The mysterious figure of King Arthur has fascinated generations of people all around the world. Countries and cultures still claim his as their own, as new theories point to the truth behind the romance of the Arthurian Legend. Who was Arthur, the central figure in a legend that has endured and grown for centuries? And where was Camelot, the great castle at the heart of that legend?
This episode focusses on the main man himself, King Arthur.
This video examines the evolution of King Arthur from a potential 5th-century British war leader into a global symbol of chivalry and hope. It explores the intersection of historical evidence, medieval literature, and political appropriation, while analyzing the theory that Sarmatian cavalry in Roman Britain provided the tactical and symbolic blueprint for the Arthurian legends.
Never has there been a figure as magnetically attractive as that of King Arthur.
For many centuries, he has been the archetypal hero,
instantly recognizable, not just in Britain, but throughout the Western world.
In fact, the words, King Arthur,
are practically a definition of what makes a hero in our Western civilization.
What is so special about this mysterious king?
In our cynical, world-weary times, we still hunger for stories of Arthur.
This says as much about us as it does about the once and future king.
But the sad fact of the matter is that Arthur, if he did exist,
lived in a time when events in Britain were so poorly documented
that it is hardly surprising that history and fantasy became entwined.
We all have our own idea of who King Arthur is, or was.
In the next hour, we will explore the phenomenon of Arthur,
from his shadowy 5th century origins as a British war leader,
to the very perfect medieval king.
There are many gateways to Arthur.
History, legend, myth, and romance.
They all lead to different Arthurs, yet they are all connected.
King Arthur is truly a hero for all seasons.
He has a universal appeal across cultures, nations, and centuries.
Arthur's story is a really good story.
Everything is there, power, sex, greed, and international relations.
There's war, there's love, there's sorcery,
and there's a link to the natural landscape.
Everybody is trying to claim Arthur.
The reason behind this is Arthur is hope.
Arthur is light at the end of the tunnel.
In the time of depression, there is always Arthur.
Arthur will return, make everything right.
The literally universal appeal of the Arthurian legend,
I think it must really find an echo in the human soul.
Arthur somehow reassures us that despite everything
that could be thrown against us, no matter what the task is,
no matter what the challenge might be, you can actually face it.
It's the spirit of Britain, it's the warrior spirit of Britain.
And that is, in essence, the spirit of Arthur.
And the spirit thus travels through many different people,
many different ages.
King Arthur.
Those two words still have the power to evoke a strange and beautiful world
where British history and Celtic mythology merge.
The truth is blurred, reality becomes whatever we want it to be.
And that holds true for the 5th, the 12th, the 15th, and even the 21st century.
Strangely, even nowadays, Arthur is probably remembered more vividly
than any number of kings whose historical existence is beyond doubt.
And yet, scratch beneath the surface of the legend,
and there are clues revealing a man, not a myth.
But the seed of the myth has been sown in the imaginations of the Britons
who witnessed Arthur's great deeds.
And each retelling of his story helped it to grow into the matter of Britain.
The matter of Britain is simply the Arthurian story.
In medieval Europe, there are three great bodies of legends.
There's the matter of Rome, which is the Greek and Roman myths,
including the Trojan War, Hercules, Jason, the rest of them.
There's the matter of France, which is the tales of Charlemagne and his court,
particularly Roland, the great French hero.
And there's the matter of Britain, which is Arthur's.
And it's interesting that it's the story of the matter of France,
which is the most specific to time and place,
and the most narrowly medieval, which has fallen through the gap.
And it's the matter of Britain, the matter of Rome, which feeds Hollywood to this day.
Unlike other historical figures,
the truth about Arthur has become so firmly entangled with the legend
that the two cannot easily be separated.
To find Arthur, we must start with the legend
and work our way back to the historical truth at its heart.
The legend is a treasure house of symbolism and imagery,
rather than historical evidence.
Yet, if we can learn to recognise their hidden meanings,
those same symbols and images can tell us so much about Arthur and his world.
