One of the biggest mistakes wine collectors make is opening expensive bottles too early.
Sometimes you simply want a mature Bordeaux that is already drinking beautifully, does not cost hundreds of dollars, and can be opened without hesitation over dinner with family or friends.
In this video, I compare two ready-to-drink Bordeaux wines from my own cellar:
2012 Château Tronquoy-Lalande from Saint-Estèphe 2015 Château Prieuré-Lichine from Margaux
One costs around US$40. The other around US$60. For mature Bordeaux, I think both offer exceptional value.
The 2012 vintage has quietly become one of my favourite Bordeaux vintages to drink today. Its Merlot-led wines often show silky tannins, approachable structure and plenty of charm.
Meanwhile, 2015 was an outstanding vintage for Margaux, producing fragrant, polished wines that combine generosity with elegance.
In this video, I discuss: Why 2012 Bordeaux is drinking so well today Why 2015 was such a successful vintage in Margaux Château Tronquoy-Lalande vs Château Prieuré-Lichine How differently these two wines taste Food pairings for each bottle Why I recently bought more of both
If you are looking for mature Bordeaux that is ready to open now, I hope this comparison helps you decide which style belongs in your cellar.
Chapters 00:00 Ready-to-Drink Bordeaux Under US$60 01:27 Why 2012 Bordeaux Is Worth Buying Today 02:10 Château Tronquoy-Lalande 2012 02:55 Château Tronquoy-Lalande 2012's Tasting Notes 03:35 Why 2015 Margaux Drinks So Well Today 04:16 Château Prieuré-Lichine 2015 05:04 Château Prieuré-Lichine 2015's Tasting Notes 05:35 Which Bordeaux Should You Buy? 06:48 Final Verdict
Wines Featured 2012 Château Tronquoy-Lalande @chateautronquoy-lalandesai9683 2015 Château Prieuré-Lichine @chateauprieure-lichine4284
If you were looking for one ready-to-drink Bordeaux today, would you choose the elegance of Margaux or the savoury depth of Saint-Estèphe?
One of the biggest mistakes wine collectors make is opening expensive bottles too early.
I have done it myself. Sometimes you simply want a mature Bordeaux to share with family or friends.
Not a bottle that's still 10 years away from its peak. And not a bottle that costs hundreds
of dollars. That's exactly why I have always kept a section of my cellar for what I call
ready-to-drink Bordeaux. Wines that are already showing beautifully don't cost a fortune and are
good enough that nobody feels short-changed. Two bottles I recently bought more of are
2012 Chateau Tronc-Poil-A-Land from Saint-Esteve and 2015 Chateau Prieuré-les-Chine from Marbot.
One costs around 40 US dollars. The other around 60 US dollars. For mature Bordeaux,
that's exceptional value. In this video, I will compare two bottles from my cellar,
explain how differently they taste, which dishes they pair best with and ultimately tell you which
one I would recommend depending on the style of Bordeaux you enjoy. And before we begin,
while you are still discovering your preferences, buy three or six bottles rather than a full case
of 12. A cellar should evolve alongside your taste. Why 2012 Bordeaux is worth buying today?
The 2012 Bordeaux Vintage has quietly become one of my favorite vintages to drink today.
It never had the reputation of 2010 nor the hype of 2015 or 2016. But that's exactly why it still
represents such good value. Often described as a mellow vintage because of the late growing season,
2012 produced wines with silky tannins, a potable structure and plenty of charm.
They are not wines to hide away for another 20 years. They are wines to enjoy now. And that's
becoming increasingly rare in Bordeaux. Chateau Tronc-Poil-A-Land, 2012. Dating back to the 18th
century, this 30 hectare Saint-Esteve estate was acquired in 2006 by the Brigg brothers, owners of
neighboring Chateau Morose, who invested heavily in both the vineyards and winery. Since 2022,
the estate has simply been known as Chateau Tronc-Poil-A-Land. This has always struck me as one of those Bordeaux
wines that's enjoyable young but becomes even more satisfying with a little Bordeaux age.
The 2012 is brewed around 57% Malot, 40% Cabernet Sauvignon, 2% Cabernet Franc and 1% Petit Verdot.
On the nose, I find red berries, baking spices, forest flora, savory herbs and crushed stone.
The palate is medium bodied, beautifully textured and wonderfully balanced. There is enough structure
to remind you it's Saint-Esteve, but enough maturity that everything feels harmonious.
As the wine has aged, it's gained extra complexity without losing the generosity that first attracted
me. Today, it's exactly where I want it to be. The 2012 Chateau Tronc-Poil-A-Land sells for around
40 US dollars. Why 2015 Margot drinks so well today? If 2012 is Mordeaux's quiet overachiever,
2015 is one of Margot's modern classics. Warm days and cool nights produce wines with dark
fruit, floral perfume, polished tannins and remarkable balance. Less powerful than 2009
perhaps, but wonderfully refined. For me, 2015 even edges out 2016 in Margot. It captures everything
I love about the appellation. Silky, fragrant, elegant. The wines are already drinking beautifully
yet still have many years ahead of them. Chateau Priory-Lichyne, 2015. First mentioned in 1444,
Chateau Priory-Lichyne became a fourth worth in the famous 1855 classification. Its modern
reputation owes much to Alexis Lichyne, whose purchase of the estate in 1951 transformed
its fortunes. Since the Ballon Group acquired the 77.5 hectare property in 1999, extensive
investment has further improved vineyard management and winemaking. The 2015 is a blend of 66% Cabernet
Sauvignon, 29% Merlot and 5% Petit Verdot. It's one of the finest Priory-Lichynes I have tasted.
On the nose, I find dark berries and sweet spices with subtle earthy notes underneath. The palate
is silky, polished and unmistakably Margot. Powerful enough to satisfy, elegant enough that
another glass always seems like a good idea. It captures that wonderful balance between generosity
and finesse. The 2015 Chateau Priory-Lichyne sells for around 60 US dollars. These are
exactly the kinds of wines I want sitting in my cellar. Not because they are famous,
not because they will double in value, but because they are ready. Ready for dinner,
ready for friends, ready for those evenings when you don't want to think too hard about what to
open. Finding mature Bordeaux at sensible prices is becoming increasingly difficult. That's why I
recently bought more of both. If your budget stretches to around 60 US dollars, I would
probably choose Priory-Lichyne. It captures everything I love about Margot. Silky tannins,
beautiful perfume and enough freshness to pair effortlessly with roast chicken, duck, veal, pork,
mushrooms or a good cheese board. If your budget is crucial to 40 US dollars, Procolanon is one of
the easiest recommendations I can make. It offers more structure, more savoury character and the
unmistakable personality of Saint-Esteve, while remaining beautifully approachable today.
I love it with roast lamb, steak, venison or slow-cooked beef. Personally, I don't think there
is a wrong choice. I would simply decide based on what was on the dinner table and that's exactly why
these two bottles continue to earn a place in my cellar. If you were looking for a ready-to-drink
Bordeaux today, which would you choose? The elegance of Marvaux or the savoury depth of Saint-Esteve?
I would love to hear which direction you would go and if there is another value Bordeaux comparison
you would like to see next, let me know in the comment section below. You will find more
of my cellar insights and tasting notes on Instagram. Massive thanks for watching today
and I will see you in the next one.