Governments Keep Getting EVs Wrong. Is Pakistan Next?
Nov 12, 2026
An electric car could be the best car that you've ever owned.
Put the same car into the wrong circumstances, however,
and it could become your most expensive frustration.
Yet government policy seems remarkably preoccupied
with changing what you buy,
while the circumstances in which you'll actually own it seem
to receive rather less attention.
So recently there's some news out of Pakistan where
that government too is now moving towards
pushing the EV.
A responsible and sensible position, you might think.
But I know that market to a little extent,
and I can't help but feel that the same mistakes
are being made all over again.
You know, putting the cart before the horse,
chasing soundbites and headlines rather than
sensible policy solutions,
and drinking the EV Kool-Aid without tempering it with the
reality of what will actually work
for real everyday motorist lives and needs.
And often the people drinking
the Kool-Aid actually have very little understanding.
Of what they're drinking, let's put it that way.
As ever, I have to make this point right up front
because some people think that I am pro-EV
while others reckon that I'm anti-EV.
I am, in fact, neither.
In fact, I'll be hosting an EV event later this month
in ExCeL London, the London EV Show.
But as I've always maintained, mobility for me
or mobility solutions are about the right vehicle
for the right person in the right set of circumstances.
And trying to shoehorn a square peg
into a round hole as ever, never works.
And often you can end up doing more damage
to any sensible and logical endeavors
by pushing solutions that markets are not actually ready for.
Pakistan's proposed automotive policy might
be yet another example of this.
It's not necessarily fair, of course,
to single out that country in this regard alone,
because nations all over the world are pursuing
this kind of directive to transition to EVs.
But this news that just came out.
I read it and I have to say I felt like I could put
a little bit more context behind it because
I've been there, I've driven there
and I kind of have an understanding of what motoring is
like over there. So let's get into all of that right after this.
A brown card guy.
Pakistan announced the final draft
of its new automotive policy on the 7th of November.
Ministers say they want affordable vehicles,
stronger local manufacturing, exports and more electric mobility.
The draft still requires cabinet approval.
Part of the proposal is a levy on combustion-engined
vehicles above 1,000 cc to help fund EV incentive.
There's already a tax on combustion vehicles intended
to support EV adoption, so how this
new charge fits alongside I guess still needs
a bit of explaining as I understand it.
Other proposed changes could bring some car prices down,
meaning the final cost to buyers
overall will remain uncertain.
But you can see that familiar carrot and stick approach, can't you?
Offer financial support to encourage people into EVs
while putting an extra charge on petrol cars
to try and put people off them.
And that risks getting ahead of reality. Charging infrastructure
there is still developing. Electricity reliability remains a concern
and many motorists have perfectly
practical reasons for choosing petrol cars.
In fact, for most motorists, especially in rural
places, that's really the only solution that will make sense.
At least for now.
I mean, an EV incentive could certainly help someone
make the switch to an electric car.
But what good does the saving do for them
if they don't actually have anywhere to plug it in?
And also think about this.
Somebody that might be coming out of an old car
and buying a new one,
they might end up with an electric thing
that they can't plug in
instead of having bought a more efficient cleaner
because it's newer, presumably,
petrol car to replace their...
you know smelly old thing.
On the other hand it could also be argued that because of the levy on
the petrol car you're asking that person
to basically fund somebody else's switch to an EV
and at the same time you haven't really helped them out
in terms of making an EV fit their
lifestyle needs. So if you look at it
that way you can understand why the whole thing feels
A little bit like a punishment.
And then there's the electricity supply.
I mean, this is a serious consideration in that country.
Pakistan's regulator found
that every distribution company assessed fell short of its standard
for how often customers experienced power interruptions.
Some performed.
considerably worse than others,
so your EV ownership experience could depend heavily
on where you live. I mean it's easy enough to say
that you know your national grid is sufficient to
manage a transition to EVs and that could well be true,
but a country that can generate enough
electricity overall could still struggle
to deliver it reliably to an individual's home.
