King Arthur is one of the most famous figures in all of history, whether you're familiar with Lancelot, or the Holy Grail, or Guinevere, or Excalibur, or the Knights of the Round Table, you've likely heard at least SOMETHING about King Arthur.
Very few people are aware of his actual origins, though. A statistic that is not helped by the terrible coverage of the subject, both online and in the real world.
In this video, I hope to shine a proper light of the Medieval origins of King Arthur. We'll see how Chretien's story developed from fiction written by Geoffrey of Monmouth. We'll see how Geoffrey adapted King Arthur from figures found in Welsh Mythology. We'll see how the mythologies of Wales shifted and moulded King Arthur to fit whatever story they were trying to tell, and we'll see how Wales in the 9th century developed one of the most famous historical figures of all time.
And maybe we'll discover who this "Arthur" really was, who inspired this character, and if he was ever a real person.
Chapters: 0:00 - Introduction 0:49 - Arthur, Roi de Bretagne 1:47 - Arthur, Rex Brittania 5:55 - Ceni bei ef Arthur 9:36 - Arthur, Dux Bellorum 20:40 - Arthur, Pendragon
This video examines the historical validity of King Arthur, concluding that he is not a single documented person but a composite fictional character. By analyzing early Welsh oral traditions, medieval manuscripts, and later French romances, the narrator demonstrates how various military leaders and myths were synthesized over centuries to create the legendary king.
King Arthur. Arguably one of the most famous figures in all of mythology.
Whether it's Lancelot, the Holy Grail, Excalibur, or the Knights of the Round Table,
everyone has likely heard something about Arthur. Despite these famous stories,
many historians believe that Arthur was a real figure. But why? Where do they think he came from?
What are the origins of this story? This topic has been done before,
but it's never been done very well. From YouTube videos filled with inaccurate information,
to the dozens of published books proclaiming to have found the real Arthur, the discourse
surrounding this figure is a mess. So today I'd like to properly discuss the historical origins
of King Arthur. I'd like to address the very question of who was Arthur, and work our way
backwards to see what, or who, historians believe inspired the legend. The reason you've likely heard
anything about King Arthur before is because of this man, the 12th century French romance writer
Arthur's most famous elements, the ones I mentioned earlier, all had their starts here,
and his stories were incredibly popular. The King Arthur that many people are familiar with
exists solely as a literary figure, and is famous just because of Chrétien. We aren't going to
analyse these elements today, and no one is claiming that this man existed, including Chrétien.
These were solely fictional works, but they did play a huge role in bringing the figure of King
Arthur and the elements surrounding him into the popular imagination. Arthur's reinvention as the
King of England would be based upon these stories. Edward I, inspired by Chrétien, even held his own
round table upon his conquest of Wales. However, King Arthur was not one of Chrétien's creations.
He owed this character, and many elements surrounding him, to another fiction writer,
although this one would try very hard to convince you that he was telling the truth.
Geoffrey of Monmouth, a 12th century bishop and writer desired, for unknown reasons, to compile
what he called the History of the Kings of Britain, supposedly from an ancient Brothonic text that was
given to him by Walter Mapp, another writer. Geoffrey sought to pass this book off as real,
but to historians today, and even to many of the time, his fictitious elements are obvious,
if frustrating. Geoffrey likes to use real names and places, and made up names and places,
and due to the age of the text, it is very difficult to determine which of these names
and places are fake, and which of them may derive from a now lost source, and there is no better
example of this than of King Arthur, the supposed King of Britain who Geoffrey claimed conquered
half of Europe. Geoffrey was not writing history, despite his claims, which is a mistake that I've
seen so many people make, trying to figure out Arthur based even partially on his depiction
by Geoffrey, but this depiction is a work of fiction. Arthur himself though was once again
a real name, plucked out of existing stories and sources, and made a central character in
Geoffrey's work. So just like what we asked with Chrétien, where did this Arthur come from?
Geoffrey's primary source appears to be the mythologies of Wales, which might come as a
surprise for many of you, as Arthur is typically seen as an English or a French figure, but before
his adoption as the King of England, or as a paragon of French chivalry, he was a popular
character in the oral traditions of Wales, and no one else knew anything about him.
