Scotland Found the Last 2 of These Trees on Earth — What Botanists Did Next Was Impossible

Flowers and plants
71 followers
5 Video Views·Jul 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe Wentworth elm, a rare ornamental cultivar once thought extinct after the devastating Dutch elm disease epidemic in Britain, was rediscovered in 2016. Two mature specimens were found hiding in plain sight at the Palace of Holyroodhouse in Edinburgh. Through a collaborative propagation effort, these trees have been saved from total extinction.
Sometime in the 1970s, a tree died in Edinburgh. And then another. And then 10,000 more.
By the time the decade was over, the disease-sweeping Britain had killed the majority
of the country's mature elms. Hedgerows that had stood for centuries went grey and bare.
Street after street lost its canopy. Scientists counted the losses in tens of millions.
One variety did not just become rare during those years. It vanished entirely.
The Wentworth elm, a cultivar bred in Germany in the 1880s and given the Latin designation
Ulmus hollandica wentworthi pendula, had never existed in large numbers to begin with.
It was an ornamental tree, valued for its weeping form and large, glossy leaves,
planted in parks and palace grounds rather than hedgerows or forests.
There were never thousands of them. After Dutch elm disease moved through Britain in the 1970s
and into the 1980s, botanists believed the last of them was gone. A single surviving specimen
at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh finally succumbed to the disease in 1996.
That was supposed to be the end of the story. It was not.
In 2016, a tree surveyor walked the grounds of the Palace of Holyroodhouse,
the King's official residence in Edinburgh. He was there for routine work, cataloguing species,
checking specimens. He found what he was not looking for. Standing in plain sight,
less than 100 feet from the palace itself, were two trees he was not supposed to see.
Two Wentworth elm, mature, healthy, and very much alive. They were 30 metres tall,
roughly a century old, photographed by visitors every single week. And nobody had recognised them
for what they were. Dr Max Coleman of the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh put it simply,
Such a discovery, he said, when the trees are 100 feet tall and standing in plain sight,
does sound rather odd. It does. But what happened next is the part worth understanding.
When British scientists confirmed what those two trees were, they did not simply record the finding
and move on. They asked a harder question. Whether there was a way to bring this tree
back from the edge? The answer took years of careful work and the combined effort of
multiple institutions. But the answer, as it turned out, was yes. To understand what made
that so difficult, you need to understand what Dutch elm disease actually did to Britain.
The fungus responsible is called Ophiostoma novo-olmi. It arrived in the United Kingdom
in the late 1960s, carried on imported elm logs from Canada. At first it was not even recognised
as a new pathogen. Scientists initially assumed it was the same, milder fungus that had caused
a smaller elm epidemic in the 1920s. By the time they understood they were dealing with something
different, something far more aggressive, the epidemic was already running. The mechanism of
disease is brutally efficient. Bark beetles bore into weakened or dying elm trees to breed.
When the next generation of beetles emerges in spring, they carry fungal spores on their bodies.
They then fly to healthy elms and feed on the young bark near the tips of branches.
The spores enter the tree's vascular system. The tree responds by trying to seal off the infection,
plugging its own water-carrying vessels with a gum-like material.
But in sealing the wound, the tree starves itself. Water stops moving from roots to canopy.
The branches die from the top down, then the trunk, then the whole tree dies and becomes
breeding ground for the next generation of beetles. The first sign is usually a cluster
of yellowing leaves in the upper canopy during early summer. Within weeks those leaves turn brown
and fall. Shoots die back from the tips, sometimes bending into what foresters call shepherd's crooks.
If you peel back the bark from an affected twig, you find dark streaks running through
the wood beneath, the visible path of the fungus through the tree's own plumbing.
By the time those symptoms are obvious enough to act on, the disease has usually already spread
underground through the shared root systems connecting neighboring trees. An elm hedgerow,
standing one week, gone the next. That was the reality of the 1970s in much of Britain.
Throughout the 1970s, this cycle moved across Britain faster than any control effort could
match. Within a decade, more than 20 million mature elms were dead. By the 1990s, that figure
had probably exceeded 25 million. Estimates of total UK losses since the disease arrived run as
high as 60 million trees. Elm had been the most common tree in many parts of England.
After the epidemic, it was not common anywhere. Scotland fared somewhat better, for reasons of
climate and species composition. The cooler temperatures reduced beetle activity. The
dominant Scottish elm, the witch elm, was less attractive to the beetles that carried the fungus.
And Edinburgh's city council had been running a program of systematic disease surveys and
sanitation felling since the 1980s, identifying and removing infected trees before they could
become beetle breeding sites. As of 2016, approximately 15,000 elms survived in Edinburgh,
a number that would have been far lower without that sustained effort. Dr. Coleman was direct
about it. The only reason those rare elms survived, he said, was almost certainly that
Edinburgh had been surveying and removing diseased elms for decades. Without that program,
many more of the thousands of elms in Edinburgh would have been lost. The Wentworth elms at
Holyroodhouse had almost certainly survived for exactly that reason. And their history is a mystery
with only partial answers. Records at the Royal Botanic Garden. Edinburgh show that three Wentworth
elms arrived at the garden from Germany in 1902. After that, the archive refers to only one tree
remaining at the garden, which finally died in 1996. What happened to the other two? Dr. Coleman's
best theory is that they were transplanted at some point to the palace grounds, possibly during the
early 20th century, when there was a close working relationship between the palace and the garden.