That's just in fact a daily reality to people living
in Pakistan with their infrequent power
Power outages that they've...
Often have and I know that from speaking
to relatives and friends out there.
It's a fairly fundamental consideration to be honest with an EV
when you're considering
you know your next journey
and you're dependent upon how you're going to charge your car before
you set off. And this is the problem really isn't it?
How fair is it to make motorists
effectively pay more before you've actually given them
a workable alternative? I mean you
can wave a financial stick at someone all day
but it won't put a reliable always-on charger
Let's imagine two people buying the same EV.
The first has secure parking, a properly installed charger,
dependable electricity and a fairly
predictable daily journey.
They can plug in when convenient,
start the next day with sufficient range for where they
need to go and really would need a public charging stop.
For them, that EV...
Could be wonderfully straightforward and perfect for their daily needs.
It's quiet, it's smooth, it's responsive,
and the charging just fits around their life.
They might actually wonder why everyone else
is making such a fuss over it.
The second person, however, lives in a flat,
parks wherever they can find a space when they get home
the night before, and sometimes has to travel
a great distance at short notice. Their nearest
convenient public charger might require a considerable detour,
a wait, or has a tariff
that changes their entire running cost calculation.
They'd be working people, probably,
Expected to get their job done.
And yet they're stuck charging.
And when they are late in getting
their work done, they'll be shouted at.
And then the next time that there is a power outage, it could be worse.
They could be sacked.
How will they keep that expensive new EV
that has lost them their job in the first place?
Of course, an EV could work for their lifestyle,
but that will depend on the local network,
on whether they have charging at their workplace,
and of course, their willingness to plan
their day ahead. But they deserve to understand
this arrangement before they are agreeing
to buy an EV. Somebody might say,
my EV is brilliant, but ask them how do they use it
And where do they charge it?
And similarly...
And another person might say, mine was a complete nightmare.
And if they do say that, be sympathetic.
I mean, clearly they've tried to make it work,
but the world simply wasn't ready or equipped for it yet.
Again, find out why and how.
This tells us far more than government ministers
trying to look progressive and responsible in the face of reality.
Remember, your first responsibility as a government is to your people.
Now look at what's been happening, say, right here in the UK.
This is another carrot and stick scenario.
Although here the legal pressures actually fall
on the manufacturers, with dealers and
consumers feeling the consequences.
So what we have here is a ZEV mandate,
which requires manufacturers to sell an increasing
proportion of electric vehicles.
But the headline targets have been running ahead of demand,
leaving the industry relying
on heavy discounts, attractive finance,
and the scheme's various credits, system and
and flexibilities that exist in it to bridge the gap.
Now, in fact, the target themselves are being reviewed,
the ZEV mandate targets, that is.
The latest consultation just closed in October,
and we're waiting to hear what changes the
government might make.
As soon as I hear anything, of course,
I will bring you that news, so just keep it locked
to my channels.
But consider the pressure that this has created.
Manufacturers need to shift electric cars to meet their obligations,
while plenty of customers, well, they still want something else.
And that can influence which cars are offered,
how they are priced,
and how enthusiastically the dealer tries to steer you
towards a particular powertrain,
whether it suits your lifestyle or not.
Then there's a financial knock-on effect, right?
Heavy discounts might help the next buyer of that electric car
when it hits the used market,
but they can also undermine the value of cars that people already own.
If a brand new EV suddenly becomes substantially cheaper
as soon as you get the tires dirty
once you've driven it off the forecourt,
what does that do to the secondhand one
that is sitting on your driveway?
It devalues it, right?
The market value has dropped.
We've seen that.
We've seen the massive depreciation
that hits brand new EVs.
In fact, I made another video, if you want to buy an EV,
the best thing is to buy a three-year-old
one. You will save a ton of money in some cases.
I'm talking tens of thousands. So owners take a
hit when they sell or they part exchange.
And leasing companies can lose money when returned
cars end up fetching less than they had calculated.
Now, those losses can feed into future finance
Finance problems too.
