Tieu Ha - From The Greatest Hero To A Tragic End To His Life

History & Culture of East
10 followers
68 Video Views·May 11, 2026
XIAO HA - FROM THE GREATEST GENERAL TO A TRAGIC END
Xiao Ha was the founding prime minister of the Han Dynasty. Today, more than 2,000 years later, the name Xiao Ha is still widely known. There is a very famous saying related to him: "Success is due to Xiao Ha, failure is due to Xiao Ha." The origin of that saying is actually a long story…
Welcome back to best of Chinese history.
Xiaohui was the founding prime minister of the Han dynasty.
Even after 2,000 years, Xiaohui's name remains well known.
A famous proverb is forever tied to his legacy.
Success is due to Xiaohui, failure is also due to Xiaohui.
The origin of this saying is a long, complex tale.
Xiaohui's life is recorded in the records of the Grand Historian and the Book of Han.
In 202 BC, after defeating Xiang Yu, Lu Bang rewarded his meritorious officials.
A heated debate over their contributions took place in Luoyang.
Ultimately, Xiaohui was ranked first for his services.
He was named Marquis of Zhan, with a fiefdom of 8,000 households.
Granted the honor of entering the palace with a sword and walking without hurrying.
Though a clerk with no battlefield record, Lu Bang insisted he ranked above the generals.
When generals protested, Gaozu argued Xiaohui's merit was eternal,
while theirs was merely tactical.
Though perhaps hyperbolic, this sentiment perfectly aligned with Lu Bang's wishes.
Yet, regarding the founding of the Han, Xiaohui's contributions were undeniable.
He established the nine-chapter law for the Han dynasty.
History Records
Xiaohui was born under the influence of the Mao Star.
The Mao Star governs judicial affairs.
When the Mao Star shines bright, the world finds justice.
Prisons are administered fairly.
When the Mao Star dims, the world suffers from cruel, arbitrary punishment.
During the Qin era, Xiaohui served as a local clerk.
During the Han era, he served as prime minister.
He drew upon the Qin legal code to draft the nine-chapter law for the Han.
He resolved all legal disputes, ensuring justice throughout the realm.
Truly, he mirrored the omens of the Mao Star.
In 209 BC, Lu Bang rose in Pei County.
Xiaohui helped Lu Bang become the Duke of Pei.
Xiaohui did not join Lu Bang alone, but brought dozens of his Qin along.
Later, during the Honshu War, with Han forces thinning,
Xiaohui mobilized all his relatives and Qin.
Anyone capable of service was sent to the front lines.
One might say his loyalty shone bright.
In October 207 BC, Lu Bang entered Xianyang, Xiying surrendered.
Generals rushed to the storehouses to loot the Qin treasury.
But Xiaohui prioritized securing Qin's maps and state records.
When Xiangyu arrived, Lu Bang left all Qin treasures for him.
Yet, he kept all the maps and records Xiaohui had seized.
These included banned texts, the classics, and the book of history.
They also contained vital data on geography, borders, and demographics.
This intelligence was key for the Han campaign to conquer the east.
As Lu Bang advanced, Xiaohui stayed behind to govern Guanzhong.
He built the capital, established laws, and secured the people.
This ensured that the Han army never ran out of supplies or recruits.
Ultimately, bolstered by Han Xi'an's brilliance at the front,
allowing the Han to overcome a stronger foe,
and ultimately triumph over the invincible Xiangyu.
His efforts were indeed monumental.
Yet the saying, success is due to Xiaohui,
arose because Xiaohui recommended Han Xi'an to the Han throne.
A brilliant general.
The only one capable of defeating Xiangyu.
Securing the empire for Lu Bang.
He chased Han Xi'an under the moonlight to secure this talent.
In 206 BC, Lu Bang was titled king of Han, leading his troops into Hanzhong.
Many soldiers were from Chu, weary of the march, they deserted in droves.
When the army reached Nanjing, word was brought to Xiaohui.
Even the supply officer, Han Xi'an, had fled.
Without waiting to consult Lu Bang, Xiaohui gave chase.
Han Xi'an possessed grand ambitions that Lu Bang could not grasp,
much like comparing the vision of a sparrow to that of a soaring swan.
