Cyber Insurance at the Crossroads

Business Insurance
4 followers
4 Video Views·Jul 7, 2026
AI, Regulation, and Rising Risk
AI Generated·May contain errors
The last thing they want to be doing is searching on Google what to do when they see a ransomware
note on their screens or essentially being stuck negotiating the price of water when their house
is on fire. So what we're seeing with AI-driven phishing, deep fakes, is that the traditional
reg flags are disappearing. We're receiving emails now that look perfectly legitimate. They have the
exact proper crammer spelling, you know, signature blocks, everything looks identical as how it
Hello everyone, welcome to the latest edition of our Cyber Insurance Power Panel as we welcome
back our favourites Derek May, Vice President of Technology and Cyber and Canadian Cyber Product
Co-Leader at HUP, Avi Sharma, Senior Vice President and Cyber Solutions Co-Leader,
Canada at Aon and Mila Arraggio, AVP Digital Shield, Personal Cyber Practice Leader,
North America at NFP and Aon Company. So welcome everyone and of course we have to begin with AI,
don't we? With threat actors increasingly using AI for phishing, deep fakes, automation,
how are underwriting controls and client guidance evolving to address this
next wave of cyber risk? Adi, what are you seeing?
Thank you Paul for allowing me to kick this off. Yes, it's no secret that AI is certainly allowing
the threat actors to scale their attacks at a pace and a level of sophistication that wasn't
possible before. It's certainly lowering the barrier for attackers. There's more frequency,
not just severity. Now, keep in mind that it's also helping organizations and the good guys
amplify their defensive techniques. So that's also a facet of AI that shouldn't be ignored.
Now, from an insurance perspective, this is certainly pushing a greater focus on controls,
people, processes and access. So controls around people, processes and access and not just IT.
Things like payment verification, callback provisions, dual authorization, these are all
becoming critical questions, not just across cyber insurance, but also across crime insurance,
specifically talking to the funds transfer fraud coverage or the social engineering coverage that
is found under these policies. So we are seeing clarification of certain policy wordings around
impersonation fraud and deep fake scenarios. But from a client guidance perspective,
not a lot has changed. We're just reiterating the message that we have been providing for the past
several years, which is position cyber as a financial risk and an organizational risk and
an enterprise wide risk, not just an IT issue. It's important to encourage simple and practical
controls now more than ever, and not just the expensive and complex tech solutions. The gap
today is really often behavioral and not necessarily technical.
Yeah. And on that note as well, Derek, I imagine it's getting more and more difficult to spot the
red flags, isn't it? Yeah. I mean, Adi mentioned it. We're in a new world now where you can have
all the security, all of the costs going into that side of things. But if we're not creating
that human firewall, if we're not building resilient employees who know what to spot,
especially with this evolving AI risk where we're receiving emails now that look perfectly
legitimate, they have the exact proper grammar, spelling, signature blocks, everything looks
identical as how it should. But again, going back to the basics of looking at who's actually
sending the email, we've seen numerous ones where even with Hub International spoofed emails where
it's coming from a Yahoo address or it's coming from an Outlook address. And so these are some of
those really basic tells that while everything else might look legitimate, it's those one or
two little red flags that will pop up that we need to be able to train our employees to spot.
So again, this is why cyber insurers are so emphatic that all of our clients are doing
that employee training on a regular basis because as the hackers evolve and their techniques evolve,
so do we as employees building that human firewall. And is this changing the offerings
as well in the personal cyberspace, Mila? Yes, this has been a major focus for us,
particularly on the client side of the equation. So what we're seeing with AI driven phishing,
deep fakes is that the traditional red flags are disappearing as Addy and Derek mentioned.
