Toyota Tacoma vs GMC Canyon Off-Road: The Results Surprised Even Us!

Cars Arena
18 followers
#GJWcars #GJWauto #GJWcar #cararena #choicecar #selectcar #comparecars #autos #cars #review #reviewcars
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the 2026 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road and the GMC Canyon AT4X on the challenging Pennsylvania Gulch trail. While both mid-size trucks are priced around $55,000 and handle narrow paths well, the Canyon proves superior for dedicated rock crawling due to its front and rear lockers and greater ground clearance, whereas the Tacoma offers versatile, high-value capability.
Case, right here we have two very different off-road pickup trucks.
But they have the same price tag.
You've brought the most popular truck in this segment, the Toyota Tacoma.
Yes.
But I've brought what I would argue is the best off-road truck in this segment.
The GMC Canyon 84X?
The very same.
Dang.
And we are here not at Ironclad Trail where we would normally film, right?
That's right.
We're at Pennsylvania Gulch, a challenge that neither of us have done in several years.
Yeah.
To see which of these trucks is the best.
And it's rated 7 out of 10 difficulty scale by Onyx Off-Road, which I am a little frightened by.
Should be good.
Case, I'm so happy that we brought these two mid-sized trucks
because this trail, the Pennsylvania Gulch, is super narrow and I think mid-size is ideal.
It's an underrated part of trucks in this category,
the fact that they fit down the majority of trails.
Where especially some wide-body trucks like full-size Raptors and the TRX or RHO,
they don't fit that easily.
It's June, right?
So stuff is starting to grow.
And as soon as you got some branches on the side,
it's really easy to pinstripe your truck or vehicle.
So I'm super happy that we got Tacoma and Canyon.
I hear your parking sensor is going off.
I'm still trying to learn how to disable them.
As Kay said, I brought the best seller, 2026 Toyota Tacoma.
And this is a TRD Off-Road model, but it's also a premium model.
I'll show you some of the technology inside of this truck.
But basically, it's off-road ready.
It's got all-terrain tires.
It's got a locking rear differential and some skid plates.
But I don't have a lot of clearance, so I'm a little nervous.
This little tangerine is, of course, our long-term GMC Canyon AT4X.
It's a truck that comes from the factory with front and rear lockers,
some pretty aggressive Goodyear Wranglers,
sliders, and quite a bit of usable ground clearance,
which means that, in my opinion,
this is one of, if not the best, rock-crawling midsize trucks on the market.
Hey, Kay, did you see that sign when we entered?
It said, first of all, what the road was.
But then it said, extremely dangerous condition.
Yeah, I don't know.
I mean, there's definitely some challenges on this stretch of trail,
but I don't know that it qualifies as being life-threatening.
Well, yeah, but there's also no reception here.
We've downloaded our Onyx Off-Road Maps, so at least we're good there.
And we've got two very capable trucks.
You know, I know I was talking about how I think that this GMC Canyon
is arguably the best rock-crawling midsize truck out there.
And I stand by that because there's other good rock-crawling midsizers,
Tacoma being one of them, but you can't get a Tacoma with a front locker.
Gladiator, you can, but that's got a pretty long wheelbase.
Ranger Raptor, you can, but this sits up taller than that.
So as far as a well-rounded rock-crawler goes,
I really love this and the Colorado ZR2.
And it's hard to believe that both of these trucks can be had
for around $55,000 or so, plus or minus a grand, out the door.
Yeah, I don't know if I would call either of these cheap trucks,
but you do get a lot of baked-in capability and they're both very versatile vehicles.
Indeed.
I mean, you could get a Tacoma TRD Off-Road for way less, almost $9,000 less.
But dude, this trail is getting hard right away.
We got kind of a boulder field coming up right now.
Yeah, and it's an interesting trail because, like you said, it is very narrow.
So I think we have the right vehicles for the location, but it's a little hard to shoot.
And I got to say, I wish it wasn't the case,
but the camera system on the Jim's Canyon is very useful because,
like with most modern trucks, the hood is pretty tall.
