King Arthur: Historical Roots - Medieval History DOCUMENTARY

Ancient Legends Around the World
22 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video traces the evolution of the King Arthur legend, from its origins as a gritty Celtic warlord protecting Romano-Britons to the romanticized, chivalric king of medieval literature. It examines how pagan elements were transformed into Christian symbols and concludes that while Arthur's historical existence is unprovable, his cultural legacy as a symbol of virtue remains enduring.
Few legends are as ubiquitous across the English-speaking world as that of Arthur,
King of the Britons. Everyone knows something about Arthurian legend, whether through childhood
storybooks or numerous adaptions. Less well-known, however, is the fact that the version of King
Arthur we all know is not the original one. Hidden amongst the gold-plated knights and
Christian artifacts of the High Medieval canon are remnants of a much more archaic tale,
with its foundations amongst the history and pagan folklore of the ancient Celts of Britain.
In this video, we'll explore the roots of the legend and try to figure out if Arthur
was a real historical figure. And you can even become a legend of Medieval Europe yourself by
playing Conqueror's Blade, the sponsor of this video. It's a free tactical MMO that now features
new content inspired by Medieval France with its Season 11 Paragons update. You fight in epic
15-player online battles for fields and fortresses, commanding units and siege engines on the ground,
and forging alliances with other players to compete in server-wide territory wars,
building yourself up as the foremost Medieval Warlord. Among the 85-plus Medieval units,
they've added three more styled after the chivalric champions of France – Alchemists,
who heal your wounded, Bannerguards, who buff your forces, and Chevaliers,
elite heavy cavalry who turn the tides of battle with powerful charges.
Take these and historical heroes like Joan of Arc into iconic battles of Medieval France,
like the Siege of Orleans and La Grande Gloire, and embark on the new seasonal campaign to earn
hundreds of rewards and exclusive French-themed gear, emotes, and more. And there are even more
updates and new seasons of content on the way, all for free! You can sign up to join Season 11
via our link in the description, which will also get you the Fleur de Lis unit attire for free!
The version of the Arthurian myth that most people know is the one developed in the High
Middle Ages. So, before we get to the deepest roots of Arthurian history, let us summarize
the evolution of the Medieval legend we're all familiar with. In 1136, English monk Geoffrey of
Monmouth finished his magnum opus, a Latin chronicle titled The History and the Kings of
Britain. This tome begins by claiming that the first king of Britain was a Trojan named Brutus,
who slew the island's native giant population, and tells a warped version of the Roman conquest
and rule over the island. A few chapters later, Geoffrey mentions the prophetic sermon of a
who uses his magic to facilitate the rise of the mighty Uther Pendragon to the British throne.
Uther's reign is spent fighting the principal foreign invaders of this era, the Saxons. But
later on, he falls in love with his chief rival's beautiful wife, utilizing Merlin's
shapeshifting magic to couple with her, thereby producing a bastard child named Arthur.
Eventually, Arthur succeeds his father and grows up to be a fine warrior known for wielding the
legendary sword Caliburn. Taking up the burden of the fight against the Saxons,
our titular hero subsequently trounces the Saxon king Curdic at the Battle of Badon. After this,
Arthur marries the beautiful Guinevere and then departs to conquer a huge chunk of Europe.
Geoffrey rounds off his tale when Arthur's nephew Mordred manages to seduce Guinevere
and usurp the British throne, forcing the king to return home and duel his treacherous relative,
where they both seem to have been fatally wounded at the Battle of Camlan.
Geoffrey wasn't the oldest historical chronicler to write about Arthur himself,
but with him, Arthurian canon as we know it today first took shape, forged with the inaugural
appearance of characters such as Merlin, Guinevere, and the iconic sword Caliburn,
later known as Excalibur. At the time of Historia Regnum Britanniae's completion and translation,
the culture of Christian nobility was undergoing a metamorphosis. The 12th century had seen an
influx of social influence from the Islamic world, from the Crusades and the Reconquista.
This had ultimately given rise to rituals of courtly love throughout the nobility,
particularly in the French-speaking world. Consequently, tales of Arthur captured the
imagination. Enter the French poet Chrétien de Troyes, who, inspired by the works of Monmouth,
composed his own anthology of Arthurian tales between the 1170s and 1190s.
