Cyber insurance trends, Al risk and broker strategy

Business Insurance
4 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 21, 2026
Featuring Damian Schade of Lockton, Decklyn Thomson of GSI Insurance Partners, and Thomas Arnott of Marsh.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedExperts from Marsh, Lockton, and GSI Insurance Partners analyze the evolving cyber insurance landscape. The discussion highlights a shift from basic insurance coverage toward comprehensive cyber resilience, focusing on the threats of AI-driven attacks, ransomware, and the systemic risks posed by Managed Service Providers (MSPs).
Risk mitigation is just as important and even getting on calls.
The ability of AI to sort of, I guess, supercharge the social engineering piece,
I think that's still the biggest concern for clients.
We're definitely seeing an uptick in the invoice fraud, business email compromise side of things.
Hello and welcome to Insurance Business TV for our quarterly cyber insurance power panel.
We're going to unpack what brokers should know about the state of the market,
including the latest AI concerns and a cyber portfolio buy-up involving local players.
We've reassembled our panel of experts.
Tom Arnott is Cyber Specialist with Marsh.
Damien Shade is Client Director Financial Lines at Lockton.
And Declan Thompson is Associate Director with GSI Insurance Partners.
Well, welcome to all of you gentlemen.
Very good to have you back.
Tom, let's start with you for the first question.
What are you most concerned about right now in terms of
cyber insurance issues impacting your clients?
Yeah, of course.
And thanks, Denny.
It's good to be back on the program again.
Yeah, look, I mean, we conducted a catalyst survey and the findings weren't too surprising.
It's denial of service attacks and ransomware, which is at the front of mind for clients.
And again, not surprising given ransomware still happens to be one of the largest
types of numbers when it comes through claims.
The severity is just through the roof.
So it's not surprising that that's what's front of mind for clients.
And that's, yeah, forms part of the advice we give is that's one of the big,
big ticket items at the moment.
I mean, it's also risk mitigation over the insurance solution as a product.
While the insurance solution is a great way to transfer your risk,
of course, we like to remind clients that risk mitigation is just as important.
And even getting on calls with incident response vendors and insurers just to
see what sort of programs and services they have available to
help actually improve resilience as a first and foremost line of defense.
Well, thanks, Tom.
Damian, what about you?
What's front of mind with your clients at the moment?
Yeah, thanks, Dan.
I agree with Tom.
I think that's sort of a prevalent area around that piece.
But I also think sort of social engineering, which is sort of the buzzword we continue to hear
and the prevalence and the ability of AI to sort of, I guess,
supercharge the social engineering piece.
I think that's still the biggest concern for clients and where we still see a lot of claims
arising and sort of similar to Tom's point, just around managing that conduit between
having a cyber policy in place, but also understanding what an incident response looks
like because we see clients that might have the cyber in place and just sort of have it
put it on the shelf and not understand what it might look like in respect of response.
So kind of managing that conduit is a critical piece at the moment.
Thanks, Damian.
And Declan, coming to you in third place,
what are your clients telling you about as far as concerns with AI and cyber and stuff like that?
Yeah, thanks again for having me, Dan.
I guess I'll add to what the two gents have mentioned.
I guess from our perspective, possibly more anecdotally and from like,
let's say, experience on claims that we've had in the last six months to a year,
we're actually finding maybe the frequency of business email compromise and invoice fraud
related sort of cyber events be on the rise, I think, particularly around the professional
services firms, construction related engineering, particularly around those where, let's just say,
maybe project related invoices are more of a concern.
We're seeing probably an uptick or we're definitely seeing an uptick in the invoice
fraud business email compromise side of things from the cyber aspect as well.
So I guess, particularly for our professional services firms,
we're just having conversations with them around, look, if you've got kind of key contracts,
key projects that you're working on, it's just being prudent and paying extra attention to
detail around the invoicing and the emails and that kind of thing that are coming through,
because that seems to be an area of concern in the past six months or so.