So my forward visibility without the camera is not great.
All right, so I was able to overcome that without the rear lockers.
So I'm going to lock it up right now.
Hey, everybody.
I want to talk about Incogni, a cool online privacy tool that people like us love to see.
You know, we're so fortunate to have a couple million subscribers across our channels,
and it's great when you guys come up to us in airports and restaurants.
It's so nice talking to you.
But ultimately, we also like our privacy.
Incogni can help keep our privacy and sanity by chasing down and shutting down
data brokers who could sell our personal information to scanners,
hackers, criminal or identity thieves.
Incogni also works to help remove our phone numbers and home address from the web.
Incogni's automated removal service does the bulk of the work.
However, if you find something you don't want out there,
Incogni's custom removal service can take care of it.
So do yourself, your privacy and your sanity a favor and check out Incogni,
the only personal data remover independently verified by Deloitte, no less.
Go to incogni.com slash TFL Offroad or click the link below.
Use code TFL Offroad for 60% off an annual plan.
They can't harm you if they can't find you, right?
I suppose for the sake of comparison, I'll do the same generally.
When I have a locker, I try to use it, not tear up the trail too much,
but we'll see how it does without.
Not too bad.
Takes just a little bit of thinking from traction control to send power where it needs to go.
Then Canyon crawls its way right up.
And again, like with Andre, that's without the rear locker engaged.
If I go ahead and kick it on, things will get much easier.
And the locker engagement on this Canyon is really good.
Okay, so I hit my button for my rear locker and it's still blinking.
See, one nice thing with this Canyon is the moment I hit that switch,
the light is on solid and I've got my rear locker.
So you're not locking up the front yet, huh?
Not quite yet.
I'm not sure it's necessary for where we're at now, but maybe a little later on.
But I gotta say it is one knock against the Tacoma and it's been this way for a long time.
It's both getting in and out of low range and also engaging and disengaging the rear locker.
There's a bit of a process in that truck.
Yeah, before we started the trail, my low range, I was able to enable it very easily, very quickly.
The rear locker is taking a little while to get in,
but also the traction control system in this truck is very capable.
And I'm also missing one piece of equipment.
I really wish I had.
It's optional, actually.
You're leaving me hanging.
What's this mystery piece of equipment?
Well, for $1,200, I could have had a disconnectable front anti-sway bar,
and I don't on this particular truck.
Yeah, that would be a nice thing to have, especially if you can't equip it with a front
locker, at least some additional articulation on the front end would be helpful.
Oh, boy, dude, it's getting steep and deep coming up here in just a tiny bit.
We're both on Goodyear Wrangler tires, but they're quite different, actually.
The Tacoma is rolling on Territory 80s, so all-terrains.
And you could see a little bit of sidewall protection and decent tread.
But mostly, I mean, it's a little bit compromised because this is also a very nice highway tire,
very quiet.
But that's also an 18-inch wheel.
This is a 265-65R18, so I don't have a lot of sidewall.
Like Andre said, I'm also on Goodyears, as he is.
But as Jen behind the camera pointed out, if Andre's got Goodyears, I've got GreatYears,
because these are Wrangler Territory MTs, so they are much more aggressive.
They measure out at about 33 inches.
So I've also got a little extra sidewall and overall bigger diameter.
It just got really dark and sinister.
The clouds came overhead.
And I was reading the comments on this trail, and it said that this trail is really washed
out, which I can see right now with my own eyes.
In any case, I'm cheating a little bit.
I don't think you're supposed to tell me that.
Well, I put a camera underneath my truck, but I have a monitor that I'm monitoring inside
my cab.
You're giving yourself an additional camera view?
Yeah, I have just modified this truck with an additional camera.
You know, you can get an underbody camera in a lot of GM off-road trucks from the factory.
Oh, smack.
I think he means, oh, snap.
Dude, I'm really shocked that I haven't touched any skid plate yet, and I think I'm about
to.
So far, so good.
Wow, I'm very impressed with this Tacoma.
Wow.
Uh-oh.
Hold on, dude.