He hardly had a standardised canon though, another mistake I've seen a lot of people make.
From one story to another, his servant becomes his son, his parents go unmentioned,
three separate individuals are named as his wife, some stories paint him as a man with
supernatural strength and skill, while others depict him as an evil autocrat who needs to be
taught a lesson on the power of God. So clearly the Welsh were not all describing the same man,
Arthur is a character in these myths, just like with Geoffrey and Chrétien,
and he is morphed and moulded to fit the frame of whatever the author wanted.
Geoffrey would pluck dozens of elements from these stories to mould his own version of Arthur,
Uther Pendragon, one of Arthur's knights? He can be his dad. What's that? Arthur doesn't have a
mother, we'll just make one up. Three women are married to Arthur? Not in this Christian household.
Geoffrey's work is a hideous Frankenstein that will look disturbingly familiar to anyone
medieval Welsh poetry or history. But as I've shown you, he did not invent the name Arthur,
he simply took it from Welsh mythology and moulded it to fit the character he wanted.
So, once again, where did this Arthur come from? Why was this man, this name so popular,
both with Geoffrey and with medieval Welsh poetry?
It is here that we now move into the shadowy realm of the historical sources.
So many people are content just to tell you the old mentions of the name Arthur,
and happy to completely ignore the debate on how reliable they even are.
The question of who was Arthur goes unanswered, but the question of the question,
what do you mean when you ask who was Arthur, goes entirely ignored.
But I'll come to that in a bit, for now let's examine the oldest mentions of Arthur,
and see why he became so famous.
Many of the videos that I've already complained about will tell you this,
that the name Arthur first appears all the way back in the 6th century,
in a Welsh poem titled Y Godovan,
that describes the disastrous invasion of Northern England by the Brythonic Kingdom of Godovan.
Who could have guessed?
Here we encounter many descriptions of the warriors that took part in the war,
but only one is of interest to us, Gwarthur, if you'll allow me.
He fed black ravens on the rampart of a fortress, and though he was no Arthur,
among the powerful ones in battle in the front rank, a palisade, was Gwarthur.
This is fascinating.
Here we have the description of one of the most powerful warriors in the army,
who fights in the front rank, who's a palisade to his companions,
and yet he is nothing compared to this man, Arthur.
Not only would this definitely hurt his feelings,
but if this poem dates all the way back to the 6th century,
then surely this proves that some warrior named Arthur was already famous by this time.
So is this our King Arthur, the man who appears in so many Welsh myths and legends?
And if it is, does he have his historical roots in the 6th century,
around the time that this poem is set?
That's the conclusion that many people, books and videos have drawn,
and just like I said at the start, it's completely incorrect.
While the events of the poem date to the 6th century,
the manuscript itself dates to the 13th,
which is after Joffrey already made Arthur famous,
and likely even after Chrétien's French romances.
However, the spelling and the typography match 9th and 10th century texts,
which would place it before Joffrey, but not in the 6th century.
We have absolutely no evidence that this text or Arthur are that old.
Furthermore, this line,
though he was no Arthur,
only appears in one of the manuscripts of Ogadoddon,
meaning that it was likely added sometime during its transcription.
In fact, there seem to be a lot of additions,
as both manuscripts vary quite a bit from each other.
Despite these glaring errors,
this conclusion of a 6th century Arthur
mixes into nearly every video on this subject,
and is the basis for so many theories on who the real Arthur was,
but in reality,
all that Ogadoddon proves is that this name, Arthur,
might have been famous by at least the 9th or 10th centuries.
So was Joffrey and the mythologies of Wales inspired by this Arthur?
Probably not, or at least only partially.
After all, it is a small throwaway line,
and it doesn't explain who Arthur was,
meaning that the author probably assumed you would already know him.
Another source purporting to be one of the oldest mentions of Arthur
is another 13th century manuscript,
known as the Annals Cambria,
which records the dates of two battles being fought by a man named Arthur,
the Battle of Badon in 516,
and the Battle of Camlan in 537.
The problem, once again though,
is that this manuscript dates to after Joffrey already made Arthur famous,
and the historian T. Charles Edwards has suggested that these records
were either invented or maybe just elaborated
to include Arthur at a later date.
