William Kelley has one of the most influential palates in wine. As editor-in-chief of Wine Advocate, he's tasted and scored tens of thousands of the world's greatest bottles. Then he decided to start making his own.
I spent a day with him in Burgundy, walking his vines in Beaune, going deep into the philosophy behind his winemaking, and asking the question everyone wants answered: what happens when a critic becomes the one being critiqued?
We talk about the extreme canopy management techniques he's borrowing from pioneers like Lalou Bize Leroy, the semi-abandoned Beaune vineyard he rescued and turned around, and why he treats every parcel - from his Aligoté to his priciest reds - with the same "grand cru" level of care. He opens up about the 50,000 wines he's reviewed over the last decade, whether critics can really stay unbiased once they're making their own wine, 100-point scores, and what he thinks the future of wine marketing actually looks like in an age obsessed with "authenticity."
Note: The audio opening minutes is not great as there was an unforeseen issues with the mics - it improves significantly once we move into the vineyard and cellar, so stick with it or jump ahead.
If you care about Burgundy, winemaking, or what it's really like inside the head of one of the industry's most respected critics, this conversation is for you.
Chapters: 00:00 William Kelly 00:52 Audio Apology Note 01:34 Critic Meets Winemaker 03:59 Soul vs. Science in Winemaking 04:57 LaLou Bize-Leroy Influences 06:18 In The Vineyard Deep Dive 11:37 Parcel Origin Selection 15:17 Into The Cellar 16:10 Aligoté 19:32 Pricing Scarcity and Demand 22:38 From Oxford to Winemaking 24:58 Critics Points Debate 27:08 Future of Wine Marketing 29:05 William’s Insider French Wines 30:08 Being Your Own Harsh Critic
William Kelly, Editor-in-Chief of Wine Advocate, shares his journey from critic to Burgundy winemaker. He details a labor-intensive, intuitive approach to viticulture, focusing on canopy management and soil health to achieve wine density. The discussion also covers the restoration of neglected plots, the elevation of the Aligoté grape, and a critical look at the wine scoring system and industry marketing.
Before we jump into today's episode, I wanted to say a few words about William Kelly.
William Kelly has one of the most fascinating jobs in the wine world.
As Editor-in-Chief of Wine Advocate, he spends his career tasting,
assessing and writing about many of the world's greatest wines.
However, more recently, he has also embarked on his own winemaking journey.
That naturally raises interesting questions.
Some people wonder how those two worlds sit alongside one another.
But I also think it's worth recognising that William's extraordinary depth of
knowledge and genuine passion for wine.
He's spent years immersed in the world's greatest vineyards, producers and vintages.
And when you've dedicated your life to understanding greatness,
then why wouldn't you eventually want to try creating it yourself?
Whether you agree or disagree, I think it makes a fascinating conversation.
And that's exactly why I wanted to meet with him.
One quick note before we begin.
I want to apologise for the audio quality at the start of this episode.
As I'm filming independently around the world,
I work with multiple different crews in different parts of the world.
And unfortunately, sometimes things happen.
And this was one of those occasions where things did not go to plan.
I genuinely considered not releasing this interview,
but William shared far too much insight to just stay on my hard drive.
The good news is the audio improves once we move into the cellar.
So if you feel free, put on subtitles or just skip ahead
to later in the episode when we arrive in the cellar.
Sorry again, but thank you for your understanding.
And I hope you enjoy this episode.
Cheers.
So today I'm in the heart of Burgundy with William Kelly,
who is the Editor-in-Chief of Wine Advertisement.
And then the man crazy enough to then start growing his own grapes.
So we're here in Bogue today.
So just thank you for taking the time.
Obviously, your background is very technical and analytical.
But Burgundy and its ethos is very much more on feel and intuition.
And it is quite romanticized.
How do you balance the two?
That's an interesting question.
I mean, I think it comes down to your personality.