The story of Arthur that most people are familiar with
is the one passed down to us from Sir Thomas Mallory in the 15th century.
It is highly likely that Mallory was a knight
who had taken part in the Wars of the Roses.
So, naturally, the Arthur he depicted is a reflection of his own world.
It was a world where chivalry was breathing its last.
In future, knights in armour with swords and lances
would increasingly find themselves up against gunpowder.
But the clash of sword on sword
and the armour-plated struggles so familiar to Mallory
are forever linked in our minds to the image of Arthur.
The book was one of the first books published,
printed in England by Caxton in 1485.
And it certainly is the basis of the story as we all picture it.
But Mallory was not original,
in the sense that virtually everything in his story
is translated from the French romances on the continent.
Mallory brought them together and made them into this,
I think, really the finest version,
certainly in English, of this whole matter of Britain.
In Mallory's story, Uther Pendragon lusted after Igraine,
the wife of Gaulois, Duke of Cornwall.
So he enlisted Merlin to make him look like Gaulois.
He spent the night with Igraine at Tintagel and Arthur was conceived.
Merlin placed the baby with an honest knight, Sir Hector,
to be raised without knowing his true parentage.
When Uther died, there was no apparent successor.
To resolve the matter, Merlin produced a sword in an anvil on a block of stone
and proclaimed that whoever could draw it out was rightful king.
Many tried, but only Arthur succeeded, as Merlin had always known he would.
As soon as he was enthroned, Arthur faced rebellion from his nobles,
but emerged victorious.
He received a new sword from the Lady of the Lake, the magical Excalibur.
He married the fair Guinevere.
He established the round table at his court at Camelot,
attracting many brave and good knights,
including the incomparable Sir Lancelot, who was appointed the Queen's champion.
While Arthur was away fighting, Guinevere and Lancelot became lovers.
After the quest for the Holy Grail had ended,
their adultery was exposed by the evil Mordred.
Mordred was a result of Arthur's unwittingly incestuous coupling with his sister Morgan,
and he burned with hatred for his father.
Arthur had no choice but to condemn his wife to death for her crime,
but Lancelot rescued her just as she was to be executed.
The lovers fled.
Arthur pursued, unwisely leaving his son as regent.
News reached Arthur that his son had declared himself king.
Bitterly, he returned to confront the poisonous Mordred.
The two sides met in battle on Salisbury Plain.
Mordred met his death at Arthur's hand,
but dealt his father a fatal blow to the head before he fell.
Knowing he was near death,
Arthur ordered that Excalibur should be cast back into the waters it had come from.
Then, a barge carrying many fair ladies sailed into view.
The sound of their weeping came over the water.
They laid the dying king in the barge,
and took him away to the mystical Isle of Avalon.
But some said he did not die,
and had gone to Avalon for the healing of his wounds.
Others claimed he slept,
waiting until his land had need of him.
Then he would return.
Rex condam et futurus.
The once and future king.
It's Thomas Mallory as the end point of the medieval Arthurian legend.
He's simply the wrap-up,
which puts it all in a set of stories that link together,
and make a nice harmonious whole.
And as the end point,
he's drawing upon what, by his time,
would have been maybe 800 years of literature.
So he's very well read.
He certainly got through all the French and the English romances
of the last three or four hundred years.
And what he's out to do is synthesize the lot.
So Mallory's somebody who's drawing upon a very big body of literature,
and using it really well.
Mallory says that he wrote the book in prison,
or at any rate, he refers to himself.
He says, pray for the night prisoner,
which has suggested he may have been a rather violent character
among these Mallories.
And he certainly knows all about combat and warfare, and enjoys it.
He was imprisoned eight times minimum.
These charges included attempts of murder, rape,
robbing from churches, abusing the clergy.
So we have this man who is putting down on paper
the ideal chivalry code,
and is himself virtually the opposite of it.
He was no Sir Lancelot.
