There soon will be tens of thousands of satellites in orbit. Possibly, even millions. Does it mean that ground-based Astronomy is a lost cause? How can we make it work? Also, how is New Horizons doing?
00:00 Intro 00:57 How's New Horizons doing 02:17 Next target 08:43 More science for New Horizons 11:07 Possible follow-up missions 13:18 Funding issues 19:05 New Horizons continues to do science 23:48 Mega-constellations vs ground-based astronomy 39:54 Current obsessions 44:27 Final thoughts
00:00 Intro 01:16 Escaping the gravity well 06:53 Limiting factors 09:47 Rockets 15:18 Can a civilizations get trapped 20:51 Current obsessions 27:09 Final thoughts
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Alan Stern discusses the enduring health of the New Horizons spacecraft and its ongoing search for Kuiper Belt targets. He highlights groundbreaking discoveries on Pluto and Arrokoth, the urgent need for nuclear propulsion to shorten deep-space travel, and the necessity of moving research telescopes into space to escape interference from satellite mega-constellations.
We're at this moment in history where the satellite mega constellations are really
starting to take off. There are over 10,000 satellites today. There are plans for hundreds
of thousands, maybe even millions with data centers in space. Is this the end of ground
based astronomy? My guest today is Alan Stern. He's the principal investigator for the New
Horizons spacecraft. He's a member of the science team on Lucy, and he is making the
argument that the astronomy community is going to need to adapt to the rise of the
mega constellations. They kind of feel inevitable, but there is this backlash. There is this
time when people can put pressure on governments to try and drive funding to provide space
telescopes to adapt to the rise of the mega constellations. So if you're interested in
just what's happening with New Horizons, if you want to know about the Lucy mission,
and if you want to hear Alan's take on how the astronomy community can deal with the
rise of the satellite mega constellations, I think you're going to enjoy this episode
quite a bit. Alan, it's great to see you again.
Pleasure. It's great to see you. Thanks for having me on.
Well, so we've got a ton of things to talk about, but let's start obviously with New
Horizons. How is the spacecraft doing?
You know, it's been launched over 20 years, almost 21 now, and the spacecraft is performing
perfectly. Nothing on it's broken. The spacecraft is almost as good as new. All seven scientific
instruments are operating and our engineers think we have the power and the fuel to run
it to 2050. How's that?
I sort of compare what's happening with the Voyagers and sort of like, you know, same
kind of power system and then just offset it, right?
That's right. And launched with much more, you know, sophisticated and modern gear because
it was launched in the 21st century, not back in the 1970s.
So power, not so power hungry, more efficient, more technology to be able to power management
on the on the software, on the yes, and much more sensitive scientific instrumentation,
higher data rates, things like that. Yeah. A lot more smarts on board.
I mean, it's a way to make people feel like, yeah, it's been 10 years more since we saw
those first pictures of of Pluto, which is crazy. Yeah.
And then, of course, we got the the images of Veracruz. So I think the first question
that I get from a lot of people is, what are your options to find another target?
Well, we're looking pretty hard. Yeah. Realize that as you go farther out, things get much
harder because the sunlight dims like the square of the distance and it has to go out
like R squared and then back like R squared. So it dims like the fourth power of the distance.
We're now twice as far out as Pluto. Two to the fourth power is 16 times harder
to find things than when we were looking for Arrokoth.
Compare, you know, in your mind, the height of a one story building to a 16 story building
and you get a feel for what a difference that is. We've been using the Subaru telescope in Hawaii
It's the best wide field combination of camera and large aperture telescope.
But it turns out the Vera Rubin Observatory, commissioned by the National Science Foundation,
can do better. And so just in the past year, it started to look at our field.
And we're looking forward to having discoveries there of Kuiper Belt objects we can observe and
maybe one we can fly by. But even better is the Roman Space Telescope that was launched yesterday
relative to this taping. And Roman is 50 times better than anything on the surface of the Earth
for this purpose. And it's even better than James Webb because it's again a wide field camera.
And we'd love to get and we're trying to get some Roman Space Telescope time because that's our
best shot at getting another flyby target. And the spacecraft, as I said, is perfectly healthy.
All the instruments are working. There's nothing more that we would like to do than to have
flyby of some ancient beast out near 100 astronomical units
and see what the solar system built way that far from the sun.
Yeah. I mean, I wonder what kind of science, I mean, you saw Pluto and then you saw Arrokoth,
which was much farther than Pluto. And now, as you said, now you're double the distance. And so
a lot of even the forces that we see, like an atmosphere in Pluto, we see maybe the hint of
some kind of fluid seeping out of Pluto. Once you're that far away, what kinds of objects,
you know, what kind of behavior would you be looking for?
