Top Gear and The Grand Tour Are Coming Back... But Why?
Aug 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe BBC and Amazon are reviving Top Gear and The Grand Tour with new presenters, sparking debate over whether these brands can survive without the original trio. The speaker questions the necessity of these revivals in the YouTube era and warns against the dangerous escalation of stunts for spectacle, suggesting a shift toward high-quality, cinematic journalism over \"circus-like\" entertainment.
So Top Gear is coming back. The BBC has officially confirmed it, although we don't yet know when,
what form it will take or who will present it, although there's already some speculation.
Meanwhile, Amazon is about to relaunch the Grand Tour with an entirely new trio of presenters. So
after several years without either program in its proper form on our television, suddenly
the two biggest brands in motoring entertainment are preparing to go head to head all over again.
And my first question is simply this. Why? I mean, do we really need Top Gear? Do we need
the Grand Tour without Clarkson, Hammond and May? Are these revivals genuinely born from a passion
for cars and a desire to celebrate motoring culture? Or are the BBC and Amazon rummaging
around in the cupboard and finding two famous car show brands and deciding that there must still be
some money left to squeeze out of these two? More importantly, if these programs are returning,
what should they actually be? Because the world that created the Top Gear as most people knew it
has frankly disappeared. You see, when Clarkson, Hammond and May were at their peak, television was
still the dominant way most people discovered car videos, right? You waited for Sunday evening to
watch this show, you watch whatever they chose to show you, and then we all discussed it at work or
at school on the Monday. Today, YouTube provides more automotive content in a single afternoon than
a television show could offer in an entire series. Reviews, comparisons, news, ownership reports,
technical analysis, restorations, road trips, supercars, cheap cars, classic cars, electric cars,
motorsport, off-roading, and yes, blokes trying to jump a 500 pound hatchback over another 500 pound
hatchback. Whatever you want to see, somebody is probably already doing it on YouTube. And usually
they are doing it quicker and with much closer connection to their audience than the television
shows ever could. So what can television bring to this party other than a famous brand, a large
invoice, and maybe a helicopter? Actually forget about the helicopters because now we've all got
drones anyway. Anyway, let's get into all of this right after this.
Let's begin with Top Gear because my honest verdict is that bringing it back is a complete mistake,
especially if the BBC intends to just recreate it as another comedy entertainment show. That
version of Top Gear belonged to Clarkson, Hammond, and May. Its enormous success was built around
their chemistry and chemistry is something that broadcasters continually believe that they can
manufacture by putting three people in a room and waiting for lightning to strike. It usually
doesn't, does it? Well, at least not in a good way. Clarkson, Hammond, and May became three recognizable
characters. Clarkson was bombastic, provocative, and frequently outrageous. Hammond was the energetic,
enthusiastic. May was the thoughtful, pedantic, intellectual. They annoyed one another,
challenged one another, and appeared to enjoy one another's company even while pretending that they
didn't. Their relationship developed over years. The insults worked because there was a kind of
affection underneath them. Their arguments felt convincing because they were coming at it from
different directions. What people sometimes forget though is that the three of them also possessed
authentic motoring credibility. Jeremy Clarkson was a motoring journalist long before he was on TV
and an extraordinarily gifted writer, well before he became one of the world's biggest
motoring television personalities. James May was a proper motoring journalist with a formidable
technical curiosity and a genuine sensitivity towards engineering, history, and design. Richard
Hammond was a professional broadcaster with an authentic enthusiasm for cars and admittedly bikes
as well. They didn't merely perform excitement because a director put a car in front of them
and shouted action. They understood why the car mattered. They knew its history, its rivals,
its cultural significance, and how it made us enthusiasts feel. That passion came through
on the screen. The antics, the explosions, and ridiculous challenges, they became
the most visible ingredients, yet the credibility beneath them is what actually made the whole thing
work. Copy the challenges without that foundation and you are left with three presenters standing
there reading jokes while a caravan is driven off a cliff. That is why so many versions of Top
Gear, when they've tried to replicate it, it's always been struggled. It's always struggled,
right? Remember they have actually franchised this show around the world and none of those
other editions as far as I know have really worked, not even the American ones, and surely that would
have worked. They copied the test track, the challenges, the faceless racing driver,
the studio audience, the scripted bickering, but it still didn't work and it didn't work
because it wasn't those trio and specifically because it wasn't Clarkson. And there was no
point searching for another Jeremy Clarkson. There will, I have to say, never be another
Jeremy Clarkson, partly because he is a unique talent and partly because the media environment
that created him no longer exists or allowed him to exist actually. Clarkson was allowed to be
opinionated, difficult, contradictory, and occasionally infuriating. Today we have a
it's removed from its context and is presented before an online
tribunal, right? Broadcasters, consequently, they will favor safer, carefully trained TV
personalities who can survive a press tour without producing a crisis. Although having said that,
Jimmy Carr is reportedly being considered for the revived Top Gear. That's what the speculation is
saying. Now, Jimmy is an extremely clever comedian, though he has the world's most annoying laugh.