I know some winemakers are very technical
and they will want to talk to you about,
you know, the level of pre-sulphides or carbon dioxide,
how much carbon dioxide they diffuse into the wines.
But things like that, little things.
And then people who become obsessive about barrels
and some who basically don't care about that at all
and just want to be in the vineyards
and have that sort of level of obsession about agronomy.
I find it all romantic, you know.
And whether it's the number side of it or the feeling side of it,
I mean, I think they go very well together, actually.
If you have a personality that can integrate,
a lot of people either have their favorite aspects of it.
Because to be a winegrower, you have to do so many different things.
It's a very difficult profession.
Yeah, not a lot of people would go from being a wine critic into winemaker.
I think it could have been the most terrifying favorite.
Personally, if you would have rated my wines badly,
I would have, like, decked down maybe,
like some people maybe wouldn't have wanted you to have done well.
And the fact that with your practices,
it's starkly different to where we are right now.
So it's pretty ballsy.
Yeah, I mean, I think you only get one lifetime
and if you've got something you really want to do,
you need to do, then just focus on doing it.
Are you sure it's been a very interesting, what, last seven, eight years?
It has been, oh, ten years.
Oh, ten years, yeah.
I'm writing a 50,000 wines review over the last decade.
Right.
No, but it's true that I did not take vacations for a long time.
But in terms of going back to kind of more that, like, intuitive sense,
has that been something that you've definitely developed
more, obviously, being in amongst the vines?
Because being a critic is so analytical, right?
Well, in some ways, yes.
But in other respects, the two are very similar
because they're about observation, right?
Agronomy and winemaking are both fundamentally about observing what's going on
and then adjusting, you know,
because what you do in the vineyards is you adjust parameters of an ecology.
In the winery, you're adjusting the parameters of a microbial ecology.
It's fundamentally very, very similar sort of processes.
And the plants tell you so much.
You know, like, you see the color of the leaves,
the thickness of the tissue, the vitality of the plants.
You know, I don't know how tall this grew last year.
You can look at the ratio between the wood that it's produced this year
and the thickness of the pruning wood from last year,
and you see where it's going.
So you just have to adapt your practices to your observation.
And in terms of canopy management, like, well, we'll get into it
because I know you do have a lot of mentors
and a lot of people that have inspired you,
but definitely more, like, actually in the vineyard.
Is there any particular people, especially more in the...
The first person to do something quite so sort of different
in the vineyards, in terms of the canopies, was Alubis Loas.
It's a huge, you know...
I was diffident to talk about influences
because it feels like you get to appropriate somebody else's work
and sort of latch on to their name.
But, you know, honor to her.
She was the person, 1999, was the first to start doing trimming.
But she was working initially with lower trellising
and then just sort of wrapping the canopies around.
If you do that, you get very compact foliage
and then you get disease.
So the logical progression for her
was to then to gradually move towards higher systems.
And then sometimes doing this sort of simple moussage
where you grade the shoots together from vine to vine.
Or, you know, what we've done this year is just a week, mostly.
Except more shade, more shade.
You really want to shade the fruiting stems
and the soils as well
and create our own microclimate that's cooler
and more susceptible to creating this variety
that we're interested in.
But then today, looking at people who are doing amazing things
Not the most expensive vines in the region,
but it all has been used as a farm.
It's high tempehs, chassards.
And I know how much it costs to do this.
You know, so just so much aberration.
Well, it's great.
So tempehs, it's way lower yields, way more man time.
Yeah, 1,500 hours per hectare
if you really wanted to do everything.
And so, and then if you take half the Appalachian maxillia,
that takes you to a bottle price to farm it.
40 to 60 euros per bottle, just to grow it, just to grow it.
Yeah, and then even knowing the price and the market,
it's like, where is that cost benefit analysis?
Yeah, I would say we're always after marginal,
the next marginal improvement.
But if you put a lot of what seem like marginal improvements together,
you get a compounding effect
and you have something that's qualitatively different.