Well, the object that we'll go to is no doubt going to be a small one,
similar in size to Arrokoth, for example. So this is a planetesimal. It's the size of
a county or a city, not the size of a whole world like Pluto.
But these are the building blocks of planets. And what we want to know is how does it compare
in the way that it was built and the time scale that it was built over and how it's evolved
relative to Arrokoth, which is the most pristine object ever studied by humankind up close.
And now twice as far out, if we can get another flyby target, we want to compare
those types of same kinds of bodies, but formed twice as far from the Sun.
And really, there's no other spacecraft that can do this in the foreseeable future,
because nothing's being built to come our way. This is our only shot.
And, you know, the science is still coming home from New Horizons. And it's funny how much we're
continuing to report on discoveries made by New Horizons. And I think the most exciting,
interesting one was just like in the last month or so about, you know, evidence that there's some
kind of liquid maybe seeping out, you know, maybe liquid nitrogen coming out of the interior of
Pluto. So what are some of the, what's some of the science that you're still keeping an eye on with
Pluto and Charon? Well, the one you just mentioned is a biggie, I think. And, you know, I'm a little
bit biased because I'm the first author in that paper, in which we interpret some geological
evidence to indicate that liquids have recently flowed on the surface of the big glacier called
Sputnik Planitia, the left side of Pluto's heart, if you will, when you look at an image.
And we came up with some mechanisms and a computer model of them for how you can
produce liquid nitrogen beneath the glacier, and then bring it up through conduits to the
surface where it spreads out. And this is not only a new kind of activity on Pluto,
but also the first evidence for flowing liquids in the present day era,
which I think is really important on a widespread basis over hundreds of miles of terrain.
So that's pretty interesting. There's new evidence for a liquid water ocean
deep beneath the surface of Pluto. There's new results coming out on the atmosphere
and on the satellites. And, you know, as people mine the data and start to do much more serious
computer modeling than we could at first when we were just choking every image down and just
reacting rather than being able to do things more carefully, now you're really seeing the science
mature. And the same is true at Arrokoth. Those data have been on the ground now for, you know,
half a dozen years and that's maturing as well. So, you know, these planetary missions are the
gift to keep on giving. They may take their data quickly in a short period of time,
but the analysis of those data and the maturation of thought about it and the testing of scientific
ideas and the modeling, you know, takes a while. We saw that with Voyager. We saw it with Cassini.
We saw it with Galileo. It's really the norm because people have to digest it and think
about it and then do real work like computer modeling and report results. And then there's
a reaction to that, this follow-up, and that's how it builds.
And all this, in many cases, just in one quick flyby. I mean, there's just the bursts of activity
and then just people are digesting the science that was done in that.
Well, we built that spacecraft to take data like a firehose and have large solid-state
memories and fast bus speeds on the spacecraft so we could, in the short time that we were going by,
in that one week, and most notably in that one day, that we could fill volumes. And in fact,
we did about as much work in the first Pluto flyby as the first six missions to Mars did
combined. That's just the advantage of modern technology. Instead of 60s or 70s technology,
it's 2000s era technology, spacecraft and instrumentation alike.
And so, you know, I find a lot of this stuff, you know, these are, they give you answers,
but they often generate more questions. And I think when we went into this the first time around,
you were talking about the kinds of scientific questions that you were interested in answering.
And so now here you are on the other side of this, but I'm guessing that the questions are
coming faster than the answers are. So what are the questions that you now have
about the outer solar system? Well, we'd like to know
a lot of things about the outer solar system. We've, one of the big revolutions that's taken
place is our understanding that the earth is kind of an oddball. It wears its oceans on the outside.
And in the outer solar system, we see lots of evidence from liquid water oceans at Pluto,
at Titan, at Europa, at many of the icy satellites. And of course, Enceladus is one good example that
I think a lot of your listeners know about. Are those biologically active sites? That's a very
important question because now we know that the whole concept of a habitable zone is different
when you can have liquid water in the outer solar system, even in the Kuiper belt.
Very important. We'd like to understand if the accretion mode for Arrokoth, which is due to
gentle, slow accretion, is typical because that changes our whole idea of how planets were built
from what we used to think back in the 20th century. We'd really like to understand what
powers Pluto's engine. It's such a small planet. Why didn't it cool off by now like the Earth's
moon did, for example, and many of the other icy satellites of giant planets that are comparable
or nearly comparable in size? Why is Pluto different? And how widespread is that?