And to be fair, he does have an interest in cars. He once set the fastest celebrity lap when he
appeared on the Top Gear show. And he has some interesting cars, including an electric converted
Aston Martin DV6, although some would suggest that that criminal act alone disqualifies him
from presenting Top Gear immediately. And you know, the public knows Jimmy Carr is a comedian
and a panel show host, right? He isn't recognized as an automotive journalist, a racing driver,
an engineer, or any kind of motoring authority. Liking cars and owning expensive ones doesn't
automatically give somebody the credibility to lead Britain's most famous motoring show.
Now, Steve Coogan would be a better choice. He is known for being a genuine car enthusiast,
a thoughtful performer, and a brilliant storyteller. Although he did turn down the show
when it was offered to him in, I think it was 2016, because he didn't want that kind of pressure.
And frankly, I can understand what he meant, because whoever takes that job will, of course,
immediately be compared to Clarkson and, of course, Clarkson, Hammond, and May. Every joke,
opinion, and review will be measured against the most successful era of that program of Top Gear.
It is one of the largest poisoned chalices in television, if you think about it.
And then we have The Grand Tour, which returns on Prime Video with Thomas Holland and James
Engelsman from the Throttle House YouTube channel, alongside Francis Bourgeois. People
who regularly watch Throttle House tell me that Holland and Engelsman are excellent. They already
have an established relationship, and that gives them, obviously, an advantage there.
I haven't watched enough of their work to pretend that I know them that well. But to be fair,
I suspect that that actually applies to a huge amount of The Grand Tour's mainstream global
audiences as well. I mean, remember that being highly successful on automotive YouTube still
does not mean that everyone knows who you are. I mean, these guys have nearly three and a half
million subscribers on YouTube, and that sounds like a lot. But let's have some context, right?
At its peak, Top Gear pulled in an estimated 350 million viewers worldwide across more than
200 territories, making it the world's most watched factual television program.
Sure, the new Grand Tour presenters could be brilliant, and I hope they are, but moving from
a YouTube channel into a major global entertainment franchise is a substantial leap. Production style,
performance, pacing, and audience expectations are all quite different. Francis Bourgeois is an
even more curious choice. I mean, I've seen his short-form videos, and in that environment,
you know, he can be great fun. He's got this thing where he sticks a GoPro with a wide-angle
thing on it stuck to his face, and he's beaming with unrestrained excitement and giggling as
trains thunder past, and his enthusiasm is really infectious in short bursts. Give him a longer
format, however, and on the basis of what I've seen, I find the limitations of his screen charisma
become much more apparent. What is charming for 30 seconds becomes rather tedious for 30 minutes.
Again, he could prove me wrong, and I hope he does. I look forward to it. The larger problem
is that the Grand Tour was specifically created as a home for Clarkson, Hammond, and May after the
BBC got rid of them, right, or lost Clarkson. Amazon wanted those three men. They wanted their
relationship and their enormous global audience that followed them from Top Gear. That was the
entire reason that the Grand Tour exists. Remove the trio, and what exactly makes it the Grand Tour,
right? The title? The budget? Stunts? Silliness? Amazon's promotional slogan for the new show with
the new presenters is, same show, new knobs, which is amusing, although it also kind of captures the
problem here. If the show remains fundamentally the same show, while the personalities at the
center are simply switched out, then audiences may feel that they are watching a poor copycat show,
honestly speaking, right? Both programs also face another danger, and this is where the
conversation actually becomes far more serious. Competition encourages escalation,
dangerous escalation. Check out Brown Car Guys' latest novel, Silent Ruin. Action, adventure, spies,
betrayal, romance, plus, of course, cool cars and car chases, it's got the lot. And don't forget how
to be an automotive content creator. The Uless Files and Quantum Races, all Brown Car Guys books
are available on Amazon and Kindle Unlimited. If Top Gear and the Grand Tour are fighting for the
same audience, each will feel the pressure to go bigger, further, crazier, and more outrageous.
Bigger stunts, more ridiculous vehicles, harsher terrain, greater danger. Every trailer for the
needs an explosion. Every episode needs a moment that will go viral and become a headline. Sadly,
we know what that could lead to. Freddy Flintoff suffered life-changing physical and psychological
injuries whilst filming Top Gear in December 2022. He later described living with post-traumatic
stress, anxiety, nightmares, and flashbacks. Chris Harris has said that three months before
the accident, he warned the BBC that unless something changed, somebody could suffer a
injury or even be killed. The BBC's subsequent independent review said its production had
complied with required policies and industry practices whilst also identifying important
lessons including clearer responsibilities and better communication. I have to include that,
but I don't think that that's anywhere good enough from the BBC. It doesn't, for example,
commit to no longer deliberately putting TV presenters' lives in danger. And think about
this. How does putting another human being at unnecessary risk help cars, drivers, or motoring
culture? I mean, I love cars. I love driving. I want mainstream media to celebrate both,
but I never want to watch somebody suffer life-changing injuries for a segment involving
an unsuitable vehicle, a manufactured challenge, just for a few minutes of television.
