Did King Arthur Actually Exist? The Evidence Behind The Legend

What Was The Life
13 followers
23 Video Views·Jun 17, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
In that time, the Saxons strengthened in multitude and grew in Britain.
On the death of Hengist, Ogtha his son passed from the northern part of Britain to the kingdom of the Kentishmen.
And from him arose the kings of the Kentishmen.
Then Arthur fought against them in those days with the kings of the Britons.
But he himself was leader of the battles.
Through fourteen centuries, the shadowy but powerful figure of Arthur has been distorted by poets, chroniclers, politicians and kings.
The image has been used for entertainment and even propaganda.
From a Romano-British warlord fighting the Saxon invaders, he had been turned, in an ironic twist, into the most English of kings, epitomising the full flowering of medieval chivalry.
So there are two Arthurs.
The armour-plated king enthroned in Camelot at his round table, surrounded by goodly knights and fair ladies, dispensing justice and defending the weak and oppressed.
And the real Arthur, a military commander, a capable strategist and diplomat, as he would have needed to be in such turbulent times.
It's possible he may not even have been of noble birth, making it easier for him to stand aside from the tribal differences and the squabbles of petty kingdoms.
He was instead a man who could command a large, highly mobile force of cavalry and infantry, crossing all tribal frontiers, making all territories his battlefield against the Saxon foe.
After the death of Uther Pendragon, the leaders of the Britons assembled from their various provinces in the town of Silchester,
and there suggested to Debrisius, the archbishop of the city of the legions, that as their king, he should crown Arthur the son of Uther.
Necessity urged them on, for as soon as the Saxons heard of the death of Uther, they invited their own countrymen over from Germany,
appointed Colgryn as their leader and began to do their utmost to exterminate the Britons.
They had already overrun all that section of the island which stretches from the river Humber to the sea named Caithness.
Debrisius lamented the sad state of his country. He called the other bishops to him and bestowed the crown of the kingdom upon Arthur.
Arthur was a young man, only fifteen years old. He was of outstanding courage and generosity, and his inborn goodness gave him such grace that he was loved by almost all the people.
But how could this highly successful British general have become the fanciful king of medieval legend?
The answer lies partly with Geoffrey of Monmouth, a Welsh cleric of Breton descent, who was responsible for bringing Arthur to a wider audience by writing his History of the Kings of Britain in 1136.
This work, properly titled the Historia Regum Britannia, was written in Latin and can be fairly described as one of the most influential books on Arthur.
Well, Geoffrey of Monmouth was a fibber, I'm afraid, as his name betrays. He was a monk at Monmouth and then he moved to Oxford.
And he was so keen on the Arthurian story that he was actually nicknamed Arthur, Geoffrey Arthur, and he was a real Arthur fanatic.
And he wrote this book, which was published in the sense that manuscript editions were published, in 1139.
And he gives you conversations between prehistoric monarchs from what would have been the Bronze Age or the early Iron Age, and every adventure, and in every age he knows what's going on.
But it's a marvellous read, and that's what made it perhaps the greatest bestseller of the Middle Ages.
And I think he was doing the job, a fair job, as he saw it.
You do sense a twinkle in his eye when you're reading it.
At one point he says that an eagle on the walls of Gloucester uttered a prophecy, he said, which I would tell you if I believed it was true.
Well, later on he goes and tells you, so I don't think he cared if you believed or not.
And he may have been surprised at the extent to which people believed it.
Geoffrey's history of the kings of Britain might have seemed, on the face of it, a serious attempt to record British history, and more particularly, to portray an accurate picture of Arthur, drawn from many reliable sources.
After all, Geoffrey was a churchman who had received an excellent education for his time.
But it would seem that Geoffrey entered the church in order to further his literary ambitions, and not because of any religious zeal.
Having no recognised archaeological authorities to hold him in check, Geoffrey was free to create an Arthur in the image of his own royal patrons.
Whenever I have chance to think about the history of the kings of Britain, on those occasions when I have been turning over a great many such matters in my mind,
it has seemed a remarkable thing to me that, apart from such mention of them as Gilders and Bede had each made in a brilliant book on the subject,
I have not been able to discover anything at all on the kings who lived here before the incarnation of Christ.
Or, indeed, about Arthur, and all the others who followed on after the incarnation.
The deeds of these men were such that they deserved to be praised for all time.
What is more, these deeds were handed joyfully down in oral tradition,
just as if they had been committed to writing by many peoples who had only their memory to rely on.
