lot of clients underestimate. It's really easy to think about
picture cyber as being around some payments and hacking and that kind of thing. But
most businesses still see cyber as an IT risk as opposed to like a possible financial risk.
So I think that the whole business interruption conversations around cyber sort of improving,
and that's definitely something that we're finding at least is being underestimated
more so in the cyberspace. And Tom, turning to you,
what are you concerned about that your clients might be underestimating?
I'd have to agree. It's a big business interruption risk at the moment. It's probably
the most common claim that we're seeing pop up being business interruption. I think with the
most severe being ransomware. But I'm still getting a lot of clients saying, oh, we're not
going to get hit by ransomware. We're too small. Why would we be targeted? But there is really no,
you know, as we all know, there's no real filter for these threat actors. They'll target anyone
anytime. But in general, I think this take up of cyber is increasing, but it's not where we
want it to be. So as a whole, we're just trying to get clients to take it up more and just be
a bit more aware of the policy in general.
And Damien, what about you? Is business interruption the one you're worried about?
Yeah, absolutely. I think they make valid points, but I sort of feel that to Tom's point,
it's still around increasing that level of understanding and moving away from that sort
of typical she'll be right attitude. And I've got a managed service provider that handles everything
and we're too small and we're not going to be a target. So it's still those conversations and
coming up with more of the claims examples and showing them a process and behind it.
So that still is sort of one of the big things on my agenda at the moment.
It's an interesting question, isn't it? This whole, I mean, it's kind of going to take a
cultural shift, if you like, in New Zealanders and Australians, this she'll be right attitude.
You summed it up very nicely there. And let's stick with you, Damien, for our last question.
It's hard not to talk about the US-Iran conflict. And there's always the thought that this is going
to have a big effect on the cyber market and the types of cyber attacks. Are you seeing any changes
that are worth mentioning? I think it absolutely has to have an impact at some stage. But at this
stage, I don't think we have seen any changes. There's been a lot of bubbling, a lot of talk,
a lot of increased activity. What it is doing from an insurer's point of view is creating that
uncertainty. And that's pretty much the thing that insurers hate more than anything, because
they don't understand, they can't quantify. So I think that just that whole layer of uncertainty
from the political unrest side, and realising how interconnected, obviously, the market is.
So if there's a cyber event in the Middle East, for example, and you've got ties with share cloud
platforms or share software systems or whatever it might be, there's no real escape from it. So
I think that we haven't seen anything significant. But I think that whole underlying bubbling level
of uncertainty is probably first and foremost in insurers' minds. Declan, what about you? What are
your observations of the importance or not of this conflict so far? I'll probably follow on from
Damien. I think that we saw kind of similar to the Russia-Ukraine kind of conflict when that first
kicked things off. We saw a lot of insurers definitely in terms of tightening up their
policy wordings and that kind of thing to better protect themselves. But I know that also on the
I guess like these larger scale cyber campaigns, were they targeting cloud providers,
software vendors, larger cyber infrastructure? So I suspect that will be on a lot of insurers'
radars. Yeah, I guess. It's hard to know and it's probably a bit too early to tell,
but I know that some of those larger losses could be on insurers' radars and we may see
that start to affect pricing, but it's probably a bit too soon to tell.
Tom, what about you? Is it a bit early to tell or are you seeing some signs there of what the
impact might be? No, I'm not seeing signs at the moment. I would also say it's probably a bit early
to tell. We'll be watching it closely as with probably the world. However, I think the risk
remains the same, but for clients it's business as usual. We're pushing awareness with clients,
we're pushing preparedness, that's more of it. It's the old saying, it's not if but when,
couldn't be more real at the moment. So if anything, it's just a really heightened awareness
exercise for clients. But yeah, again, too early to tell with the market,
but again, we'll be watching it pretty closely. Great. Thanks very much, Tom. And thanks to
Business TV. Bye for now.