I'm a little hung up.
No, I just got rocks in front of every tire, so I need to bump it a little.
All right, I'm changing my line just a little bit.
Oh, what am I hitting?
It's like a sway bar.
Front A-arm?
Oh, like a tiny bump.
Oh, man.
Just a tiny bump, huh?
Okay.
All right, dude, I hit my front A-arm on the driver's side.
So let's see if you can clear this without touching.
I gotta say, Andre, I feel pretty good about it because this canyon sits up tall from the
factory.
It's a little bit of a hike to get up into the driver's seat, but it's worth it for the
extra clearance.
I got a couple of big rocks in front of me here.
I think you're doing okay so far.
It's pretty awesome here in the canyon just how tall this truck sits.
It's not necessarily talked about a lot, but you can take some pretty hard lines and cruise
your way over quite a bit.
Now, you can get an even taller version of this truck if you have, you know, 70 or so
thousand dollars to spend on an AEV version of this truck with factory 35s, which is just
a ridiculous amount of clearance and, honestly, tire on a factory midsize truck that comes
with a warranty and everything.
But it's a lot of money.
This truck is a lot more reasonable and especially even a Colorado ZR2 that you can get closer
to $50,000.
That's a lot of off-road ability for a truck in that price range.
So these machines are pretty impressive.
I do really like taking this canyon off-road.
Let's see, I'm sliding a little bit.
I might go ahead and kick on my front locker just like that.
So I think you got to the same place where I was, so you need to go a little bit driver.
And again, you just can't see anything beyond the hood of this truck because it's so tall.
But a little bump, a little scrape.
I mean, I have no idea what...
I don't understand.
Shut up!
And your truck is yelling at me.
Yeah, I can't see anything of the trail in front of me other than what the camera shows,
which flattens everything out.
So line choice is a bit of guesswork.
But luckily, the truck is capable enough to get through it and it's got a lot of underbody
protection, so I don't worry too much.
Yeah, so I was watching what was going on and you hit right on the...
If the skid plate is here and the arm is on this side,
it was right on the corner of the skid plate.
Yeah.
So you touched in the right place.
When I was further down the trail, so I didn't see exactly what line you took,
so mine might have been very different.
But pretty much with this truck, on a trail like this, that's as narrow as it is.
And with this hood, where your field of view is limited,
you kind of need a spotter to pick a line because the camera helps,
but it's not the same as actually being able to look out of the front of the truck.
And my underbody camera that I installed didn't help me either,
but we chose the same line on this obstacle.
Right on.
So it seems like so far it's kind of a tie.
A little bit, yeah, yeah.
Even though you have a little bit better traction.
I mean, your locking differentials are working.
Yeah, I still feel confident that the canyon is going to float to the top.
That's my prediction.
The more challenging stuff is coming.
Let's see.
This tier D off-road model has the premium packages I mentioned,
which comes with an interior upgrade and also technology upgrade.
This is a large 14-inch horizontal display here,
which I call my home's television screen.
But it also provides me a view of my surrounding cameras.
This is very useful.
I can actually see where my wheels are pointing on this top screen.
I have a proximity warning chime,
which is a little bit annoying.
I need to turn it off,
but I can also see on the side of my truck and also below my truck.
Once I start moving,
this image is going to be filled in by the terrain I'm going over.
It's not perfect,
but at least it's letting me know some of the obstacles I'm about to take.
And I also have multi-terrain select.
I can go through several modes
and I have crawl control system here.
I can select the speed.
And I'm already in four low,
so I'm locked and loaded.
Oof, that tree is close.
Close!
So just to illustrate the problem,
this is my point of view.
You can see the trail well ahead of you,
but your view of what you're immediately rolling over is pretty limited.
And this camera view does help,
but everything, of course, looks very flat in a camera view.
So it's hard to get a real good idea of the terrain that you're driving over.
So you kind of got to memorize the trail in front of you
and pick your line based off of that.
Okay, I'm still monitoring my cameras.
And actually side view,
because I want to protect my sidewall of my tires.