So the conversation is shifting from awareness more to resilience for us. And from a client
guidance perspective, we have embedded that directly into our personal cyber offerings. So
it's not just about coverage. It's about three key elements, ongoing education, real-time support,
and access to experts when something happens. And the goal is to help clients, whether those
are personal clients or through our partnerships with our commercial clients and our affinity
group clients to respond to the increasingly sophisticated social engineering, not just
recover after the fact, but hopefully extend the protection beyond the business itself to
all of the different players who can impact the business. So employers and affinity groups
are looking for ways to support employees, clients, and executives who are often targeted
individually. And we're increasingly positioning the personal cyber solutions as part of a broader
risk strategy, helping close that gap between the corporate and individual exposures. So as
underwriting evolves, we're evolving the product as well to try and respond to all of these key
needs and provide that valuable support. Well, let's look at how the regulators are
reacting as well. We are seeing some signals of stricter enforcement in 2026. So Derek,
how are you seeing this impact demand for higher limits, incident response services,
policy wording perhaps around fines and penalties? Yeah, historically fines and penalties haven't
played a major factor. You know, we certainly have the coverage included in the policy,
but I'm a little bit skeptical that it's just going to dramatically rise where it's kind of
gone from very little activity to, you know, again, not expecting it to go astronomical.
But I think, rest assured, the policy is there to protect our insureds from fines and penalties.
Again, we're insurable by law. But yeah, again, I think time will tell. And I think Adi is going
to build on my answer just with some of the regulatory pieces. Yeah, because I imagine,
Adi, that high limits are becoming sort of higher on the equation if you want as well.
Yeah, I mean, and that has been the case, Paul, since almost late 2024 at this point,
where organizations are really striving towards getting the right policy limits and the right
level of cyber insurance coverage for a variety of reasons. The risk is obviously arguably higher
than it used to be before. There's more sophistication. Cyber awareness within organizations
is at an all-time high. You know, many surveys across the insurance industry as well as the
cybersecurity industry show that organizations are most concerned about cyber risk when you compare
to some of the other risks that are out there. And really, right-sizing your insurance program
today is more affordable than it was before. We were obviously in a very competitive market.
And then finally, to answer this question, in 2026, we do sort of foresee some upcoming regulatory
changes in Canada. So in terms of client discussions, there's certainly more discussion
around the insurability of these fines and penalties under cyber insurance. And of course,
that's a topic for an entire zone. But these fines are insurable under the law in the jurisdiction
that they're charged, specifically the ones coming up in Canada. So that's something that clients
want to know about. Number two, will regulatory action coverage actually be triggered if there
is a security breach and no privacy incident? Because historically, regulatory action coverage
has been tied to a privacy incident. And then number three, will regulatory action actually
be triggered if there is just an allegation of non-compliance, which is an isolation from an
actual cyber incident? So there's a claim for non-compliance, which has nothing to do with a
cyber privacy incident. Will regulatory action coverage be triggered in that case? So those are
some of the questions and discussions that clients are having around this, and understandably so.
But to Derek's point, we haven't seen regulatory coverage and fines and penalties be a driver for
organisations to buy insurance. Whether or not that will change, only time will tell.
But these are some of the topics that clients are looking to discuss with us.
And of course, Adi as well, we're also seeing a heightened focus on critical infrastructure
resilience. So how are insurers addressing accumulation risk and third-party risk tied
to shared service providers? Yeah, I mean, systemic risk and third-party
risk and accumulation risk is obviously a big concern for insurers. We've had some recent
events that have showed this to us, and some of which have been very near misses and could have
been a lot more disastrous than they ended up being. So yes, insurers are highly focused on
aggregation risk, whether that's to do with cloud service providers, shared service providers,
national infrastructure dependencies, MSPs or managed service providers.
What this really means for underwriting is that there is more questions around
vendor concentration. There is scenario testing, which means carriers are concerned about
what happens if one provider goes down? What is the impact to your business?
And what is the impact to their portfolio as a result of that?
In terms of market actions, we are seeing the attempted use of exclusion for widespread
events in certain cases, and also more conservative capacity deployment. We do see declinations
sometimes if a carrier is exposed to aggregation risk in different parts of the world for the same
organisation. But luckily for buyers, the market is still very competitive. So it is difficult for
carriers to take any extreme actions, even though they may sometimes want to. So again, this might
shift as market dynamics shift. But for now, you know, we're still seeing a relatively stable
environment when it comes to carriers putting on any sort of extreme exclusions or restrictions
on cyber insurance to protect themselves against third party and aggregation risk.