Another big question is why are the planets of the Kuiper belt so diverse? They have different
colors, different compositions, different satellite systems, different densities. Why is that? Why
aren't they all cookie cutter? But they seem to be a very heterogeneous population, probably as
diverse or more diverse than the terrestrial planets down here. Why is that? There's a lot
of big questions running around. We need to do a lot more exploration to get to the bottom of them.
We need more missions, commercial spaces, creating innovations, and dropping prices.
I think the 21st century is going to be a hold on to your hat ride for space exploration.
A couple more questions about New Horizons. This sounds like a whole bunch of other stuff that I
know you're working on. I think the last time we talked, you had put out a new proposal for
a potential follow-on mission to go back to Pluto. Maybe this time to stay, maybe an orbiter.
Have you had a chance to progress some of those ideas?
Have not. The difficulty is that when the Planetary Decadal Survey of the National
Academy of Sciences met early in the decade, they placed much higher priority on going back to
Uranus or Neptune and doing some other things than going all the way back out there
to the Pluto system. It is a long haul. With current technology, putting an orbiter there
is something like a 20 or 25-year flight time. Because you can't go fast all the way,
you have to come to a stop. So it takes a lot longer than New Horizons.
Now that said, there are companies, a wide variety of them, that are working on
different kinds of nuclear fission and even nuclear fusion propulsion that can speed up
our crossing of the solar system by a factor of 10. You could get to Pluto in one year instead
of a decade. You could put an orbiter there in a couple of years instead of a couple of decades.
Similarly, it'll speed up human Mars missions and other things. And we really need that. We
need to get past the sailing ships and to the era of at least steam engines.
You know, one of the really great ideas that's come along and, you know,
really captured everybody's imagination is this idea of the solar gravitational lens. And I think
there's ideas about interstellar probes that would actually get out into the, you know,
beyond the heliosphere, in the places that New Horizons is approaching at this point.
That's right.
And then, as you said, you know, maybe missions to Uranus. Like, the outer solar system is more
and more of a priority, and it just comes back to the laws of physics. Better propulsion systems.
That's what we need. And, you know, the Chinese are already planning an interstellar mission.
They're going to launch at least two spacecraft in different directions to get out into
interstellar space. I wish we were doing that here in the United States.
You know, one of the concerns that we had a couple of years ago was that there was some
issues with funding. A lot of NASA projects were kind of on the chopping block, and then
Congress stepped in and restored funding, and all of these missions weren't cancelled or
postponed or any of that. You know, what is the sort of stability at this point of New Horizons?
Are you guys safe?
The spacecraft and the mission team is safe now. We've been through those battles, and
I think we're past that. The current extended mission lasts through almost the very end of 2029,
so three years from now, roughly. We have two priorities for that extended mission.
One is to study the Kuiper Belt, and the other is to study the outer heliosphere,
the sun's environment, as the Voyagers did, as we approach now interstellar space,
where Voyager already is. Unfortunately, on the helioscience side, there are some funding issues.
We don't have enough funding to keep the heliospheric instruments
working and the spacecraft transmitting data 12 months a year. For lack of a couple of million
dollars a year, which is pretty small potatoes in a $25 billion NASA budget, we're having to
close down the two heliospheric instruments. We'll have a significant gap in the data they've
returned, if not a very long gap of years, because we can no longer afford to run them and to keep
the spacecraft operating the way that it turned those data. It's a crying shame. It's super
science. It's been peer-reviewed and ranked at the very top of the priorities for New Horizons,
and yet we just need a little bit more money in order to be able to make it come true now.
Every year things get more expensive and our dollars buy less.
But in this case, I mean, it's not like the heliospheric instruments require
electricity or some kind of ongoing funding. You're talking about it's funding the salaries
of people to process the data and make it available and keep an eye on the instruments.
It's more than just that. It's also funding the mission control team
to command, plan, and then command the spacecraft. In the last year, for example,
we were hibernating because we don't need mission controllers when we're hibernating
for 11 months. And during that time, we can't send commands to the spacecraft and we can't
receive any data from the spacecraft. And that means it builds up a backlog of data
while it's recording from the scientific instruments. But it all comes down to paying
people, the flight planners, the mission controllers, the science team.
And we don't have an electricity bill on the spacecraft. The electricity is free.
It comes from our radioisotope thermoelectric generator. And we don't get a phone bill either.