And then it's like, wow, that's really good.
Yeah, I hate to even use the word like trendy,
but like obviously moving more into this style is,
and like Aeschylus' Sermon,
it was more like it is becoming increasingly kind of popular.
It's true, and it's photogenic.
And I'm not such a fan of the Aeschylus personally,
because when you have, imagine you have one stake
where you were to tie this whole plant to one stake,
you create a lot of branching.
And you also create a situation
where if you lose the basal leaves around the fruit,
you have the fruit can be very exposed to the sun.
We use Aeschylus on a couple of very small rows,
which are difficult to have wires.
But overall, I think the wires are pretty good
because you create this wall of shade
rather than these tightly bunched positions.
I love Hawker because it's nice and cool too.
I know, it is nice.
You can actually kind of go and do it.
Can't make it worse, I guess.
You know, vineyard jungle.
One does have questions about,
because you do have a larger surface for transpiration.
Are we increasing the hydric demand on the plant?
Or is that successfully counterbalanced
by the fact that we have more older foliage,
which has a lower demand on water?
We maybe create more of our own microclimate,
which is a bit more humid
and a bit more shaded and cooler.
I don't say everybody can do it this way.
There's a way we're trying to do it
in pursuit of making the best possible vines
that we can imagine.
But I don't know if it's the right way.
So far, the plants seem happy, but no.
They look happy.
That's it.
They look very happy.
So you just have to trust the signals.
It looks a bit different to some of the other vines
next to us.
Absolutely.
I feel like we have to talk about
how to do that differently.
I mean, the approach that we've taken here
is an extreme one.
I didn't see it.
I don't know.
I haven't had a little trim in a while.
Which is good.
All you have to do is put separation.
People make all sorts of claims
about it's a micro-arousal network and things.
I'm not an expert on that, but it is nice.
And it's peaches.
A little home-made snack as you're going to ponds.
Exactly.
And the idea was just to respect
the physiology of the plant.
So we did a suite of practices.
One is unperched soil,
which is really about decompacting it.
So only animal traction for the cultivation
and only backpack sprays for all of the treatments
so that the amount of weight
that's being distributed on the soil,
it's not very much.
And it's very randomized.
It's not, you know, it's practically
always going in the same place
in the middle of the road.
So that's been the case since summer 2022.
I've started to, you know,
these are the soils here
that are quite prone to compaction.
So it's not an easy,
it's not particularly an easy terroir.
It can make very good wines.
It's not a bad terroir,
but it's not an easy terroir.
Some terroirs are just,
even an idiot could make.
Yeah.
And this is not a vineyard
that gives you the illusion of intelligence
because it's super easy to compact
and prone to mildew
and then to botrytis late season.
So the challenge is to find a way
of getting the grapes right,
fully right before they start to rot.
There's a lot of people,
you could easily pick them a bit early
on the early side,
make it fruity, delicate, charming.
But that's a lot of,
that's sort of the image
in many people's heads of what bone is.
But in fact, if you go down
and the neighbor kindly dug a hole,
I have such a small passport,
I'm not really in the business of digging holes.
And after a certain depth,
about 50 centimeters,
there's this blue marl.
Oh really?
So it's like,
the same as in a vineyard like Beaumarien,
high altitude sites,
you always have low pH.
If you can get into that
and then get the grapes right,
you have wines with real density
and cut that is very far
from the sort of fruit forward,
easy, stereotyped bone.
And that's what we're trying to do.
Yeah.
It's pretty ballsy
that you've just kind of,
yeah, not really gone towards the norm,
but really kind of gone your own way
and you need to deal
with a few different varieties.
You see, right,
rather than,
these are the lateral shoots, right?
Rather than removing them,
we just cut them off.
It occurred that I didn't want to see
any of the grapes until harvest.
And that's basically true.
Because if you look inside the canopies,
that's where all the fruit
is completely protected from the sun.