Because if I pop it here,
there's not a lot of options for changing tires or towing.
So that's why that sign was warning us to say that
if you have a problem on this trail,
it's very difficult to get out.
Now, both of these trucks have, of course, turbo fours,
which not everybody loves.
And granted, they don't sound particularly good,
but they do give you quite a bit of low-end torque,
which is nice, especially when you're on a trail.
You don't have to get into top end of the rev range
to deliver the torque that you need to push you up a couple rocks,
which is good.
Now, the way this trail is set up is interesting.
It's not necessarily individual challenges or climbs
like what we have on some other trails where we test,
but more so just a continuous uphill climb,
which is, I guess, the only kind of climb
where you've got pretty consistent rocks the whole way.
And every now and then, you just need a wee bit of a bump.
I've got to be honest, I'm a little surprised,
but it doesn't really seem like this canyon, even with...
Do you want me to tow you?
Yeah, yeah.
I was just saying on camera, I'm a little surprised,
but it doesn't really seem like this canyon's
having any easier of a time on this trail than the Tacoma is,
which is interesting.
I mean, I've got front locker engaged
and we've tested this canyon against Tacoma's up in Moab before
and it did much better than the TRD Offroad,
but today, not so much.
Well, I know what you're saying,
but I think it's the difficulty of this trail.
It's unpredictable, dude.
Yeah, and it could just be my choice to some degree,
but yeah, I mean, so far, Tacoma's doing great.
I'm very impressed with this Tacoma here right now.
So I've got Bilstein shocks on this truck
and so far, I mean, this is very slow,
so we're not getting to see all the capabilities of these shocks,
but they're good overall for not the top-of-the-line package,
but kind of this middle-of-the-road package
because there's still the TRD Pro
and Trailhunter editions of the Tacoma
and those have a little bit more stout gear
and even more skid plates
and those are more expensive because they're hybrid.
This is not a hybrid.
I have a 2.4 liter four-cylinder turbo,
non-hybrid version of the Tacoma
and 278 horsepower,
which is plenty for what we're doing right now.
Really good stuff.
Okay, Case, I think we've got the roots coming.
Oh, I love the roots.
Oh, you mean the plant?
I know, I know, I love the roots also,
but actually, these are the tree roots,
which are kind of difficult.
Jenna's a rock star today.
She's climbing 2,000 vertical feet in a matter of a mile,
so she's a champ.
I'm just relaxing behind the steering wheel of a Tacoma.
Oh, I just touched my rear axle trailing arm.
Hold up.
Oh, okay, I'm not relaxing anymore.
This is challenging.
Okay, now I'm working out.
I mean, the truck is working out
and I'm trying not to damage it.
So that's what's happening right now.
Still hopeful that this Canyon is going to demonstrate
its increased capability over a TRD Off-Road Tacoma.
And I'm hoping that happens right now.
So far, no touching, no slipping.
Taking it nice and slow.
Look at that.
Fully locked.
It's a little better than me.
Yeah, see?
You know, it's feeling like a fully locked truck
because it is.
Man, that front locker and the predictability of it
and the slightly more aggressive tread on these tires.
I think there's definitely plenty of situations
where it helps you out a bit.
You know, you could air down a bit more
and I think that Canyon would be unstoppable, really.
Yeah, that's true.
Obviously, this truck isn't on beadlocks or anything,
so you wouldn't air way, way down.
But no, we could be lower.
I didn't really air down
because I wanted all the ground clearance I can muster.
Yeah, fair enough.
So far, the Tacoma really hasn't had many issues bottoming out.
I know you said you touched down on one of the front A-arms
and I saw the exhaust pipe drag just a little bit,
but still not bad.
Yeah, I touched my rear axle trailing arm as well.
Yeah, I've got a couple of little nicks.
I was just saying to the camera, Jen,
that there's a lot of vertical here
because we're traveling about 2,000 feet vertical climb
over the course of two miles,
which is actually quite a heavy, heavy incline.
You know what?
I'm not driving, but I can feel it.
