"Get Off Our Roads, Mr Singh": US Government's Racist Poster
Sep 12, 2026
Imagine opening your phone and finding that message attached to a picture of someone who
looks like you, carries a name familiar to your community and is being confronted by a giant
robot. At best you think it's a joke. At worst you figure some crazy far right group has posted this.
What you probably would not expect is that it was posted by the United States Department of
Homeland Security. And alongside that message are the words America for Americans. Now there is a
fatal road collision behind this story and there are legitimate questions about a driver's actions,
commercial licenses and the responsibility of the authorities. All of that deserves serious
attention as it would for any such serious case involving anyone. But what we ended up with was
a government department using a transformer style graphic to tell Mr. Singh to get off American
roads. It was posted on 9th of September and the image has since been removed no doubt because of
the obvious backlash it would have provoked. I think it's important to look at what is actually
going on here and what the implications are of an official government body of one of the most
significant countries in the world putting out an image that looks like this and says what this says.
Let's get into all of that right after this.
So let's start with who is Mr. Singh. Well the Department of Homeland Security, the DHS says
the Mr. Singh reference is concerning Harjinder Singh, an Indian national accused of causing a
fatal collision in Florida. His immigration status itself has become politically disputed.
Authorities say that he entered the United States illegally in 2018 while California officials say
federal authorities had confirmed that he was legally present with a work permit when his
commercial license was issued. What is clear is that he obtained commercial driving licenses
in Washington and California and worked as a lorry driver. He is accused of making an illegal U-turn
in Florida and causing a collision that killed three people. Three lives lost and families left
dealing with the consequences. They deserve a thorough investigation and accountability for
whoever failed them whether that's the driver or the system that allowed them to be in control
of the vehicle. A heavy commercial vehicle carries enormous amount of destructive potential.
The whole system surrounding the person operating it has to take that seriously and as such should
be scrutinized. My questions would begin with the maneuver. What happened? What did the driver do?
What was going on with him? What should he have done? And then you follow the chain backwards.
Was he properly trained? Was he qualified? Had his competence been assessed adequately? Were his
documents checked? And if the system failed, investigate it and fix it. If somebody broke the
law, establish that through the proper process. If a training provider is waving people through,
deal with it. If an employer is cutting corners, hold them accountable. Each of those things could
help prevent the next tragedy and that's really what people should be looking at in the wake of
such an awful incident. Instead, somebody appears to have looked at this and decided
that the most useful contribution from Homeland Security would be a picture saying,
you don't know how to drive Mr Singh. Not Harjinder Singh, just a Mr Singh and by implication,
any person who is named Singh. I would love someone to explain to me the practical benefit
of casting such a wide net of expression. Does it improve training? Does it help an examiner
identify an unsafe driver? Does it stop an employer putting somebody unqualified behind
the wheel? I don't think so. What I can see it doing is encouraging people to associate a
particular name and appearance with incompetence and possibly becoming the recipient of anger and
hate. And that is where the story starts to become much more disturbing. The name Singh, for example,
is shared by millions of people. It is particularly associated with Sikh people,
although it does extend beyond the Sikh community. When you put Mr Singh beside the image of a brown
bearded man in the head covering, you are using something that is instantly recognisable. Then
it's not even about a Singh anymore. It becomes about the perception of the type of person
being shown in this image on this mock poster. Now, DHS may say it intended to refer to one
particular individual. But when people see this while scrolling, they don't think of one particular
driver accused of causing a road crash. Indeed, I didn't until I looked into it further after being
sent it to find out what is this all about? What most people will do is see it, jump to their
conclusions based on whatever their preconceived notions might be, get enraged, leave an angry
comment and then share it onwards, spreading hate further, whether intentional or not.