We actually have a primary source from the Battle of Badon,
and this source doesn't mention Arthur at all,
but more on that later.
You see, this is really the problem with a lot of discussion
on the historical King Arthur.
So many people attribute him to the 6th century,
just because some manuscripts set in this era reference him.
But these documents are not that old,
they were all written after Arthur had already become famous,
and there was nothing stopping the authors from including a reference to him,
especially because Joffrey claimed that he was a real historical person.
So what then is the oldest historical mention of King Arthur,
one that predates Joffrey of Monmouth?
Were these manuscripts inspired by the same individual
as Joffrey and the Welsh myths?
To attempt to answer this question,
let's go back to the early 9th century.
The Kingdoms of Wales had suffered a lot of turmoil by this time.
Old dynasties had collapsed and new ones arose in their place.
The English Kingdom of Mercia had been attempting
to conquer the country for centuries,
and they'd only just recently stopped their invasions.
In the face of all of this,
an incredibly fascinating document was written,
This manuscript aimed to, well, document the history of the Britons,
who were the Celtic-speaking people of Great Britain,
all the way from the biblical flood to the present day,
which would have been around AD 829.
Despite its title and its premise,
the Historia Britannum is not a history.
Its focus on exaggerating the power of the new kings of this region,
known as Gwynedd,
turn it into a glorified propaganda piece,
claiming that these rulers were the ones to unite and defend all of Wales.
It has a very heavy anti-English bias,
mirroring the anti-Welsh bias in the writings of English monks such as Bede,
and most importantly, it is extremely religious.
Its author even calls it a sermon.
Within all of this lies our main objective,
as the Historia Britannum dedicates a significant portion of its time
to describing how the Welsh were to beat back the English three times.
The first had already happened,
and it was by a Welsh general named Vortimo.
The third was prophesied to take place in the future,
under the leadership of those new kings of Gwynedd that I mentioned,
but the second, and what would have been at the time the most recent,
was under the command of a man named Arthur.
Arthur, despite his modern adaptations, is not a king here.
He's a leader of battles,
Ducs Bellorum,
said to not be as noble as the kings under his command.
Despite this, by wielding the power of Christianity,
and no I'm not joking,
he was able to beat back the Saxons in 12 decisive battles,
forcing them to summon hordes of reinforcements from Germany,
who eventually went on to found the kingdoms of England.
Whatever happened to Arthur, the author doesn't say,
but it's implied that he staved off Saxon advancement
across the whole of Britain for at least a few years.
These 12 battles have become central to most analyses on the figure of Arthur,
despite how different the source makes him.
He's no king,
he has no birthplace,
no companions,
no knight to the round table,
no chivalrous adventures,
that element of superhuman strength and skill
that we can see in some of the Welsh myths is present,
but Arthur isn't unstoppable.
The author and the audience weren't blind,
Arthur may have held off the Saxons for a while,
but nowadays they were right outside the door.
Arthur was though, thanks to this document,
made a national hero,
an ancient defender of Great Britain against what was seen as an unstoppable force,
so it's no wonder Joffrey of Monmouth was so captivated by this character.
Joffrey's Arthur is clearly inspired by this Arthur,
although Joffrey elaborates just a bit by making him a king,
with a birthplace in Tintagel and Cornwall,
with his knights and a family,
and while he still fights these 12 battles,
he also goes on to wage war against the Roman Empire,
and conquer half of Europe.
The superhuman strength of Arthur,
seen in his capability to defeat hundreds of foes single-handedly,
may have inspired many of the abilities of Arthur seen in the Welsh myths,
while Joffrey seems to have taken inspiration from both of these sources.
So then, is this the oldest historical mention of Arthur,
the one that made the name famous?
Does the Historia Britannum depict the original historical Arthur?
Well, Joffrey and the Welsh myths are clearly inspired by this,
the poem of Ogadoddin could easily be referring to this Arthur
as their warrior of supreme strength,
and as we've seen,
Chrétien took inspiration from all of these,
but mostly Joffrey.
The problem though,
lies in a question that's rarely even asked when discussing this topic.