Well, I'm driving,
so I'm letting the turbocharger do all the breathing.
That's good.
So...
I can use a turbocharger right now.
Like in the Tacoma,
this GMC Canyon also has plenty of different camera views
that will let you cycle through
and see some of your surroundings,
which is good because visibility
in a lot of modern vehicles is not the best.
So you have that as an option.
The other really impactful thing
that we've got going on with this truck
is front and rear lockers.
So obviously the Tacoma has a rear locker.
This Canyon has a front locker as well,
which is going to be a huge help on any difficult trail.
And as well, we have our settings for the transfer case,
two high, four high, four low,
and a four auto mode as well.
All right, Keith,
I think we're coming up to the final obstacle
at the top of this trail,
which is the V-notch,
very narrow,
and also lots of articulation as well here.
Nice, yeah.
This is going to hopefully show
more than some of the smaller obstacles so far,
differences between these two trucks.
I think I missed that rock on my passenger side,
but just an inch, dude.
Yeah, width is definitely the enemy on this trail.
You really don't get a ton of line choice
just because of how narrow it is.
Nice.
This Canyon just feels right at home on the trail.
It's really nice to drive.
All right, Case,
so last time I was here was several years ago,
and I think the trail looks different
because I remember this V-notch
being a sideways obstacle where you lean,
and right now I'm not leaning.
Yeah, likewise,
it has been a long time since I've been up here as well,
and I don't much remember it,
it's like you get through it,
no problem sticking to the left.
Well, now I'm leaning the other way.
I'm leaning to the passenger side now,
and I remember several years back,
I was leaning to the driver's side.
Yeah, it is funny how much these trails change over time.
They're never quite the same.
I might touch on this rock.
I'm not quite sure.
Oh, wow, this gorgeous aspen grove.
This is crazy beautiful.
So we're trying to stick left here.
See how we do.
This Canyon is not incredibly wide,
but it's wide enough to feel very stable side to side,
so I don't worry too much about leaning one direction or another.
Not that this is a super extreme lean that we have going on here.
So really feel very comfortable cruising the Canyon through terrain like this.
The other nice thing about having lockers is just the predictability of it.
There's fewer situations generally where you have to use momentum,
which is nice because that lets you have a nice controlled approach
to whatever obstacles you're climbing up.
Let's see how the Canyon does as we start to lift some tires.
And as always, cruise it slow.
Only use momentum when it's strictly necessary.
Okay, I think this is the end.
We need to pick up Jan.
This Canyon is just solid as a rock on the trail.
Case, my tires are still intact.
I cannot believe it.
Yeah, both of us made it to the end of the trail.
No worse for wear, which is good.
Touch the underside a little bit, but that's what these trucks are for.
But the comparison between the two, what's your verdict?
Okay, so here's where I am.
I think you touched maybe once significantly on your skid plate.
I've touched like three or four times.
So from that standpoint, your truck was better.
But the traction on this Tacoma is really impressive.
Yeah, I was surprised by it on this particular trail.
I really don't think that the Tacoma in most ways performed any worse than the Canyon,
but I would still pick this truck over the Tacoma purely for rock crawling
because of the factory rock sliders, the bigger tires, extra clearance,
and that front locker is all pretty nice stuff to have.
I think the GMC Canyon, the way you see it here is a great value
for what you get as far as running gear.
This, I could make it better value by subtracting the premium package
and maybe selecting the towing pack, the rear locker, and the anti-sway bar disconnect.
And then that would make it a little bit more affordable.
I just have trouble with paying almost $56,000 for not a TRD Pro.
You know what I'm saying?
Yeah, which is fair enough.
There is a reason that a lot of people pick the Tacoma.
It is a truck that will get you just about anywhere you want to go.
But the Canyon is still my favorite between the two.
I think we agree there.
And also there's thunder, so we got to get out of here.
Let's go.
Is that Andre or Bigfoot?
Jen.
Oh, no worries.
Is that moose?
Because those are pretty large.
I'm guessing they're not deer.
So that could be a moose, dude.
That's some good droppings.