The DSN doesn't actually send us a bill every month. We do need to pay people to plan the
mission, operate the instruments and the spacecraft. And then we need to pay scientists to
process the data, make science out of the ones and zeros, and archive the data in the public
archives that NASA has so that they're there for perpetuity. And we don't have enough to do all
that. And I hope we can get that fixed. It shouldn't be a big problem.
One of the questions that I get from my audience is, is there a way to have some kind of
collaboration? Another heliospheric science group could adopt those instruments. Maybe Canada,
or some really good work out of Europe and things like that.
Are those kinds of collaborations post-mission launch on the table?
I think they could be. I'm not going to speak for NASA, but I think NASA
would be receptive to listening. That's my judgment. There are lots of collaborations
between other space agencies and NASA. And I think if Canada, for example, or other countries
wanted to come and say, we'll help, we'll fill this little gap for a couple million dollars a year
if you share the data with our scientists, I know my team would be receptive. But it's really,
ultimately, as NASA spacecraft, it would be up to them. The same would be true if some commercial
benefactor or foundation were to come forward and say, I just want to see this get done.
And we'd like to fund some of those salaries. I think NASA would take it seriously and have
a discussion. That's my intuition. Yeah. I mean, it's been pretty
interesting seeing Jared Isaacman work. And I think there is a sort of a new vitality at
NASA at this point. People are kind of excited so far.
He's very innovative. He's got a long list of things he wants to do to make NASA
work more quickly, as he says, take more shots on goal. I completely agree with that and to have
some fast wins. A fast win would be someone or some entity or some nation coming forward to say,
we're going to rescue that heliospheric science. Just let us play in it with you.
That could be a real win-win for both that entity, that country, that
benefactor, and for NASA, and frankly, for humankind and what we learn.
Our instruments on New Horizons, the ones that are now turned off as of this coming
new fiscal year, are a thousand times the sensitivity of the Voyager instruments
because they were built in a generation later with much better technology. So there's a lot to learn
and we want to get them turned back on. And there's still a ton of really useful
science coming from that spacecraft. There's two papers that came out that I thought were
really interesting. One was essentially using New Horizons to measure the parallax effect from
really far away from the sun. You guys have done these measurements when it was close to Earth.
And then again, recently, you can see the movement of the stars because of the movement
of the spacecraft. That's been incredible. And Todd Lauer, who led that investigation
and led those scientific papers, has actually used the data to reconstruct the position of
New Horizons without any Earth-based tracking or foreknowledge. He can show that from the parallax
alone, we can get a navigational fix on New Horizons. It's not as accurate as what we can do
with the Deep Space Network, but it's very important because it is, in all of history,
the first example of a planetary mission doing interstellar navigation the way that
the spaceships of Star Trek would do. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I love this idea that,
you know, if you took New Horizons, just randomly spun it around and put it somewhere within a few
dozen light years of here, it could take some pictures and figure out, with some help from home,
kind of where it is just by the changed positions of the stars in the sky.
In fact, we can do that from within our own solar system. We don't have to be light years away.
That's the accuracy with which, you know, Todd Lauer showed that we can do this, that we can do
it from in the Kuiper Belt, which is, you know, literally next door compared to going to another
star system. I think it's impressive. Yeah. And the other piece of science that I
really loved was essentially using the pretty big telescope on New Horizons to look at the
universe away from the light pollution of the inner solar system, all of that zodiacal dust,
all of that material that's in the solar system. You're out so far away, it's this pristine sky,
and you're getting this baseline measurement of the darkness of the universe that we've never
had before. And this, again, has recalibrated the number of galaxies in the universe, for example.
Yeah. It's a very important measurement for cosmology and extra galactic astronomy. You
can only do it when you're out, you know, as far as we are beyond all the foreground
interference of interplanetary dust, which is itself very faint. Your eye could never detect
it. But with very sensitive telescopes on New Horizons, we've been successful now in making,
by far, the best measurements of the cosmic optical background. And several scientific
results have come out of that. As a result, a number of scientific papers. It's a completely
unique contribution. Another interesting thing, and you didn't bring it up, but I want to talk
about it for a minute, is that we have a dust detector on board. And that dust detector,
which has been operating ever since we launched, traces the number of impacts on the spacecraft
due to micrometeoroids. These are really fine dust particles, oftentimes the size of smoke
particles. And the origin of those impacts is that they're created by dust in the outer solar system,
which is created when Kuiper Belt objects run into one another.