When you say,
who was the original Arthur,
or what man inspired the Arthurian legends,
who exactly are you talking about?
Plenty of people have dedicated time to finding Arthur,
based on his depictions by Joffrey,
or in Welsh mythology,
or on the false assertion that he must be from the 6th century,
but hardly anyone stops to acknowledge that these men are characters.
As we've seen,
the Arthur of Joffrey was different from the Arthur of the Welsh myths,
and these Arthurs were vastly different from the Arthur of the Historia Britannum.
From one text and one author to another,
Arthur's father becomes his knight,
his mother pops in and out of existence,
his councilman becomes his son,
his servant becomes his son,
and his number of wives constantly changes.
He's either the righteous king of Britain,
an evil autocrat,
or not even a king at all.
In some stories,
the saints of Wales must convince him of the power of God,
but in others he carries a cross on his shoulders for three days and nights,
and defeats the Saxons while displaying Mary on his shield.
You can't find Arthur based on these depictions,
as I've hopefully shown you so far,
the Arthur that many people know is simply a character,
based on centuries upon centuries of different stories and adaptations,
shifting and changing to meet the author's needs.
These stories don't depict an individual waiting to be discovered,
the only thing they all have in common is the name,
Arthur.
Nothing else about this character is even remotely consistent.
It does seem that this name was originally made famous by this book,
the Historia Britannum,
describing Arthur as this great warrior in general,
and as a national hero of the Britons,
but does this source depict an original historical Arthur?
Is this the source that historians point to
when they assert that Arthur may have been a real person?
Well, no,
there's nothing historical about this book either.
If you recall,
the Historia Britannum is not a history,
it's a hyper-religious,
self-described sermon filled with political bias
and designed as a propaganda piece.
The entire plot,
the conflict between the Britons and the Saxons,
starts because the Britons weren't Christian enough.
A pagan ruler named Vortigern,
who consorts with Druids,
is convinced by Satan to allow the Saxons to enter Britain.
Luckily his son,
in a great act of redemption,
holds the invading army back at Kent for a while,
until eventually Arthur,
bearing the image of the mother of Jesus on his shield,
defeats the invading force 12 times,
all across Britain.
Not only does the guest appearance of
The Devil
immediately betray the lack of historical value,
but these 12 victorious battles
also do not do us any favours.
Despite supposedly being so famous,
these conflicts are almost entirely lost to us.
We can only properly identify
three actual battles in this list,
and only two of these come with a date.
The Battle of the City of the Legions
is likely referring to Caerleon Vower,
or Chester,
which was taken by the Northumbrians in 616.
The Battle of Badon
was likely somewhere near Caer Vadon,
or Bath,
and actually has a primary source,
the work of a monk named Gildas,
along with a potential date of 516.
And finally,
the Battle of Bregyn
appears to be the Battle of Bregyn,
or Brewyn in Welsh,
but we don't know when this took place.
The first problem we can see
is that two of these battles
that Arthur supposedly fought at
took place 100 years apart,
making it biologically impossible
that they were fought by the same person.
The second problem lies
with the sources we have on this battle,
none of which attribute them
to a man named Arthur.
The Battle of Chester
was fought by King Selyv of Powys,
alongside King Cadwal of Ros
and King Iago of Gwynedd,
and it wasn't even a victory.
The Battle of Brewyn
was fought by a man named Urien Reged,
and the Battle of Badon,
the only one with a primary source,
is said to have been fought
by a man named Ambrosius Aurelianus.
In fact, as I said earlier,
this 6th century source
does not mention Arthur at all.
The remaining battles
are completely lost to us.
Some may have connections
to Welsh poetry,
but we really can't say for sure.
All the historians can say
is that out of the 12
supposed victories of Arthur,
only three can be identified,
two of which took place
over a century apart from each other,
one of which wasn't a victory,
and none of which are attributed
to Arthur anywhere
except for the Historia Brittonum.
This is hardly a historical account
of a real person's career,
and as I've shown you,
any hope of constructing
a real historical individual
from this text,
whether they were named Arthur or not,
is completely impossible.