So a relatively stable environment. Derek, would you agree with that?
Yeah, absolutely. I think Adi hit the nail on the head. While insurers definitely ask about
vendor risk as they're going through the underwriting process, by no means do negative
answers in that territory usually lead to a decline. It is something that is on the radar.
But I think with the position the insurers are in with the soft market, as Adi mentioned,
they may want to dig into these things a little bit more, but the market just isn't there yet.
And so if they start asking those questions and declining risks on that, there's probably
going to be 10 other insurers lining up to write those risks. So we have to continue to monitor
this. It seems like there's never a month that goes by without some sort of fairly large scale
vendor that goes down that impacts many insureds around the world.
But we haven't yet got to that point of critical mass from the claim perspective,
which is pushing it into a harder market. Let's talk about the SMEs of Canada right
now. And of course, they seem to have been increasingly targeted for cyber incidents. So
Derek, how are you seeing product design, pricing, minimum controls being changed in
order to make cyber insurance accessible without weakening underwriting discipline?
Yeah, I think as a broker, this has been an interesting area to track,
especially if we go back to COVID. And back then, pre-COVID, we were not asking very many
questions. And then after COVID, we started to ask a little bit more questions. But now with
a soft market, we're headed the other direction again. So the insurance carriers that are really
specialized in working with those small and medium-sized businesses have probably scaled
back the number of questions more recently than they perhaps were asking before. But what they
are doing behind the scenes is typically some sort of domain scan. And so if they do find some
sort of critical vulnerability, they are flagging that, and that could lead to a decline or maybe
different pricing. But really, again, because of the soft market, it does seem we're headed
the same direction of less questions, a little bit less underwriting, and more of the model of
underwriting at scale, if you will. So adding many companies to the portfolio so that the losses of
the few are paid by the many. And of course, SMEs is a really underpenetrated market as well,
isn't it, Adi? Yeah, SMEs still remain the most underpenetrated segment of buyers in Canada,
which is concerning because they understandably don't have the big wallets to adequately recover
from some of these cyber incidents. Now, from a client discussion standpoint and a product
accessibility standpoint, I don't think we need to make a lot of change in this space. I think
there's a variety of very strong products from some very creative and strong carriers that focus
on this segment of buyers, and they've done a very good job to make these products as accessible
and affordable. So from a product availability standpoint, I actually think we've done a pretty
good job in the insurance marketplace to cater to small to mid-sized enterprises.
What's still lacking, though, I think, is the education to this segment of buyers. I don't think
a lot of them understand the value that cyber insurance and the fundamental value that cyber
insurance could provide to their business. And this is something that we as a broking and insurance
community need to do better at and educate this segment of buyers. It's very important for them
to really understand that cyber insurance is a lot more than just being a financial indemnification
vehicle to them. It's really providing them with the infrastructure that they need to effectively
respond to a cyber incident, which for small to mid-sized businesses is extremely, extremely
important. The last thing they want to be doing is searching on Google what to do when they see a
ransomware note on their screens or essentially being stuck negotiating the price of water when
their house is on fire. So it's important for us to educate clients as to how much value cyber
insurance provides to these organizations in addition to just the financial protection.
Yeah, of course, that's a point as well, isn't it, Mila? The risk itself doesn't just sit with
the organizations, does it? No, and to kind of take a look at that, this is an area where
we consider that it often extends directly to the individuals behind the business
as we look for ways to provide support with our product offerings and respond to this.