And there were scientific models, a number of them, that were put together to make a prediction
for when this dust would fall off as we left the Kuiper Belt. And it was predicted that once we
got past about 48 astronomical units, or 48 times as far from the Sun as Earth, that we would go off
a cliff. In fact, they called it the Kuiper Cliff. That the dust distribution would wane
dramatically because there are no more objects out further. But we're now at 66 astronomical
units, way past 48. We're 1.2 billion miles further out, and the dust impact rate has not only
not waned, it has actually increased. And what does that mean? Does it mean that there's a
second Kuiper Belt out there making a new source of dust or an extension to the Kuiper Belt?
Or some physics in the way that dust particles get out that far from the
classical Kuiper Belt? Any of those things are possible. And even though we go farther and
farther every year, the dust distribution remains high and above what the models were predicting.
That's a new mystery, and it was not even hinted at until New Horizons went out there
and took the first dust detector that went beyond the orbit of Uranus.
So I'd like to shift gears. You recently wrote an op-ed and you've been thinking about the impact
of these mega constellations on astronomy. Let me guess, pro or con?
Both, actually. First of all, I want to say that I have been in the minority
in the space science field. In my view, we need to learn as astronomers and planetary scientists
how to accommodate these constellations. They're giving internet to people who
otherwise wouldn't have it in the third world. That's a social good.
The streaks on our images are a small price to pay, in my view, for giving billions of people
a step into the 21st century. What's coming next, though, is not just constellations that
were 10 years ago unimaginable. Tens of thousands, a hundred thousand satellites.
But now SpaceX is talking about putting data centers in space. You know, they're a lot of
trouble getting them licensed on the Earth. They require a lot of cooling. They require a lot of
electricity. And Musk and SpaceX have a plan to put a million small data centers in space.
And that's a whole different ballgame when you have not 10,000, 20,000, 100,000 satellites in
the sky, but a million. I think it means more or less the end of ground-based research astronomy.
There's just going to be too much interference to make it practically useful, in my view.
Again, I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing, and I want to draw an analogy.
You know, when electrification happened to cities in the middle and late 19th century,
in the late 1800s, all the telescopes were in cities where the astronomers lived.
And once the lights started coming on everywhere in cities, they had to begin to migrate
the observatories out to remote places. And that was expensive. And it was a heavy lift in that day
to put telescopes on mountaintops far away. And in those days, you couldn't operate them by the
internet. There was no internet, and people had to travel out to these remote sites to do the
astronomy. But there was really no choice because the cities became uninhabitable for astronomy.
Yes, teaching astronomy does fine. In a bright city, you can teach kids how to use
telescopes and cameras and things. But for serious work, we had to put
telescopes on mountaintops and on islands and all kinds of places to get away from the city's
light. And I'll tell you what I think is going to happen in the near future. As these mega and
super mega constellations start to go up in later in the 20s and into the 30s, I think all serious
research-grade astronomy has got to have to move into space. Get above the satellites,
maybe in cislunar space and Lagrange points like we've already begun to use for some applications,
including James Webb and the Roman Space Telescope that just launched out.
And I think that's the future of research astronomy. It's all moving to space.
It's going to be expensive, but a telescope on the ground can only operate at night. A telescope in
space can operate 24 hours a day. So if you want to replace the 100 biggest observatories on the
earth that can only operate maybe eight hours a day with ones in space, you probably don't need
100. You probably need more like 30 or 40 because they can go 24 hours a day instead of eight.
So that's one thing in our favor. The other is that the constellations themselves,
the mega constellations, are expected to generate revenues that could be as much as $10 trillion
in the 2030s. Those are published numbers in filings to the Securities and Exchange Commission
to build these kind of satellites. $10 trillion. If we tax them at just one percent of their
revenues, you could pay to move all astronomical observatories of the same capability out into
space. And it would also be a lot of work for the commercial space industry to build those
telescopes, the instruments, to do the launches, to maintain them. And I think it's very likely to
be what's in our future within a decade or a couple of decades from now as astronomy migrates
off planet. And really, I don't think any serious astronomy or not very much will be done from the
earth. We'll still have people look through telescopes. We'll still have teaching. But I
think all the serious astronomy is going to move away from mountaintops and islands and out into
space. That's our future. But I mean, I think for a lot of people, their expectation is you're
going to get the worst of all worlds. You're going to get the mega constellations and you're not
going to get the funding for the telescopes. Well, I don't think the funding is going to come
from a NASA or National Science Foundation. Where I think it should come from is by taxing
the revenues of the constellations. And let me tell you, there's a lot of similarities
that already exist on the earth. There are taxes on every commercial airplane flight that pay for
all the FAA flight controllers, all the air traffic controllers. There are taxes on chemical
companies that pay for Superfund cleanup sites. There are lots of analogies already in the tax
code, not just the United States, but other countries as well. And there's no reason we
shouldn't apply the same kind of structures in space. And it could be a win-win. It could be
that the constellations rescue astronomy, which they are creating the problem for,
and do it for a price that's not going to hardly be noticed with a 1% tax.
