They Killed 10,000 Trees To Save An Ancient Forest - Did It Work?

Flowers and plants
71 followers
1 Video View·Oct 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTo restore the biodiversity of Scotland's Caledonian Pine Woods, Planet Wild and Cairngorms Connect implemented a counterintuitive strategy of killing and uprooting trees. One year later, this intervention has successfully broken up monoculture plantations, encouraging the growth of native birch and rowan trees and creating vital habitats for rare wildlife.
I know it sounds backwards, but sometimes you have to kill a few trees in order to save
a forest. And that's exactly what Planet Wild did here just over a year ago. Teaming
up with local foresters, they used some rather unorthodox approaches to kill thousands of
trees. But what I wanted to know is, has it worked? What would success even look like
just one year on? To find out, I headed up to Scotland to see for myself, and what I
found was actually pretty surprising. For this one, we are in the heart of the Abernethy
Nature Reserve, which is one of the largest reserves in Britain, and it's home to unique
and now rare wildlife. But there's a problem here that many do not see. Scotland is missing
almost all of its old-growth forest, the Caledonian Pine Woods. If you know where to look, you
can find fragments barely holding on throughout the country. And despite now being small,
these are still magical places, rich with native trees like birch and rowan, and of
course, Scots Pine of all ages, from the gnarly old granny pines to the young saplings
who are coming up around them. Caledonian Pine Forest has declined by 99% of its original
range. It's a huge loss. But the unsuspecting problem is that while much of Scotland is
now forested, it's the wrong trees. Here at Abernethy, thankfully, the dominant tree cover
is the native Scots Pine, and not the non-native Sitka Spruce, which has become so prevalent
throughout the country. But even here, things still aren't quite right, because the Scots
Pine that make up these woods are in fact plantations. They are monocultures. A single
age, a single structure, a single species. This lack of diversity is terrible for biodiversity.
And so, one year ago, Planet Wild partnered up with Cairngorms Connect and began shaking
up the forest here. Or should I say, pulling down the forest. Using chains and a winch,
trees were uprooted and pulled down to the ground. This intervention simulates the damage
of a violent storm which would sweep through and wipe out a whole host of trees. But other
trees were left standing. But they didn't make it out unscathed. Hundreds were killed
through a process known as ring barking, where the bark is removed around the circumference
of the stem. Now, I know this might still all sound a bit barbaric and a little counterintuitive
when it comes to protecting and restoring nature, but this, this is exactly what this
forest needed. And now, one year on, let's see what's happened. Let's join Fraser and
head to the exact location of Planet Wild's project. This is where we need a capper just
to be asleep. Yeah, we're not likely to get one here, but this is fantastic. This was
only done, when was the Planet Wild filming done? It was a couple of years ago? Yeah,
I mean, I think it was last year. I mean, that's when the video came out. So what are
saying? Birch trees, dozens of birch trees, young pine tree, another young pine tree,
more young birches, more pine. The region in here, if you look through here, there's
nothing. There's only this one age class of planted trees. There's no other ages
or other species of trees. But here, where we've done this winching, we've got young
trees, we've got birch trees. And birch trees, the sign we've really struggled with in the
past, because they're much more palatable to deer. To me, that's success. Small wins,
but it's, you know, as we were saying, this is year one of a never-ending process, right?
