Professional risks in 2026: Market shifts you can't ignore

Business Insurance
4 followers
14 Video Views·May 9, 2026
Insurance Business TV brings together leading market voices for the first New Zealand Professional Risks Power Panel of 2026. In this fast-moving discussion, the panel breaks down competitive pricing, growing insurer capacity, cyber and health and safety claims trends, client expectations around policy response, and the rising pressure AI is placing on professional indemnity and liability risk.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Pricing is still very, very competitive at the moment.
I think the biggest gap is between what clients think the risk they've transferred to the policy.
So like some premiums are dropping like 50, 60 percent. The trend is not going to continue.
Hello and welcome to Insurance Business TV for our first Professional Risks Power Panel of 2026
for New Zealand. We're going to look at what the market's doing right now, including the biggest
gaps between customer claims, expectations and how their PI policy actually responds.
Our experts are here. Nina Croft is back. She's Associate Director and Northern Manager of
Financial, Executive and Professional Risks for Willis. Nina is in Auckland. And we have two new
panellists to welcome. Also in Auckland, Tom Lemer, Liability Broker with ICIB, BrokerWeb
Insurance and Risk Advisory. Hi, Tom. Welcome to the panel. Thanks for joining us.
Hi, Daniel. Yeah, thanks for having me. Looking forward to it.
And in Christchurch, Ethan Gerrard is Managing Director at Gerrard's Insurance Brokers.
Welcome, Ethan.
Yeah. G'day, Danny. Nice to be here.
Good to have you both. Good to have all of you. Let's start with you, Nina. What do you see as
the biggest single shift in the professional risks market as we head into 2026? Is it pricing,
capacity, claims trends, buyer behaviour? And can you give an example of that?
Hi, Danny. Yeah, thank you for having me. Great to be here. Yeah, that's a great question. I think,
you know, personally, I don't think there's any sort of one great shift. I think all of
these factors are still very much in play. You know, pricing is still very, very competitive
at the moment. There's still plenty of capacity in the market. We saw new entrants coming in last
year, but also more capacity in terms of insurers having more flexibility to do stuff that they
potentially wouldn't have considered in a harder market. Claims trends continue to run. I mean,
just touching on two topics, particularly you will have seen all over the media last year,
large scale and smaller cyber events, well documented, and also health and safety
continues to feature. Underwriting scrutiny, whilst insurers are still certainly scrutinising
risks properly, they are, as I mentioned, being a little bit more flexible. And I guess in terms of
the buyer behaviour, you know, financial economic pressures are still really impacting,
particularly in the sort of the SME space with, you know, those smaller businesses next to,
you know, the salaries they pay the employees, insurance is their next biggest cost. So they're
really looking to, you know, continue to try and drive premium savings. And then I guess,
in terms of a sort of the one sort of a big focal point for all of us really is the AI piece,
which we touched on last year, it continues to be growing and evolving, you know, we stay
trying to stay ahead of the curve, we're growing and learning and evolving alongside.
There's been a couple of, there's been some discussion that, you know, some of our London,
the London carriers are starting to mobilise plans to address, you know, generative IA risks
across several lines of business, because there's been a wave of litigation in the US,
which is, of course, raising the stakes for potential claims. And we've started to see the
emergence of those exclusions in the US. And for us as brokers, whilst I guess, we do not fully
comprehend the challenges we'll face yet, we will increasingly need to help our clients demonstrate
robust AI oversight. And definitely governance, especially with regards to PI will become
insurability. So a bit of a mountain there, but sort of all of those factors are still in play.
Thank you, Nina. Tom, moving to you. Nina mentioned AI risks,
is that a big shift for you? Or what are you seeing? And what's an example of it?
Yeah, thanks, Daniel. AI, AI risk is certainly emerging within the businesses that we've been,
you know, dealing with and talking to and assisting with their insurance programmes.
I mean, quite timely, a very recent example is we've got a financial institution that we're
assisting with their professional indemnity policy. And there've been questions in the
pre-renewal process in respect to how can they utilise an AI tool as part of their web platform.
And so it becomes a little bit tricky when you go, what potential scope of advice would an AI
tool potentially be putting out to the public? I know that's a little bit more niche, but with
other businesses that we're looking at, I think this is probably common across the industry.
We're seeing businesses utilise Copilot or ChatGPT or some functions internally. And
there's certainly just a little bit of concern as to where that professional advice scope does,
how far would it extend? And so it's very interesting, you know, hearing Nina's comments,
looking to America and seeing where that direction is going to take us here locally.
And yeah, so we'll be trying to stay ahead of the curve on that particular risk.
And Ethan, coming to you in third place there, are you staying ahead of the curve? Are you
seeing a single shift that you're particularly watching? And what's an example of that?