While Monmouth attempted to cobble together a credible historical chronicle,
de Troyes' works read like a blockbuster action-adventure abound with heart-thumping romances,
beautiful maidens, and daring duels. It was in the Frenchman's writings that knights such as
Gawain, Percival, and Lancelot first appear in the high medieval canon. Perhaps the Frenchman's
greatest contribution, however, comes in his unfinished Percival the Story of the Grail.
In it, the young knight Percival encounters the mysterious Fisher King, ostensibly named because
of his fondness for fishing. Percival lodges in his home, which happens to be a mysterious
castle of delights, where time seems to stand still. There, Percival encounters a procession
of beautiful youths carrying a series of magnificent yet mysterious objects, a bloody
lance, a set of ornate candelabras, and finally, a shallow dish, which de Troyes called un graal.
This marks the first time that the grail appears in the Arthurian canon, although it isn't holy yet.
Over the next few centuries, various authors added bits and pieces to the developing canon,
during which the Christianization of key themes in the Arthurian mythos became common.
This is particularly evident in Robert de Boron's Joseph of Arimathea,
which reinterpreted the grail as the chalice that the titular Saint Joseph used
to catch the last drops of Jesus' blood as he hung on the cross.
The next major development came in the 13th century, when the anonymously authored Vulgate
Cycle expanded on the quest for the now definitively holy grail, this time with Lancelot
and Gawain on its sanctified trail. It is here that Arthurian romance as we know it today was
more or less fully developed, but as we stated in the beginning, these medieval authors were
not the true originators of the Arthurian mythos. To discover those origins, we must jump back nearly
a thousand years, to an era of British history shrouded almost entirely in mystery. The year is
500 AD, and Britain is inhabited principally by the titular Britons, an indigenous Celtic people,
who up until recently were subjects of Rome, an empire that had abandoned them. In the 5th and
6th centuries, social collapse was the order of the day. No longer supported by the infrastructure
of the empire, the most Romanized of the Britons were forced to abandon their heated villas and
gridded towns, and revert to a more rugged style of living. While politically the island fractured
into petty kingdoms ruled by warlords, for whom life was cheap and blood flowed freely.
To top off an already terrible situation, Germanic tribes like the Angles, Saxons, Frisians, and
Jutes had left their homelands, and through a mix of conquest and assimilation of the local Romano
Britons, slowly became the masters of Eastern Britain, eventually becoming the forebears of the
modern English people. Meanwhile, the native Celts who insisted on retaining their culture,
retreated to the hilly western regions of the island, eventually becoming the ancestors of the
modern Welsh people. It is in this era that Arthur first emerges as a pseudo-historical warlord,
fighting against the Saxons. The name first appears in a 6th century compendium of Welsh poems
known as the Gothadin. Here, a Briton hero named Gwawruddur was described as
not Arthur amongst equals in the might of feats. This line implies that Arthur was a well-known
figure to the 6th century Celts, and was considered the benchmark for heroism in his age.
Between the 7th and 10th centuries, the borders with the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms had
more or less crystallized. Although the Britons had lost much of what would become England,
they retained their independence throughout much of Cornwall, Cumbria, and Wales, and had
even managed to establish states in Brittany. As the age of Saxon invasions faded into generational
memory, it became remembered as an era of epic legend. In the courts of the Celtic kingdoms,
highly respected bards composed literary epics of warriors who performed great acts of heroism
while fighting the Saxons. Meanwhile, monks in Welsh monasteries chronicled the history of their
kings in Old Welsh, and it is in these enigmatic pages that we can find the more archaic, original
Arthur. Other than extremely fragmentary early poems like Gothadin, the oldest surviving account
of Arthur in Celtic literature lies in Nennius, a Welsh monk who lived in the 800s. His work
Historia Brittonum depicts Arthur as a glory-bound leader who bore the title dux bellorum, a Roman
word roughly translating to general or warlord. Nennius ascribes 12 great battles to Arthur,
who leads the Romano-Britons to victory against not just the Saxons, but also their Celtic cousins
from Scotland and Ireland. This all culminates in the dux's ultimate triumph at the Battle of Badon,
where Arthur crushes the Saxons so decisively that he eradicates their hold over Britain for
an entire generation. Another manuscript that seems to back up Nennius' testimony of Arthur's deeds
is the Annales Cambriae, a compilation of Old Welsh genealogies compiled around the 10th century.
