Mayim Bialik told me that believing the sun will rise tomorrow is the same thing as religious faith, and I think she's right.
I brought a real meteorite into the studio to prove we're not just stardust, we're something even stranger.
Mayim Bialik is a neuroscientist who explores the intersection of science and spirituality on her own podcast.
We cover: - Why asking "what happened before the Big Bang" might not even be a valid question - Why I'm not just stardust, but literal Big Bang matter, and what that means - What the mysterious "arrow of time" reveals about whether our universe had a beginning - Why a meteorite sitting on my desk explains where our elements actually came from - How I define faith using the Hebrew word emunah, and why that word doesn't need scientific proof
🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
This discussion explores the origins of the universe, the nature of time, and the intersection of scientific inquiry and personal faith. The speakers examine whether \"before\" the Big Bang is a meaningful concept and discuss the physical composition of humans, contrasting \"star stuff\" with \"Big Bang stuff.\"
We're mostly made of Big Bang stuff.
So what happened the Tuesday before the Big Bang
is a legitimate question,
if and only if the universe existed before,
even if time came into existence, as we know.
I can't help but think of sort of the Old Testament
kind of concept and also the mystical implications of that.
You know, I'm not like,
oh, the Old Testament says,
and therefore it's a science book,
but the mystical implications of how do you imagine
what nothingness looks like, right?
What is before there is, right?
And that's sort of like the mystical concept.
And what I love is that you're not afraid to talk about
some of these parallels because, you know,
we just spoke to Sir Robert Edward Grant,
a very unusual kind of polymath,
but his big thing, his overarching thing
is like everything repeats everywhere.
You can find it everywhere.
We're all just mirrors.
Everything is like self and shadow and all this stuff.
But I think about it even with this,
like what are these patterns that we're seeing?
So yeah, if you could kind of help us understand
what could come before and how do we even imagine that?
My job is to ask the question and maybe answer it,
but certainly ask it,
what happened on the Tuesday before the Big Bang?
There are certain cut conceptions
where that doesn't make any sense.
In fact, Stephen Hawking, the late great Stephen Hawking,
said asking what happened before the Big Bang
is like asking what's north of the North Pole.
So I always turn around, South Pole.
I've been to the South Pole.
When you get to the South Pole
and you go south of the South Pole, you're going north.
There's nowhere to go but north from the South Pole.
So is there a possibility that you could go before time
if time came into existence?
We have to kind of wrap our minds around something, right?
Not only did all the matter that would later become us,
that this came specifically from the Big Bang.
We're all stardust.
Well, stardust is actually,
so Carl Sagan made that case, right?
He said we're all stardust.
So this is a meteorite.
So this is a real meteorite.
This is star stuff.
The hydrogen is not star stuff.
The hydrogen in your body is Big Bang stuff.
It's even more mind-blowing than star stuff.
This came from a supernova that exploded
in our neighborhood in the galaxy,
about 150 million years before the Earth was created.
This predates the Earth
and it's made of very different materials
than the hydrogen in this guy.
It's made of iron, nickel, cobalt.
We're mostly made of Big Bang stuff.
So what happened the Tuesday before the Big Bang
is a legitimate question,
if and only if the universe existed before then.
Even if time came into existence as we know it.
This is the way I think about it.
We're here on a Tuesday.
I'm asking the question,
what happened on Tuesday before the Big Bang?
We can keep going back 24-hour periods, right?
We go back seven 24-hour periods last Tuesday.
Keep going.
You eventually get back 13.826 billion years
and that's some day.
Maybe it was a Tuesday, maybe it wasn't.
Let's say it was a Wednesday.
I wanna know what happened the day before.
Now that question doesn't make sense
if time came into existence at that moment.
A lot of people think of,
especially if you're with no insult,
you're not trained in science.
People think that time exists
and then we got inserted into it.
And the calendar was going and it was going
and there was a January or whatever.
There was a Tuesday and then we evolved.
But time only exists because of matter having,
you get it, being stretched, yeah?
So it's like you can't know what happened before time
because there was no time.
So if there's a relationship between time and temperature,
there's a big mystery in science called the arrow of time.
The laws of nature seem to be reversible.
In other words, if I show you a ticking grandfather clock,
a pendulum going back and forth,
and I ask you, turn away and now look at it.
Where did it start from three weeks ago?
You can't possibly know.
You can't even tell if you're looking at it in reverse
or looking at it in forward.
You mean if you take a snapshot?
Yeah, so the question is, does that apply to time?
It applies to space, does it apply to time?
So where do the laws of physics break off
from being time bound to being time irreversible?
Like when you mix coffee and cream together,
you don't spontaneously see them break apart
into two different sets of cream and coffee, right?
So the arrow of time, did that have a starting point
or did it emerge from a preceding universe
that sort of sacrificed itself, collapsed,
just like the star that became this meteorite,
exploded, spewing its guts all over our galaxy
to birth our solar system.
So true, there could be a preceding universe
that collapsed, exploded, if you will,
and became our existing observable universe.
But we can't see that.
Well, can we infer that it exists?
So in science, we have multiple ways of arriving
at some approximation of truth.
There are no facts in science,
but what you can do is you can falsify things.
And this is interesting to me
because people always ask me,
how do you reconcile being religious and being scientific?
So the most important thing
about a scientific truth, perhaps,
the closest you can come to truth and proof
is resistance to being wrong,
to resistance to what's called falsification.
So I can't prove that the earth is a perfect sphere,
but I can prove it's not flat.
I cannot prove that the sun
will always come up in the east, right?
Something could physically happen.
It's not outside the laws of physics,
therefore it cannot be proven.
But you could falsify for today, it did come up.
Well, I mean, you just defined faith.
Because when people ask me,
especially like, how can you be a scientist
and how can you have faith?
And I say this to my kids,
because I have kids at that age, right?
Do you believe that the sun will come up tomorrow?
And they say, well, yeah, of course.
I said, that's what it feels like.
Like, that's what it feels like.
The way that you honor that,
the way that you commemorate it,
the way you pray over it,
that's culturally specific.
And that depends on your particular DNA
and your personality and where you were raised
and how all the things line up.
But it's the same faith.
Like, to me, it's like,
that's why when people are like,
how can you be a scientist and a person of faith?
How could you not?
Well, I'll never criticize people
for having faith or not having faith.
I've talked to the greatest atheists in the world,
the greatest agnostics in the world.
So I'll never complain.
And you know, you point out,
90% of the National Academy of Sciences
in the United States,
the most prestigious scientific society
in the history of the planet,
does not actively proclaim a belief in God.
They're either atheists or they're agnostic.
And so, look, are they not good scientists?
Of course, they're great scientists.
Have there been incredible religious scientists
throughout history?
Of course there have, that was the norm, right?
And so, that to me is not a question,
but you hit the nail on the head.
To say in Judaism, we use the term amunah.
Amunah is a sense,
and it's where the word amen comes from.
So if I had faith in something,
that by definition means it's not subject
to scientific scrutiny.
Otherwise, I could have proof, right?
So I say, and you wouldn't get any credit for it either.
Having faith?
Okay, I have faith in you on gravel.
There's a lot of proof for it.
No, I would have to subjugate that sense of my needs
to someone's notion of putting me in a box
and saying what I am or am not entitled
to believe as a scientist.
I'll choose for myself.
Thank you very much.