Well, it's interesting that that's coming back. That sounds like it's a fairly basic one. It's
interesting that invoices are now an issue again. Declan, let's stick with you. We've had that
powerful AI called Mythos introduced into New Zealand, apart from other countries as well.
AI is continually in the headlines. What's your current biggest AI concern right now?
Yeah, I will say I definitely am not the fountain of knowledge when it comes to the AI space,
but I guess from conversations that we've been having with clients in the past, say,
three to six months around AI had been around the speed and I guess scope of AI's ability to
penetrate, let's say, industries or particular businesses at a much faster rate and probably a
lot easier than cyber threat actors used to be able to previously. So a lot of the conversation
has been around that and the development of AI and what the risks look like for cyber.
But I guess also that on the other side of the coin, it is also meaning that some of those AI
tools are being used and are being implemented in the defence or in cyber risk management,
cyber protection. So we are trying to, I guess, also have conversations around, look, there is
some useful tools, particularly from insurers. I think the New Zealand cyber security division
itself has also started to implement some of this. There is the counter side to that where some of
these AI tools are going to aid in the defence and cyber protection. But I think ultimately,
it still goes back to that conversation of AI is just going to significantly escalate
the ease and speed and scope of which cyber actors can penetrate New Zealand businesses.
Thanks, Declan. And Tom, how about you? Was your attention piqued by the introduction of Mythos and
what's an AI concern for you right now? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I'd have to
definitely agree with Declan. It's certainly just heightening the threat environment.
Mythos, if that gets in the hands of threat actors, it's just going to be another tool that
they can use to take advantage of businesses and just the rate and speed that these are developing.
It's also more of a client side conversation with the governance piece, ensuring that
clients don't adopt technology, new technologies too quickly, put the right checks and balances
in place to ensure that they're doing it the right way. And yeah, just a big part of that
governance piece is also important to consider. And Damian, what about you? How do you see AI
right now in Mythos? Yeah, absolutely. I agree wholeheartedly with the comments and I would
sort of just add from a client perspective, making sure that when we're kind of engaging
with clients that similar to what Tom said, they've got a clear understanding and a clear
remit for how they use AI. They understand what they're using it for and the purpose and where
the information's coming from. And if there's some governance around that and their understanding
is aligned, then that sort of puts them in a sort of a relatively strong position because
we certainly talk to clients and partners that don't have that level of governance within AI
and they sort of let a lot of people sort of go a little bit rogue and that's when we can
sort of see issues. So yeah, a really good governance framework around it and then
understanding clearly what you are using it for and the purpose is really important in my view.
Damian, let's stick with you. It's always interesting to look at how your role as
broker changes over the years and a trend for the last couple of years has been how cyber
attackers are targeting entire IT platforms rather than just going for big-name companies
and I'm just wondering how that has changed the way you give advice as a broker. Yeah, I mean I
think it absolutely has. It's sort of particularly service providers or managed service providers or
anyone that's got sort of a huge allotment of clients that they manage. It's really important
I think for us from engaging with our clients that our clients understand the implications when
there's an issue with a managed service provider because often our clients will default to the
managed service provider or the platform and be comfortable that they will manage any cyber
related issue but one of the things we've been discussing with clients recently is how they
manage a situation when their managed service provider is compromised and they can no longer
have they can't handle the response and there's an issue with the integrity of the data and being
able to get up and running so making sure that our clients have a reasonably strong process in
place to manage that transition in the event that the managed service provider is compromised
because you're absolutely right they continue to be the biggest target because of the tentacles
they had sort of across the board but from a client side making sure that our clients don't
entirely rely on them and they have a plan B in the event that they are compromised.
Declan what about you what's the change in the way you give advice?