Depreciation has several causes,
including changing technology, competition, and the
supply of used cars, but fundamentally,
there is this concern over the perceived value of
these cars.
Policy-driven pressure to discount adds another complication.
And for the brands themselves, repeatedly slashing prices
risk weakening confidence in their brand values,
in what their cars are actually worth.
So the manufacturer, you know,
traditionally manufacturers never used to do this.
They used to try and maintain use values as high as possible
because that gave their brand value.
Now the opposite is happening
and it's not really even in their control.
My concern is that pushing sales faster than
the ownership proposition develops can create
expensive problems throughout the market.
In fact, we have seen that.
You can put manufacturers under pressure
to supply electric cars, but persuading motorists
to want them requires affordable,
dependable ownership that fits within their lifestyle
needs.
Now, to be fair, there's a serious argument
for government intervention, and it does deserve
a hearing.
Governments have reasons to act on transport emissions,
urban air quality and dependence on imported fuel.
In India and Pakistan, for example,
air pollution is a serious health issue, and vehicle exhausts
certainly contribute to it.
Fuel costs can also put considerable pressure on household budgets,
especially with what's
happening now in the world.
When people are concentrating on earning a living,
feeding their families, and keeping
their transport running,
environmental considerations can understandably slip down their list of
priorities choosing a cleaner alternative
It requires money, access
and the confidence that it will actually do the job.
At the same time, when it comes to India and Pakistan,
to be fair, there is a resourcefulness
in the subcontinent that also does deserve recognition.
Repairing things, reusing them
and keeping them going can be an economic necessity.
I mean, I have seen spark plugs being reconditioned.
Now, this is recycling in action.
This is not a wasteful throwaway society.
So kudos for that.
But all the practical pieces still have
to come together before EVs start to make sense.
A charging company wants
to have customers before investing in a charging network.
A customer wants a charging network before thinking of buying an EV.
A manufacturer of EVs wants to have confidence that demand will grow
before committing to investing in production of EVs.
Everybody's waiting for somebody else to go first.
Now, policy can help them move together.
Predictable incentives, clear standards,
and sensible requirements can give businesses
confidence to invest and motorist confidence to switch.
And we have to be realistic.
Vehicles and infrastructure will develop together.
Expecting a completely finished national charging network
before another EV can be sold
would leave everyone just waiting indefinitely.
That's never going to happen.
However, governments should explain who pays during that development,
who benefits during that development,
and how they'll protect people with limited alternatives
to what they're imposing upon them.
If you can afford the subsidized EV
and have somewhere dependable to charge it,
the policy could work nicely for you.
But if you still need a petrol car,
an extra charge to buy that petrol car
can feel like another hardship that's piled onto
your already stretched budget.
You're helping fund the transition
that you yourself can't actually participate in.
Not yet, anyway.
And that's hardly going to win electric cars any new fans, is it?
Here's the risk I think policymakers underestimate.
Imagine someone stretches their budget
because the incentives look attractive and the alternatives
are becoming more expensive.
Then charging proves inconvenient. The local support is poor
or a breakdown becomes a difficult thing to resolve.
What story will they tell their family?
Probably something along the lines of, I tried one, never again.
Their experience may involve a particular
car or inadequate support or a purchase that
never really suited their circumstances.
But in conversation, all of that can collapse
into an overall verdict on electric cars generally.
You can see how that could create lasting distrust.
How much it contributes to wider EV skepticism
is difficult to pin down without proper research,
but it seems a risk worth considering when designing policy.
A satisfied owner can be a persuasive advert for others.
But a disappointed owner has a story too,
and their relatives may hear it in excruciating detail
at the next 10 weddings, possibly with photographs on their phone.
Building confidence means showing people
that somebody has thought through the ownership
experience, including charging, running costs,
servicing, what happens when it all goes wrong
and what happens end of life of that car.
That's the reassurance that people need before spending
their money on technology that for
some of them still feels unfamiliar, complicated and a little alien.
They need to be able to picture how it will fit
into their everyday lives.
Then there's the emergency preparedness, right?