Caxton could not have known when he published it in July 1485
that, barely a month later,
Henry Tudor would win the crown and end the Wars of the Roses
when he marched into battle at Bosworth
under a fluttering dragon banner, the emblem of Arthur.
The matter of Britain had become real again.
Henry was not the first king to use Arthur.
Kings from William the Conqueror right through to Charles I
found ways to claim kinship with him.
In fact, when Henry Plantagenet was crowned in 1154,
he wasted no time in presenting himself to the nation
as the legitimate heir of King Arthur
to win over his reluctant British subjects.
In the legitimacy stakes,
the Tudor dynasty had more justification than some.
With its roots deep in Welsh earth,
it could rightly claim to represent
the original British population
that Arthur had defended so many centuries before.
One of the really fascinating problems
in identifying Arthur's historical figure
is the complete failure of any royal families
to trace the blood link back to Arthur.
The obvious people to do it are the Welsh princes,
who, after all, are the descendants,
the people Arthur's supposed to have ruled.
And not a single family tree
in a culture which loved family trees, like title deeds,
traces a family back to Arthur.
On the other hand, there may be some of the loss that did so.
What monarchs do later
is try and identify themselves
as the inheritors of Arthur's land
and give themselves a spiritual link with Arthur,
which is why Richard the Lionheart is Cocker Hoop
when the monks of Glastonbury
claim to have dug Arthur up on English soil,
which, of course, Richard rules.
That's why Edward I,
just before he starts bashing the Welsh and bashing the Scots,
is very keen indeed to identify himself as the heir of Arthur.
And Henry VIII, the greatest egomaniac
of the early modern period,
the king of the Reformation,
the king of the superabundance of royal palaces,
chooses to paint himself as Arthur
on the round table at Winchester.
So Arthur is a kind of theme
taken up by exceptionally ambitious monarchs
as a way of putting some glitter
on what they intend to do anyway.
Mallory's story was the culmination
of centuries of tales told about Arthur.
It drew on many sources,
particularly the French romances,
which themselves sprang from pioneering books
like Geoffrey of Monmouth's History of the Kings of Britain.
Published in 1138, it was a bestseller.
Geoffrey brought Arthur out of the Celtic twilight
into the sunlight of popular recognition.
Geoffrey of Monmouth is one of the most amazing characters
of the Middle Ages.
At the time, he was called a prized liar
by a lot of good scholars.
He was an appallingly bad historian,
if historian he was.
There are descriptions of kings who,
if they lived, were in the 7th century
or living in the Iron Age or even almost Bronze Age.
There are verbatim accounts of conversations,
letters written at a time
long before writing existed in Britain,
so it's clearly fiction and it reads like fiction to us
and it's rather surprising that anyone ever believed it.
But one can't dismiss Geoffrey.
On each re-reading, I see clearly that 90 or 95%
is his own cheerful invention and very entertaining,
but behind it is a 5%,
which is well worth the historian's investigating.
Prior to Geoffrey's attentions,
Arthur's name and exploits crop up in various texts.
Early church records,
well-meaning histories,
ancient genealogies,
miraculous lives of saints,
Welsh poems and stories
such as the Black Book of Carmarthen
and the Book of Taliesin.
These sources record a hazy time in British history
where historical fact can be interwoven with myth.
If Arthur existed,
it is this age in which we will find him.
The real Arthur belongs in a time
when the Roman Empire withdrew from Britain
after four centuries of occupation and integration,
leaving the inhabitants to fend for themselves
against attack from all sides.
Saxons, Angles, Jutes,
Frisians, Picts, Irish raiders.
It was a time of hardship, bloodshed and political turmoil.
Central government was in meltdown.
Military capability practically non-existent.
And gradually, the former province of Britannia
split into warring factions,
reassembling along the old Celtic tribal lines,
each with its own chief or king.
The so-called Arthurian period
fits very neatly into the gaping records of history.
It really is the Dark Ages.
