Property risk, Resilience, and the Road Ahead

Business Insurance
4 followers
4 Video Views·Jun 27, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedIndustry experts analyze the shift in property insurance toward granular, data-driven risk assessment and the critical issue of under-insurance caused by inflation. The discussion emphasizes a transition in the broker's role from a transactional intermediary to a strategic risk advisor focused on client resilience and long-term insurability.
The more precisely insurers comprise the risk, the less the insurance pool actually spreads it.
The consequences of being underinsured are a lot more real for many clients.
Where it used to be about a 5% adjustment or a 5% gap, we're now seeing about a 25 to 30% leap.
Hello and welcome to Insurance Business TV for what is, for now at least,
our final property insurance power panel. We're going to have a final deep dive unpacking the
property market shifts of the last 18 months, some challenging placements,
and where our panel has seen innovation that's helping their work. Our brokers are back.
Melissa Jolly, Managing Director of Pinnacle Insurance Brokers in Perth, is with us.
Jody Geraghty, Account Manager, Corporate Risk and Broking, Property and Casualty with WTW,
is also here. And Martin Birch, Principal of Agrisurance in Sydney, also joins us.
Hi everyone, and welcome back for one last time. It's nice to have you all on board.
Let's start with you, Martin, and looking back over the last 12 to 18 months,
what are a couple of the biggest shifts in property insurance risk for your clients, do you think?
Greetings, Danny, and greetings to the fellow panel members. The biggest shift in recent time,
not necessarily just 18 months or so, but it's a gradual move towards more granular risk assessment.
On this panel, we're not really focused on residential buildings or the home market per
se, more SME corporate, but nevertheless, the market is moving away from broad regional pricing
towards a much more individualised risk assessment. I suppose that the reasons include the
insurance affordability problem, that's pricing and capacity concerns. But possibly the biggest
of all is technology, more satellite surveillance, more connected data, more smart apps,
weather related tools, and so on. It's all facilitating a gradual move towards
more granularity in risk assessment. Insurance is traditionally operated on a pooled
community risk, community pricing and so on. So it's spreading the losses of the few across the
many. But it seems this inevitable outcome is that technology and all this data capability is
really facilitating driving this more granular risk assessment and individualised pricing.
So the irony to me is just that the more precisely insurers can price the risk,
the less the insurance pool actually spreads it. So that seems to create a tension between
this actuarial precision and the more traditional social utility of insurance. It's a real
conundrum. But just one more thing is that part of the shift is definitely that underwriters are
increasingly looking at not just the property itself anymore, but they're also starting to
look at the resilience profile of the insured business. And that, again, it's just more granular
risk assessment. A company with strong governance, maintenance and business continuity
and recovery capability just increasingly presents a better ISR risk because it is more likely to
minimise the financial loss covering Section 2 of the BI exposure, simply because the business
can bounce back quicker. So that's my take. Thank you, Martin. That was great with those
conundrums, ironies and all that data coming in. Jodie, moving to you, where are you seeing the
big shifts over the last year or two? Look, from a bit of a different perspective,
although I agree with Martin, one of the biggest changes I've really noticed is that much more
sharper focus on the under-insurance, especially where the replacement values and business
interruption periods are actually fit for purpose. It's not a new issue, but over the last
12 to 18 months, it's definitely come to the surface more. Your rising construction costs,
ongoing material and labour shortages, your supply chain delays and general inflation have all pushed
the rebuild cost higher and stretched out how long things take to get back up and running.
That's made the consequences of being under-insured a lot more real for many clients.
As a result of that, brokers have needed to be far more proactive in educating clients
on the consequences of under-insurance and helping them address it. That's included encouraging more
professional building valuations for commercial risks and for individual clients that the use
of valid online calculators. So the role of the broker has increasingly shifted from a placement
focused to an advisory, ensuring clients understand not just the premium impacts,
but the real risk exposure they face at claim time.
Great. Thank you, Jodie. And Melissa, coming to you,
how are you seeing things over there in Western Australia?
So I've actually got a similar response to Jodie. It's definitely under-insurance over
here in WA. It's driven a lot by the surging construction costs that we're seeing over here,
and it's creating a massive disconnect between traditional sum-insured values and the actual
replacement costs, which, of course, we don't see that until it's claims time and
people have to experience that, unfortunately. So where it used to be about a 5% adjustment
or a 5% gap, we're now seeing about a 25% to 30% leap. Half of that is labour shortages,
but it's also the material price hikes. Another thing we're noticing or have noticed,
and I loved our previous panel discussion, it was based on those lithium-ion batteries
and the ignition density. So we've pivoted from seeing batteries as like a tech novelty and
nice to have or an add-on. It's actually becoming now a primary fire peril and something that
insurers are having to factor into their underwriting a lot more. The shift has come
from a total fire risk to specific charging hygiene, also the way things are installed,
et cetera, especially in the strata and commercial warehouse sectors.
