Commercial fleet risk in 2026: What insurers are watching

Business Insurance
4 followers
6 Video Views·Jun 20, 2026
Featuring Lee Sherback of HUB International, Shaylee Nowicki of Purves Redmond Limited, and Tyler Orlecki of Navacord.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedIndustry experts analyze the Canadian motor and fleet insurance market, highlighting challenges like extended vehicle replacement cycles, driver shortages, and regulatory complexity. The discussion emphasizes the need for active safety enforcement and the transition of insurance brokers from generalists to specialized strategic advisors to manage volatility and risk.
The biggest problem is, you know, Canadian fleets want to make sure they exist.
If you aren't enforcing the rules that you have on paper, you're still high risk.
Hello everyone, welcome to Insurance Business TV and our second ever Motor and Fleet panel. Yes,
this group who met for the first time early this year have been brave enough to return and share
their market knowledge with us, so let's meet them again. They are Shaylee Nowicki, she is
Senior Broker at Perves Redmond. Tyler Orlecki, Partner and Senior Risk Advisor, Transportation
and Energy at Navicord. And Lee Sherbak, Senior Vice President, National Transportation and Energy
Practices at Club International. So welcome all, and with supply chain pressures easing slightly,
but vehicle availability still uneven across Canada, I want to know how are fleet operators
replacement cycles and vehicle mix decisions influencing underwriting and risk selection
now in 2026? Tyler, any thoughts on this? Thanks Paul. Yeah, I'm finding that clients are
running vehicles longer. They're going past what their previous ownership cycles would be if they
were running them for three years. They're looking more at a five-year interval. They're also looking
to bring some of the maintenance in-house, and then I'm seeing more buybacks on the claim side,
just for pure parts sourcing. The other trend that I'm seeing is all-in leases are becoming
more and more common across my book of business, so that means that clients are buying a lease
that includes all of the anticipated maintenance and servicing included, and that is just purely
for a cost certainty aspect to their business. So we're seeing different approaches or some
combination all three, but clients are adapting most certainly. Okay, so would you agree with
that Shaili, that clients are trying to keep the vehicles for longer now? Absolutely. I'm also
finding maybe when their pickups are, the lease is expiring, instead of releasing a pickup for
managers and supervisors, they're more going for hybrid models or electric vehicles, cars mostly
over the pickups just to save fuel costs and just overall costs to save money for their company.
Yeah, and I imagine that the complexity of these fleets, Lee, as well is another consideration.
Yeah, I mean cost control has become a dominant priority for the transportation space, especially
with tariffs involved and new technology and vehicles. So what you're seeing is a lot of
mixed fleets whereby they may not have the technology in all the units anymore. You've
got hybrids, you've got EV opportunities in both light, medium and heavy vehicles.
So the schedules are starting to look a little messier, maintenance becomes a little messier at
times, but it all comes back to survivability. And these guys are looking to do what they can
to make sure that they can survive the next cycle, so to speak. And that may be through
changing the laws where different jurisdictions are required to run cleaner vehicles.
And so they're taking shortcuts in Canada where we don't have the same
complexity in that as our US counterparts. So the biggest problem is that Canadian fleets want to
make sure they exist. And if they have to run maintenance on a vehicle that's 10 years old,
where they normally cycle them out in five, they're going to do that because they need that
cost certainty in place for themselves and they can't always afford the new vehicle with all the
fancy technology. Another change that we've seen is the persistent issue now around driver
shortages. So Shaley, from your perspective, how is this labour challenge translating into risk,
I suppose, particularly in terms of driver quality, training, fatigue, and indeed,
how are insurers responding from both an underwriting and a risk management perspective?
Unfortunately, clients are being forced to hire younger, inexperienced drivers or
making their current drivers work harder, which is causing fatigue, driver burnout.
Then you've got the less experienced drivers who their losses seem to be more of a severe nature
because they just don't know how to react to certain situations because they just haven't
had the experience or the training. Is that something that you're seeing as well,
Tyler, that drivers are perhaps being graduated a little bit too quickly?