And then what happens? The next driver with a turban who pulls into a truck stop suddenly ends
up getting the wrong kind of attention. Associated Press has reported that the North American Punjabi
Truckers Association estimates Sikh drivers make up around 20% of America's trucking workforce,
while advocacy groups estimate that that's approximately 150,000 Sikh truck drivers
are working in the country. There is no definitive official count, so both of these figures should be
treated as estimates, but it's quite a lot. And unsurprisingly, the same reporting described that
Sikh drivers are experiencing harassment following that Florida crash. Think about the scale of that
community, but not just that. Think about the service that they provide. They are people driving
through the night, delivering food, collecting freight, managing vehicles, maintaining vehicles,
running businesses and spending days and nights away from their families. Then imagine one of
those drivers who has done his job responsibly for, say, 20 years. He checks his truck, he follows the
rules, he takes breaks when he's supposed to, he gets the load where it needs to get to safely,
and then he opens his phone and he sees a government, he sees his government presenting
someone with his name and appearance as a person who cannot drive and should get off the road.
How is he supposed to feel? What exactly has he done to deserve that? And why should the next
conversation that he has with a stranger begin under a cloud created by a juvenile government
communications team? Why should a law-abiding, hard-working, safe and dedicated worker be made
to feel he now has to apologize for the actions of a single driver just because they may share a
skin color or surname? The unfairness should be obvious that apparently needs to be pointed out,
especially when the insult itself concerns driving. Now, listen, I haven't driven in India,
but I have driven in Pakistan, and driving in Pakistan can require a level of constant observation
and awareness that people used to more predictable and organized traffic might find exhausting and
frankly traumatic. You are assessing the motorcycle coming alongside, the pedestrian approaching the
road, the bus, the pedestrian actually meandering across the road, the bus moving across the road,
the condition of the surface, and the possibility that that person is about to do something that
you hadn't considered, and then they go and do something entirely different anyway.
Also, you know, traffic lights might be optional. One-way signs are suggestions,
and a family of five could be perched on a single motorbike. You need to understand
movement. You need to anticipate. You need to judge space, speed, and intentions, sometimes
with very, very little room for error, and you need to remain calm enough throughout to make
sensible decisions while all of this chaos and craziness is happening around you. I would say,
put your average American driver accustomed to their familiar roads, wide lanes, and automatic
cars into some of those conditions, and I reckon they wouldn't survive 10 minutes before they
started hyperventilating. Now, I'm not condoning this kind of traffic chaos. I'm not saying that
one nation is a better nation than another when it comes to driving, but what I mean to say is that
driving in demanding conditions like these is challenging and does require skill,
and it is extremely unfair and short-sighted to make assumptions about someone's driving skills
based on where they come from, their skin color, or surname, or what they choose to wear on their
head. It's just an inherently arrogant thing to do. Now, to be fair, commercial truck drivers have
unique requirements, and rightly so. A person who can negotiate a crazy, busy street in a small car
still needs the appropriate training to operate a big, massive, heavy, destructive lorry. Experience
needs adapting to the vehicle and the country. Road rules matter. Understanding signs matter.
Being able to communicate in a safety-critical situation matters. All of that, however, can be
taught. So, if you want safer roads, demand better standards. Fund enforcement. Investigate
dangerous operators. Make sure the people making decisions know what they are doing.
Surely, a government department should understand that. Instead, somebody reached for Optimus Prime.
I do have to wonder how that meeting went. We got a serious issue involving commercial vehicles,
immigration enforcement, and people losing their lives. How should we communicate this?
I know, I know. Let's have a giant robot. Excellent. Give him a badge. What? Okay,
I kind of get it. It works on social media, right? If you have an action-movie-style poster,
then that image benefits from when you're scrolling through, your mind is trained to stop
and give it a look in case it's a movie that you've missed or that you want to see.
A familiar character, of course, also catches your attention. And you see an instantly recognizable
hero and someone there that that hero is confronting. It makes the message easy to
share and readily digestible. But look at what happens in the process. A human being
becomes the opponent in an action scene. Questions about evidence, individual circumstances,
and due process disappear behind this kind of pop culture imagery. And the poster is cheating.