Geoffrey obviously felt little or no need to depict Arthur as he'd encountered him in the writings of the 8th century chronicler Nennius.
Thus, his Arthur dresses and acts exactly as a 12th century monarch,
and his descriptions of warfare and the social scene are based on his own experience.
Geoffrey's intention, as far as we can tell, was not to deceive, but to entertain.
He was as enthralled by the enigma of Arthur as many before him had been.
With true Celtic exaggeration, he romanticised Arthur in a way that had never before been so blatant or so successful.
That success was to spark off the development of a legendary Arthur.
At a time when I was giving a good deal of attention to such matters,
Walter, Archdeacon of Oxford, a man skilled in the art of public speaking and well informed about the history of foreign countries,
presented me with a certain very ancient book written in the British language.
This book, attractively composed to form a consecutive and orderly narrative,
set out all the deeds of these men from Brutus, the first king of the Britons, down to Cadwallader, the son of Cadwallow.
At Walter's request, I have taken the trouble to translate the book into Latin.
Although, indeed, I have been content with my own expressions and my own homely style,
and I have gathered no gaudy flowers of speech in other men's gardens,
if I had adorned my page with high-flown rhetorical figures, I should have bored my readers,
for they would have been forced to spend more time discovering the meaning of my words than in following the story.
In the eight centuries that have passed since Geoffrey of Monmouth completed his great work,
other writers and poets have been inspired to compose new tales of Arthur,
adding fashionable elements such as courtly love and deeds of heroism based on a code of medieval chivalry.
Chrétien de Troyes, the French poet, writing just thirty years after Geoffrey,
added the important new ingredients of the grail and many new knights as part of Arthur's court, notably Sir Lancelot.
He is also responsible for naming Arthur's stronghold as Camelot,
a name he may have borrowed and corrupted from the Roman name for Colchester, Camelodenum.
Robert de Bouron, writing around 1200, introduced the concept of the sword in the stone,
and in the generations that followed, author after author added to the story,
embroidering and inventing, culminating in Sir Thomas Mallory's Mordatha,
and nearer to the present, Tennyson's Idylls of the King.
These are all celebrations of an Arthur many times removed from the man who united the British against the heathen Saxons.
There was undoubtedly an Arthur long before Geoffrey wrote, and he picked up a real character,
and so are some of the others. For instance, Gwenevere appears in Welsh stories,
which are certainly older than Geoffrey of Monmouth, as Gwenhwyfar,
and some of the knights appear too, like Kay and Bedivere, who are Kay and Beduire,
but Lancelot doesn't, unfortunately.
He comes clearly from French stories written at the end of the 12th century, slightly later,
though that again includes very old myths of the Lady of the Lake and so forth.
The sword and the stone, I'm sure, is older and must represent an ancient myth,
which you find in other cultures.
The round table, I think, must also go back to very old ideas.
To me, the most striking episode, and the one which most people remember,
which I'm sure is very much older, and that is the mysterious birth of Arthur,
which people will remember when Uther Pendragon is disguised by Merlin's magic
as the husband of the beautiful Igerna on Tintagel, and he sleeps with her that night,
and that night has begotten the infant Arthur, who is later born and becomes king.
Well, that's a very old story, much older than Geoffrey of Monmouth.
Before Geoffrey romanticised and popularised him, Arthur was a name heard in songs and folktales,
remembered and passed on around the winter firesides of those in whom the Celtic blood still ran strong.
Small wonder then, perhaps, that his story was so helpful and so flattering to Henry I
and to his bastard son Robert.
What better ancestor for a Norman king to claim than Arthur,
most renowned and heroic of all the kings who ruled before the Saxons?
After all, in Geoffrey's time, it was generally believed by folk
that Arthur had actually been anointed and crowned king of England a mere 600 years before.
Arthur himself put on a leather jerkin worthy of so great a king.
On his head he placed a golden helmet with a crest carved in the shape of a dragon,
and across his shoulders a circular shield called Prydwen,
on which there was painted a likeness of the Blessed Mary, Mother of God,
which forced him to be thinking perpetually of her.
He girded on his peerless sword called Caliburn, which was forged in the Isle of Avalon.
But who was the real Arthur?
In truth, hardly anything of him is known, and prior to the 12th century,
his name occurs so rarely in manuscripts and historical records
that it is difficult to understand how his fame has endured.
There are only a handful of references to Arthur,
the earliest being a fleeting acknowledgement of his skill in battle,
which occurs in a 6th century poem by Anorin called Igododin.