It seems that once again,
Arthur has been used
as a character here,
just like in the Welsh myths,
and in Geoffrey of Monmouth's work,
and in the French romances,
this time as a military commander
of superhuman ability
who fought the Saxons
all across Great Britain,
fighting and winning famous battles
regardless of whether or not
he was even there,
or if they were even victories,
or if it was even chronologically possible
to fight at all of them.
So while the Historia Brittonum
may have made the name Arthur famous,
you can't figure out who Arthur was
based on this source,
or on any of these sources
I've mentioned so far,
and we can't yet determine
if he was even a real person.
The Arthur that most people know
is a character.
His most famous elements
originate from 12th century
French romances,
which adopted this mythical
king of Britain
from the 11th century
fictional work of Geoffrey of Monmouth.
Many of the surviving Welsh myths
seem to have taken a lot
from Geoffrey too,
mainly by making Arthur a king,
although it's clear that
Geoffrey borrowed a lot
from these stories as well.
The name itself, Arthur,
was made famous by the book
we just covered,
but this manuscript
isn't describing a person
who's waiting to be discovered,
it's describing a character
with an eclectic career
of pre-existing historical
and mythological battles.
So can we identify who Arthur was
from any of the sources
we've examined so far?
No.
This character is so wildly inconsistent
that absolutely any fact
that you can discern
will be disputed in another text.
His offspring,
his parents,
his career,
where he lived,
how Christian he was,
whether or not he was a king,
these all change constantly
to fit the author's need.
So if Arthur is a character
in the Historia Britannum 2,
where did the author get him from?
As we've seen so far,
all iterations of this character
have been inspired by something else,
yet unlike these past iterations,
the Historia Britannum
does not seem to have been inspired
by the adventures
of a single individual,
as the name Arthur
becomes extremely rare
if we go further back than this source.
Even though these Arthurs
are so wildly different from each other,
we can still trace one Arthur
to another Arthur to another,
but now the trail has run cold.
That's not to say
that some historians don't believe
that there may have been
a real individual named Arthur,
who perhaps was a military general
that inspired these initial legends,
but as the historians John Davis
and T. Charles Edwards both say,
we know absolutely nothing
about this hypothetical Arthur.
Where did he live?
Where did he come from?
The myths disagree,
and now that the trail has run cold,
we're forced to look elsewhere.
So just like what we asked with Chretien,
Joffrey,
the Welsh myths,
the Godalden poem,
and now the Historia Britannum,
we're going to finish off this video
by asking,
where did this Arthur come from?
And can we discern
if there was ever a real Arthur,
and who he might have been?
The Arthur of the Historia Britannum,
while it's uncertain
if he's based on another man named Arthur,
certainly takes influence
from other individuals in history.
The first and most obvious candidates
are the three generals
who fought the battles
that Arthur is claimed to have won,
Ambrosius Aurelianus,
King Selyv,
and Urien Reged.
Unfortunately,
due to the age of these individuals,
the documentation surrounding them
is very scarce,
and it's hard to reconstruct
much of their lives,
an issue that will come up again
when we examine
some of the more popular theories
about Arthur.
Ambrosius Aurelianus
is a clear inspiration.
He fought and won the Battle of Badon,
leading the Britons
in holding off the Saxons in advance
for a generation,
mimicking the outcome
of Arthur's career
in the Historia Britannum.
He was apparently a Roman,
descended from a Roman family
remaining in Britain.
He may have been leading forces
to defend what was left
of the Roman government,
an endeavour that his parents
had supposedly undertaken before him.
Does this make him Arthur, though?
Well, what does that mean?
He certainly inspired
the figure of Arthur,
fighting the Saxons,
holding their advance.
But did he fight 12 battles?
No.
Did he fight at Chester,
or Brewin?
No.
Was he a king?
No, but the earliest versions
of Arthur weren't either.
Was he a Christian?
We don't know.
Is he connected to any
of Arthur's supposed family?
No.
So it really depends
on what you mean
by who was Arthur.
Some people are looking
for an individual
to match Arthur's career,
even if their names
are completely different.
But as we've seen so far,
there is no concrete career
to even be matched to.