By borrowing the emotional attachment people already have to that hero. What I mean is,
in the case of this particular example, think about it. People all over the world grew up with
Transformers. We remember the toys, the cartoons, and the films, and the values that were associated
with those characters. Optimus Prime is supposed to represent courage, leadership, righteousness,
self-sacrifice, and the importance of protecting others. Yes, okay, I get it. In vehicle form,
he's a semi. He's a big American lorry, right? So, hence maybe the reference. Ha ha ha. Very clever.
But he's so much more than that. He's a hero to millions globally. Hasbro, which owns the
Transformers brand, has been quick to respond. The company said the imagery had been used without
permission, disassociated his brand from the post, and highlighted the qualities associated with
Optimus Prime, including humility, compassion, and justice. So a toy company has had to explain
basic morality and heroism to the US government. Just think about that. And there's a further
complication, actually, with choosing Optimus Prime as a DHS agent. He comes from another planet.
You have recruited an alien robot to tell people that they don't belong in America. In fact,
it gets even more awkward because the original transforming truck toy that became Optimus Prime
came from Takara's Japanese Diaclone range. Hasbro adopted Japanese toys into the Transformers brand
and developed the characters and mythology that we know today. But even the supposedly all-American
hero that is being used to tell foreigners that they don't belong has itself an immigrant ancestry.
Do you think that someone might have maybe googled Optimus Prime before coming up with this official
government poster? Might have been a good idea, right? Now, you may think that I'm joking about
all of this, right? But if you're a fan of classic superheroes and pop culture icons,
this is actually really annoying. A much-loved character has been turned into a figure of
authoritarian state control and a vehicle for public humiliation, pun intended. The government
is dressing up the exercise of power as entertainment and it's just a horrible use of a beloved icon.
Check out Brown Car Guy's latest novel, Silent Ruin. Action, adventure, spies, betrayal, romance,
plus, of course, cool cars and car chases. It's got the lot. And don't forget how to be an
automotive content creator. The Uless Files and Quantum Races, all Brown Car Guy's books
are available on Amazon and Kindle Unlimited. And then you come to those three words,
America for Americans. So I guess they mean these people then, right? Because if we are deciding who
belongs to ancestral purity, an awful lot of pale faces are going to have to start packing.
Most Americans descend from people who arrive from Britain, Ireland, Germany, Italy, Scandinavia,
and, of course, Africa, Asia, and practically, in fact, everywhere else on earth. That is what
America is. And it's such a far-right style phrase as well. I mean, I've heard the same
thing here and it's not in a kind and welcoming way. England for the English. Which English?
The Anglo-Saxons came from continental Europe. Before them came Romans, Celts,
and farmers whose ancestors traveled from Anatolia, modern-day Turkey. They're the
guys that actually built Stonehenge. And before them, there were people such as, of course,
the famous Cheddar Man, whose DNA analysis indicates they had dark skin. That is where
these purity slogans collapse into nonsense. Being American is a nationality and a citizenship. It is
not an ethnicity. Anyway, the point is that a person born an American to Punjabi parents is an
American. A naturalized citizen wearing a turban is an American. Someone whose family has lived
there for generations remains American regardless of whether their face fits somebody's preferred
image of an American face or not. So who exactly is the poster addressing when they talk about
our roads? Because the man it has chosen to place on the receiving end looks South Asian to me,
does he not? The implication I see is that somebody who looks like him, looks like us,
has to explain his presence more so than a 25-foot alien robot. That is why I regard this image as
overtly racist and exclusionary, and why hearing it from an official government channel is frankly
so alarming. Just think about the practical consequences. You cannot look across at the
driver in the next lane and see his immigration status. You cannot determine citizenship from a
beard. You cannot distinguish between a visitor, a permanent resident, and somebody born down the
road by looking at their turban. But you can encourage suspicion of all of them by putting
that appearance into an official government post on social media. And once that suspicion is out
there, the person, actually all persons, are subjected to it and have to deal with it in real
life, at the fuel pump, at work, in front of their children. The official who helped publish the image