He fed black ravens on the ramparts of the fort, although he was no Arthur.
The warrior referred to in these lines, having reduced vast numbers of the enemy to carrion,
is nevertheless deemed by the poet as unable to match Arthur's reputation.
It's extraordinary to think that Anorin may have written these words
within one or two generations of Arthur's lifetime.
Igododin is a North British poem.
That's to say it was written in a language similar to modern Welsh,
and which a modern Welshman can in part still understand.
Probably in the second half of the 6th century, when people spoke a language,
the ancestor of present-day Welsh, from the Channel up to the River Forth in Scotland.
And it tells about a king, Mynyddfawg, of Edinburgh,
whose army set forth 300 of them and marched all the way south to Caterick in Yorkshire
and fought a glorious battle against the English invaders.
And there they were killed, but they died gloriously, as in The Charge of the Light Brigade.
And then this poem was written to commemorate them.
It's the source of much controversy amongst Welsh scholars,
but I think the general agreement is that the nucleus of it was a real poem,
written by a poet called Anorin in the 6th century.
And the interesting part from an Arthurian point of view
is that it does at one point actually mention Arthur.
Although the first mention of Arthur may have been in Igododin,
there is an earlier record of 5th century Britain, but Arthur's name does not appear in it.
It was written by the monk Gildas in about the year 540,
and in it he denounces the rulers of his time
and explains how Britain came to be in such a sorry state.
Its title is The Ruin of Britain,
and it's an outright attack on the wickedness of the authorities and clergy of his day,
and in the preface to the work he tracks down the causes of that wickedness.
In so doing, he provides a unique account of 5th century Britain,
a backdrop to the rise of Arthur,
yet one from which Arthur was strangely absent.
This angry old monk took a dim view of the squabbling of the local British rulers,
and he felt, with some justification no doubt,
that their lack of moral fibre had both led to the supremacy of the heathen Saxon invaders
and been punished by it.
He likened the British plight to that of the Israelites,
and he saw their predicament as divine retribution.
Gildas was a northerner, possibly a Pict born on the wrong side of the Roman frontier,
but lived most of his life in the south,
and in that fact may lie the answer to his silence about Arthur.
As a Pict, he may have had no love for a commander who spent his time driving back the Picts,
who'd been a thorn in the British side for generations.
In fact, the Picts had often allied with the Saxons and the Irish,
causing yet more trouble for the British.
Gildas was a cleric writing in the 6th century,
and so he is unique and extraordinary from an Arthurian point of view
because there is somebody whom no historian doubts was actually writing,
and we do have his writing from sometime in the first half of the 6th century.
But what's disappointing is that he doesn't mention Arthur.
This has been taken by some historians to disparage the whole Arthurian story
and to say, well, if the one person living at the time who wrote about it in some depth
and who lived within the time of people who would have actually known him and doesn't mention him,
then how can anyone suggest he lived?
He seems quite clearly, for reasons which I don't think we'll ever know,
not to be able to tell you about certain things.
For example, it's an absolutely undoubted fact that the Anglo-Saxon invaders
were in possession of a very large part of eastern and southern Britain at this time,
yet you wouldn't know that from Gildas.
So it's not extraordinary that he doesn't mention something very important.
He doesn't tell you about the kings of North Britain who were reigning at that time.
He's writing under some political stress, it seems to me that's quite clear,
and that he could very easily have a reason for not writing about Arthur.
Up until the early 400s, Britain had been prosperous and sophisticated.
A true Roman province in which all free-born Britons were Roman citizens and proud to be so.
British society was headed by landed gentry in whose veins ran the blood of Celt, Roman
and in some instances a mixture of other nationalities from the Roman world.
There was a thriving agricultural and industrial economy due to Roman efficiency and organisation,
which had controlled the province of Britain for just under four centuries.
The breathtaking spectacle of a hoard belonging to a prosperous Romano-British family of the time
was recently uncovered in Suffolk.
The exquisite workmanship and richness of the jewellery and the household items revealed
bear witness that the owners of this treasure were living in style.
None of this changed immediately when Rome severed its links with Britain in the year 410.
When the Roman Emperor Honorius told Britain to look to its own defences,
the former province was remarkably successful in doing just that, at least for a generation.
Gildas attributes this continuing peace to the reign of a supreme ruler he names as Vortigern.
This expression is not a name or even a title, but is thought to have been a description
rather like a nickname, as in the Celtic tongue it means Overlord or High King.