Britain and America have spent years
developing training and procedures for dealing
with electric vehicles after accidents. We have
guidance covering recovery,
repairs and even the safe storage of damaged EVs.
Preparing the people who deal with these cars takes time,
equipment, training and investment.
So how far has that work progressed in Pakistan?
Its existing EV policy does call for emergency service training,
including Rescue 1122,
and the procedures for handling battery fires
and accidents. Now that's encouraging,
but now we need to know how much has actually
been delivered, where and whether
The equipment and expertise are actually keeping pace
with the cars that they want to have on their roads.
If an EV has a serious accident,
can the local rescue crew handle it safely?
Can the recovery operator transport it correctly?
Does the receiving garage know how to assess the battery
and where to store the vehicle safely?
Then consider the conditions.
Those vehicles might encounter in that part of the world, right?
In areas affected by flooding,
there are badly broken roads or washed away surfaces.
How well suited is an EV to those environments?
What happens after a flood happens
and the car is exposed to water damage
and the substantial impact that might occur underneath the car?
Battery protection, ground clearance
and access to qualified inspections for that car.
All of these things matter and will become very important.
A damaged battery can present electrical hazards and,
in some circumstances, a delayed fire risk.
Owners and the people handling
the vehicle need to have clear procedures.
Floods and broken roads create problems for any car.
EV adoption brings additional training and handling requirements
that need to be built into the response.
And if a road is washed away
or electricity is out for an extended period,
how will stranded motorists be supported?
These are all practical questions that governments
and manufacturers should be able to answer
as adoption grows, but we need to have some of those answers now.
After all, the responsibility
for these vehicles continues long after the showroom handover,
right through to the roadside, the recovery truck,
the repair workshop, you know, after sales.
Create car content.
Brown Car Guy has written the only comprehensive guide
that tells you exactly how.
Get it now from Amazon or Kindle Unlimited.
Then there's China.
And I can't help being a little cynical here.
Chinese manufacturers have plenty of cars to sell
and strong reasons to find more customers overseas.
According to the International Energy Agency,
China produced about 20% more electric cars
than its domestic market bought in 2025.
That number is expected to be higher,
I reckon, this year as well.
Overseas sales help keep those factories busy.
Pakistan could offer another growing market.
Its government has already discussed Chinese investment
in car production, charging infrastructure
and in training.
And that could bring real benefits, more affordable cars,
jobs, skills, better support for owners.
But how much of that will actually reach ordinary Pakistanis?
How much manufacturing will actually happen locally?
And who will maintain these cars,
supply the parts and honour the warranties in five or
ten years' time?
Then there's the political relationship.
Pakistan has long cultivated powerful allies
and neighbouring China is a particularly important one.
It already supplies much of Pakistan's military hardware.
Islamabad has considerable reasons to keep Beijing on side.
So I think it's fair to ask whether the relationship
could be influencing the enthusiasm for Chinese electric cars.
Could Pakistan be offering a convenient outlet
for China's growing vehicle production
while moving too quickly past questions about charging,
electricity supply, road conditions,
and affordability
and even usability for the regular motorists in the country? Of course,
All of that is speculation on my part.
We can't say for sure that that is what is actually happening here.
And after all, Pakistan does have
legitimate reasons to tackle pollution
and reduce its dependence on imported oil.
But environmental ambitions,
commercial interests and political priorities can all overlap.
The concern is whether the political enthusiasm
is running ahead of the practical preparations.
Are ordinary motorists' needs getting the attention that they deserve?
Have the people promoting the transition properly considered
how it will work in Pakistanis' everyday lives and conditions?
This is Brown Car Guy's exciting new thriller.
New York Times bestselling author Rick Hoskin said of it,
it's a spy story through a different lens.
Get it now at Amazon or Kindle Unlimited.
So what would a credible transition actually look like?
Well, I'd start with five practical tests
to help people switch with confidence.
First, charging that people can actually use. Working
chargers in useful places with clear prices,
affordable ones, and easy payment. Pakistan has
talked about around 3,000 public charging facilities by 2030,
which I don't think would
be enough to be honest. But okay, that's fine.