I mean, what you see is,
you see, and this is a replant,
this is a young vine
with the less heavy shooting system.
And this has a,
you see this yellowing basal leaf.
And you'll see a few vines like that
among the replants.
But the original old vines in this plot
don't really show any signs of it.
You don't really think that happens
because it's tough.
You know, we also began cultivating
quite early,
starting to preserve the hydrate reserve.
We had heavy winter rains, you know,
so we didn't really want
to burn through that.
You knew it was going to be
an early harvest.
Early harvest often means it's hot and dry
in the runoff to harvest
to conserve that hydrate reserve
and be able to get the vines.
Again, fully ripe,
because as I said,
you can pick partially ripe
and then they'll be fresh.
Yeah.
They will never be profound.
But for me, I mean,
this is a very personal vision of things,
so I don't make any claim
for that to be an absolute truth.
It's the truth as I see it.
Yeah. And in terms of your,
like, talking through the site selection,
like, it's quite a process.
Like, what did you do
to come up with this parcel?
So this is actually a fun story
because I belong to two older friends of mine
who are microbiology professors
at the University of Berkeley,
and they bought it from a retired physician
at the Bone Hospital
who had this and another small plot
for a sort of weekend,
you know, hobby project.
And they made one for around 20 years
and then they passed it on to me.
So normally, you know,
normally I go out looking
for a particular plot
or a particular site
that interests me or whatever,
and I don't want the vineyards
to resemble each other.
I want them all to have a strong personality.
But I'm really grateful for this one
because on paper,
it's just Hwasu and Bone.
Nobody's even heard of it.
It's not a famous.
So it's a very small plot.
It's a relatively modest revelation.
And would I ever have spent
so much time in a vineyard like this
if I'd had already some Grand Cru
or a bit of a novelaire
or something like that?
Probably not.
But now I'm conscious of,
firstly, what I've been able to do
with it agronomically
and in the winery.
And secondly, you know,
the value added you can have
by having that degree of intimacy
with the parcel
and really getting to know it
and spending a lot of time in it.
That's something I want to replicate
across all the parcels.
Again, it's one of the things
that's convinced me
how essential it is to remain small.
Yeah.
And to look at the intrinsic quality
of a parcel rather than its reputation.
Because if there's, you know,
the bigger there's a delta
between what is being done
and what can be done,
the more interesting it is
in a lot of ways.
And it's a million
different decisions, right?
But what, from kind of
when you first started to now,
what are some of the biggest takeaways,
especially with this parcel?
I mean, just I think it's gotten better
faster than I ever would have thought.
We gathered more low-hanging fruit
sooner than I believe.
Because the truth back in 2018,
you didn't.
No, I managed it for a few years
for my friends.
And back in 2019,
this vineyard got a letter
from the commune saying
it was so badly maintained
that if it carried on like that,
it would be repossessed by the commune.
It was essentially a semi-abandonment, right?
And now look at that, you know, so.
With the industrialization of wine
and the commercial winemakers,
it's like, there's such a focus on,
like, they can use whatever they want.
And then for the people
who are actually doing more biodynamics
and organic farming,
it's crazy expensive to maintain.
And then you get constant checks.
So a lot of the actual,
honestly, they don't even bother with it,
but they're still using those practices.
And you use it,
it means you have to use so much,
so much copper.
Worry about it,
demand and going over there.
They only have the right to use
two kilograms of copper per hectare this year.
They used so much in the last three years.
It is a rolling average.
I mean, we haven't used
two kilograms this year either,
but that's not because we said,
that's just what,
but that's our standard.
It's to keep it very low.
Complements it,
it has to do with other things
to boost its efficacy.
And don't keep a margin
that if you really need to do it,
you can hit it hard.
Sometimes in Burgundy you do,
you do not hit it hard.
A lot of people with opinions about this
can only farm the places like
California or Oregon,
they use three treatments
a year with neem oil
and then they're good.