Yeah I think a lot of it follows on from what sort of Damien was mentioning I think like
cyber discussions over the last few years have sort of migrated you know initially possibly
from around the product and what it can cover now to more so around cyber risk management
cyber resilience and so I think a lot of those conversations particularly around service
providers and that kind of thing at this stage for us just look like having open discussions
with clients around you know what possible solutions or risk management can be found
internally as opposed to relying on a cyber policy so it's just simple questions or simple sort of
discussions openly around who hosts your data you know who has admin access who manages your backups
because those kinds of things I guess they work more they're a lot more helpful to clients in
terms of business continuity plans of disaster recovery plans as opposed to the reliance on
the cyber policy so I think discussions have generally moved more towards okay let's talk
about what you are doing internally first as opposed to the cyber policy you know just sort
the ambulance at the bottom of the hill kind of mindset so yeah I guess that migration of
discussion from product policy more so towards cyber resilience is where we're headed at least.
And Tom what about you what's this targeting of platforms done to your discussions with clients?
Yeah I mean Declan and Damien have basically covered it off it's just about incorporating
third-party risk into your already your current risk assessments just looking outside the
organization and for brokers to ensure that you know the policy does respond to
excuse me outsourced service provider you know business interruption because it's so much more
than just a risk to just internal businesses now with supply chains getting hit so ensuring that
the policy does actually respond to when your dependent service provider does go down is
pretty vital nowadays. Let's look at the market for a second because there have been some changes
recently that may or may not impact your jobs as brokers. Emergence who are a provider in New
Zealand recently brought up Blue Zebra's cyber book. I guess this could give you more options
for your clients but I mean what would make you change cyber insurers for a client when the
markets have been disrupted like this? Are you looking around thinking oh what's this gonna
what's gonna happen? Tom what's your take on this? Yeah I mean at any point if you're looking to
market a policy I mean the first thing that a broker should consider is the level of coverage.
First and foremost are you downgrading coverage? Are you adding coverage? What additional services
does that insurer provide? Do they do onboarding calls? Getting to know the client and even claims
performance you know claims being paid out but just a couple of things to consider when moving
insurer but yeah first and foremost probably coverage number one item. And Damian what do
you consider when you're thinking about maybe moving a client? Yeah similar to Tom's comments
I think coverage is obviously critical but I think particularly from a cyber perspective what their
incident response looks like, what their onboarding process, what their experience is in managing
claims because that's a critical component of a cyber related issue. It's something that
are they handling it internally? Do they have expertise or are they outsourcing it so they're
just essentially a middleman in the middle of a process? So depending on what you kind of need
from the particular insurer I think there's a lot of options at the moment the markets are obviously
ultra competitive and there's plenty of capacity so it's a good opportunity for us as brokers to
sort of compare and contrast those but they're probably the key areas. And Declan you get the
last word on this cyber panel or what are you comparing and contrasting if you're thinking
about moving a client? Yeah I mean clients always I guess like it's always important to have
discussions with clients around pricing stability pricing those kinds of things just from a general
insurance perspective not specifically tied to cyber but I think where cyber does or where
cyber conversations do sort of differ is in terms of we're always looking I guess at sub-limits for
some of the key risks that we've talked about even today in terms of
business interruption, social engineering, those kinds of things. It's really important if
we're even considering a change of cyber insurers that we are I guess brokers are looking closely at
some of those sub-limits or you know limitations that might apply and then I think realistically
the boys at the nail on the head in terms of actually in the last 12 months or so a lot of
the conversation or a lot of broker thought has gone into well what does the incident response
or the forensic sort of teams look like what does the claims response look like for
for our clients in the event of a cyber claim because for a number of the New Zealand insurers
at least locally it is as simple as a phone you know a phone call to kind of take things from there
so if that's not the case or if the incident response doesn't stack up with what we currently
have in New Zealand at least we're not looking to get better than that's definitely a consideration
that you know should be relayed to clients and should be made by brokers so yeah I guess those
those would be the two key things we are looking at. Great well thank you Declan and that wraps up
our cyber power panel for New Zealand. Thanks also to Tom and Damien and thanks for watching
Insurance Business TV. Bye for now.