He became High King of Southern Britain in about 425.
At first, Vortigern did better than other petty rulers who had sprung up all over the country
after the break with Rome.
His nickname indicates that he had the support of the poorer classes,
as well as the aristocracy from whom he came.
Otherwise, he would have been known by a Roman name.
So it seems that because he could call upon the allegiance of such a large cross-section of the population,
he maintained authority for almost a generation.
But even Vortigern, with his widespread support,
could not gather enough military strength to counter the ever-increasing pressures of all his frontiers.
Vortigern had the idea, unwise as it later turned out,
of employing a bunch of violent Jutish mercenaries, led by two brothers called Hengist and Horsa.
Then came three Kiels, driven into exile from Germany.
In them were the brothers Horsa and Hengist.
Vortigern welcomed them then, and handed over to them the island that in their language is called Thanet.
Vortigern earned himself the undying hatred of the British for his mistake.
These mercenaries were allowed to settle, and within twenty years or so were abusing their host's hospitality,
and then rebelled against their British masters in the Revolt of 441.
Gildas goes on to say,
All their inhabitants, bishops, priests, and people were mown down together,
while swords flashed and flames crackled.
Horrible it was to see the foundation stones of towers and high walls thrown down.
There was no burial save in the ruins of the houses, or in the bellies of the beasts and birds.
Indeed, excavations in Kaester by Norwich have revealed thirty-six charred bodies from that terrible time,
found in the remains of a burnt-out building, silent witness to the ferocity of their Jutish attackers.
Others had fled, never to return.
Vortigern had let the Saxons in by the back door, and would never be forgiven for it.
In fairness, he had little choice in the matter, beset on all sides with no other hope of defence.
The practice of hiring German mercenaries was by no means a new one.
Indeed, the Romans had themselves done it,
and there is much archaeological evidence for settlements of Angles and Saxons under Roman rule in Britain.
By Arthur's time, the word Saxon had come to mean a multitude of Germanic settlers,
and indeed the modern word Sassanact is still used by the Scots today as a derogatory term for the English incomers.
So, this is the world that Arthur grew up in,
a world in which the Saxon expansion threatened still further,
a Britain destabilised without the protective cloak of Rome.
The great country houses and estates of southern Britain were left to the wind and the rain.
Large-scale farming and industry ran slowly down, as the roads that the Romans had built became more and more unsafe.
The Dark Ages, I must say to me, sometimes unconsciously conveys the idea of its being almost always mid-winter.
It really means a period of which we don't know very much.
It is also a period after the Roman occupation, when the legionary forces were withdrawn at the beginning of the 5th century,
when Britain was left to her own devices, and when we know that eventually the ancestors of the English,
who were heathen barbarians, overtook and clearly ruined most of the island.
The Roman fortresses were destroyed and the villas fell into decay.
But what we don't know is exactly how long this process took,
and there's great disagreement among archaeologists and historians.
My own view, very briefly, based on the latest discoveries,
is that some form of Roman tradition did continue for a considerable time,
probably maybe two or three generations, quite likely, I think, into the 6th century.
And Gildas, whom I mentioned earlier, talks about people with Roman ranks, about rectores, rulers, judges and so forth.
We find an inscription of 540 in North Wales, which refers to the consular date at which the king died.
So a lot of Roman tradition went on.
Most of the towns and cities deteriorated. Some decayed. Some were stripped bare. Others simply disappeared.
It was truly the beginning of Britain's Dark Age.
Petty warlords sprang up all over Britain,
and inevitably the tribal violence which had lain dormant on the centuries of Roman rule erupted with a new vigour.
Leaders rose and fell at an astonishing rate, and the rule of law was no longer respected.
More and more people fled to the towns and cities as supplies failed,
some choosing migration to northern Gaul,
others preferring to seek refuge in the newly re-fortified strongholds of their ancestors.
Famine and plague claimed many.
One such deserted Roman city is described in the earliest known Anglo-Saxon poem.
Shattered the shower shields, roofs ruined, age underate them.
And the wielders and the rites.
Earth grip holds them, gone, long gone.
Fast in graves grasp, while fifty fathers and sons have passed.
Wall stood, grey lichen, red stone.
Kings fell often.
The first serious historical documents in which Arthur is named
were compiled meticulously by a Welsh monk in Bangor, North Wales.
He's known to us as Nennius, and he was not the author of these documents.