But it's really not the way here.
2024 we had to do 33 treatments
in this busload.
Just to make 180 litres of wine.
Yeah.
It's incessant.
They're very hands-on.
No, it was awful.
We didn't have time.
We didn't have,
apart from two weeks in August,
we didn't have more than
three consecutive days
without it raining.
So what do you do?
I know that was hysterical.
So now we're in the cellar here
in Colmar.
I know you make a variety of different wines,
but I have to talk to you
because I think it is such an exciting...
I mean, you won't say new
because historically...
It has a very long history in Burgundy
as a secondary wine.
Yeah.
White variety,
but it was maybe planted,
if you go back 200 years,
it was planted on some better terroirs
than is often the case today.
Hillside sites was quite common
in the Cote du Nez.
And it was often pruned with spur pruning
rather than cane pruning.
It's naturally quite productive.
There's some varieties,
so if you spur prune them,
you don't get any fruit at all
because they're really not very fruitful
close to the trunk.
But if you do cane pruning on Aligota,
you make huge crops.
It's not really...
None of them are bad clones
and bad selections and things.
So for me, it has a lot of potential.
Yeah, especially obviously
with the warming climate.
But site selection,
Mark, can you talk to me
about how you even approach that?
I think Aligota from scratch,
you don't necessarily have a huge
choice about that very much.
But generally speaking,
they're below the Camille Appalachians
and some on the other side of our own 74.
But there are also some high up in the hills.
The main thing is Aligota's
really good genetics.
So all the vines, pre-clonal.
So clones come in France back in 71 almost.
And everything before that is pre-clonal.
And we have vines from 1928, 1932, 1936.
Yeah, everything before 71
was in the soil selection.
So there were no cuts.
So how do you even go about
like kind of sourcing them?
And that was your choice to do for...
Well, it's not, you know,
Aligota tends not to be ripped up.
Because if you think it costs,
let's say, €3.50 per plant.
And then the labor of planting a vineyard,
all the trellising of all of the costs.
And you have to sacrifice
at least three years of production.
If you have an existing vineyard
that's still producing a good amount of wine,
and Aligota tends to produce
a good amount of wine,
you have no incentive to rip it up
and replant it.
So there's a lot of world
by Aligota around.
And then you just want to find the good spots.
And, you know,
incredibly, we're bringing it
into domain production
and farming it with the same methods
that you saw in the Trois Chaux,
in one of the philosophies that I have,
should treat everything the same way.
And now, of course,
there is a hierarchy of appellations.
Some sites are better than others.
That's not true,
but I would prefer to reveal that
rather than reinforce it.
And so we give out this,
you know, Grand Cru treatment,
if you wish, to everything.
I don't let the chips fall where they may.
And Aligota is typically
more on those kind of higher sides,
and it's more kind of...
Higher or lower, yeah.
It's supposed to be quite, like,
fresh, very, like...
Yeah, it's naturally very high in acidity.
And yet, like, I know with,
in terms of, like, oak usage,
you use 100% new oak.
On everything.
Which, typically, a lot of people
would think it's, like,
typically, in their mind,
they would think that's very heavy handed.
What, who, like, I mean,
I know there was some other influences.
I mean, again,
Larivie's Loire du Vinay,
it was the first time I tried an Aligota
that was really quite interesting.
And she does that.
Same farming,
no matter the appellation,
same winemaking,
no matter the appellation.
And it works great.
You know, low yields,
you have high acidity,
a lot of leaves,
moderate alcohol percentage,
so limited solvent capacity.
Aligota gobbles up oak,
you know, the way Chardonnay did
20, 30 years ago.
Chardonnay is harder to get an oak
to wine balance than Aligota,
because it's a bit higher in alcohol,
a bit lower in acidity, often.
And so it's...
it doesn't need subliminal sweetness.
You can't digest it the same way.
And a bit more alcohol extracts,
it extracts a bit more from the barrels.