Absolutely. I'm finding that as the driving population continues to age, new drivers
are being graduated sooner and faster and definitely being pushed into positions
earlier than they would have in the past. In addition to that, mentorship and lead drivers
call it. They're harder to come by and there is less of them just due to that demographic
aging out of the workforce. Then with the workforce changing demographic,
companies are definitely reviewing their logistics and operations. I've seen some
companies going to more of a regional model so that drivers can be at home every night with
their families as the younger generation doesn't want to be on the road every day, it seems.
From an insurer standpoint, we are seeing them start to recognize this trend and they understand
that for the stability of industry that they need to get on board with these younger drivers. I am
seeing increased comfort, but that comes with them trying to get in front of fleets in person
and try to figure out what their defensibility exactly is. If they feel that there's an aspect
of the defensibility that these companies are bringing to the table, then they are definitely
more likely to work with them moving forward. From an insurance and risk management standpoint,
we are seeing positive developments there for fleets that are bringing good safety and risk
management and compliance practices to the table. Lee, from your perspective, are we seeing any
differences in the demographic of drivers today? The driver demographic is substantially broader
than it was in the past. Drivers are operating at older ages and then you have the younger guys.
We're seeing fleets with guys 60, 70 years old and bringing in the 20-year-old. We're
seeing that in the management space too. As you get that turnover, the knowledge transfer isn't
the same as it used to be. That creates other internal issues from both the carrier standpoint
as well as the insurer standpoint. In addition to that, the way we train people of the different
generations, as we all know, is substantially different. You can't yell and scream at
everybody the way we're all raised. It's creating all kinds of issues for the carriers and the
insurers to their part are doing what they can to help mitigate and coach. At the end of the day,
it makes it a much harder risk to quantify when you have such a varying range with carriers and
their employers. Something that we're all trying to avoid yelling and screaming about right now is
these different regulatory changes across all of the provinces, from safety compliance to
emission standards. How are evolving regulations shaping fleet risk profiles right now? Are they
creating any new exposures that insurers need to account for? We have everything from various
ELD compliances to greenhouse gas emissions regulations in different jurisdictions. Then you
have insurance laws being changed in different jurisdictions as well. We're learning to, as
brokers, educate our clients more, become more teachers, sometimes a set of advisors. We're
educating them. They'll pick on Ontario with their upcoming changes. There's a lot of data there that
now, as a broker, you have to be aware of. To do our job as an advisor, we have to advise those
clients of those changes and make sure we're walking through the steps to ensure adequacy
of coverage. It's not as simple as just accident benefits is required and included anymore. We're
having a lot more discussion there. Then obviously in January 2027, we're having to have additional
discussion on the Alberta side with the changes to the Alberta Insurance Act. It really becomes a lot
more incumbent on the broker to be in front of their clients, have a communication, and making
sure that there's valid training that we're sharing with our clients. I imagine as well,
Tyler, that it's just getting harder to keep up to date with all of these changes, isn't it?
Yeah, to Lee's point there, Paul, it definitely is becoming harder to stay up to date. But I think
from the broker perspective, this is where your advisor as a sector specialist carries their weight
in gold. I think that the days of general brokers in specific areas of the industry,
transportation and cyber easily come to mind. I think that those are slowly going away
because there's just simply too much changing too fast for any one person to know everything
in every different industry. So I think that as an advisor goes, the role of the broker is
definitely going to have to become more and more specialized. And the people that truly want to be
in the auto and fleet specialty are going to have to be very knowledgeable on the regulation, not
just in Alberta, but across Canada as it is changing quickly and vastly across the board.
On the client-facing side, I feel that clients are a little bit gun-shy just because of the
amount of change going on, whether it's regulatory or statutory or political in nature. But
everything from EVs and alternative fuel sources, these bring on a whole different layer
of complexity as well as costs, and it's uncertain. And in the prior questions, we really
talked about uncertainty and cost certainty. This makes it a little bit harder on the client. So
I think that they're really just looking to have a path forward. They might dip their toe
in the water on some of this, but at the end of the day, they have to protect their bottom line.