We might say he was the editor,
but he himself admits in his preface to his History of the Britons in about 829
that his method of working was haphazard.
I, Nennius, disciple of Elvodigus,
have taken the trouble of writing down a few fragments
which refute the stupidity of the British race of which they are accused,
because their learned men had no knowledge
and had not written in books any record of that island of Britain.
But I have made a heap of all that I could find,
both in the Roman annals and in the chronicles of the Holy Fathers,
that is, Jerome, Eusebius, Isidore and Prosper,
and also from the annals of the Irish and Saxons
and from the traditions of our elders.
Like Gildas before him, Nennius was a monk,
but he had few literary aspirations
and he confined himself to arranging the assortment of ancient documents
in what he thought was their true historical order.
Whether he was as gripped by the figure of Arthur is not recorded,
but by the 9th century when Nennius compiled the documents he had found,
Arthur had become a folk hero, especially in Nennius' native Wales.
Amongst those documents, the two most important are
the Annals of Wales and Nennius' History of the Britons.
The annals are thought to contain accounts from 5th and 6th century history,
copied down at around 800.
So they may have been altered at any time by monk copyists,
censoring or adding to texts as they saw fit.
People are very curious and often ask people like myself
who are studying this period what sort of evidence there is.
Well, in a sense, there's very little.
The direct sources used by historians are very few,
and we've canvassed most of them.
The only one I haven't mentioned so far is the History of the Britons,
which used to be attributed to Nennius,
which is the most important, which was written in the year 829 in its present form.
But there's actually very little.
There's the mention in the Gododdin.
There are other early Welsh verses.
There's a Welsh poem about Geraint, the Prince of Devon,
which is later than Arthur's time, but mentions Arthur.
So there's not a great deal.
But what there is is highly suggestive,
and there are other ways of examining the evidence.
Archaeology doesn't really tell us very much, unfortunately.
It tells us a great deal about the conditions of life,
to some extent about political conditions,
because fortresses have been excavated and so on.
But we don't really, for the most part, know who lived in those fortresses,
and we don't really know whether Arthur lived in one or another.
But what we do have is the History of the Britons,
which in the year 800 records Arthur's 12 great battles.
Most of the sites are not very easy.
In fact, none of them is identified for certain.
That, to my mind, is a bit of an argument for saying they're genuine,
because it seems to me a forger would have picked on known and well-known sites of the period.
He doesn't.
And to the extent that they can be satisfactorily identified,
they do appear the sort of places you might expect battles at the beginning of the 6th century.
In those days, the Saxons increased in numbers and grew stronger in Britain.
But at Hengisteth, Arthur, his son, went from the northern part of Britain to the kingdom of Kent,
and from him arose the kings of Kent.
Then Arthur fought against those men in those days, with the kings of the Britons,
but he was the leader of battles.
The first battle was in the mouth of the river which is called Glyne,
the second and third and fourth and fifth,
on another river which is called Dub Glas, and is in the region Linois.
The sixth battle on the river called Bassas.
The seventh battle was in the forest of Celedon, that is Cat Coet Celedon.
The eighth battle was at the fort of Gwynion,
in which Arthur carried the image of the Blessed Mary Ever-Virgin on his shoulders.
And the pagans were put to flight,
and there was a great slaughter of them by the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ,
and by the grace of the Blessed Mary the Virgin, his mother.
The ninth battle was fought in the city of the Legion.
He fought the tenth battle on the shore of the river which is called Tribruet.
The eleventh battle was on the mountain called Agned.
The twelfth battle was at Badon Hill,
where nine hundred and sixty men perished at one charge of Arthur's,
and no one killed them save he himself,
and in all the battles he was victor.
And they, when they were defeated in all the battles,
sent for help to Germany,
and their numbers were ceaselessly added to,
and they brought kings from Germany to rule over those in Britain.
It's clear from Nennius' account that Arthur was an experienced military campaigner,
and Nennius always refers to him using the Latin word for soldier,
miles, pronounced milles, rather than calling him king.
It's even possible that Arthur may not have been a name,
but an epithet as Vortigern was.
Some have claimed the name Arthur stems from the Roman name Artorius.
A Roman officer called Artorius Justus served in Britain in the third century.
But Arthur is not an unusual Celtic name of this time either.
Another suggestion which historians have advanced for some time
is that the fact that a number of dynasties of the time,
of kings whose genealogies have been preserved,
tend to call their sons Arthur.
This is in the two, three generations after the time when Arthur would have lived,
which again suggests that there was a famous Arthur
after whom they wished to name their sons.
