Protecting Your Clients in a Changing Cyber World

Business Insurance
4 followers
1 Video View·Jul 26, 2026
Featuring Jack Petts from March and Mark Luckin from Lockton
AI Generated·May contain errors
Increased use, adoption, opportunity associated with it.
It's outstripping governance essentially.
I think the biggest concern really is AI adoption
and how fast it's moving compared to the governance piece for a lot of organisations.
Hello and welcome to Insurance Business TV for our quarterly Cyber Insurance Power Panel.
We're going to unpack what brokers should know about the state of the market,
including the latest AI concerns and a new player who recently entered the market.
We've assembled a new panel of experts.
We've got Mark Luckin.
He's Cyber and Technology Practice Leader for Lockton.
And Jack Petz is Managing Principal in the Cyber, Media and Technology Practice at Marsh.
Well, welcome very much to both of you.
Thanks for coming along.
And Mark, let's start with you.
What are you most concerned about right now in terms of cyber insurance issues
impacting your clients?
Thanks, Dan.
And nice to be here.
I think for clarity straight off the bat, certainly no cyber insurance issues
as one might kind of interpret there to be any issues in the market or anything at the moment.
But one of the main pieces I think that's a kind of a recurring theme
and has been since the existence of cyber insurance is that persistent gap of
knowledge and perception of cyber insurance by organisations.
It still continues to be one that certainly myself and a number of colleagues and peers
kind of find ourselves up against.
The difficulty that we're finding at the moment in terms of it being an issue is
there is, and certainly in pockets and in certain sectors,
quite a bit of fatigue around the topic of cyber data and technology risk
and how insurance kind of falls in to play a relevant role there.
So finding our ways around that and addressing that as an issue to use the phrase mentioned.
Yeah, the other piece I think as well is
how people are managing this current soft market cycle
and really conveying the value of cyber insurance beyond just price,
like any soft market cycle.
I think that's naturally where people's minds go.
So making sure we're kind of keeping relevant messaging there
beyond just a competitive pricing environment in cyber insurance at the moment.
Well, thanks, Mark.
And Jack, what about you?
Is it more of those kind of, I guess,
issues that have been burning for a long time
or is there something right now that's pressing your clients?
Yeah, so I think the biggest concern right now, Daniel,
is how fast the threat environment is evolving
compared to how quickly organizations are realistically keeping up.
So we're certainly seeing more sophisticated attacks,
third-party dependencies and greater scrutiny from insurers.
So the conversation certainly shifted.
What we really try to establish for our clients
is those that can demonstrate the controls,
governance and preparedness to make them an attractive risk.
And there's also a big focus on c-cell exposure,
which has been the case now for some time.
But businesses may feel comfortable with their own controls,
but there's an increasing reliance on cloud providers,
software vendors and managed service providers
and other technology partners.
So increasingly, we are seeing that major cyber events
do not just begin in the client's own environment,
but increasingly across third-party dependencies as well.
In addition to that, we're certainly seeing a greater focus
on the regulatory environment, particularly in Australia.
So there's been recent updates to privacy legislation here in the region.
So when something goes wrong, it's no longer just an IT problem.
It's increasingly a legal, operational,
reputational, even board-level risk.
So clients need to look at cyber insurance
as part of their broader business strategy,
not just a solution on its own.
And I think you probably both agree that AI
is making all this stuff just a lot more complicated.
So let's have a look at AI.
And Jack, let's stick with you.
We just had that very powerful AI called Mythos introduced into Australia,
and it's continually in the headlines.
What's your current biggest AI concern right now?
Yeah, it's a good question, Daniel.
I think the biggest concern really is AI adoption
and how fast it's moving compared to the governance piece
for a lot of organizations.
So, you know, most businesses are experimenting
or actively using AI in some form,
whether that's internally through third-party platforms
or embedded in tools that they buy.
Policies, oversight, risk management frameworks are catching up,
but there's still some way to go.
From a cyber perspective,
as it relates to the threat discussion,
there's really two sort of angles that we're looking at here.
The first is threat actors who are using AI
to improve their phishing, social engineering
and the scale of the attacks that they're launching.
And then secondly is the organizations themselves
who may be more exposed to sensitive data leaks,
which in turn creates privacy issues
or indeed just relying on tools that they don't fully understand.
So the concern is less about sort of one specific AI platform.
It's really more around unmanaged AI adoption.
So businesses that do this well
are ones that treat AI as a governance issue
and a risk issue, not just as an innovation opportunity.
And Mark, what about you?
What's your biggest AI concern right now?
I think to be frank, echoing a lot of Jack's sentiment there, Dan.
I think it's not a concern around it
necessarily being a completely new risk category.
It's more around this, again,
to one of the points Jack was speaking to,
the compression from a risk perspective,
the compression of the timeframe of a cyber event
when AI is leveraged to severity.
So it's just shortening that timeframe
around how quickly a cyber data
or technology related event can escalate
and turn into quite a severe event.
The other piece is around, you know,
you don't have to be on the second page of the fin
to read about the next organisation
that's capitalising on the opportunity that is AI, et cetera.
But again, this kind of increased use,
adoption opportunity associated with it,
it's outstripping governance essentially.
And governance needs to look a lot more
than just simply having an AI policy in place.
But, and I guess tying it back
to what the insurance market is expecting as well,
organisations really meaningfully taking into account
their risk, their exposure,
how they're managing that risk and exposure internally,
how, you know, they're managing use of tools,
access to tools, data, ingestion, et cetera,
contractual obligations and liabilities
and associated exposures.
There's a lot to consider from both the threat
and risk landscape from threat actors utilising AI
and then from organisations' own use.