So many of these incidents actually start with personal exposure. Some examples could be a
compromised email, a social engineering attack, something targeting a business owner or even an
executive who's being targeted outside of the corporate environment. So one of the ways that
we've adapted our product design is thinking about how personal cyber protection can complement and
work hand-in-hand with what the business has in place. So from a design perspective, we've built
solutions that can be offered through organizations or affinity groups to support employees, business
owners, and even clients directly as an incident response mechanism. And it's a way of extending
protection beyond the corporate perimeter, especially for the SMEs that may not have the
same level of internal controls or resources. At the same time, we're not lowering our underwriting
standards, but what we're looking at is reinforcing the basics while supporting that education and
access to expertise is really, you know, is really going to be critical to help clients
understand how to manage these day-to-day risks and prevent incidents. So for us, accessibility
isn't just about simplifying the coverage, it's about expanding how and where the protection is
delivered and making sure the individuals that are connected to the business are also protected
and a big part of that risk strategy. Let's talk about the bigger cyber claims picture here if we
can. There are, of course, rising legal forensic and business interruption costs at the moment. So
Adi, how are you seeing loss ratios managed through pricing sub-limits or
panel and vendor strategies? Yeah, Paul, this is a great question and, you know, yes,
legal, forensics, BI costs are not getting any better. And that brings me to the point that
we're actually in a unique time and place right now where claims and losses are high,
specifically frequency, but pricing is also extremely competitive. In fact, it's the most
competitive that it's been over the past five to six years. There's a variety of reasons for this.
Insurers are obviously more comfortable with the quality of risk they're insuring due to,
you know, having better underwriting and lost data. Overall, we are living in a more cyber
hygienic environment. As I mentioned before, the awareness around cyber risk is at an all-time
high, which means organizations are investing in their cyber postures, which is bringing more
comfort to carriers. And finally, all of this is leading to it being a growth line of insurance for
many different carriers, which is sort of resulting in a bio-friendly environment being very competitive.
So this is actually, I would turn this question around to say this is an excellent time for brand
new buyers to enter the market. If cyber insurance is not an existing line of insurance within your
insurance portfolio, then this is a great time to explore what it can do for an organization.
And it's also an excellent time for existing buyers to rightsize their programs because it
is affordable and it is a buyer-friendly environment, but the threat landscape is certainly
not friendly to anyone right now. It's a unique time, Derek, and I guess that's a time when
appropriate cover just becomes all the more important. Yeah, as Adi mentioned, we're putting
a lot of emphasis on rightsizing limits for insureds right now. With the soft market, that's
definitely making it more palatable to do that. But again, this all comes back to proper benchmarking.
So we want to make sure that when we are benchmarking appropriate limits for our clients,
this is not done by just simply looking at what their peers are buying, because again, we don't
know necessarily what their peers have done from their own customized benchmark perspective.
So what we do is we use the available resources from an analytic perspective. Obviously, we do
look at peers to some degree. There's many resources on there through many cybersecurity
companies that we can tap into just to try to give our buyer a little bit more information.
And that way, they're not just throwing a dart at a dartboard to try to choose that limit.
Educating them on other losses that we've seen out there. Again, the rising costs of forensics,
you name it. Every year, we're getting reports on what the average ransomware loss is and what
the average amount of payment is. Now again, that can vary widely depending on how badly the
threat actors have got you in their system. Essentially, if they've seen your cyber policy,
if they've seen your financials, that's going to dramatically change what ransomware amount
they're going to be asking for. But again, we can come back to the averages and the different
data that is out there to try to provide some semblance of proper benchmarking for them.
Okay. And this is sort of a unique time. Is that being reflected on the personal cyber
side as well, Mila? Absolutely. I think it's
a really great time for organizations to be strategic about using the new coverage offerings
that are available through personal cyber that can work hand-in-hand with a corporate policy,
but also for individuals to take advantage of these new coverage options that are now being
offered at a very affordable rate. While the incidents are increasing and the risks are
increasing, there's really a strong support that's available now at a very reasonable
cost point to get covered and get insured and protected.
Great thoughts as always. And indeed, huge thanks to all of you for your time. We're
recording our Q2 edition a little bit later than usual, so we'll have a quick turnaround
for when you see this panel again. So stay tuned right here on Insurance Business TV.