No, it's just really interesting,
because I kind of think most people
think that's like counterintuitive,
but it really does bring it together
very beautifully.
And I mean, yes,
we have a little bit,
Daphne and some of her Aligotas
do go more,
I think you said before,
just the passive,
gone crudely more shade.
Oh, in many cases.
And I mean, I think in the glass,
they often do that too.
Yeah, and I...
They're not as good as her,
so I think more a shade.
Yes, and I mean...
If you line them all up
and knock them down,
it is the first wine in the range for a reason.
It's not her best wine,
but it's a great wine
and it shows what you can do
if you just remove the constraint.
And I'm not going to ask you,
because I know some of your bottles
they're very expensive
on the market itself,
but I know it's different to Excella.
And so I'm going to talk to you about that,
because I know that there is a big difference
between what the domain sells it for.
And then it's just,
I mean, it's the distributor,
it's the restaurants,
it's the market itself.
But how do you think that that can aligot
I think kind of in the market?
Do you think it can kind of play in that?
I mean, that's for the market to decide.
It's not certain, you know,
how we price the wine.
They're expensive.
We have expensive practices
and make an apology for that.
But they're not.
They're really a fraction,
a tiny fraction.
But there's a lot of scarcity
and it's new and people are curious
and spend a lot of money
on a lot of things.
I sometimes buy bottles of wine
for more money that makes sense
because I really want to drink it.
So I can understand the reflex.
I have 8,000 bottles in my private cellar.
And I'm not going to tell people
they should be more restrained
or more sensible.
It's like, why do I need 8,000?
What am I going to do with 8,000 bottles of wine?
That's a lot.
I mean, okay, it's, you know,
I'm 36, but it's still a lot.
It's still a lot.
Yeah, no, you can have a lot of fun
and you should share a lot of it.
And it's great.
And it's got like good ageability.
Oh yeah, it's bulletproof.
You know, we're typically between pH 3.05
to pH 3.2 max.
Your highest pH is 3.2.
And then we do 20 to 23 months
on full leaves in your barrels
and a very relaxed environment.
And then we bottle it with the M30.
So under 20 or 15 to 20 ppm
of free SO2 on about 65 to 100 microns.
And just in terms of the chemistry,
everything is there to aid.
And with our own vignette,
we are able to push the concentration higher,
push the ripeness higher.
I've never tasted an overripe Aligoté.
I don't think it exists.
No, I don't think I have either.
So you just pick by the end
and you're done with the rest, you know?
Yeah, for the fun.
And if you go away for an extra week.
The latest I've done is October 2nd.
I also did that, you know,
there's some growers like Sir Jacques-Antoine Cauchy
who was famous for crushing and spritzing a lot
before pressing, taking a lot of solids.
I mean, when I made my first Aligoté,
you have a pumpkin with a basket press
and a barrel and a funnel.
It's all worked out.
You actually put two buckets
and you fill the barrel with juice from the bucket
and then ferment it in the barrel
and left it for 24 months
and bottled it for the barrel.
And yeah, you're good.
So it's not...
Sometimes you see people say,
oh, but there's...
I don't know.
There's a funny critique that I saw
simply saying the wine was too perfect,
or this is too much, this or that.
Genuinely, just crush the fruit,
press it, put the juice
and everything in the barrels,
and that's it.
There's no...
We didn't do anything.
Now we chose the barrel, of course,
and we chose the barrel very attentively.
That's what you do before, too.
And you pick the right harvest date and so on,
but there's not...
It's not like we're going around
like adding fakes.
We're doing very well.
And then the one we don't rack,
we don't find.
So there's nothing in this.
It's just the juice, right?
We don't add specifically.
Sometimes we might chat about it,
but try not to.
Yeah.
But like going, I just...
The way that you got into where we are
standing right now,
you said it was 19th century history at Oxford.