can grin at their perceived cleverness, close their laptop, and go home thinking nothing more
of it. Meanwhile, the entire brown population of a country is now being judged about how they drive
before they've even turned a wheel. Consequences, people! This should trouble anyone who thinks
government has to be responsible and to treat its people fairly. And this is what happens when a
government deliberately creates fear and suspicion of the other. Because, eventually, almost anyone
can become the other. I'll give you an example. You might imagine that an elderly white British
couple on a driving holiday would be about as safe from this as anyone could possibly be. Yet,
when Karen Newton and her husband were turned back at the Canadian border following problems
involving their vehicle paperwork and immigration status, she was shackled and spent six weeks
in US immigration detention, despite her visa actually being valid. DHS disputes parts of her
account and says the couple had a history of overstaying, but that still leaves serious
questions about why a 65-year-old tourist was restrained, separated from her husband,
and held for six weeks and reportedly made to sleep on the floor. One moment they were driving
along thinking about fuel, directions, where they're going to stop for lunch, and the next
their freedom is entirely in the hands of a system increasingly encouraged to regard anyone from
somewhere else with suspicion. So, yes, it can happen to brown people, but when you create fear
and suspicion of the other, it can happen to anyone. It can happen to you. And that is the
context in which a government publishing this juvenile threatening imagery becomes especially
unsettling. Because the people behind the messaging belong to institutions with real power over human
beings. Now, coming back to the case of Mr. Singh, one individual case using the message cast
suspicion across a vast community, a vast community of hard-working people that are serving the
community, right? Why should the Sikh driver with a clean record have to carry that accusation? Why
should the Asian family in the car beside him wonder whether they will also receive the same
hostility? Why should an American citizen have to defend his place in his own country because his
government has made someone with his appearance into a target? I find this disgusting. And I find
the casualness of it almost as horrifying as the message itself. The idea of it, the heroic imagery,
the insulting line, the fact that it comes from a government account. Somewhere in that process,
someone should have had the judgment to ask, wait, wait, wait, wait, what are we doing here? Should
we be putting this out? I mean, we are talking about people's livelihoods, their dignity, their
safety. We are talking about the possibility of encouraging strangers to treat them with contempt
and even outright hatred. All for the sake of a shareable image on social media. And yes, okay,
it has been removed, but why the hell was it published in the first place? I mean, who authorised
it? Why? How? And could it happen again? Yeah, probably it could actually. Just deleting the
leaves every one of those questions unanswered. My concern is the mentality that allowed it to
appear in the first place. The assumption that that was an acceptable way for a government
to speak about human beings, indeed about the people that reside in its country. Childish
racism becomes considerably more frightening when the institution publishing it also has the power
to detain and deport people. And if you still think I'm making a mountain out of a molehill,
then you haven't been on the receiving end of prejudice, insult and attack by someone easily
influenced by such casually dangerous messaging. I do know that many Americans will also be appalled
by this. And I hope that they demand answers because the drivers already living and working
there deserve a government that treats them with respect. They deserve to pull into a truck stop
without a federal social media campaign having helped turn their face into a reason for suspicion.
They deserve to be judged on how they actually drive. I mean, that is the standard that I care
about on this channel, right, which is an automotive motoring channel, you know,
competence, responsibility, awareness and consideration for other people. Somehow the
US government has managed to produce a driving or road safety type campaign that demonstrates a
remarkable shortage of all four of those things. So tell me what you think. Has this changed how
you feel about visiting America? And if you are a Sikh or a South Asian truck driver working over
there, I'd particularly love to hear what you think about this and what your experiences are.
I look forward to reading the comments and I'll catch you all in the next video.
If you found this video useful or entertaining, support the BrownCarGuy channel at these links.
Hit like, leave a comment and make sure you're subscribing.