And it's interesting too to me that most of these kings are in the north of Britain
where I suspect that the real Arthur lived,
possibly based on the old Roman legionary fortress at York.
Some think that Arthur and Ambrosius, mentioned by Gildas, were one and the same.
Geoffrey of Monmouth invented a blood tie between Ambrosius and Arthur
by making Arthur the son of Uther Pendragon,
who was supposed brother to Ambrosius.
But there is no historical evidence for this
and no way of knowing who Arthur's parents were or where he was born.
It's a commonly held belief that Arthur took up the struggle against the invaders
where Ambrosius left off.
Unusually, Gildas names Ambrosius
where he'd kept silence about other figures, notably Arthur.
Of Ambrosius he said,
Their leader was Ambrosius Aurelianus,
a gentleman who, perhaps alone of the Romans,
had survived the shock of this notable storm.
Certainly his parents, who had worn the purple, were slain in it.
It's plain that both Ambrosius and Arthur shared a strong desire
to rid Britain of the heathen invaders
or at least to stem the tidal wave of eager Germanic, Pictish and Irish settlers.
Perhaps Ambrosius invented Arthur with his authority
and passed him the torch to bear onwards into the darkness.
Knowing nothing about his background or descent,
we can only assume that he must have come from a British family of some importance.
The influence of Rome was still very strong in such noble families.
Arthur may well have spoken in the local Celtic dialect,
a type of primitive Welsh,
but he would also have had a working knowledge of Latin as a matter of course.
What he looked like and how old he was when he took up the fight, we cannot know.
One thing can be said with certainty.
He was a British military commander
who appeared on the scene in the latter half of the 5th century
and succeeded in curbing the Saxon incursions
and, in parts of Britain, actually halting their advance altogether.
The battles mentioned by Nennius took place over a wide area of Britain,
roughly stretching from Strathclyde eastwards to Northumbria
or possibly even to Lincolnshire
and from Chester to some point south-west
where Baden Hills saw a British victory so overwhelming
that it subdued the Saxons for the following 50 years.
As Gildas puts it,
Baden was not the least slaughter of the hangdogs
and also almost the last.
Only two battle sites of the twelve mentioned by Nennius
have been tentatively identified,
but the important fact is that they indicate the scope and reach of the military force
of which Arthur may have been the leader.
Such a force, with its ability to respond to threats from all over mainland Britain,
would have cavalry as its main component.
The resounding defeat he inflicted on the Saxons at Baden
demonstrated superbly that, in a pitched battle,
cavalry had the edge over foot soldiers.
The tradition of cavalry had been inherited from the Romans,
whose most effective troops in the twilight of Rome's power
had been their light or fast-strike cavalry.
The Celts themselves had a reputation for superb horsemanship.
Indeed, they had sold their services as auxiliary cavalry
the length and breadth of the old empire
and Rome had learned much from them.
Now the wheel turned again
and all of that knowledge and experience passed once more into Arthur's hands.
It's safe to assume that he, along with Ambrosius,
revived the use of cavalry as a hammer with which to break the enemy ranks.
We might get a better idea of Arthur's strategy if we could identify the battle sites
because they really are, I think, the most tantalising clue.
And it may be that the day will come
when one of the sites is properly excavated
and if we find evidence of a battle contemporary
then I think we would obviously be very near.
But we wouldn't know, for instance,
whether the battles occurred in successive years
or all in the space of one campaign
or over the whole of Arthur's lifetime,
so we wouldn't know much.
It's from the early Welsh poetry we know how the battle was fought.
They were very stylised.
There was considerable use of cavalry, as I say.
The nobles prided themselves rather like medieval knights,
so there is a resemblance.
But there's nothing unusual about using cavalry.
In fact, cavalry was usual among the Britons at that time
and I don't believe, and there's no evidence to suggest,
that this was imitating, as was suggested in the Oxford History of England,
the armoured knights, the cataphracti of the late Roman Empire.
I don't think so.
This was an aristocratic form of warfare
from these hill forts where they had their horses.
And I think, as much as anything,
it reflects the aristocratic prejudice of the poets
who are writing for their kings
and are writing about what they wish to know about,
just as medieval minstrels write about the adventures
of Lancelot and Gawain riding out in armour.
But it doesn't mean that everyone did.
It just means that the audience wanted to hear about that.
But it does still reflect an aspect of the warfare.