Yes, that would be great. But I think the cynical view is you won't. It won't. Like,
I think the cynical view is that we're already at this point where these constellations are
starting to go up and, you know, the FAA is giving it the green light, but astronomers were
not consulted. And even in simple ways to just coordinate the locations of the satellites with
the observations that the astronomers are trying to make, you know, here's when you can turn on
Vera Rubin and here's when you don't, when you need to wait, you know, that kind of stuff could
be happening. There could be a lot more international collaboration that would show a
that they're sort of being good community members. And it is the tragedy of the commons
again, right? And so, yeah, like, I think, where are the teeth?
So let me make my point, Frasier, a different way. I think, you know, there's an old World
Wildlife Foundation ad that has a rhino running through the picture. And the copy at the bottom
of the ad says, run, rhino, run, extinction is forever. Well, that's where we're headed in
astronomy with constellations of a million satellites. And we have a choice as scientists
and science advocates to either see the demise of astronomy due to this or to be proactive about it
and find our way out and move astronomy off the planet above all the interference that's being
created. And, you know, honestly, we're not going to be able to fight it. The social good that's done
by what these constellations are doing for billions of people on Earth is not going to be
overcome by a few thousand research astronomers complaining about streaks on their images that
are obliterating them. We need to get ahead of the ball and find a win-win. And if we don't start
soon, we're just delaying the inevitable. And I, for one, am in favor of getting going. And if the
idea of taxing the revenue at sort of a 1% level turns out to be a lead balloon, let's find another
way. But I think we need to start facing the fact that there are just going to be too many satellites
in the sky to usefully do astronomy in the very near future. And we need to start adjusting to
that new normal, the same way that our ancestors in astronomy in the late 1800s had to adjust to
the electrification of cities. They had to find another way and another whole set of funding
mechanisms to afford to do things far away from the cities. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, like, I agree.
And I totally see that as the sort of the realistic answer. And I think that there is just,
you know, for a for a giant segment of the audience that's watching this right now,
there is a kind of predeterminism here that, you know, we're already partway through this
transition into the loss of the of the skies. We already lost the skies from slight pollution in
general, right? Like a third of humanity can no longer see the Milky Way, that that this is just
what happens. And in this case, you know, you've got billions of people making individual choices
to point their lights up in the sky with satellite mega constellations. You've got these
choke points that you can stick your thumb on the CEO's wallet and say, no, you are not allowed to
launch this mega constellation until you have made sure that the astronomers are made whole.
And it is kind of incredible when you think about, you know, SpaceX is a rocket company. They could
they could launch telescopes with every Starlink launch like that would end of and the telescopes
are so off the shelf now that you could you could absolutely pack these things in with with every
with every launch like this is all obviously possible. And yet it has not I've not seen a
single telescope packed on funded by SpaceX, right? Yeah. And I think the reason for that,
Frasier, is that is that most of research astronomy has been on the wrong track.
They have been trying to mitigate the effects with computer image processing
and to complain about the satellites. Instead, let's find a way to coexist with them. We can
coexist by putting in telescopes farther away than all the interference the satellites make.
Make it a win for the constellation companies as well. It's tremendous for their public,
the public's perception of these companies. The same way that many companies do things to help
improve the environment or help with STEM education and many other causes. Astronomy
is suffering from these constellations. I think the constellation companies don't have a duty,
but they have an opportunity to to do something that I think will be inspirational to people
around the world for the public good and which will create more business for commercial space
by building and launching all these new observatories. So I'm an optimist. We're at
the beginning of this. I'm basically suggesting that the research astronomy community, people
like myself and science communicators, move from dragging our heels complaining and trying to
write better computer codes or have Claude write those better computer codes for us
to analyze the data and instead completely sidestep the problem by putting the observatories
in deep space in large numbers. No longer just the occasional launch of the next space telescope.
Let's move them all out into space and be done with it once and for all.
In fact, from deep space, we can do better than we could do even from a 19th century dark sky.