So until there's more definitive direction coming from the government and the political side,
I don't think that the adoption will go too much higher than what we're seeing right now
on some of these alternative fuel sources and whatnot. That's a good point that Tyler's just
raised there, Shaley, isn't it? There is a real push as well for clients to change over their
fleets to electric vehicles, for example. There sure is. But what I find is infrastructure
developing at that rate in which clients are buying these vehicles. Charging stations,
for example. The other thing that's a little bit scary and clients are asking about is
cyber. Now, cyber is actually a risk for auto. You know, hackers getting in and taking over
vehicles. Could this happen? How do we stop it? And if they do, can you imagine the losses?
So cyber, we got to look at cyber. Hopefully, in the future, we'll probably see cyber being an
add-on to auto policies. Now, let's continue that theme about
risk a little bit if we can. Just looking at portfolio performance, where are you seeing the
biggest disconnect today between perceived and actual risk in commercial motor? And Tyler,
if I start with you, how are you addressing that gap with brokers and insureds?
Absolutely, Paul. One of the biggest gaps that we're seeing over at Navacore is
basically the theme of this whole discussion. It comes down to drivers. And yeah, we can get
drivers onboarded and approved, but when you have major claims and events happening, it's
behind-the-scenes risk management and what they're doing to follow their safety and
maintenance protocols in order to avoid nuclear verdicts and remain defensible from their insurance
company. I always say to clients that when there's a claim that happens, it's not the small
claims that the insurance company worries about. It's the big claims when the lawyers get involved.
And from my position, it's making sure that what's actually on the paper is what's
actually happening in that company on a day-to-day basis so that they are defensible when major
claims do happen. So that's one of the major gaps that I am seeing. The other one is the
market conditions. If I was a client in this market, I would probably be pretty confused
because it's almost like the Alberta weather. One day, it's as hard as hard can be, and
you're just hoping for a single-digit rate increase, and then the next year, premiums are going down
8% to 12%, maybe sometimes more. For clients, that's confusing. But again, another common
dialogue on this entire interview has been the role of the advisor and the broker and just having
open channels of communication with your clients. We've seen clients get a little bit
comfortable in soft market conditions, and then that comes back later when the market changes,
if they're putting the wrong type of claims through, where they get those huge rate increases
and whatnot. So I think that the role of the broker in both market conditions is extremely
important in that, as a broker in the industry, we should not be taking our finger off the pulse
of what's going on and just remembering that the market can change at any given chance,
and that the work we're doing today is what's going to set our clients up for success in the
future, irregardless of what's going on in the larger market picture. Yeah, that role of the
broker really is vital, isn't it, Shaylee, especially when it comes to safety protocols,
as Tyler mentioned? Yes. More and more clients are asking us to help out with their safety,
manual safety protocols. But just to add on to what Tyler said, if you can look great on paper,
and you can have all these safety protocols in place, but if you aren't adhering to them,
if you aren't engaging with them, what's the point? When you have the telematics,
are you reviewing the reports? Are you reviewing those reports with the drivers that are showing up
as having the bad behavior? This is going to be loss prevention. So if you aren't enforcing the
rules that you have on paper, you're still high risk. You're not being risk-focused to ensure
your premiums remain steady. Awesome. Good points, both from Tyler and Shaylee. Lee,
do you agree with that? Yeah, 100%. I think this is a situation where clients are busy
managing their operations. There's a lot of different fixtures that they got to pay attention
to. And they're not always focused on reforming their fleet to new specifications or new compliance
regulations. So it really allows an opportunity for the broker to get in front of them as an
advisor, to speak about underwriting risks, to speak about compliance gaps, and do some
mapping with clients in that situation, which again, is going to help the stronger fleets
continue to be better and hopefully bring out the bottom fleets into a more prominent position
within the sector. So it's one there that, especially those pre-renewal and midterm
conversations, can help put the clients on much firmer ground going into the renewal cycle,
with clear identity of where the exposures are, what changes are being made, because it does take,
as we all know, 12 to 24 months to really notice any significant change. But it's being able to
have that communication with the underwriting team and put your client in that best position
for a move forward, not only from an insurance standpoint, but also from a regulatory compliance
standpoint. So another excellent panel. Huge thanks to everyone for your time. And of course,
to everyone watching, this group will be back in Q3, but until then, keep it right here
at Insurance Business TV.