Ambrosius fought at Badon,
his leadership staved off the Saxons,
he is very obviously
an influence to the character of Arthur
that the Historia Brittonum created.
But to say that he was Arthur
would rely on you
ignoring everything else
about both individuals.
The Battle of Chester, for example,
King Zelliver fought and died
defending his home here,
and this battle
was later credited to Arthur.
Despite his loss,
he seems to have been described
as an excellent general,
being named as Sarfgadai,
the Serpent of Battles,
and as one of the three
battle leaders of Great Britain,
a title that would be translated
into Latin and given to Arthur,
Dux Ballorum, the Leader of Battles,
so he's clearly an influence
on the figure of Arthur too.
Urien, a king of the Kingdom of Reged,
is a bit trickier.
He is claimed to have defeated
the Northumbrians several times,
and he is the subject of
eight surviving praise poems.
The Historia Brittonum includes him,
but they make him Arthur's successor
in the North,
fighting and dying against
the newly arrived kings of Bernice.
His career doesn't match up
with Arthur's much
aside from defeating the Northumbrians,
but only one of his battles
are given to Arthur,
Broin,
although other battles
such as Gwinon and the Glyne
have been theorized
to be located in this area.
The Gwinon, perhaps,
is even meant to be
the Battle of the Gwen Valley,
also fought by Urien,
but this isn't confirmed to any degree.
It's possible that Urien and Ambrosius
both form an overarching inspiration
for the figure of Arthur
in the Historia Brittonum.
Two successful generals
combating the encroaching Saxons,
one in the South
and one in the North,
with their victories
both being attributed to Arthur.
Again, though,
neither of these men are Arthur.
Arthur's career and life
are not concrete,
it isn't possible for him
to have fought all of these battles.
Urien and Ambrosius
just seem to have been
an inspiration for this figure
in the Historia Brittonum.
Arthur's name itself
must also have come from somewhere,
although as I said,
this name is very uncommon
amongst the Britons
prior to the 9th century.
It's important to note again
that we aren't looking
for a guy named Arthur
who fits this character,
because there is no individual
who fits this character.
We're looking for someone
who may have inspired him.
One candidate is
King Artur ap Pedair of Dyfed
in South Wales.
This name and kingdom was Irish,
which I made a video about
if you're interested,
but it was adopted into Welsh
as Arthur.
So the author of the Historia Brittonum
could have used this king
as inspiration,
but his Arthur wasn't a king,
and the author doesn't mention anything
about this region of Wales.
But even if he was knowledgeable
on this area,
this Arthur doesn't have
a very notable career at all.
He's hardly more than just a name.
Hang on,
did I just say that this name
came from Irish?
Does that mean Arthur was Irish?
No, he isn't connected
to a single Irish story
until the 13th century,
after Geoffrey of Monmouth's work
was translated.
Also, it's a bit misleading
to say that this name was Irish,
because it wasn't used in Ireland,
but it was used by Irish people
only in Britain.
If you aren't aware,
there was quite a substantial
Irish migration into Britain
following the Roman withdrawal,
and they adopted
plenty of uncommon names,
If you notice,
these are all Latin names.
Unlike the native Britons,
the newly arrived Irish
seemed to have been much more eager
to adopt the names of the Romans,
many of which would have still been
circulating around Great Britain,
including Arturius,
an Irish form of the Latin Arturius.
If Arthur entered Welsh from Artur,
Arturius,
and ultimately from Arturius,
then was there someone
with one of these names
that were an inspiration for Arthur?
If we go all the way back to Arturius,
then only a single candidate comes up,
Lucius Arturius Castus,
a senior officer in the Roman Sixth Legion.
This Lucius Arturius
led an army from Britain into Gaul
to suppress a rebellion,
which mimics King Arthur's invasion of Gaul
in Geoffrey of Monmouth's book.
But again,
Geoffrey was writing fiction,
we have no reason to believe
anything that he says.
In addition,
Lucius' career wasn't exactly famous
or notable in Britain.
If Geoffrey was mimicking anything,
it's much more likely that he was inspired
by one of the self-proclaimed Roman Emperors,
leading their legions from Britain
in an attempt to conquer Rome,
just like his King Arthur.