Yeah, well, we mainly deal with a lot of small businesses,
Daniel, so probably the most volume in New Zealand for any office. And across them with
the AI piece, what we find is that people like to call AI a lot of fancy things, but really it's
most businesses in that space are just using it to automate things. So like drilling down and
finding out what they're actually using it for, if they're even calling it the right thing,
has been super helpful. As far as other shifts that we've been noticing is that last year was
just a great year in the FinPro lines in general. So you're getting really good wins for clients
and some premiums are dropping like 50, 60%, which is amazing, right? But then these clients
are expecting the same thing to happen again this year, which admittedly is not going to be the case.
It kind of, as what I see, reached kind of the bottom. So these ones that we were getting,
the trend is not going to continue, but the clients are still expecting them.
Another one we're seeing is employment disputes cover, and especially in the SME market,
it's just, I feel like that's going to be a real niggly one in the next sort of 12 months
because the economy is still in a bad place. So these claims are just going to keep rising
and rising over time. And you see a lot of these no win, no fee firms popping up,
especially advertised across the media. So people really just are happy to take a chance.
So the underwriters are really losing money on this or not making a profit,
and it's just going to get worse in my opinion. Ethan, you mentioned some premiums coming down by
50% or even 60%, and that's creating an expectation that that might keep happening
from some of the clients in this soft market. But there must be some areas where it's still
pretty tough to get insurance. Are you finding any insurance challenges?
Oh, 100%. So the biggest one for us in the SME space is that businesses are dealing overseas.
So you've got this small business, you might have this amazing counter that's got this product,
they want to sell it in the US. Now, they're just getting it off the ground. Is $5,000 or $10,000
as a minimum premium going to be palatable when they're selling their business? I mean,
that means they're going to make like $10,000 or $20,000 a month just to cover their insurance
cost. Now, that's been quite prohibitive for us and a lot of people have actually not started
trading in what is the world's biggest market just because of this prohibitive factor of the
cost of insurance. Now, is that going to change? Probably not, but it's definitely a frustration
on our end. Thanks, Ethan. And what about you, Nina?
Where are you seeing insurance challenges? I mean, certainly Ethan has touched on some
key themes, particularly in the SME space. He's pretty much covered the things that I wanted to
say. But yes, even for the larger organisations or larger corporates that are dealing in territories
all over the world, the US, Europe, Hong Kong, and the Asian markets, it also depends very much
on where they're sitting. It can be very tricky to also understand all from a broker underwriting
perspective where the local paper is required in those other markets. So it's not just the
clients doing business in those territories, but us fully understanding what is required to place
business into, do a new local paper, can it be written out of New Zealand, all this sort of
stuff. And I guess, we touched on it in the previous, the sustainability of premiums is
certainly a concern whilst we've had big drops of 50, 60, 70%. Are those going to be sustainable?
It's going to go up the other way. Clients are going to struggle with that. But also, I guess
we're also measuring that with where we have been seeing those significant increase with
underwriters telling them, you know, just having open arms discussions saying, guys, you're leaving
just too much money on the table. Because trying to then get back up from there to where we're
going to go is going to be incredibly hard and it's going to hit businesses, you know, very, very hard
from a financial perspective. Thanks, Nina. And Tom, what about you?
Where are you seeing insurance challenges right now?
We were seeing insurance challenges that even though like we've acknowledged that we're in
a soft market and we're seeing that underwriting appetite and capacity has increased, particular
challenges that we're facing is in respect to startup companies that we're assisting locally.
So it's fantastic that there's a lot of real ingenuity and creativity from local New Zealand
companies that all seem to lean into a tech space. There's some absolutely fantastic, weird
and wonderful inventions and products and services that they're putting together and looking to
expand and grow quickly like Ethan and Nina touched on that creates challenges with him
trying to make sure the cover extends to the United States or into Europe, making sure,
of course, you've got a little bit of policy, but it is economical as well.
And in some occasions, there's the challenge that even though their underwriters want to
write business and they want to put money in their coffers, yeah, there's still just a real
tricky, tricky niche risks out there. And that's probably the biggest challenges I've been facing
certainly at the start of the year. Let's stick with you, Tom. And you've
all mentioned this, that gap in customer expectation in the sense that they've had
these big discounts, some of them, and they're probably thinking they're going to get them again.
But what are you looking at in terms of the policies themselves? Where are you seeing
the biggest gaps between what the clients are expecting and what the policies actually do?