Because even in a perfectly dark planet before electrification, there were still clouds and fogs
and seeing and turbulence and all these other interference sources. Once we go to space,
we're really in a sweet spot for how to do astronomy 24 seven in a way that's
better than from ground based. I mean, it would really suck to just lose
ground based astronomy entirely. Like there's some really nice advantages as you
develop a new piece of hardware for your existing telescope. You just walk over,
swap it out that there's there's all these advantages that that exist. And and yet,
when you look at the size of the Hubble Space Telescope and its capabilities
compared to similar ground based telescopes, you need to get really big and have a lot
of extra technology just to match the the fact that you're just out in space.
So yes, exactly. Yeah. So so like, I agree. Space telescopes are great.
And I think it's just comes down to, I think, for most people. I mean, I mean,
I think we are in this really interesting moment of leverage. When you look at the pushback that's
happening with just the A.I. data centers that that these communities are going,
we don't want these things. You're going to have to really make it worth our while. And you're
seeing a lot of pencil sharpening coming from the A.I. companies to get approval in various
municipalities for these A.I. data centers. And I think it's that same that same thing,
which is that if people can direct that outrage against the mega constellations
for the kinds of causes that they're interested in, then we can get some kind of some, you know,
get some mitigation, get those space telescopes operational that, yeah, we have 20 new space
telescopes going up this year, which is only one percent of the of the of the cost of these mega
constellations. And that was due to the public pressure on the governments to force those mega
constellations to fall in line. And then I think that's where that's where we get there.
And so I think I think it is interesting that we are in this moment where where there is leverage
to be able to to push that. It is a very special time and it is a very important fulcrum that we're
at a point in time that I think in 20 or 25 years, we're only going to have two two options. I think
one is going to be that we move astronomy off the planet. The other is that we do a lot less
astronomy that it's just it's just the sky is too polluted by it. But the social good of all
this networking and moving data centers off the planet instead of polluting the planet
argues that we astronomers are too few and too too impotent to overcome this enormous social
good. So let's do a judo move. Let's find a way to get the best of both. And I'm an optimist. I
think it can be done. Yeah, well, it's funny because I do think it's kind of like I see where
you're going and I do feel it's inevitable that this will happen. This will be figured out. But
there's this kind of grief, I think, is how I feel that that I, you know, you're in bargaining maybe
and I'm still in denial. So I'll catch up. I'll catch up with you on the stages of grief.
There must have been people on both sides of the argument, you know, in the 1860s and 70s and 80s
that were saying, oh, we're losing astronomy from the cities and people could just go in
their backyard and point a telescope and make discoveries and see wonderful things. And now
they have to make a trip out into the country. Isn't this awful? But here we are 150 years later
and we're just used to that as the new normal. Yeah, it's downright romantic to go to the top
of a mountaintop in Chile and stare at the night sky. Yes, sir. Alan, what are you obsessed with
right now? Ah, well, I'm obsessed with the future because it seems that after a pause, you know,
things were going very fast in the early 20th century and the mid 20th century. And it seems
that a lot of things took a pause, particularly in space, all across the late 20th century in the
very earliest parts of this new one. And now it's as if we hit the gas pedal again and it's going
faster and faster. I'm really of the belief that we're in the era that people will look back on
and say, back then in the teens and 20s, that's when Star Trek began. That's really where the
breakout moments were. Because we've now gotten to a future where it's mostly commercially
supported. The latest McKinsey report in the worldwide space economy says the space economy
of the world is now north of $600 billion per annum, per year. 600 billion. NASA's budget's
only 25. Imagine that. It's mostly commercial space activities. It's not NASA, ESA, JAXA,
the Chinese. It's really commercial space. This is fueling a lot of innovation in every nook and
cranny of space. Some of it faster than others, but we're really at the breakout moment. And I
think that my children and grandchildren will be, you know, in an era in their working lives
where we start to see humans moving out off the planet in significant numbers for exploration
and for public good, for science, with outposts on the moon and then Mars and other places around
the solar system. And who knows what good will come of that any more than what did people know
in the 15th century about what the Americas would become and how they would change the world by
inventing democracy and creating the largest economic forces on the planet. And not without
trials and tribulations and difficulties, space might be just the same. We humans and our history
are kind of messy. But in general, things are going in a good direction in many respects.