This is the thing we have to remember. Look at the lichens on that bit of deadwood there,
and mushrooms. Do you know your lichens? No, I don't. They have some pretty superb names,
but I can't store that sort of stuff. I'm going to call this a fairy's cup. There we go. Fairy's
cup. You know, if you say it confidently enough, no one's getting a question. Some areas like in
America, Canada, you'll get beetles will move in, and they'll kill like a patch of trees,
creating a stand of deadwood. So in some areas we replicate that by ring-barking a whole load of
trees together. Under the bark of the insects, it's fantastic. That's just from all the deadwood,
and you see all the holes in as well. The progression of the deadwood as it goes through
its life, and then you've got fungus coming out of it as well. Once it's dead, it's only
just started. That's it, that's it. Yeah, this is what we forget is dead is sometimes better than
alive. Look at that. Oh yeah, already, look at that coming up. All that burnt tree gin,
that is fantastic. Like, like that is really superb. For us on the reserve, we were so
predominantly just pine, but we strongly suspect there should be a much more mixture of pine and
birch. To see this starting so quickly, it's fantastic. Fraser's seen something else he likes
over here. All the birch, I'm just, I'm blown away with just all this birch tree gin. But yeah,
that's fantastic. And so quickly, so quick. This is accelerating a natural process, like we could
wait for a storm event to come through, but when is that going to happen? And we don't have the
time now, do we? No, I mean, that's one thing here, it's because our Scots pine forests are
actually really quite resilient to wind events, so we don't get a lot of this naturally. Storm Amy
that we just had, did push over some trees on the reserve, which has been fantastic. It's
saved us a bit of money and it's done things naturally, but a lot of places, we still need
to come in and intervene. So as you can see, this project, it's, it's working. You know, it's only
been a year, but we're able to see new life coming up. Look here, look, look, one of my favourite
trees. Look at this, look. Here we have a beautiful red rowan. This work without Planet Wild,
it wouldn't have happened. And so often with nature restoration, there are brilliant people,
brilliant projects, but they just need the extra funding. And that's what Planet Wild offers. If
you're still not sure about who Planet Wild are, then I recommend going and checking out their
YouTube channel, where they make a video about each of their missions, whether it's protecting
oceans, bringing back endangered species, or like in this case, restoring forests. These missions,
they are all over the world. And that's what I really like about Planet Wild and why I became
a member too, is because of the sheer diversity. You kind of never know what's coming next,
but you always know that it's going to be impactful. And there's now well over 13,000
Planet Wild members globally. That's the beautiful thing about this. Anyone from anywhere can join
this community and you can give whatever you can. That's the key here, because when like-minded
people come together, you can have a real impact and stuff like this can happen. And if you do want
to become a Planet Wild member, I've got a special offer for you. The first 100 people to use the
If you do that, you'll get your first month of membership for free, so you can start
helping nature right now. Yeah, we've got the kind of birch coming into the sort of bare ground here,
but you were saying that these areas in here, this is perfect for the capercaillie, right?
Yeah. So during the summer, they quite often get mites in their feathers and they like to come
into these places where they've got fine sort of grout. Oh, look at that. See, that's perfect.
A capercaillie would go in there and it would dust bath. It would get in and it would shuggle
itself down into all that dry, sandy material and try and get rid of its mites by dust bathing them
off. And sometimes they'll come in, like the hen will come in with the chicks and then they'll all
be dust bathing under these root plates. And they'll go into places like that as well, where
it'd be super dry for them to dust bath. So yeah, the root plates are really important. And then
also, yeah, the bits of grit, you know, they'll come along and they'll eat little bits of grit
like that in winter time to fill their crop. So there's some places where we're specifically
winching trees to create root plates to keep capercaillie off tracks, because quite often
they're going to tracks and paths to get these tiny bits of grit to help them digest the pine
needles. And that brings them into conflict with people and dog walkers and cyclists and cars.
So if we can keep the capercaillie away from tracks and paths and people, they're happier.
They're less likely to, you know, come to harm. And then they can just stay in the woods and be safe.
Yeah, yeah, we're just sort of looking at all the bird life, crested tits, right?
Yeah. Just saying, like, woodpeckers coming in and you wouldn't get woodpeckers without the dead
wood, would you? No, they would have no food source and nowhere to burrow a hole. So yeah,
so yeah, a great spotted woodpecker just flew in, flew in through this winch patch and then
landed in one of the dead trees through there. So just satisfied to see and know that we're doing
work, help, we're trying to help everything. Yeah, it's just, it's just the little things
like that, which really affirm that you're doing the right thing. You know,
the awesome thing about nature restoration is that it can take so many different forms.
Sometimes it's about winching over and simulating a storm and, you know, ring barking a few trees
just to create that diversity and bring life back. If you want to keep watching the channel,
then check out this video here. But in the meantime, thanks for watching. Leave curious.