And what can you do about that? Yeah, definitely. I think the biggest gap is between
what clients think the risk they've transferred to the policy and then actually seeing what the
policy is doing when it's being put under some actual stress. Contractual liability
exclusions are typically a bit of a pitfall with client expectations. So often with us,
we try and mitigate that by saying send through contracts with prospective customers,
with prospective suppliers so that we can review any cause that relates to insurance or whether
that's a limitation of liability, whether you're putting a whole harmless provision in there,
just so that we can prevent any exclusions or any headaches coming into claims time,
where I think the clients don't necessarily appreciate that. It might be one thing to read
a contract and see that they need $5 million of professional indemnity insurance, but then they
might read, okay, in the event that something goes wrong, something goes bang, we're going to
hold the third party harmless in the event of a claim, not appreciating that that's going to
very likely trigger the contractual liability exclusion in a policy where for them, I think
it's more of a case that they're happy to jump into a contract and happy to start drumming up
that business. So there's certainly an education piece from a broken side when we're having those
discussions with clients. And then there's, I know it's a little bit niche looking at DNO
expectations, but the Protective Disclosures Act has caused a couple of headaches. I'm not sure
whether that's across the industry, but certainly on our side in respect to client expectations.
So when there have been, again, I can't say all too much given the nature of the act,
but when there have been allegations made under the Protective Disclosures Act against
a director or officer of a company or organisation, the act, it's a little bit wishy-washy
in the sense that it says that one of the actions you can take is an internal investigation,
or you can just dismiss the matter and then let it run its course and then go
and be investigated by a regulatory body or something of that nature.
And we're just finding that the DNO policies at the moment aren't necessarily responding to
the initial investigation that one might do internally. And that's causing some definite
pain points for the clients. And it's one that we're working closely with the underwriters on
to see if we can plug that gap, because of course, if you don't do that internal investigation and you
let things run, it could turn out to be a much bigger and much costly issue.
That's a little bit wordy, but apologies. Tom, I think you've won our respect by taking on
the regulations there. I think you did very well. Ethan, turning to you, where are you
seeing the biggest gaps? I'm going to carry on with what Tom did really well, bringing up the
DNO side of things. For us, it's probably just like the customer expectation of how that policy
responds, right? So a person will set up a limited liability company, I'm fully protected, and then
that doesn't protect me. But in saying that, especially across our space, insurers just love
putting on that insolvency exclusion, and that seems to be quite hard to sometimes get rid of.
I mean, a lot of times, especially on the insurer side, they can't be expected to intimately
understand every sort of business type. So when you're looking at the financial statements,
what they're picking up is a bigger risk might not actually be, like I'll take our business,
for example, we spend a lot of money on marketing. Now, we could cut that off tomorrow,
and we'd be in an extremely good financial position. But at a quick glance of financial
statements, you wouldn't actually realise that. So I think there just needs to be a bit more
connection between underwriters and saying, this is how we get this exclusion removed,
or how we're looking at it. So we can actually go ahead and get our clients properly protected
in that case. Thanks, Ethan. And Nina, what about you? Where are the gaps?
I think both Tom and Ethan have pretty much covered that off. I'll just briefly, I guess,
do a broad overview as well. As Tom said, and as Ethan alluded to, all policies are finite in
scope, and they don't cover every and all eventuality, particularly looking at contracts
and the contracts that clients enter into. Of course, we can only look at those from an insurance
lens, we can't give any sort of legal advice. But it is also ensuring or educating the clients
that not all risks can be transferred to insurance. Clients still need to ensure that
they have robust controls across every part of the business. And that will also have a direct
impact on premiums if they're very risk averse, got good robust processes in place. As we all
know, gaps, and Ethan alluded to, insurers fill gaps with premium if they're not sure. So it's
really ensuring that those gaps are exposed. And I guess for us as brokers, we need to guide our
clients, we need to ensure we are not transactional, that we are risk focused, that we have an
understanding of what's important to them to ensure that we can address those coverage gaps
appropriately. But we also need to advise when what they're looking for isn't or what they've
signed up for, the policy may just simply not respond. We all know that liability policies
all have contractual liability exclusions. And then that basically say, there'll be no cover
for a breach of contract unless you would have been liable at law in the absence of something
written. Obviously, there's variations to that and things can be noted. But yeah, it is that,
I guess, managing the gap between the expectation of what the clients think
they're going to get or signing up to and what they're actually going to get.
Thanks, Nina. And for the last question, if I had the power to give you ultimate control
of the insurance market, for this last question before you get back to your customers,
if you could change how the market operates in one way that would help clients and the
sustainability of the market, what would that be? Nina, let's start with you.
I guess also just these are themes we've touched on throughout and Ethan just also before. I mean,
ultimately, I'd like to see a lot less remarketing of every risk and getting our insurer partners in
front of our clients in order for them to fully understand the risk. There is so much you can
glean from, or only so much you can glean from proposal forms, emails, calls, but nothing is
enlightening as a face-to-face client meeting where you have the broker, the underwriter.