But you're encouraging people to buy EVs today.
Where can they reliably charge them today, not in 2030?
This is a question that needs to be answered.
Second, recognize that people's lives work differently.
Some people can charge on their driveway, maybe.
Others will need to charge at work or near their flat
or somewhere along their normal route.
The arrangements have to fit their lives with safe installations
and dependable electricity supply.
All right, third.
First, be honest about the costs involved.
Show buyers what they'll pay for finance,
charging, insurance and servicing and explain
what the warranty covers.
If the savings depend on cheap home charging, say so.
Someone relying on public charges needs figures
that reflect those circumstances so they can
understand what their monthly outgoings are going to be.
Fourth, build the support network as sales grow.
Train technicians, recovery operators,
emergency responders, available spare parts and proper
consumer protection.
People need confidence that help will be there
when and if they need it.
And fifth, publish progress on all of that alongside the sales figures.
If a region is struggling...
Identify the problem, explain who will fix it and how,
and then give a realistic timetable
for that to happen.
Different vehicles will also become practical at different speeds.
A bus or lorries or electric rickshaws returning
to a depot may have a predictable route and
a planned charging window that can all be controlled
and orchestrated and organized.
But a private car doing unpredictable journeys faces
a very different set of challenges.
The former might already make sense today, but the latter might not.
But even having said that, even
a depot charging needs enough power and enough time
to make sure to get those vehicles ready for work every day, right?
Each of these things needs policymakers
who understand the job that the vehicle does,
the conditions that it operates in, and what could go wrong.
They need to look at all worst case scenarios
as well as best case scenarios.
So this is where I get frustrated.
Electric cars can be excellent in the right circumstances.
They can make somebody's motoring life easier,
cheaper and more enjoyable.
Surely government policy should help
more people reach those circumstances.
Instead, we keep reaching for targets, taxes and financial pressure
while motorists are still wondering what an EV actually is.
I mean for a lot of people it's a case of what is it?
Where do I charge it? What will it actually
cost? Who will fix it? What happens if I break down?
What happens if I run out of electricity?
What happens if the battery goes flat?
What happens if the car gets damaged?
These questions deserve proper answers before people are asked
to stretch their budgets and change fundamentally how they get around.
And if somebody still needs a petrol car,
making it more expensive leaves them with less money
and exactly the same practical obstacles
and less incentive to actually trade up to a cleaner,
more efficient car, which ultimately would
also be beneficial to the environment.
You can understand why they might resent.
The fact that if they have to pay more for their petrol car,
they're hoping to fund someone else's
subsidized EV and yet their own solutions are not being
or their own problems are not being
resolved. Whether it's Pakistan,
Britain or anywhere else, motorists deserve policies that
are built around the lives that they actually lead.
Governments should be able to demonstrate
the benefits for ordinary people alongside
the benefits for manufacturers, investors
And political allies.
Show us the working charges,
show us the actual realistic costs, show us the trained people,
the spare parts supply and the support if something should go wrong.
Give people a compelling ownership proposition.
If you do that, you give them a natural reason to switch.
Push them into a purchase that makes their lives harder
and their disappointment could
damage confidence in electric cars for years to come.
A target for 2030 needs a workable plan
and the transition needs to work on people's
driveways as convincingly as it works in a minister's speech.
Earn the switch.
Give people confidence.
Make the car fit their lives.
Tell me where you're watching this video
from and what would make an EV a sensible choice for you?
Or if you already own one, what made it work? And if it hasn't worked,
what went wrong? These are the experiences
that we need actually to compile to help policymakers
listen to our needs before they reach for that stick and carrot again.
Thanks so much for watching. Hope you enjoyed this,
found it useful. Make sure you hit like,
Like, share, subscribe, all the rest of it.
And I'll catch you in the next one.
Please support independent content creators.
You can support Brown Car Guy at these links.
And make sure you hit like, leave a comment,
share this video and don't forget to subscribe.
It all helps, it really does.
So please do it!