You were the president of the wine circle at Oxford,
which I know is quite a renowned,
probably the world's most renowned kind of tasting group.
We've had a good time.
It's a pretty good way to get into the world of wine.
And then you started to do kind of a harvest.
Was there a moment where you kind of realised
kind of on this journey
that you're like,
I'm exactly where I'm supposed to be,
or just a moment or story?
I don't know.
I mean, I'm feeling pretty good about it now, I have to say.
For a long time, I just was working so much
that I didn't think about, you know,
more existential stuff.
I was just busy doing things
and trying to support a family
and all these things to create something.
I didn't really have time to do it.
And I started very small.
I started with two barrels of Chambord, you know.
It's not, wouldn't have been the end of the world.
I mean, if I hadn't liked it,
I didn't like it.
It's over there.
And there was, I had an ambassador
from an interesting,
in a country I find quite interesting,
came to visit me recently.
I went up and got with her to talking about,
you know, progress and improvement.
It's not, you know.
I think it's like everything.
I mean, it's the same when I met some athletes,
musicians, people are very successful,
finance, whatever.
Everyone looks at what they've achieved
in a number of things.
How about some magic trick
or there must be some talent.
You just have to want it a lot.
And then going after it.
It was very iterative, actually.
Well, actually it's glamorous.
Yeah.
Then people think and everyone in with wine.
Everyone's like, oh, but do you do this or do that?
And then, oh, but do you do that?
And actually, you're always looking.
It's fine.
Yeah.
People are looking to externalize quality
onto a technique or a particular process
that is somehow going to be the magic trick.
But if it was that easy,
everyone would be doing it, you know.
And there isn't really anything.
I mean, there are some details,
some pieces of progression.
I think in terms of choosing your barrels,
some of those details.
And there are a few little things,
but it's not the big picture of this.
And I'm sure I think any,
I mean, I've had the opportunity
to ask those sorts of questions
of most of the greatest winemakers of France,
at least in some of the others
for the rest of the world.
I think they all said pretty much the same thing.
And it could be a little,
you don't believe it at first.
People are saying, oh, I don't really do that much.
You know, actually that's actually the truth.
Yeah.
And I've just talked to you a little bit more
on like the what could have won critics side.
I know there's always this kind of push-pull.
I know there's so much you can kind of like
this next generation,
but in terms of points,
like it's always kind of the two-sided debate.
What do you think kind of the future
of kind of critics and points are going?
That'll be interesting to see.
I mean, I think advantage of points
is it means the critic has nowhere to hide.
So they have to take a stance
that's comfortable and easily understandable.
You can't hedge it.
And as a critic,
it's very tempting to be sort of conflict averse
and just say, you know, it's good in parts.
You know?
Yeah.
Very interesting.
You know, when it's just words,
it's very easy to avoid taking a stance
about something to be evasive
and having to score wins does oblige that.
Equally, there's a lot of compression
and clearly also inflation of scores,
which makes it harder to operate in that space
and say things that are fair
without seeming punitive.
Anything below 92 today is considered
as like a don't buy,
which is even when I started this 10 years ago,
at least the 90 was not a score
that people would be incensed by.
But today, you know, today,
there are plenty of British who think
they should be in the score,
in a three point scale between 97 and 100 every year.
And so how do you operate independently
and with integrity in that kind of world?
It's very difficult.
I know we're talking about kind of the 1%
of the world of wine
when we're talking about those kinds of scores.
And when you look at the kind of...
No, I think more like the 10%.
A lot of very high scores.
Yeah.
Everyone's a winner.
Everyone's a star.
And that's the thing.
I've done a lot of reading of wines.
There's a lot of critics that do hand out
a lot of under 40 scores.
And is the point to me to identify
a really good tasty wine
and that's fantastic,
that's 100, great.
Or is it are we really talking
about a profound experience?
I think wine can be that,
but it isn't very often.
That's just how it is.
And I'm like listening to like cuisine.