What we face is a Roman Britain
in the process of meltdown.
It's literally a land of ruins,
huge ruined towns, great ruined walls,
legionary fortresses, aqueducts,
just melting into the landscape as they moulder away.
And left among these ruins are a group of people
busted down to an impoverished subsistence agriculture,
in other words, peasants farming small tracts of land.
They're people living in the ruins of
the closest thing today being a nuclear holocaust
and trying to pick up the pieces.
The only really real contemporary writer
living at the time of when Arthur would have lived
is the possibly monk, certainly,
Ecclesiastic Gildas,
who wrote about the middle of the 6th century.
And he describes the departure of the Romans,
the coming, the invitation to the Saxons
to help the Britons against the Picts and the Scots.
How the Saxons then themselves,
having been invited in,
became a dreadful menace and began to overrun the island.
And then, he says, there arose a leader,
Ambrosius Aurelianus,
the last of the Romans who fought successfully.
There then came a period,
and he seems to imply that there's a big gap of a generation,
until that famous victory at the Battle of Bowden Hill
when the heathens were slaughtered.
And since then, we have enjoyed peace.
Somebody around 416
imposed such a serious defeat on the Anglo-Saxons.
And caused such genocide upon them.
It halted for 40 years their advance into Britain.
And there is evidence to prove,
in certain cases,
it caused some of them to re-migrate back to Gaul.
The traditional view has been
that this reverse in Saxon fortunes was down to one man
who managed to unite his squabbling, disorganised countrymen
and lead them to victory.
The name we have given to that man
is Arthur.
The evidence from this period for the existence of Arthur
is, at best, dubious.
Yet, his name seems to echo down the ages.
The earliest references could even date
from very nearly within the lifetime of Arthur and Merlin themselves
because there's a very early Welsh poem called the Gododdin
about an expedition of warriors fighting the English
towards the end of the 6th century.
And Arthur, after all, if he lived, was at the beginning.
And in one verse, it says of a certain warrior who was killed,
he blotted ravens before the rampart,
but still he was no Arthur.
In other words, Arthur was a much more magnificent figure
probably than any normal warrior could hope to be.
Which means that within two generations of the real Arthur,
he had become this magnificent figure
or was remembered as this magnificent figure.
Arthur is also mentioned in passing
in some church documents called the Welsh or Easter Annals.
Written down between the 8th and 10th centuries,
they possibly draw on earlier records going back as far as the 6th century.
Two brief entries for the years AD 518 and 539
refer to Arthur's victory at the Battle of Badon
and then the Stryford Camlan in which Arthur and Mordred perished
and there was plague in Britain and Ireland.
And that is all.
Every other person named in the annals,
and there are over a hundred, is a genuine historical figure.
It is hard to see how Arthur and Mordred could be fictitious in that context
and tempting to conclude, therefore, that they are not.
Another early appearance of Arthur is in the History of the Britons.
This was a 9th-century hodgepodge of historical fact and fable
compiled by a Welsh monk called Nennius.
He began by saying that Arthur was not high-born.
There were many more noble than he.
And he described 12 battles,
probably borrowed from much older accounts.
Interestingly, he called him Dux Bellorum,
leader of battles or war leader.
Dux is a title for high-ranking officers
within the later Roman military command structure.
It roughly equates to duke or leader.
Some scholars see in Dux Bellorum
a continuation of Roman military traditions
by a commander-in-chief struggling to defend a very Roman way of life.
Others take the view that it simply underlines that,
whatever else he was, Arthur was not a king.
I think you've got to place him at that time
when the Romans were beginning to collapse.
And I think he was a Roman soldier.
Maybe he wasn't so much a king, but he had to end up being a king
because he was probably the leader of all those peoples
who lived all over the British Isles
who had got to like living like Romans.
In the very, very first sources, it could be that he is a king.
The title he's given is Dux Bellorum, famously,
which means leader of the battles,
which could mean that he's a local king who becomes a paramount
leading a confederacy of other petty rulers.