Despite Xiaohui's insistent recommendations,
Lu Bang kept Han Xi'an as a mere supply officer.
Feeling his talents were wasted, Han Xi'an decided to leave.
Xiaohui caught up, persuaded him to return, and went straight to Lu Bang.
Lu Bang didn't see Han Xi'an's genius, but he relied on Xiaohui as his right-hand man.
Heeded Xiaohui's counsel, Lu Bang agreed.
When Xiaohui called Han Xi'an a peerless talent, Lu Bang offered him a command.
Xiaohui insisted a mere command was too small, he deserved to be commander-in-chief.
Lu Bang immediately sought out Han Xi'an and promoted him.
Xiaohui demanded a formal ceremony, complete with an altar and rituals.
Though Lu Bang detested such formalities, he laughed and gave his consent.
By the time he was a renowned general, Han Xi'an marched north,
pacified the Three Qings, and pushed east to vie for the empire.
Lu Bang was overjoyed yet regretful, joyous to have such a peerless talent,
but regretful for having overlooked such a brilliant commander.
Looking back at Xiaohui's life, he had indeed rendered monumental service to the Han dynasty.
He reached the pinnacle of a subject's power, achieving ultimate success and recognition.
Yet, it is a pity Xiaohui could not sustain this legacy,
as his own fate became bound to the very man he once championed.
He bowed to Empress Lu as she plotted to lure Han Xi'an to the palace.
In 196 BC, the rebel Qin Shi rose and died, and Lu Bang departed to suppress the uprising.
Empress Lu summoned Xiaohui, claiming Han Xi'an and his followers were conspiring
with Qin Shi to assassinate her and the crown prince.
She then ordered Xiaohui to trick Han Xi'an into entering Chang'e Palace to be executed.
Xiaohui received the order, finding himself in a dire predicament.
He knew Han Xi'an well, a man who would repay a single bowl of rice with a fortune in gold.
Such a man, who repaid humiliation with grace, surely lacked the heart to commit treason.
Furthermore, when Han Xi'an held the troops of Qi,
with the power to sway the empire in his hands.
Rebellion would have been as easy as turning over his hand.
Yet, Han Xi'an remained steadfast, refusing to betray his master,
ignoring the urgings of Wu Xi and Kuai Tong, and refusing to carve up the empire.
Why, then, after Lu Bang had unified the realm, would he suddenly plot a rebellion?
Let us consider this further.
Early in the Han Dynasty, Han Xi'an was in fact as the king of Chu in his homeland,
like a tiger returning to the mountains.
If he intended to rebel, why not then join forces with Ying Bu and
Ping Yu to plot their move?
Why would Han Xi'an wait until he was under house arrest in Chang'an?
He has feigned illness for six years to plot rebellion.
Besides, his supposed ally is just a minor general and I.
How could they ever coordinate a rebellion?
Therefore, Empress Lu's accusations hold no merit.
Yet, Xiaohui could not speak a word in Han Xi'an's defense.
He knew Han Xi'an's peril stemmed from his own greatness,
fueling Lu Bang and Empress Lu's suspicions.
Six years ago, following Qin Ping's scheme,
the emperor already intended to eliminate Han Xi'an during a fake inspection.
It failed only because Lu Bang feared Han Xi'an's immense prestige,
leaving him hesitant and indecisive.
Empress Lu, however, was autocratic and ruthless,
far more devious than Lu Bang.
Xiaohui anticipated that if he did not yield to her orders,
his own life would be at stake.
Ultimately, the prime minister of Han,
once so prestigious, had to bow to the cruelty of Empress Lu.
He gritted his teeth and lured Han Xi'an into the palace.
Xiaohui claimed Qin Shi was defeated, and as Lu Bang returned,
Han Xi'an had to offer congratulations despite his illness.
Though a brilliant general, Han Xi'an was upright and naive,
never suspecting Xiaohui would deceive him.
But once Han Xi'an entered the bell tower at Chang'an Palace,
he never came out again.
Empress Lu did not just kill him,
she was vicious enough to exterminate his entire clan.
Xiaohui was coerced by her to betray the man whose talent Lu Bang feared day and night.