But there is mention in the poems, allusions,
that it's not their prime interest,
in ordered movements of troops
and there is an expression, forming the battle pen,
which does give the impression of forming up a phalanx, maybe,
of men with spears and shields.
And it would be inconceivable that there wasn't
some sort of discipline and order
and, indeed, that the king, like Arthur,
who carved a name for himself and, if it was,
he won the great victory at Mount Bardon,
didn't make use of superior tactics to his adversaries.
Equally, the adversaries were obviously very formidable indeed,
or we wouldn't be speaking English at this interview.
In contrast to Arthur's highly mobile and disciplined men,
the Saxons mostly fought on foot,
as, indeed, they continued to do right up to the Battle of Hastings.
They had no apparent strategy
because they had no sense of central leadership.
Small bands of Saxons in one community
would be loyal to one chief,
but fought mainly for the love of it,
with the added incentive of rich rewards if they won.
Military discipline was not their strong suit
and their war gear varied according to their means.
Unlike the British under Arthur,
for whom uniformity and consistency of equipment,
particularly horse harness, would have been essential.
In a large force, particularly cavalry,
standardisation of essential items of equipment
would have been the only practical way
to make the most of horses and men.
Such a demand would have been met
by a cottage industry of craftsmen,
armourers, leather workers,
and perhaps even field surgeons,
as well as the more obvious baggage train
of cooks and quartermasters.
The logistics of directing so complicated a piece of military machinery
indicates that Arthur must have been as capable a diplomat
as he was a soldier,
for to keep his men and horses fully effective,
vast resources would have been needed.
It's not beyond the bounds of possibility
that the church, with its great wealth,
was one of Arthur's main benefactors.
But whether it did so willingly
or with a little prompting is hard to say.
Certainly, in the first few centuries following Arthur's lifetime,
the record-keeping clergy
seem to have been unwilling to give him any credit,
as Gilder's silence on the subject of Arthur
may perhaps bear witness.
Well, as I've said earlier,
the direct sources are very sparse
and for the most part, unfortunately,
not that satisfactory.
They require an enormous amount of discussion and evaluation.
But I suppose if one were to look for a parallel,
it would not be back in the imperial Roman past
nor in the knights of the Middle Ages,
but it would be in what was going on in Gaul
across the Channel at this time,
which is far better documented
because people were writing letters and so forth
which have survived.
And there we do see, I would think,
a rather similar picture to Britain.
For example, you have in northern Gaul
a Roman leader, Cyagrius,
who is still acting as a Roman officer,
though he's now cut off completely from Rome itself.
We have in the letters in the 5th century
of Sidonius and other people,
long correspondence has survived of these Roman aristocrats
living on in their villas,
sometimes perfectly peacefully
and on good terms with the local Gothic king
or Frankish king,
writing, corresponding, even acting on their behalf.
There's a description of a Gaulish landowner,
a young and dashing man called Actidius,
who with, I think, a handful of horsemen,
I forget the number, a dozen,
rides through the whole of a Gothic besieging army
in order to relieve the city in southern Gaul.
So if you read those sources, which are accessible,
then I think that gives perhaps a more clear impression
of what was going on in Britain
than the speculation from much later sources
which have survived in this country.
And one has to remember, too,
that historically what happened in Gaul
seems to be happening on another planet
because we read that as a separate part of history.
But the real Arthur, the real people who lived at that time,
the real Cai and Bedouin, Cai and Bedouin,
knew what was going on to some extent.
They talked with merchants delivering wine
at ports on the southern and western coasts.
They themselves must occasionally have travelled there.
Enormous historical events can and must have taken place
of which we know nothing.
And I think, therefore, again, studying the history of Gaul,
which is so much better documented,
does give one a much fairer and more clear picture.
Whilst British resources ensured
that each man had the bare essentials,
there must have been a fair amount of looting
and opportunist stealing, so that as time passed,
at least the higher ranks of each side
would have had items such as chain mail,
helmets and possibly even swords
which had been taken from the enemy.
Arthur's men may have, if they took Rome as their model,
carried long straight cavalry swords or spears or both.
They may have carried shields, but even if they didn't,
they would almost certainly have worn body armour
of either chain mail, leather armour or scale.
The latter is vulnerable to upward thrust,
not a wise choice of armour for a cavalry man.