Thank you, Melissa. And we'll stick with you for our next question.
And some of what you've all said will probably bleed into this one because
the issues do cross over somewhat. But if you're looking at the property placements you've done
in the last year or so, what do they reveal about where the market is actually failing
and what realistically can be changed to deal with that? Melissa?
So WA, we're a big state over here, so there's a lot from north to south and everywhere in between.
In general, it's a bit of a square peg round hole situation with some of these more regional
businesses or properties. The market is failing a little bit with the mixed-use strata
and anything regional WA assets. There's a bit of a lack of risk appetite for properties in
these areas that don't fit the perfect algorithmic box. We know insurers have guidelines that they
need to follow, but it doesn't help for people sitting, I guess, on the fringe of those. And it,
in turn, forces our clients into expensive, potentially restrictive Lloyds placements.
So that's a tricky one that we're still navigating. What needs to change? Similar to what
Martin was saying originally, it's that more granular underwriting. So realistically, we do
need insurers to stop redlining entire postcodes, just writing off a whole postcode because it might
be bushfire-prone or flood-prone, or industries, certain sectors that they just won't touch.
We would really like to see them start rewarding clients who invest in physical resilience.
There are certain things like thermal imaging for switchboards, which some people have been
very proactive about, which is positive, and also formal battery management policy. So again,
changing the risk, encouraging clients to do that and rewarding them.
Thanks, Melissa. And Martin, what about you when you think about challenging placements
in the market at the moment? Where is the market failing and what realistically can be changed?
Danny, my contribution on this point is perhaps a little bit off-centre in that I don't see
market failure per se as a big red flag, just in my experience. I've found that the greater
difficulty in the value chain is with clients who are not on the same track in terms of the
current insurance market. Old is not necessarily a problem, but in poor maintenance, poor condition,
clients with high risks, with no apparent willingness to embrace a risk management
paradigm, I think they find themselves on the periphery of insurability because I do think the
market is changing. So that's not market failure, it's that certain property owners are just not
meeting the market. I think it's just reality. So again, I just don't see pure market failure as
such in terms of difficult placement. It seems to me the change in the expectations of some insurers
is a bigger issue, not the insurers. And that's just a general observation on my side. I think the
willingness to embrace a risk management paradigm is, there's a new narrative I think you'd tell
and that's just resilience, business resilience. That's my take on it.
Thanks, Martin. And you mentioned change and innovation is creating a lot of change in the
market right now. I'm wondering, Jodie, where have you seen brokers and insurers innovating
and collaborating particularly well in recent months?
Yeah, look, I should caveat this, I guess, by saying that I primarily work in the corporate
space. So my experience may differ from those working with the SME or personal lines.
But one area where I'm starting to see positive change, granted not on every risk,
is the way both brokers and insurers are leaning more heavily on the data and analytics. So there
is far less reliance on the assumptions or the broad market views and more focus on the actual
facts of a client's risk profile, which leads to more informed underwriting and better outcomes
overall. I've also seen strong results where there's genuine collaboration between brokers
and insurers during placement or renewal. So when insurers are given the chance to hear directly
from clients through presentations to understand their risks, the improvements that they've made
and their broader risk journey, it tends to create far better alignment. Those conversations often
lead to more constructive underwriting discussions and ultimately better terms for the client.
When everyone's working from the same information, all parties that are involved win.
And Martin, over to you, where are you seeing insurers and brokers collaborating well?
Dan, if you take a high level helicopter view, I think the market is gradually shifting from
simply transferring risk to actively reducing risk. That may well be the modern insurance story
in a sentence. One of the most encouraging developments has been the move towards genuine
public and private sector collaboration. We've spoken about this before on the panel.
So initiatives like the Hazards Insurance Partnership, the Disaster Ready Fund,
they reflect a broader recognition that insurance affordability cannot be solved by insurance alone
or insurers alone, sorry. What we are now seeing is a coordinated investment in high
mitigation infrastructure. Again, this has come up before in the panel. So
building levies, flood retention, resilient public assets, retrofitting, because ultimately
the most sustainable way to reduce premiums is to reduce the underlying risk itself. And that's
the kind of collaboration that will improve the capacity and pricing problems that we've got.