The Historia Brittonum's fondness
for Northern Britain
suggests that we should look up here too,
and if we do,
we find one Artur son of Aedon,
from the Irish kingdom of Dalriada.
This man, like Arthur,
was never a king,
instead he served as a general,
fighting against the Picts of Northern Britain.
The historian N. Hyams
suggests that this Arthur very well
could have inspired the author
of the Historia Brittonum,
as he is the only general
named Arthur that we know of,
although again it's worth noting
that he isn't suggesting
Artur is Arthur,
just that he inspired part of his character.
We have no records of this man
fighting the Battle of Badon,
or Browin,
or Chester.
The final mention of Arthur
that occurs before the Historia Brittonum
is actually in this manuscript.
At the very end,
two miracles are listed.
The first is the existence
of a giant pawprint
in a rock near Biest,
supposedly belonging to Arthur's dog,
and the second is a tomb
belonging to Arthur's son
that apparently changes in size
every time it's measured,
something that the author
has observed themselves.
If this miraculous portion
of the manuscript
is a part of the original document,
and this is disagreed upon,
then some portions of the legend of Arthur
appear to have already existed
by the 9th century.
Although these are hardly
the island-spanning adventures
of a leader of battles,
Arthur here is just Amelas,
a soldier,
connected with two legends
in southern Wales.
In fact,
Arthur is connected to this area
in many of the later Welsh myths too,
as his court is placed
at the town of Carleon here,
and the peak of the nearby mountain range,
Pen-y-Fan,
was known as Cadar Arthur.
The historian Enhaim also suggests
that Arthur may have been
a local legend
that was familiar to the author
of the Historia Brittonum.
Clearly, as we've seen,
the name already existed,
and the author said himself
that he's visited one of these sites.
Was a man named Arthur
a local figure
famous to the people of this region,
allowing the author
to easily adopt and adapt him
for a much grander purpose?
Maybe.
But that does depend on
if these miracles were a part
of the original manuscript,
and if they weren't,
then we're right back at square one.
Other people have suggested
some less-than-stellar candidates
for the origins of Arthur,
many of which end up ignoring
the fundamental fact
that you can't find an individual
who fits all of these attributes,
as they simply pick
and choose individual aspects
and try to fit them onto a person.
A common one is Athruis ap Mureg.
The theory goes that the names
are similar,
they lived in the same place,
and around the same time,
so they must be the same person.
Armed with all the knowledge
that you've already seen,
can you identify what's wrong with this?
That's right.
All of it.
Who says Arthur's from the 6th century?
Joffrey, the fiction writer?
Some of the saints' lives
place Arthur in the 5th century.
The Historia Brittonum
places him in the 7th.
Which one of these is correct?
Also, who says
that Arthur's from South Wales?
Some of the Welsh myths
place him at Caerleon, yes,
but some of the potentially
older stories of Arthur
connect him to Bruchaneog.
Athruis himself is also
not from the 6th century.
He lived at the same time
as a man named Saint Odocius.
His great-grandson died in 775.
His father is in charters
dated from 620 to 685.
The names are a bit similar,
but Arthur is consistently
spelt like this,
except for in Irish sources
and in a single 13th century manuscript.
No story about Arthur
ever spells his name as Athruis,
or as the older form Atreus,
and vice versa.
As I said,
this theory relies on simply
choosing these aspects
of the character of Arthur,
and then trying to find
someone who matches them.
This also disregards the fact
that Athruis is only ever
mentioned three times,
as a genealogical link
between his father and his son.
He's never referred to as a king,
and some of the early genealogies
leave him out.
Hardly the famous
island-spanning career of a legend.
Other theories place Arthur
outside of Britain entirely.
We've already discussed
how the Roman officer
may have inspired Joffrey
to write about Arthur
crossing the channel
to invade Gaul.
Although again,
he was probably inspired
by the way more famous
Roman emperors
who did the same thing.
But some have connected Arthur
to a unit of Sarmatian cavalry
that Lucius may have commanded.
This theory relies on
a connection to Arthurian mythology
that the historian Enhaim
describes as superficial,
except for a similar story
about the sword in the stone.