Of course, there is some risk inherent in doing driving stuff and doing motorsports and in
adventurous filmmaking. Experienced professionals can assess and manage that risk as much as
possible. The danger, however, begins when escalating editorial ambition, tight schedules,
and competition for spectacle create pressure to keep pushing. If two giant motoring programs
are competing again, the temptation will be there to outdo one another. And that is precisely
what they must resist. Nobody needs to be fired from a catapult in a Reliant Robin. Nobody needs
to cross an active volcano in a shipping container that's been converted into an
amphibious mobile production office. Nobody should have to risk death because a producer
needs a dramatic trailer shot. A serious accident would cause enormous suffering,
damage the program, and hand further ammunition to those who portray car enthusiasm itself
as reckless and irresponsible. That harms the very culture that these programs are supposed to be
celebrating. In fact, I believe that the antics and escalating craziness that made these shows
famous are exactly what they now need to abandon. It has already created a generation of social
media viral copycats doing all of the same things on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube.
Plus, you know, YouTube already does all of this stuff better, right? Car reviews are better. Car
news is faster. YouTube offers unlimited car guy silliness, outrageous bills, cheap car challenges,
drag races, and even destruction, right? And much of it is produced by people that have a direct
knowledge and understanding of their audiences. There's very few editorial restrictions,
and the production turnaround speed that, you know, we can do as YouTubers would leave lumbering
legacy broadcasters weeping in their sleep. Television cannot compete with YouTube on this
basis. What YouTube usually lacks, though, is the funding scale, professional research,
exceptional access, and world-class production capability to create something truly epic.
That is where major broadcasters and streaming platforms still have an opportunity.
Give me beautifully made driving tours that explore countries, people, and motoring culture,
with stunning cinematography, and presenters who allow the journey to breathe. Give me ambitious
documentaries about the rise of the Chinese motor industry, the death of the affordable sports car,
the history of the motorway, the transformation of Formula One, the battle over autonomous driving,
the decline of the manual gearbox, or the communities fighting to preserve classic cars
around the world. Investigate car theft, insurance costs, dangerous roads, manufacture failures,
and political decisions impacting our freedom to own and drive cars. Take us inside factories
design studios, racing teams, and engineering departments that, you know, us independent
creators, for example, we don't have access to that sort of stuff. Tell us why cars matter. Explore how
they changed societies, enabled freedom, reshaped cities, created industries, and became objects of
aspiration, identity, and art. Use the budget that you have to make something profound, cinematic,
and memorable. Spend the money on access, research, photography, and storytelling, rather than
another exploding Morris Marina. For Top Gear especially, this could mean returning to its roots,
but with much better production qualities. The original Top Gear, don't forget, launched way back
in 1977 as a proper motoring magazine program. It covered new cars, road safety, consumer advice,
fuel economy, insurance, motorsport, and real issues affecting real drivers. A modern version
could retain personality, humor, and entertainment, while once again taking cars and motorists
seriously. It could use the extraordinary resources of the BBC to investigate, explain, and document
a transport world that is undergoing the greatest transformation since the invention of the motor
car. That program might genuinely have a purpose. Just trying to recreate the Clarkson era
entertainment format with three replacement personalities is pointless. And anyway,
all those old shows, with that trio, are widely available on reruns and repeats.
You can go back and watch them anytime. So, any attempt to recreate those shows,
all it does is remind us how good those original shows were. The Grand Tour faces an even greater
identity crisis because its identity was Clarkson, Hammond, and May. Amazon is asking new presenters
to inherit a program specifically built around those three people. And that may prove impossible,
regardless of how talented those replacements are. So, should these programs return? I don't
think so, actually. Relaunching Top Gear as another comedy entertainment show would be a mistake.
The BBC would be chasing a past that it just cannot recreate with presenters who will
inevitably judge against the famous trio. A completely reinvented Top Gear built around
serious journalism, magnificent films, consumer advocacy, history, culture, and epic driving
stories could justify its existence. It would need presenters with knowledge, authority,
curiosity, and an authentic emotional connection to cars. Not comedians, and this is Rowan Atkinson,
but really it needs the sort of people who would still be telling motoring stories
even if there was no BBC contract. As for the Grand Tour, I remain deeply skeptical.
Its entire reason for existing departed with Clarkson, Hammond, and May. The new team,
okay, they deserve a fair chance and perhaps they will create something fresh enough to be able to
establish their own identity within that brand. But I'm not so sure. Both shows need to stop
chasing bigger explosions and begin searching for intelligent TV programming ideas. They should use
their money and influence to elevate motoring culture rather than turning it into a circus.
They should inspire people to understand cars, appreciate driving, and recognize the enormous
role that the motor vehicle has played in our lives and in human history. Most of all, they
must remember that no television program, streaming contract, ratings battle, or viral clip
is worth somebody's life. Now tell me what you think. Tell me in the comments. I look forward
to reading your views and I'll catch you all in the next video. If you found this video useful
or entertaining, support the BrownCarGuy channel at these links. Hit like, leave a comment, and make
sure you're subscribing.