The annals speak of the Battle of Badon, dating it to 514AD. It also briefly mentions Arthur's end,
claiming that in 537AD he and Mordred fell in the strife of Camlan. These accounts also line
up with those of the aforementioned Geoffrey of Monmouth, writing centuries later. A theme worth
noting in these texts is the more untamed version of Arthur they depict, in contrast to his depiction
in the medieval canon. While Geoffrey preserved Arthur's warrior spirit, the medieval French
romances that followed depict Arthur more as a regal, castle-bound monarch. Meanwhile, the Welsh
Arthur evokes the gritty imagery of a blood-soaked, battle-hardened warlord. Many other prominent
characters appearing in the medieval works also have potential roots in older Celtic literature.
The most obvious example of this lies in the medieval Welsh poem, Peredur son of Evraug,
whose main character and story beats seem to resemble Chrétien's Percival, the story of
the Grail. Although actually not much older than Chrétien's story, the Welsh Peredur is
nevertheless theorised to be directly derived from the same ancient Welsh folk story that Chrétien
based the Percival romance on. Another place where we can draw these types of parallels
lies in another Welsh poem, How Culhwch won Olwen. In it, Culhwch, son of Cyncylleth of Celython,
is bound by a curse to never marry, lest it is to the beautiful Olwen, daughter of the mighty
giantess Bethadan. To that end, Culhwch rides to the court of his cousin, the battle chief Arthur,
to ask for aid in winning his beloved's hand. Arthur pledges to help his wayward kinsmen,
and so he and his best men join Culhwch's cause. Among these men are the warriors Gwaelchmai,
Cai and Bedwyr. Together, they ride for Isbethadan's castle, where the giant king has
them complete a set of impossible tasks as a condition for giving up his daughter's hand
in marriage. At some point, Isbethadan demands that Culhwch and Arthur fetch for him the prized
pseudo-magical cauldron of Dionach, steward of the King of Ireland, and possibly also a giant.
Although originally received as guests by the Irish, hostilities quickly bubble once Arthur's
men try to take the cauldron. As a fight breaks out, one of Arthur's warriors, Ghencleog,
grasps Arthur's sword Caledwch and uses it to slay Dionach and all of his men. Subsequently,
they return to Britain with the cauldron in hand. A few more episodes of epic adventure follow,
culminating in Culhwch eventually obtaining Olwen's hand in marriage and ostensibly living
happily ever after. We can see clear similarities between the story of how Culhwch won Olwen and the
high medieval Arthurian romances of later centuries. For one, Arthur's warriors in Culhwch
seem to be an archaic Welsh version of the Knights of the Round Table. Gwaelcmai is an earlier version
of Sir Gawain, while Bedwyn and Cai are linked to Sir Bedwyr and Sir Kay, who feature in the
More dubiously, the Irish slaying warrior Ghencleog has been theorised to be the root for
none other than Lancelot. In addition to this, Culhwch's saga is where Arthur's legendary sword
Excalibur makes one of its earliest appearances in extant literature under its original name,
Caledwch, which might just be the old Welsh word for sword. As generations passed, the histories
and sagas left behind by the early medieval Welsh were preserved through manuscript or oral
tradition. These stories eventually fell into the hands of the high medieval authors. Thus,
Celtic warriors and magic cauldrons eventually became chivalrous knights and holy grails.