And I remain an optimist and look forward to that future. And then if you don't mind,
I'm just saying for my own sake, I'm looking forward to making my own second space flight,
again on Virgin Galactic, this time funded by NASA as a research mission that should fly early
next year to do some astronomical research from a suborbital mission. The first experience I had
with space flight was just thrilling. We got everything done that we wanted to do, nine
objectives in the space of that flight, and I'm ready to go back and do it again and do it again
and again as this proliferates itself. Yeah, yeah. Man, that experience, I mean,
you can't even put it into words. Hard to put into words. Thrilling rocket ride up to altitude,
unbelievable perspective on the planet. I could even show you one picture. You know, I didn't
have a lot of time to lollygag out the window because we had to set up flight test objectives
and I was being graded on how many I could get done and how well. But that all turned out,
but what little I got to look out the window was mouthwatering. And you know, I think space flight,
a lot of astronauts say it's addictive. And certainly my first taste of it, just what,
maybe you want to go back and do it more and more often. Yeah. Yeah. It's like, I don't know,
like my experience is like seeing an eclipse, seeing a total solar eclipse of my eyes. And
you're like, okay, I want to do this for the rest of my life. I just want to see more and more of
these, collect them all. Yeah. Yeah. And it, you know, I don't know, you know, like I did a dive
to the Titanic in 2022, but I didn't get the urge to keep diving to the Titanic the way that my
first space flight in 2023, um, um, maybe a space flight addict. Um, but I guess different people
are interested in different things. This is my, yeah. Well, it's, I mean, it's great that you get,
you get to do some science and experience that at the same time. I mean, that that's being an
astronaut. So, um, well, Alan, thank you so much for coming back and giving us an update on,
on everything and, and good luck with new horizons. I'll let you know if anybody reaches
out and wants to partner up with, uh, the heliospheric science and, uh, that'd be awesome.
And yeah. And, and send more pictures when you, uh, when you complete your next, uh, flight.
I sure will. And Fraser, thank you for having me on. It's always, uh, a pleasure and you're
such a good interviewer. Um, I, uh, I just want to say thank you.
Thank you. All right. We'll see you next time then. I hope you enjoyed this conversation with
Alan Stern and I'm sure you are going to have some feedback for me, for Alan, for the astronomy
community, for the satellite major constellations. But if you want, we did a longer version of the
conversation where we talked about his work on the Lucy mission and what we're expecting to find as
Lucy makes its way out to the Trojan regions around Jupiter. Exciting mission, brand new science. I
think you're going to really enjoy that. As always, I put that longer version over on Patreon. It's
there totally ad free. You don't have to subscribe. It's not behind a paywall. It's just freely
accessible. I'll put a link down in the show notes. All right. I'm going to give you some
final thoughts, but first I'd like to thank our patrons. Thanks to AIM Kingston, Andrea Pedretti,
Brian Boddy, Kerwin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Bialek, David Gilton, David Mattson, Thraller
Reading and Math for Toddlers, Evan Dot Pro, James Clark, Jerry Madden, Jim Burke, Marcel Smiths,
Michael Purcell, NASAOceanGuy, NordSpace, OneStepAnimals.org. Please follow my nephew at
vbrick6994, Ring Kaidu, Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Stephen Foundland-Munley, Team49,
TailslipsCanada, Vlad Shipplin, Wolfgang Klotz, and Zelda. Be right back sending the next two
months to Nepal Flood, who support us at the master of the universe level and all our patrons.
All your support means the universe to us. Well, what a treat to talk with Alan Starr. I mean,
he is one of the most legendary principal investigators for spacecraft missions and
not just the ones that we talked about. You know, I think my first interview with Alan was when we
were talking about the Deep Space One spacecraft, which pioneered ion engines and star tracking and
a bunch of other technologies. And he is still working hard, doing science, communicating with
the public, flying to the edge of space and proposing new missions. And it was just great
to be able to sort of reach out and chat with him. There was a couple of topics that we talked about
after I stopped the camera, and I wish I hadn't, which is, of course, he is a huge proponent of
Pluto being a planet. And he brought that up a couple of times. You might have heard him say,
the planet Pluto and so on, you know, totally rejects the IAU decision to to call it a dwarf
planet instead of a planet. And Alan is is a proponent of like, let's just call them all
planets, right? Titan is a planet. Mimas is a planet. You know, there's probably 120 planets
in the solar system. And if that's what it takes for us to sort of properly recognize the stature
of these objects, so be it. And yes, kids can remember this many things. You know, I think about
how many Pokemon kids can remember. Or you think about the, you know, Alan says the periodic table
of elements, you know, we can remember a lot of things. And that that sort of shows the how
important each one of these objects are in the solar system. And, you know, I'm coming around to
that point of view. I try to sort of sit on the fence, but I got to say, I am leaning more towards
they're all planets. Alright, we'll see you next time.