Let's look at one of the trends
that seems to have been increasing in frequency
in the last few years
and that's how cyber attackers tend to target
entire IT platforms, not just big name companies.
So, you know, service providers that provides software
for thousands, if not millions of people.
Is that changing the way you guys give advice
to clients as a broker?
Mark, let's stick with you on that one.
I think to be honest, it has for a while now.
It really has and it should continue
to change the conversation from, you know,
how secure are you or how resilient are you,
which is probably the better question to be fair,
to how critically dependent are you
on these third-party providers?
I think where it's changed more recently
is that it's become a more of a holistic focus
and what I mean by that is less purely technology focus
or technology provider focused
and a little bit more of a broader remit
to other critical third parties
that people might not traditionally associate with risks.
So, yeah, again,
your more traditional third-party providers
like other professional service firms,
lawyers, accountants, et cetera,
that conversation needs to continue to broaden
and frankly, you know, in our opinion,
needs to be at the forefront of conversations
when you're talking around cyber data and technology risk.
I think it also, again,
tying it back to an insurance and cover perspective,
it needs to drive your coverage mindset
when it comes to placement and renewal
of particularly cyber insurance.
So the vast majority of markets
now have a pretty strong foundational base
when it comes to cover and protecting
an organisation from events
that materially impact them directly.
Now it's more, well,
how are we covering off
our contingent business interruption risk,
our third, fourth and party associated data loss risk,
by example.
That coverage piece and that risk piece
needs to become more foundational
for organisations moving forward in this environment.
And Jack, what about you?
Is this platform targeting change
the way you give advice?
Yeah, so I'd largely agree, Daniel, with Mark.
I think the conversation is an evolving one
because it's really not just what happens
inside your own four walls anymore as a client.
So we're certainly spending more time
speaking to our clients
around their critical dependencies,
you know, who are their technology providers,
where are your concentration risks
and what happens if one of those providers goes down
and how well could you continue to operate?
So yes, it certainly does change
the insurance conversation.
Mark raised some very good points
in relation to coverage,
but, you know, dependent business interruption,
those contingent exposures,
waiting hour periods
and various sub-limits as well
on how the policy wording would respond
when the problem starts with a third party
is increasingly something that we're discussing
with our clients.
So the advice has become broader.
Strong internal controls still matter enormously,
but clients need visibility
over their supplier ecosystem,
applying for a disruption outside of their network
and an insurance program that reflects that reality.
Let's take a look at the cyber market in Australia
because there's been some quite big changes
in the last year or so
and one of them in the last few months.
First of all, we had Cowbell coming into the market
as a new player
and just recently Emergence
bought up Blue Zebra's cyber book.
And as brokers, is this good news for you
or do you kind of worry about this kind of stuff?
Is it giving you more options for your clients
or does it shake things up
and is it a nuisance when this sort of disruption goes on?
Jack, what do you think of that?
Yeah, there's definitely been a lot of movement
on the insurer side over recent years in cyber.
It's a growing line of business
and I would certainly say that more choice
is definitely a good thing,
but I wouldn't necessarily move a client's business
just because there's a new market entrant
or market activity.
I think there's a couple of different things
we would look to consider.
The first is,
has there been a genuine improvement in coverage?
So clearer wording,
broader protection for clients,
better treatment of business interruption coverages,
instant response services
or even fewer restrictions that could matter
in the context of the claims.
So that would be one of the first areas
that we would look at.
Second, in addition to that,
is the claims and response capability.
Cyber insurance is not just about indemnity,
it's about what happens in the first few hours,
within days, an instance.
So it's really important that the policy operates
and responds in the way that a client wants it to.
The quality of the insurer's panel,
vendor panel,
also their claims handling and breach response
on what's that can make a real difference.
And then lastly,
I would say that the insurer fit and value
is also a very important point.
So for example,
some insurers are better fit for certain industries,
different risk profiles
or levels of cyber maturity.
So with all of that combined,
there's any new market entrants
that offer a better coverage,
stronger service
or they're a better underwriting fit for clients.
All of that in addition to obviously competitive pricing,
then that's a strong basis to recommend the move.
Well, what about you, Mark?
Does the entrance of Cowbell
and emergence buying up Blue Zebra,
does that have any impact on
where you're putting your clients?
Are you considering moving them?
I think as a broker,
always very much welcome competition
and new entrants, frankly,
it's always good to
potentially have some leverage there
to kind of drive further market competition
for the sake of client's benefit.
I think echoing Jack's sentiment,
there, you know,
change for the sake of change
is not something that we'd ever advocate for,
but where it makes sense,
where new markets are providing
kind of meaningful differentiation,
whether it comes through a coverage piece,
pricing, of course, is always a consideration.
Add values, I think meaningful add values
where the cyber insurance market has matured a lot
or kind of most tangibly in our opinion
over the last couple of years
is really starting to offer,
yeah, meaningful add-ons or add values
than what it used to do over the last couple of years.
So, you know, where do these new entrants sit
with respect to that positioning?
I think also foundationally as brokers,
we need to make sure that we continue to understand
what's important to the client
as straightforward as it might sound.
So are they an organisation that values,
you know, longevity of relationship and pool premium
and, you know, that potentially being a mitigant
for when this market eventually turns?
Are they more price-driven?
Is there opportunity for cross-class alignment
that might exist there?
I, yeah, there's, of course, so many factors
that go into considering a change,
but to kind of circle back
to one of the points in the beginning,
definitely welcome new entrants,
definitely welcome more competition.
This market will eventually change,
but for now it's, yeah,
we look forward to it continuing to be buyer favourable.
Great. Well, thank you, Mark from Lockton.
Thanks, Jack from Marsh.
And thanks for watching Insurance Business TV.
Bye for now.
