Don't get it wrong: This is the real reason the Qing dynasty ruled for so long!

History & Culture of East
10 followers
26 Video Views·Oct 5, 2026
This video analyzes why the Qing Dynasty (Jurchens) was able to rule China for nearly 300 years, while the Yuan Dynasty (Mongols), though militarily more powerful, lasted less than 100 years. Key factors include:
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video analyzes the historical contrast between the Mongol-led Yuan Dynasty and the Jurchen-led Qing Dynasty. It explores why the Yuan collapsed quickly due to social oppression and unstable succession, while the Qing maintained control for nearly 300 years through strategic cultural integration, administrative balance, and stable governance.
China is considered one of the cradles of human civilization.
The North China Plain has seen the rise of countless prosperous, glorious dynasties.
The Han expanded their influence across the surrounding regions by conquering,
plundering, and ruling over many other peoples.
Even so, powerful as they were and having conquered many peoples,
the Han still had enemies they feared.
Those were the nomadic peoples from the north.
Throughout history, the Han were ruled twice by minority peoples.
The Mongols destroyed the Song and founded the Yuan,
and the Manchus destroyed the Ming and founded the Qing.
Yet when you look at these two dynasties, what do you see?
The Mongol Yuan, despite being seen as immensely powerful and having built
one of the largest empires in history, lasted less than 100 years.
The Jurchens, compared with the old Mongols, were far weaker militarily.
And achieved far less in conquest.
Yet they ruled the Han for nearly 300 years.
So where does the difference lie?
How did the Jurchens do it?
Let's find out in today's video.
Welcome to Battle Cry, Chinese History.
The northern threat.
The northern enemy.
Is one of history's most sensitive phrases, and later generations, when they mention it.
Many people feel a strange heat inside themselves.
A feeling that may have passed down through generations of Vietnamese.
Because the north has been our sworn enemy through the ages.
Yet if you ask what Vietnamese and Chinese have in common.
That phrase above is the easiest thing to spot.
Yes, Dai Viet was not the only nation to have a northern enemy.
And neither was China.
The north was the greatest threat.
To the peace of the Son of Heaven's realm.
Across many dynasties.
And there were times when they were ruled.
By ethnic minorities.
Whom they had long called.
Barbarian hordes.
Let's start with the Qin.
When the Qin fall, the Hu rise.
It means.
The Qin fell because of the Hu.
This prophetic line left.
The age of chaos with one of history's great wonders.
The greatest in human history.
Qin Shi Huang thought the word Hu meant the northern barbarian tribes.
So he mobilized troops and hundreds of thousands of laborers to build a wall
stretching northward for defense.
Ironically, the one who brought down the Qin was Prince Hu Hai.
The legacy left by the emperor who unified China.
Also laid the foundation for the great wall that came later.
Going back a few centuries further,
the great unification before Qin was the Zhou dynasty.
And it too fell to northern barbarians.
Just because of one smile from the beauty Bao Xi.
King Yu of Zhou stirred up chaos in the court.
And gave the Chu Emerald tribe a chance to pour into the central plains.
The warring states era when China was torn apart.
Began then.
After the Qin, northern enemies appeared more often and grew even stronger.
Becoming a constant threat to the Han.
More than half the kings and princes of the southern and northern dynasties.
In the fifth and seventh generations.
Carried the blood of northern outsiders like the Xiongnu and the Xianbei.
And Lushan, who ruined Tang Minghuang's brilliant reign.
Was also of Hu origin.
The Tang collapsed into the five dynasties and ten kingdoms period in the 10th century.
Much like Vietnam's revolt of the twelve warlords.
Once again, many of those rulers.
Came from minority tribes like the Xia Tuo.
The next great unifier of China, the Song.
Did not fall early.
Yet it still left behind some rare royal tears in history.
It began with the Khitan state of Liao.
After losing the war, the Song emperor had to sign a peace treaty.
Pay tribute of gold, silk, pearls, and jade.
And call the Liao ruler elder brother.
When Liao weakened, the Song joined forces with the Jurchen Jin to destroy it.
Only to end up sending tribute to Jin instead.
The Song emperors had a new uncle king, the Jin ruler.
Unable to withstand the pressure and bullying from the north.
Chancellor Wan Unshi tried to find a small victory.
To claim a great achievement with tiny Dai Viet.
Land of the southern barbarians as the main target.
But contrary to Wang's plans and ambitions.
The Song invasion of Dai Viet failed miserably.
Giving rise to the immortal Nam Kwok Sun Ha.
And the Song's weak, appeasing foreign policy.
Still couldn't save them from the Mongols' horse-hooped weed killer.
As the old saying goes.
Wherever the Mongol horses passed, even grass could not grow.
The Song fell, and China lay under Mongol saddles.
The Han were forced to the bottom of society for nearly a hundred years.