Or it could be that he's a mercenary or a professional
who's brought in as a leader for all the troops.
Or it could be that he's even a late Roman official
existing long after the fall of Rome using a Roman title,
which entitles him to coordinate the various troops of Britain.
When the armies went back and the legions went back,
they left a power structure that was already set up.
Quite a lot of their troops would have had land here,
would have had wives here.
They would have stayed.
The power base would have been there.
They'd have been in power for two or three generations.
Necessarily, they wouldn't have wanted to go back
and fight in the Roman wars
because they had their land, they had the power.
This is a nice system.
They'd have stayed and they'd have tried to keep the Roman ideals going,
the Roman values, the Roman civilization
as they knew it in Britain at the time.
Was Arthur one person?
The defence of Britain against the Saxon hordes
would have required Arthur
to appear in many different locations at once.
Some historians believe that the only explanation for this
is that there was more than one person resisting the invaders
and the myth of a British war hero
is an amalgamation of many local memories.
Other scholars believe that this need for mobility
points to Arthur having been a cavalry officer.
I think he had to get himself organised
as a leader of people who were actually horsemen.
I think he was the leader of a...
If he was a soldier, a cavalry regiment.
And he could move quickly from place to place.
The whole idea of the Romano cavalry was that it could move.
It was a force that carried itself.
It had everything it needed
and it was designed to go to troubled spots.
And it would do Harrison attacks.
It would wear them down.
It would give them sleepless nights.
The legend would have been used as Arthur is appearing everywhere.
Arthur is attacking Anglo-Saxon invaders from all quarters.
They wouldn't have known what would happen.
It was almost like the Jesse James syndrome in the States.
If anybody robbed a train, it was Jesse James.
If you got attacked, it would have been Arthur.
Nennius had more about Arthur in a section of his history
entitled The Wonders of Britain.
The two marvels concerning Arthur seem to have no basis in fact,
though both recall his origins by naming him Arthur the Soldier.
There's the imprint of his gigantic hound
on a stone in South Wales.
And there's the tomb of a son of his,
of whom nothing else is known,
which, however many times you try to measure it,
the measurements will always be different the next time.
He's become already a magical and superhuman figure.
And that's in Nennius' history written in 829.
That is three centuries later, but still in very early times.
Nennius also has another interesting story in his pile of documents,
all about dragons.
The story related by Nennius was a pure myth
and probably already a very ancient tale by the time he discovered it.
In it, the High King Vortigern,
having betrayed the British people to the Saxons,
was trying to protect himself by having a fortress built in the mountains.
But no matter how much was built by day,
at night it was swallowed up again.
Vortigern's magicians told him a child should be sacrificed,
but one with no earthly father.
The young Merlin, known then as Ambrosius, was just such a child.
Brought before the king, he challenged the magicians
to say what lay beneath the foundations of the castle.
Of course, they could not.
Merlin prophesied that a deep pool was under it,
and beneath that, two hollow stones inside which slept two worms,
one white, one red.
The pool was found and drained.
Sure enough, two stones were revealed.
As Vortigern and his retinue looked on in wonder and fear,
the worms were released and began to struggle with each other.
Vortigern demanded to know what this battle signified.
Merlin replied that the worms represented two dragons.
The white one was the dragon of the Saxons,
who had been welcomed into Britain and had seized much of it.
The red worm represented the dragon of the British people,
who had been driven out.
He foresaw that the brood of the white dragon
would possess nearly all the land from sea to sea,
but that one day the red dragon would rise up
and throw the English back across the sea they had come from.
The red dragon is now instantly recognised
as the national emblem of Wales and its people.
But how did this exotic and mythical creature
come to be associated with the descendants of the Britons?
And why red rather than another colour?
The answers can be found by following the trail of the dragon back to its home.
Dragons feature strongly in the world of Arthur,
but not as monsters to be slain.
They had great importance in their own right.