Often a client will just say, nothing has changed, everything's the same. But if a simple
sort of round table discussion can be very insightful and can draw out so much additional
information and fill all those sort of coverage gaps, because clients like to talk about their
business. And even though you've known them for a long time, if you don't have those sort of
discussions, you can glean so much. They might have said everything's the same, but then you
have this discussion and then they tell you all these wonderful things that they're doing and
all this sort of other information comes to light. And that also sort of practically demonstrates to
clients how, or to insurers, how clients run their business. Ethan was alluding to the fact that you
might just look at the financial statements and go, well, that doesn't look that great.
But if you actually understood where the risk was or that the picture wasn't as bad, so it really
gives insurers an insight into how they run their business, how robust their risk management
processes are. And then that also naturally leads to strong and I call sticky, but stickability
relationships, which will ensure that we have robust coverage and premiums remain sustainable.
And with those gaps that are generally filled with premium and those are removed,
the costs then of policies become competitive and sustainable. And then even in a hard market,
whilst there will be impacts, they will be less severe when the risk is fully understood.
And then I guess finally, just loyalty to insurers is often underestimated, particularly
in the market that we have. And I do get the financial economic pressures on clients, but it
can be so vital at the time of a grey area claim or something that can be quite tricky. Preserving
that sort of long-term continuity in relationship can stand a client in really good stead, especially
with liability plans, which have a very long tail nature. And if we have that sort of
that continuity, it also ensures a good understanding as risks grow and evolve,
you know, and then coverage can also grow and evolve alongside those risks.
Sorry, a bit of a mouthful, but sort of a broad overview there.
Thanks, Nina. And Tom, coming to you, what's one thing you'd like to change if you could
that would improve outcomes? Yeah, so I think it sort of echoes
what Nina was talking about just before, but it's engaging conversations with the client early. So
kicking off your pre-renewal process earlier, absolutely getting in front of your client
so that you can sit down and discuss and better understand the risk. I think that's probably been
one of the key themes from the discussion today is brokers need to sort of understand the risk
and relay those to clients better to better do the education piece. It goes twofold. I know
from businesses and prospects I've been talking to in the market, even in the last two months,
coming back from holiday, one of the things that's been common at clients have been voicing
and prospects have been voicing even to start the year is the broker that I'm currently with,
I haven't heard from them in a few weeks. I've had to send them follow-up emails,
chaser emails. So there's certainly that client engagement piece there.
But it's also you want to get in, you know, you want brokers to sit down with clients early,
so as to educate and so as to ensure that their businesses are properly protected,
because that's ultimately why they're paying money, not so that we can eat well,
but to protect their business in the event that something goes wrong. So I mean,
thinking back to a point that Ethan raised earlier in the piece when he was talking about
the importance of the employment protection liability, so employment disputes and,
you know, I think we're seeing increased claims there as well. But certainly a lack of education
we've found with clients that we've taken on board is that they will say, hey, look,
Tom, two months ago, we've had somebody that filed a personal grievance, we've hired a lawyer,
we've paid them a settlement, can we claim this with the insurer? And I hear that's a work your
magic and, you know, put the Shakespearean song on when you go to the claims team for that.
But if you're having the conversations earlier, you're building that rapport and you're building
that trust, a lot of these things can get nipped in the bud earlier and you can deliver
an excellent service and a service that client expects. So that's what I would change for 2026.
Thank you, Tom, and for your rather Shakespearean sounding language there.
Ethan, you get the last word. What are your thoughts on something you'd like to change?
Awesome. I absolutely adore this question. Thanks, Danny, because it makes me bring up
one of my favourite subjects and it's like the education, which Tom's already touched on. But
I think the biggest change probably needs to come on the broker side of things, actually.
So at the moment, as we can see diverging in this space is that there's a lot of really senior
people with a lot of awesome experience. Nina's been doing this for a long time,
to a lot of knowledge. And there's a lot of people even in that 55 to 65 range that are
going to age out of insurance soon. And then there's not a lot of people down the other end
that are actually picking up or learning this knowledge. So with industries, you really want
to leave it better than when you started, right? So like if you want to make the next generation
better than you are. So how do we do that? Well, we need to get people like Nina and get the
knowledge out of their heads to all these young people so they can actually do this. So whether
that's be like online training courses or videos, and I'm talking about getting it across the whole
industry to improve every broker, not just specifically in broker. So how do we get people
like her in front of everybody to share that knowledge, to then make everybody better,
and then the clients will benefit as a result. So that's my 100% thing for 2026. I think it needs
to be worked on hugely. That's a great point to end on. Thanks, Ethan. And thank you, Tom.
Thanks, Nina. And thank you for watching Insurance Business TV. Bye for now.
