A philosopher of science argues the origin of the universe points to something the equations can't contain. Most physicists reach for a multiverse to avoid the conclusion. He thinks that's the tell. Stephen Meyer, Cambridge-trained philosopher of science and director of the Discovery Institute's Center for Science & Culture, on why the fine-tuning problem won't go away. We cover: why "the multiverse" may be a metaphysical escape hatch, not a physical theory, what the beginning of time demands of any honest cosmology, the one thing a designed universe and a random one can't both explain, and where the evidence actually runs out. The hardest question in cosmology isn't what caused the Big Bang. It's why the question refuses to disappear. 00:00 The claim most physicists won't say out loud 01:12 Why the multiverse might be an escape hatch 02:35 What a beginning demands of physics 03:48 Where the evidence actually runs out 📬 Get the transcript, fascinating bonus content, and my Monday M.A.G.I.C. Message: https://briankeating.com/yt 🌠 Have a .edu email and live in the USA 🇺🇸? You automatically win a meteorite: https://BrianKeating.com/edu 🔔 Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/DrBrianKeating?sub_confirmation=1 🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating ⭐ Join this channel for perks, monthly Office Hours, and your name in the Member Roster at the end of every episode: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmXH_moPhfkqCk6S3b9RWuw/join 📚 My books: Losing the Nobel Prize (memoir): http://amzn.to/2sa5UpA Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner: https://a.co/d/03ezQFu Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner: https://a.co/d/hi50U9U Galileo's Dialogue (first-ever audiobook): https://a.co/d/iZPi9Un 🌐 More: 🏄 Twitter: https://twitter.com/BrianKeating 📚 Substack: https://briankeating.substack.com/ss ✍️ Blog: https://briankeating.com/blog 🎙️ Audio-only: https://briankeating.com/podcast
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The discussion explores the philosophical and scientific debate over whether the vastness and complexity of the universe suggest a lack of divine design or, conversely, a creator of immense creativity. The speakers challenge the notion that a God must be \"economical,\" arguing that extravagance does not disprove a designer and that design detection should focus on the presence of an agent rather than the motives behind the design.
The way that's a way that ideas are often tested in philosophy.
You test them by counterexample.
Yeah, and I want to bring up another one because this comes up in the film and I was shocked.
I say shocked Stephen to find you agreeing with noted atheist Sean Carroll.
He once told me that the God hypothesis the least likely of all scientific hypotheses
because God is not a good Theory God God is a weak Theory
and the piece of evidence that he gave was look at all the galaxies in the universe.
There's about probably something like a trillion.
Maybe maybe you know an order of magnitude more certainly not an order of magnitude less
that's known in the observable universe alone.
And then you can fold in the multiverse and his point is that's an awful waste of space
kind of aping Carl Sagan's line in the movie contact
and I push back on him and he didn't really have a good answer.
But but I was kind of surprised to find similar veins of that argument
running through the story of everything.
In other words, look at how special we are.
What's the point of all those galaxies?
Essentially, you're conceding Carol's point like a God should be economical.
He should be parsimonious if he exists,
but he doesn't and so therefore this is sort of capitulating that there's a waste of space.
Now. I say this kind of ingest
but but you do make that in sort of a fine-tuning argument or other people Luke Barnes
and and and others in the film go about this
and justify it from a scientific point of view the the conditions
on Earth had to be just right with Jupiter in this place
in that place.
What's the point of Jupiter as for life on Earth?
So what gives are you moving to Sean Carroll side of things?
Is this is an extravagant universe that that is clearly I don't think waste of space.
I do think it's an extravagance,
but where did we get the idea that God must be something less than extravagant?
We have a whole host of these arguments in evolutionary biology.
Darwin made these God wouldn't have done it that way.
Steven Jay Gould made these God wouldn't have done it that way arguments.
Where did these atheist scientists gain access to the mind of God
to know what he would or wouldn't have done?
It's their mind or though they have access to their own mind.
So they're where are they deriding those predicates in the argument?
But first of all, I got this wrong in return of the God hypothesis
and I think you sorted me out.
I had quoted an earlier figure of 200 billion galaxies
and I was off by at least an order of magnitude though,
you know a paperback we I think we corrected that and it's a trillion,
right? But either way it's it's it's a lot
and here's the other crazy thing.
We didn't even know this until a century ago up until 1924.
They were still debating whether or not the Milky Way with the only
galaxy that's just a mind-blowing thing a new awareness of the human
race the vastness of the universe,
but I think it's just as like from from a theological point of view.
It's just as plausible to say that there are so many galaxies
because God is a God of great creativity and he expresses that
creativity in an extravagant way that gives us a universe to to
Marvel and to wonder at my counter example again to give you more
ammunition perhaps is you know,
you could have made that statement again,
like you said in 1922,
but you could also made it a thousand years ago with respect to the
number of elements.
Yeah, we used to believe there were four elements the smartest man
who ever lived by some opinions Aristotle,
right? So Aristotle believed in the four elements,
right? Which we all know is all there is.
No, of course not.
And so I said to Sean why are there a hundred and sixteen elements,
you know, like aren't most of those extravagant.
We don't use anything above I think ionine in terms of atomic mass
in our bodies like we don't need it.
So is that not extravagant?
But if you had asked that question,
you know, a couple hundred years earlier,
he would have been in a pickle,
right? Because we only knew about,
you know, maybe a half dozen elements in the 18th.
We didn't know about helium until a hundred years ago.
These arguments about what God would or wouldn't have done are very
weak on either side.
Okay, I think they're dispositive.
We do know something about what minds do.
However, we have we have uniform and repeated experience about
about the kinds of things that minds generate and that gives us a
foothold into the larger metaphysical discussion about whether the
universe is the product of a mind or life is the product of a mind
versus undirected material processes.
And this is where I think this these advances in design detection
allow us to make some solid inferences about whether or not life is
designed, whether or not the universe is designed.
We don't know why the designer did what the designer might have done,
but we can at least infer that a designing agent acted. Speculating
about, you know, why someone would do this or that is is inherently
more than deciding whether or not there was a someone. If you look at
the Rosetta Stone, you can see a mind was behind those inscriptions.
Why did the mind include the same message in three different scripts?
We don't really have access to that. Different kind of question.
Right.
And they wrote the most famous four words in human history, please
like and subscribe.
So make sure you do that for Steve's channel for my channel.