On that note, let us examine another angle by which we can examine the Celtic origins
of Arthurian romance, the relics of Celtic paganism still extant in the high medieval
stories. Although by the 6th century AD the Britons were a predominantly Christian people,
the stories they told still featured ancient Celtic themes, such as magic cauldrons,
enchanted boars and capricious pagan gods. These magical elements spotlighted heavily
in early Welsh Arthurian literature and accordingly were then brought into the
Latin and French romances, where their pagan roots were whitewashed and replaced with Christianised
backstories. The poster child for this retconning is none other than Merlin. In the 13th century,
French poet de Boron found Merlin's unexplained magic powers unsuitable for his Christian
sensibilities. Thus, he explained that the sorcerer must have been born as a biblical demon,
only to have his evil nature washed away by baptism, allowing him to keep his magic without
becoming the Antichrist. De Boron has effectively rewritten Merlin so that the Christians could
understand and accept him, but the sorcerer's true origins have little to do with Christian
scripture. Most of the academia agrees that Merlin's origins lie mainly in Myrthyn Wyllcht,
a mysterious character who appears in the Annales Cambriae and across several fragmentary Welsh
poems. From what we know of Myrthyn, he was some sort of bard, who upon witnessing the bloody
battle of Arderyth in 573AD went mad and fled into the forest, where he lived amongst the
beasts and received the gift of prophecy, invoking the imagery of a classic pagan druid, the caste
of priests who had been the law-keepers of Celtic peoples since ancient times. Pagan roots and
Christianisation can also be applied to the Holy Grail, which is often compared to the quintessential
magic cauldron of Celtic mythology. Originally associated with the goddess Ceredwen, enchanted
cauldrons feature several times throughout the Welsh Arthurian tales. To find one that inspired
the Holy Grail, we must look at the story of Branwen, daughter of Clear. This tale features
a magic cauldron capable of bringing dead warriors back to life, which is in the possession of an
magical giant king, Bran the Blessed, who was mortally wounded in the foot while committing
casual acts of genocide in Ireland. Meanwhile, in Detroit's story of the Grail, the Grail is a
supernatural serving dish of sorts, capable of miraculous acts of healing. It is in the possession
of a mysterious, implicitly magical monarch known as the Fisher King, who also suffers chronically
from a wound to the leg. Obviously, there are significant parallels between the magic cauldron
of resurrection in the Branwen story and the Grail of Chrétien de Troyes' story, making the case for
the Grail's literary origins as a magic cauldron even stronger. Of course, de Beron would later
erode away the Grail's implied pagan origins, much as he did with Merlin, this time shackling
its backstory to Christian saints and the blood of Jesus Christ. Having thoroughly examined the
origins of Arthurian romance and its roots in Celtic folklore, is it possible to confirm whether
or not there is any solid historical truth within the legends? Unfortunately, the answer is probably
not. All historians can confidently determine is that if he did exist, it was probably in 500AD
during sub-Roman Britain and the Age of Migrations. Over the centuries, many people have postulated
theories on the conditions under which a real Arthur might have existed during this era,
depicting him as everything from a pagan Irish warlord to a Roman general to a Sarmatian
horse lord. However, the fact of the matter is that none of these theories have enough evidence
to stand on, as almost none of the historical Arthurian literature we have today was actually
written in the era that he was supposed to have lived in. Naturally, the French-Latin medieval
stories of the 12th to 15th centuries are decidedly unhelpful in deciphering a real historical figure,
as they have distorted their original Celtic source material beyond recognition and are at
least 700 years removed from Arthur's 500AD timeslot. Even the more archaic Welsh texts are
historically dubious, as although they were written closer to the so-called Age of Arthur,
the oldest of them still only appears a few centuries after his time,
plenty of time for historical fact to distort into lore and legend, which clearly happened,
given all of the supernatural, magical elements in the Welsh Arthurian tales.
So, to summarise, it seems as if Arthur occupies a similar historiographic space as the works of
iconic tales of an era long gone, featuring quasi-historical themes, locations, and events,
but untangleable from the magic and mythology woven into its fabric as the story is retold
generation after generation. We will never know if there was ever a true Arthur,
but he was real to the medieval courtiers of 14th century France, who modelled their acts
of courtly virtue upon the lessons his stories set. He was real to the 9th century Welsh shepherds
of Powys and Gwynedd, who saw in him their direct ancestor, and a symbol of glory days gone by.
Finally, while we may have dismissed his existence in our modern world,
the impact that the seminal King of the Britons has had on our culture and social memory
will, for centuries yet, remain very real indeed. More videos on the historical realities of
legends are on the way, so make sure you are subscribed and have pressed the bell button to
see them. Please, consider liking, commenting, and sharing – it helps immensely. Our videos would be
impossible without our kind patrons and youtube channel members, whose ranks you can join via
the links in the description to know our schedule, get early access to our videos, access our discord,
and much more. This is the Kings and Generals channel, and we will catch you on the next one.