What do you think needs to,
or if anything needs to kind of change
in the way that like the wine market
needs to communicate more on board.
Sorry, I'm giving you the big questions.
I think people,
everyone wants to be authentic.
But very few people want people to see
what their authenticity would look like.
There's a lot of people
trying to look authentic who are not.
And so that's the problem
that people should just do that.
I guess I was thinking of doing
sort of retiring wine critics
advice to winery proprietors.
One of them would be
not to take criticism any more seriously
than you take praise,
which works when inverted.
And the other would be
never let yourself be photographed
doing something
that you wouldn't actually do.
And so there's just a lot,
there's a lot of,
there's a lot of that.
I don't think that works.
Yeah, I don't think it works very well.
Well, we had you on camera
just pouring out and licking the wine.
You know, nothing to hide in that regard.
But I'll say I've been pleased
and it's not just me doing it.
No pretence that it's,
until 2023, it was just me.
But now it's different.
But I'm not, you know,
I'm not about to go and be photographed
in a suit licking the drain
with some brush
that's just been handed to me off camera.
You know, that's not.
So I think there's just people,
people are the only,
the only true authenticity
is that sales is actual.
The simulacrum of authenticity
is not the future of wine marketing.
And people better say,
we have a nice brand.
This is a nice product
and you can buy it for a nice price.
Rather than everyone
trying to be an artisanal genius.
It's a lot of who is.
And there are not many fanatic,
obsessive people in the world
who are really very interested.
And some people,
it's perfectly honourable
for wine to be a business
in the way that they're growing
sweet corn or carrots as a business.
It's not, you don't expect people to,
to create this sort of huge
philosophical raison d'etre
for why they're doing,
growing those products.
Why does every winemaker need to have,
you know, have that?
And that's fine.
We don't need very much of this stuff.
Particularly when we're trying to do this.
Yes.
Like the world of the market
doesn't need very much of that.
I don't want to make too much.
Favourite, like,
hidden gem wine regions.
I know you probably won't speak
to producers of sorts.
No, but I would say some of them,
like Jean-Noël Vincent in Saint-Penel.
People down in Lafayette-Chalonaise,
Vincent Duraud and Duraud-Jean-Fial.
Maxime Cottonceau in Buxelles.
Because there's this idea
that all Burgundy is like,
pricelike, but like,
this stuff.
Yeah, because people drop the,
like, the wine score.
It's like.
And everyone wants it.
On a Tuesday night,
like, people who are Soms,
who don't have the budget.
What was your recommendation?
So those would be,
those would be some people,
and even, you know,
going a bit further south.
So Burgundy doesn't have to
just be very expensive.
That's what we like to call it a lot, yeah.
And that's not very artisanal producers.
If we're doing a lot of the work
that we do,
and then,
because it's a lower appellation,
they can't sell it for the price.
I need a list of those.
I'm happy to send you
some of my sort of favourite,
you know, insider French fries.
Amazing.
And it really is quite remarkable
what you have achieved.
And when you're just at home
with your wife, with Gretchen,
if you're sitting,
you're opening a bottle of your wine,
like,
how hard is it to not be a critic
in that moment?
Or do you just sit and enjoy it?
What goes through your mind?
There are not many of the things
I'm truly happy with,
or happy with at all.
Sometimes there is.
Every now and then you think,
well, it's not so bad.
Or it's better than I remembered it.
Because in your mind,
I could go through a list of everything
I don't like about every wine.
But then you're like,
oh, it's not that Irish.
Yeah.
And I'm kind of good.
I'm good with that.
Oh, and we were saying how the market
does determine prices
and the quality of things.
It's certainly dedicating.
And the long haul, right?
In the short term,
the market is a betting machine,
and in the long term,
it's a weighing machine.
We're still in the very short term,
so I just hope that we do things seriously.
I mean, you know,
I found one thing
when the final ways is called in.
Thank you for taking the time.
Pleasure.