The problem though
is that the sword in the stone
was invented by French writers,
an interesting connection,
but it's one that comes up
500 years after
the first mentions of Arthur.
This isn't even mentioning
how this unit of Sarmatian cavalry
was very small,
stationed in only a single city,
and was so Romanised
that they weren't even considered
to be foreign troops.
Hardly the environment
for an island-spanning
cultural pollination.
And finally,
Rheothamas is a 5th century figure
whose career mimics that of Arthur.
Some people think
that this man is Arthur,
and that the reason
these names are so different
is that Rheothamas is a title.
Disregarding the fact
that we don't have any proof
that this is a title,
Rheothamas first appears
in a manuscript dated later
than Geoffrey of Monmouth's work,
meaning that his story
was almost certainly
just inspired from this.
As we've seen,
the figure of Arthur
that most people know
is a work of French fiction,
based upon centuries
of Welsh myths and legends.
These stories are not consistent.
They aren't depicting
the adventures of an individual.
They don't agree on when
or where Arthur lived,
if he was a king,
if he was Christian,
if he had a family.
Four different people
are named as his son,
but two of them become
regular people on other stories,
and the other two go unmentioned.
He has three different wives,
his knight becomes his father
in some stories,
and in others,
his mother phases
in and out of existence.
Historians are not looking
for an individual named Arthur
that has done all of these things,
because look at this,
it isn't possible to be
all of these things at once.
So many people attempt
to find Arthur
by picking and choosing
what to consider real
and what to consider fake,
despite the fact
that all of these stories are fake.
Arthur isn't named as a king
until Joffrey made him one.
Arthur's from Cornwall
or the north of Britain,
or Carillion,
or Breheniog,
depending on what story
you're reading.
He supposedly fought two battles
a hundred years apart
from each other,
despite the fact that
neither of these battles
are attributed to him.
Some people attach him
to people whose names
simply start with the same letter,
even though nothing else
about these people
match the figure of Arthur.
It's clear that
the oldest story of Arthur,
the Historia Brittonum,
made this name famous.
It hardly exists at all
before this.
His inspirations here
are sometimes obvious,
like the Saxon defeating commanders
of Urien Reged
and Ambrosius Aurelianus,
or the battle leader
of Selefsafgadai.
But other times,
they are not.
Why Arthur?
Why such a rare name?
Was the author inspired
by the glories
of the Brittonic prince Artur,
or perhaps a local legend
of a soldier in Breheniog
that the author
had heard of himself?
We don't know.
Arthur is one of the most
profoundly fascinating figures
in all of history,
whether you believe
that he was purely mythological or not,
to the people of the time,
he was very real.
Welsh society forgot about Arthur
and then re-adopted him
in the 1800s.
Even though he's commonly seen today
as an English or a French figure,
he has his origins here.
You may side with
Davies and Charles Edwards,
who think that Arthur
may have been a Welsh general
who we don't know anything about.
You may side with
Jackson's theory
that his origins lie in a praise poem
that's been completely lost to time.
You may believe
Haim's theory
that Arthur Mac Aden
was the original inspiration,
or that those old miracles
portray Arthur's origins
as a small, local legend.
Or maybe you believe
that Arthur was completely invented
by the author of the Historia Brittonum.
In the end,
this figure,
one of the most famous
and most arguable historical figures
of all time,
has his origins here.
We can't find a man
to fit all of these attributes,
but we can find the individuals
who made Arthur what he is.
A soldier, a general or a king,
living, fighting and dying in battles
centuries apart from each other,
none of which actually mention his name.
He was inspired by
Brythonic commanders
and Roman emperors.
He became one of the most influential figures
in all of history,
but his origins remain elusive.
There is no one individual
that inspired these stories of Arthur.
That isn't possible,
unless you pick and choose
what to consider real
and what to consider fake.
Historians have been searching
for the people
that made the earliest versions of Arthur,
and I hope I've shown you that today.
But for now,
the origins of Arthur
lie mostly in mystery.
Although maybe we've found the people
who inspired the character
in the first place.
Thank you very much for watching.
If you want to see more mysteries,
I made a video covering a mysterious kingdom
that went missing from medieval Britain.