The head gardener at Holyrood at that time had trained at the botanical garden.
There are records of plants moving between the two locations in that period.
No record exists of those two elms going out, but that may simply mean the documentation did
not survive. The mystery of their arrival at the palace may never be fully resolved,
but the fact of their survival almost certainly can be explained. Edinburgh's sustained program
of elm management, running for decades without interruption, created the conditions in which two
unusually rare trees could quietly persist without being destroyed by the same disease
that had killed every other Wentworth elm on the planet. The city did not set out to save the last
specimens of a variety, but by managing its elm population with unusual rigor for decades,
it appears to have done exactly that. When Dr. Coleman arrived to take cuttings,
and found the Wentworth elms instead, the question became what could realistically be done?
Propagating a tree vegetatively, from cuttings rather than seed, is technically demanding work.
The Wentworth elm is a hybrid, and hybrid trees often do not breed true from seed.
Taking cuttings from large, mature specimens, and persuading them to take root and grow,
requires skill, patience, and no small amount of care. The people who set out to do this
knew the stakes. There were two trees left on Earth. If the cuttings failed,
or if disease reached Holyroodhouse before the saplings were established, the variety would be
Multiple teams worked on the propagation in parallel, specifically to reduce that risk.
Horticulturists at the Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh, staff at the Historic Environment
Scotland Gardens Nursery, and teams at the Saville Garden at Windsor Great Park,
all worked from material taken from those two trees. The decision to spread the effort across
institutions was deliberate. Any single site could have a setback. Working in parallel meant
that the loss of one propagation attempt would not end the project. Stuart Lorette,
Head Gardener for the Palace of Holyroodhouse at Historic Environment Scotland,
described what his team did. The elm planted at Holyrood was grafted in March 2021,
using a technique called splice grafting, in which a young shoot from one of the mature
Wentworth elms was joined onto a seedling elm collected from within the palace gardens.
The graft took. The sapling was planted out in March 2024, and it now stands in the grounds of
the palace beside one of the two trees from which it came. Two more saplings were grown at the Royal
Botanic Garden, Edinburgh, before being sent south to the Saville Garden at Windsor Great Park,
and from there to Highgrove, the estate in Gloucestershire managed by His Majesty's charity,
The King's Foundation. The King is patron of the Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh. One of the saplings
was given to him and the Queen as a coronation gift from the people of Scotland in 2023.
He planted it at Highgrove. The intention now is for the Highgrove trees to produce
cuttings of their own, which will be planted back on the Windsor estate and incorporated
into what will eventually become a collection of ancient and veteran trees. A species once reduced
to two individuals is no longer in immediate danger of disappearing, but whether it will ever
be common again is a different question. Dutch elm disease remains active throughout Britain.
Young elms still germinate from the roots of trees lost decades ago, but most succumb before
reaching maturity. The pathogen is still there. The beetles are still there. The Wentworth elm
saplings growing now will need monitoring and care for years to come. What has changed is that
the trees exist at all, and that the people who found them chose to act. There is something worth
sitting with in the detail that these trees were hiding in plain sight for decades. Thousands of
visitors photographed them. Gardeners maintained them. Edinburgh's own arborists almost certainly
walked past them during sanitation surveys. And because Edinburgh had been so diligent about
removing diseased elms throughout the 1980s and the 1990s, the surviving elms in the city
were simply assumed to be the common species that had made it through.
Nobody connected the weeping branches, the large glossy leaves, the distinctive drooping form of
the canopy, to a cultivar bred in Germany in the 1880s that had been declared extinct decades before.
To be precise about what the Wentworth elm looks like, it is a weeping tree, the branches arching
and trailing downward in a habit that made it attractive as an ornamental planting in the late
Victorian and Edwardian periods. The leaves are large and glossy. In spring it puts out clusters
of small red flowers before the leaves open. A handsome tree, conspicuous in any setting.
The two at Holyroodhouse stood nearly 100 feet tall for the better part of a century,
and were admired without anyone realising what they were. It took a botanist with the right
training at the right moment to see what was actually there. That is not a criticism of
anyone who missed them. It is a reminder of how much remains unknown about the living world,
and how much depends on the specific knowledge of particular people in particular places.
Simon Milne, Regius Keeper of the Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh, described the propagation work
as a testament to the skill and dedication of conservation horticulturists across multiple
institutions. That is the formal version. The less formal version is that a handful of people
in Edinburgh decided two trees was not enough, and did the slow, careful, unglamorous work of
making more. There are now at least three Wentworth Elms where there were two. There will
be more if the programme of cuttings at Highgrove proceeds as planned, and the saplings establish
themselves on the Windsor Estate. But there is something simpler underneath all of it.
Someone noticed. Someone acted. And a tree that the world had finished mourning
is now standing in a garden in Edinburgh, with a young sapling growing beside it,
grown from its own branches, planted in the ground three years ago, already putting out
new leaves each spring. The question of whether this variety will be re-established across Britain
in meaningful numbers remains genuinely open. But the question of whether it will survive at all
is no longer what it was in 2016. If this is the kind of story that does not make the evening news,
but probably should, there is another one on screen now.