And Melissa, where are you seeing positive signs of collaboration?
I think we're in a really exciting period where people are using technology to their advantage.
And so I think the best innovation at the moment is encouraging our clients to work with insurers
and go from a reactive to more proactive in terms of property maintenance and assessing risk, etc.
So they can use IoT sensors, they can use water leak detection, anything like that in commercial
buildings just to try and prevent the losses from happening before they do. It's also really
great with all this technology, we have a lot more data that we can kind of set up pre-renewal
strategy sessions with both our clients and our insurers, meet months in advance and see where
the risks are. And we can try and put together an actual risk improvement plan. We might identify
if they've got asbestos, okay, when is the plan to potentially replace that, if there's cladding,
if there's all sorts of things such as that, instead of just doing a last minute broking,
actually put a plan in place so that insurers feel comfortable that our client is ready to
take on that risk mitigation and work together. Thank you, Melissa. And this is the final question
coming your way from possibly the final ever property panel. And so I'm going to ask,
it's a slightly cliche journalistic question, but it often extracts a good answer. I'm interested if
each of you had one message to brokers about how they should approach property risk, resilience
and insurance over the next five years. What would that one message be? Melissa, you start in the hot
seat. Yes, well, I'd just like to take this opportunity to say thank you very much for
having me on the property panel. It has been wonderful. And to my other panellists, it's
been great to know you both. I'd say for brokers over the next five years, things are going to
change. So be proactive, not reactive. Insurance policies aren't going to be set and forget. We are
going to have to stay on top of them year on year. So try to stop being, have a more transactional
approach to it and be a bit more of a risk architect. So really think what could go wrong
for your clients and really work with them to get that better result.
The focus should always be on resilience over the premium. So let's try and build this profile
that's really good and really insurers want to actually write the risk. Better maintenance,
better documentation, different things like that. So yeah, just working together with
your clients to make their risk profile better. Thank you, Melissa. And Jodie, what's your
message? Yeah, look, to start with, on a similar vein to Melissa, thank you so much for having me
on the property panel. It's been wonderful. And I've enjoyed also getting the perspectives from
around the country. But if I had to leave brokers with one message, it would be to enjoy the
softening market, but don't waste it. Similar to Melissa, use this period to help clients strengthen
their position, not just from an insurance perspective, but in terms of risk mitigation,
resilience, processes, and overall understanding of their exposure. We know the market is
a cyclic. And so while things feel more favourable right now, history tells us that it will change
again. At the same time, brokers should really focus on the fundamentals, particularly the
quality of information we're putting in front of insurers. Strong, well-articulated submissions
matter more than ever. If insurers are left to make assumptions about a risk,
those assumptions are rarely leaned towards the best case scenario. The more clearly we can tell
a client's risk story and demonstrate how it's being managed, the better position that client
will be regardless of where the market goes next. Great. Thank you, Jodie. And Martin, you get the
last word. Wow. Those last two segments by Melissa and Jodie were fantastic. I agree that there is
change occurring. So my thoughts are that over the next five years, the real value of a broker
will increasingly lie in helping clients become more resilient, more prepared, and ultimately
more insurable. The profession is evolving from insurance intermediary to strategic risk advisor,
and in an increasingly automated and data-driven market, trusted advice and advocacy is going to
matter more than ever. So our clients who fail to adapt to this changing risk landscape may
progressively find themselves moving towards the margins of insurability. In summary,
if you create a table with key themes and takeaways, it might look a little bit like this.
A theme would be a move to granular underwriting, and the possible takeaway is that's structural
market evolution. If the next theme is the rise in secondary perils, these perils are now having
mainstream capacity pressure and pricing impact. If a theme is data and modelling,
the takeaway is access to high-tech precision tools is changing insurable behaviour.
If you have a look at the theme of the resilience narrative, I think a core insurability driver
for the future is what the takeaway is there. If we look at a theme of government collaboration,
then the takeaway is that these necessary systemic responses to the whole of the economy paradigm
is a great takeaway, and it's happening. If we look at a theme of broker evolution,
the takeaway is strategic advisory role. And the insurance affordability story,
I think the takeaway is a structural shift to a resilience narrative.
That's me. It's been fantastic. It's been great to meet Melissa and Jodie and yourself,
Daddy, and thank you very much for inviting me onto the panel. It's been a great journey.
Well, thanks, Martin, and thanks, Jodie. Thanks, Melissa. From my perspective,
these discussions have been a rare mixture of fun and information,
so thanks again, and thank you for watching Insurance Business TV. Bye for now.