Before Garaint the enemy's scourge
I saw white horses, tensed red
After the war cry, bitter the grave
In Llangborth I saw the clash of swords
Men in terror, bloody heads
Before Garaint the Great, his father's son
In Llangborth I saw spurs
And men who did not flinch from spears
Who drank their wine from glass that glinted
In Llangborth I saw Arthur's heroes
Who cut with steel
The Emperor, ruler of our labour
In Llangborth Garaint was slain
Heroes of the land of Dovenite
Before they were slain, they slew
Under the thigh of Garaint, swift charges
Long their leg, wheat their fodder
Red, swooping like milk-white eagles
When Garaint was born, Heaven's gate stood open
Christ granted all our prayer
Lovely to behold, the glory of Britain
Of course, Arthur would have had more than just cavalry at his disposal.
The units of foot soldiers he commanded
would have been a mixture of the descendants of old soldiers
who had served under the regular Roman army,
volunteers from the villages and farms,
and in the remaining British-controlled towns,
any such town militia that could be spared,
and were acceptable to the dux bellorium,
the war leader or leader of battles, as Arthur is often called.
The weapon of choice for an average foot soldier on the British side
is likely to have been the spear.
Because swords were expensive to produce,
they remained almost exclusively the weapons of the nobility
or those fortunate enough to acquire them on the field of battle.
Shields were the principal form of protection for these poorer British folk
who couldn't possibly afford body armour,
let alone iron helmets.
But unlike the professionally produced and finished shields of the earlier Roman troops,
these would have been edged with rawhide
and possibly painted in crude copies of the patterns of the Roman legions.
Iron helms were rare in the Saxons' ranks too,
even amongst nobility.
Spears were the most common weapon on both sides.
In contrast to the sword,
very little skill or training is needed to use the spear effectively enough to injure or to kill.
Very few actual weapons have been found from this time
that can be said to be definitely British.
One reason for this may be that the Britons, being mostly Christians,
had abandoned the practice of bearing their weapons with their dead,
whereas the Saxons, very much still a pagan and warrior society,
still persisted in consigning their most treasured possessions,
including their swords, spears, mail shirts and helmets, to the grave.
Anno Domini 516-518.
The Battle of Baden,
in which Arthur carried the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ
for three days and three nights on his shoulders.
And the Britons were victorious.
The aim of such a huge infantry army pushing so far into British territory
must surely have been to overcome and destroy the main British cavalry force,
which was, after all, the only thing standing between them and mastery of all Britain,
and also to wipe out the British base.
The Saxon army was composed of the armies of Kent
and of the South and West Saxons under the overall leadership of Ale,
and was for those days an enormous force of warriors.
Arthur's cavalry was probably no more than a thousand.
And if it was a siege, the hard-pressed cavalry needed a steep hill
for the dismounted warriors to hold against the greater numbers of the Saxons,
and there are many such hills outside Bath.
And on one of these hills, Arthur triumphed.
At Baden, Arthur crushed the Saxons so thoroughly
that it was to take them decades to recover.
He created, by brute force, a breathing space for his fellow Britons.
For a while at least, they need not fear the ravages of the Saxon seawolves.
Arthur had won a piece and could expect to enjoy the acclaim of the people.
Though he was never a king, he did more than any king of Britain had ever done.
Although many of them were of nobler descent than he was,
he was nevertheless twelve times designated commander.
Peace may have brought Arthur rewards as well as the gratitude of the British.
For a warlord of his stature, it would be quite natural for him to seek a permanent stronghold.
An ancient hill fort at South Cadbury in Somerset,
last inhabited at the time of the Roman invasion,
had been shown by archaeologists to have been re-fortified
at the end of the 5th century, when Arthur's military career was at its peak.
In the centre of this hill fort stood a great feasting hall,
with a lofty thatched roof and gabled at each end.
Was this the Camelot of Legend, where Arthur celebrated his greatest victories?
History is so far silent.
Anno Domini 539.
The Battle of Camelot, in which Arthur and Modred perished.
And there was a plague in Britain and Ireland.
Arthur got his peace, and perhaps was able to enjoy it for a short while.
The Saxon threat had been warded off, and the country could once again flourish.
But the old hostilities resurfaced between the petty chieftains.
Civil war broke out, and Arthur may have been drawn into it.
Legend says he and his son died at each other's hands in a fatal power struggle.
Yet men say in parts of England that King Arthur is not dead,
but had by the will of our Lord Jesus into another place.
And men say that he shall come again.
I will not say it shall be so.
But rather will I say that here in the world he changed his life.
But many men say there is written upon his tomb this verse.
Here lies Arthur, the once and future king.