The Ming, having reclaimed Han independence.
Worked hard to rebuild and shape the country into what it is today.
Their grand efforts proved useless against the fighting power from the north.
China once again fell into the iron grip of a familiar people.
Who had once founded the Jin.
The Qing was established by the Jurchens, with shaved foreheads and queues.
The Qing became the last feudal dynasty before the Republic of China.
So throughout imperial China's history.
Threats from the north always weighed heavily on them.
Twice they lost the realm.
First when the Mongols overthrew the Song and founded the Yuan.
Then when the Jurchens overthrew them and founded the Qing.
And yet the Mongol Empire.
Seen as one of the most powerful in world history.
Ruled China for less than 100 years.
The Jurchens, however, ruled the Han for nearly 300 years.
So why did the Jurchens manage this?
Let's continue to the next part of the video and look at each reason one by one.
The first is how they treated the Han.
Looking back to the days when the Mongols first set foot on Han land.
Two ministers, Yelü Chuqai and Macaulay.
Promoted Han law and order to preserve the Han system.
But a courtier at the time drove the Han out.
However, one court minister at the time ordered the Han to be expelled.
And turn the central plains into a giant pasture to strip away its wealth.
Yelü Chuqai strongly opposed this.
He said wealth could be collected through taxes.
And the institutions of the Han lands should be preserved.
Han customs, laws, tax systems, and so on.
In the newly conquered former Song territories, would stay unchanged.
But by Kublai Khan's time, after the Litan rebellion,
Yuan Shizu gradually stopped using Han officials in the system.
And then placed them under an extremely harsh regime of control.
Early in Yuan rule, the Han were ranked at the very bottom.
The empire's people were divided into four classes.
The Mongols were first class.
The western region peoples were second.
The Han from the former Jin territories.
And the Khitan and Jurchen were third class.
While most people south of the Yellow River were classified as Namrun, fourth class.
In other words, the Han were placed at the bottom of society.
And this was the core reason for the Yuan's rapid collapse.
This brutal oppression triggered wave after wave of Han uprisings in the south.
By 1368, Zhu Yuanzhang had founded his own dynasty
and sent the great general Suda North to storm Dadu.
The Yuan, and the Mongol empire as a whole, collapsed in less than 100 years.
The Yuan's rise and fall became a lesson the Qing later avoided, and they handled it better.
Because they came from a minority themselves, the Qing court worked hard.
To build a stable system of rule across all of China.
Blending minority cultures with Han culture.
They also knew how to win over the Han.
Han men who served the Manchus were highly honored.
For example, their own generals and Han officials were promoted based on merit.
Those who helped found the dynasty were ennobled,
made feudal lords, and given control over vast lands in southern China.
The first of them was Wu Sengui, who was put in charge of Yunnan and Guizhou.
Meanwhile, generals like Xiang Qishi and Geng Xiaoming governed Guangdong and Fujian.
Together, the three were known as the Three Feudatories,
and later the revolt of the Three Feudatories broke out.
When they rose up against the Qing court.
Of course, nothing is absolute.
Ethnic harmony was part of it.
But even within that harmony, the Manchus still ranked higher.
And they ruled with both carrot and stick.
Just look at the Q hairstyle to see how they terrified the Han.
While the Han usually wore their hair in a bun or long and parted at the sides.
The Qing forced them to wear the Q.
Their order was simple, keep your hair, lose your head, keep your head, cut your hair.
And of course, everyone wanted to stay alive.
And so the famous Q hairstyle appeared.
This is seen as one of the acts showing the Manchu's ambition to assimilate the Han.
Under the Qing's iron discipline,
this hairstyle gradually became widespread among the people.
All men had to wear the Q.
Clearly, the Qing tried to build a Manchu cultural influence over the Han.
But in the end, the result was the opposite.
They were influenced by Confucianism, by the civil service exams, by poetry, and by Han art.
In other words, the Han ended up assimilating the Manchus.
And even if that emperor, the one on the Q-haired throne, was Manchu.
The realm itself was still Han culture, still Han tradition.
Once they had pacified and united the peoples.
The Qing gave rise to a concept that is still very famous today.
That concept was China.
And it was a concept built on harmony.
After conquering Han lands and the surrounding minority peoples.
The Qing called their state China.
Qing emperors declared that both the Han and non-Han peoples were part of China.
Chinese here was also defined to include Han, Manchu, and Mongol,
and the Chinese people referred to all peoples within their state.
In short, they made life easier for the Han than under the Yuan.
The second issue was the examinations.
In its early years of rule, the Yuan did not hold examinations,
so it could not bring educated men into its government.
During Yuan rule, they initially did not hold civil service exams.
So in nearly 100 years, only 16 exam sessions were held altogether, producing 1,139 jinshi.
That number was far too small compared with the vast number of educated men.