Though gifted at recognizing talent and governing,
Xiaohui failed to foresee this tragic outcome.
Han Xi'an's death became the turning point of his own life.
Lu Bang Grew Suspicious
At the height of the war,
Lu Bang heard of Xiaohui's massive public support.
He granted him 5,000 households,
promoted him to chancellor,
and sent 500 guards to protect his mansion.
While Xiaohui was hosting a grand banquet,
Zhao Ping arrived to visit him.
Zhao Ping, formerly the Marquis of Dongling,
lived as a humble melon farmer after Qin fell.
Zhao Ping warned Xiaohui that disaster was looming.
The emperor's reward was not a favor but a cage,
those guards were there to watch him, not protect him.
Han Xi'an's execution did not earn Lu Bang's trust,
it only deepened his paranoia.
The only way to survive was to reject the honors
and donate his private wealth to the military.
Xiaohui followed this advice,
sacrificing his fortune to save his own life.
Soon after, in the seventh month,
Qingying Bu rebelled,
and Lu Bang marched to suppress him.
During the campaign,
the emperor sent messengers back
to check on the chancellor multiple times.
An advisor warned Xiaohui,
if you keep accumulating merit,
your entire clan will be in danger.
You are already chancellor,
you cannot rise any higher.
You have managed the state for years
and have won the people's hearts.
The emperor keeps checking on you,
because he fears you could seize control
of the heartland with a single word,
and that the empire would no longer belong
to the Lu family.
To save yourself,
you must tarnish your own reputation.
Force the people to sell their land cheap,
only then will the emperor rest easy.
Xiaohui complied,
and Lu Bang was overjoyed,
finally seeing him as no threat.
Soon after defeating Ying Bu,
Lu Bang returned to Chongyun,
only to find the people complaining
and accusing the chancellor
of forcing them to sell their land at low prices.
Lu Bang returned and tossed
all the accusations at Xiaohui,
leaving him to answer to the people.
Yet Lu Bang felt strangely relieved.
Xiaohui saw right through this.
Xiaohui knew that Lu Bang's wariness had vanished.
The emperor was genuinely pleased.
Xiaohui also breathed a sigh of relief.
He thought it best to speak
while the emperor was in good spirits.
Xiaohui approached Lu Bang and suggested
that the imperial gardens be opened
for the people to farm,
but before he finished, disaster struck.
Hearing Xiaohui plead for the people,
suspicion flared in Lu Bang again.
He suspected Xiaohui was using imperial land
to buy the people's loyalty.
Lu Bang accused Xiaohui of taking bribes
from merchants to seize imperial land
for personal gain.
He ordered Xiaohui arrested, shackled,
and thrown into prison.
Later, an official advised Lu Bang
that Xiaohui had long guarded Guangzhou
while the emperor campaigned abroad.
If Xiaohui had wanted to rebel,
Guangzhou would have been lost
to the emperor long ago.
Lu Bang listened, though he remained displeased.
Eventually realizing that keeping Xiaohui
imprisoned was unjustifiable,
so he ordered his release.
At that time, Xiaohui was over 60 years old.
Though he survived, he was deeply shaken.
From then on, Xiaohui remained
as prime minister,
but grew quiet and cautious,
focusing only on self-preservation.
He lost his former vigor and resolve.
Soon after, Lu Bang passed away,
and a year later, Xiaohui fell deathly ill.
Emperor Hui visited him,
asking who should succeed him as prime minister.
Xiaohui still seemed fearful,
daring to say little.
Only when Emperor Hui suggested Chao Qian did
Xiaohui nod in agreement.
The Book of Songs says,
rarely does a good start see a good end.
The ancients believed everything needs
a consistent beginning and end.
Yet, how many can endure life's trials
and remain steadfast?
Keeping one's faith without wavering is rare.
Take Xiaohui, with his monumental contributions,
founding an empire and assisting his sovereign,
serving the state with unwavering devotion,
only to lose his clarity.
As he faced the turning points of his life,
he truly brought himself
to the verge of a fulfilled life,
only to cast a shadow over his legacy.
Xiaohui, in his final years,
burdened by the weight of his station,
ultimately isolated himself.
The proverb of Xiaohui remains a timeless warning to us all.