So many talented scholars never entered Yuan service.
The Mongols, used to ruling the world from horseback,
without the help of Han scholar officials, had very weak governing ability.
Because of this decision by Yuan founder Kublai Khan,
the leadership ranks were filled mostly by Mongols at the very top.
The Han were simply pushed aside,
which drained Mongol and Simu children of their motivation to study and even their ambition.
Quite simply, they already knew that from birth they would be placed straight into high office,
so why bother?
By contrast, the Qing's basic policy was to split appointments between Manchu nobles and Han
officials, and those who had passed the state's highest examinations.
In other words, if a Manchu or a Han wanted to become an official,
the only way was to study hard and pass the exams.
Otherwise they would be commoners forever.
The Qing had one defining feature, a dual appointment system.
Under it, every post in the central government was jointly held by one Han and one Manchu.
For example, under the Qianlong Emperor,
members of his family wore a special robe marked with a round emblem on the back.
While Han people were allowed to wear only robes marked with a square emblem on the back.
That meant any soldier in the palace could easily tell them apart from the imperial family.
Just by looking from behind.
Of course, the emperors didn't fully trust the Han.
So they set up a body called the Grand Council.
It handled military and intelligence matters.
Later, it oversaw every branch of government.
Its members also held the power of chancellors.
And, of course, they were Manchus.
This was much like the earlier three offices in our system.
Just with a different ethnic group.
As for administration, the Qing divided the government into six ministries.
First was the Ministry of Personnel,
which managed civil appointments and administration for all civilian posts.
Including evaluations, appointments, and dismissals.
Second was the Ministry of Revenue, in charge of taxes and state finances.
Third was the Ministry of Rights, which handled all matters of court ceremony and etiquette.
Including ancestral sacrifices, seasonal rites, and many other rituals.
It also received tribute missions from foreign states.
The Ministry of War may sound powerful,
but in practice it only controlled the local garrisons.
The regular army, of course, was directly controlled by the emperors and Manchu generals.
The Ministry of Justice handled all legal matters,
including overseeing trials and running the prisons.
Sixth was the Ministry of Works, which handled all state construction,
including palaces, temples, and repairs to waterways and canals.
It also minted coins.
So we can see that the Qing learned a great deal from the Yuan's collapse.
They still let Han officials serve in the bureaucracy.
But they always kept a tight control system in place,
to stop those Han officials from plotting rebellion.
At the same time, iron discipline and good rewards kept Han officials from turning against them.
A classic Karadenstic approach.
And the third reason, the Yuan had no stable system of succession.
The throne was always up for grabs.
Succession was a huge matter in ancient times.
The Mongols had a very different custom from the Han, who followed primogeniture.
The Mongols passed most of a father's legacy to the youngest son.
In other words, when a great Khan died, the eldest son would become the next great Khan,
but military power would fall to the youngest son.
For example, after Genghis Khan died, Ogedei succeeded him as great Khan.
But his youngest son Taoyui inherited most of the empire's military power.
When Ogedei died, Taoyui's clan, backed by strong armies and skilled commanders,
overthrew the Ogedei clan's rule.
That was also one of the roots of the Mongol civil war.
Even after Kublai founded the Yuan, they still couldn't solve the succession problem.
That became another festering wound, and it helped bring the Yuan down fast.
From 1295 to 1368, in just 73 years, the Yuan had 10 emperors.
That means, on average, each one ruled for just over 7 years.
With a court that chaotic, they naturally spent most of their energy on internal power struggles.
And after each round of turmoil,
the biggest losses were often the elite commanders who fought over the throne for their masters.
By the time Zhu Yuanzhang's uprising broke out,
most of the capable generals were already gone.
By then, the calm, battle-hardened ones were mostly in the grave,
while the Yuan court was still busy fighting itself.
After taking all three hits, the Mongols' early downfall was only natural.
By contrast, the Qing borrowed the Han way of passing power on,
the eldest son inherited the throne.
At this point, many of you may ask,
wasn't the Qing famous for the nine princes' struggle for the throne?
Yes, but it stayed within the prince's schemes,
brothers using every trick to tear each other down.
It never plunged the realm into chaos, never split into warring factions,
and if it didn't hurt the people, they had no reason to care.
Not every dynasty could do that, just look at the one before it.
The Jingnan Rebellion was famous for one thing,
Zhu Di seized the throne from his nephew, Zhu Yunwen.
That shows the Qing learned a great deal from Yuan rule.
And that helped them last nearly 300 years, with a mix of force and conciliation.
They never gave the Han too much freedom,
but never squeezed them so hard they couldn't breathe.
As the saying goes, feed the hawk too well, and it flies away.
Starve it, and it comes back to bite you.
So they never fed the hawk full, but never let it starve either,
just enough to keep it struggling and obedient.