In fact, Arthur's name, Pendragon, is a good example.
In early Welsh, pen meant head and dragon had come to mean leader.
Arthur would have been a Pendragon, meaning head dragon,
and the head dragon was the battle chieftain,
rather similar in nature to other cultures
where you'd have a shogun, for instance.
It would be exactly the same.
Rather than Arthur as a king or an emperor,
he was a battle chieftain in the same way
that other cultures had battle chieftains for that purpose.
Arthur himself was described by one bard as the victorious dragon
and was praised for his glorious slaughter
of the Saxons at the Battle of Badon.
He often wore a helm with a dragon crest in the medieval tales,
not to be confused with St George.
He was the dragon who defeated his foes, the Saxons.
The red dragon was his emblem and stood for both him and his people.
But the question still remains,
how did a red dragon come to be associated with Arthur
and the British in the first place?
Some scholars suggest a strange possibility,
that the red dragon came from the steppes of Russia,
north of the Black Sea.
We have already seen how the Arthur stories
had made much of his military prowess.
And in his title, Dux Bellorum,
we can hear the distant echo of Rome's armies.
In order to make sense of the Arthur puzzle,
we must remember that legends have to grow out of substance.
It's not unreasonable to say that the real Arthur
would have lived in a world shaped by more than 400 years
of Roman roads and buildings, culture and customs,
law and language.
That heritage did not disappear overnight.
The Dark Ages did not suddenly fall on Britain
like a heavy grey curtain.
On the contrary, things fell apart gradually, imperceptibly.
And for Arthur, placed within a generation or so
of Rome's abandonment of Britannia,
his way of life was still worth fighting for.
He may well have been proud of his Roman inheritance
and that included his Christian beliefs.
With heathen Saxons pushing ever westward,
it was another powerful reason to resist them.
If he did exist, round about 500,
which is where the stories put him,
then he was certainly a Christian for the simple reason
that we have no evidence of surviving paganism,
particularly among the upper classes,
by the end of the 5th century.
And all of the oldest traditions of Arthur
portray him very clearly as a Christian monarch.
In fact, there aren't any traditions that do otherwise
until the 20th century.
And the new desire to put Arthur
at the interface of paganism and Christianity
tells us much more about the religious dilemmas
at the beginning of the 21st century
than it does about the Middle Ages.
You've got to realise that in Dark Age Britain,
that yes, there was Christianity,
but you've also got to realise that a lot of the writers
who have written up the legends in years to come
are writing from a very church-backed monarchy.
And so they are making Arthur out to be very Christian.
If you actually look at the evidence to support that,
there is none.
The only evidence we see is the Merlin figure,
which is quite obviously going back to pagan Britain
and a Druid advisor.
So the likelihood of the original Arthur
actually being a Christian is pretty doubtful in my mind.
Part of Arthur's heritage was a military one.
More specifically, it was a strong cavalry tradition.
The Romans had always made a point
of recruiting the warriors of their conquered enemies
into regiments.
In this way, they could take them from their homelands
and control them,
using their skills in the service of Rome.
And when the nomadic Sarmatian warriors
of the Russian steppes were finally conquered,
the Romans already knew that these were the most advanced,
well-equipped and effective cavalrymen
that they had ever come across.
They would make a formidable addition
to the garrison of Britannia.
And it would keep them out of trouble.
This was the reason for the sudden influx in AD 175
of 5,500 Sarmatian horsemen and their mounts into Britain.
Transported across a continent, Black Sea to North Sea,
they were stationed at first
with the Sixth Legion on Hadrian's Wall,
where some of their horse armour has been found,
and later transferred to Ribchester,
a fort guarding the Pennines.
It must have made an incredible impact on the locals.
To put it into proportion,
the garrison of Britain had about 11,000 cavalry
shortly beforehand.
To ship over half as many again in one transfer
and to one area must have been overwhelming.
The Sarmatians were a ferocious nomadic people,
living as wagon dwellers on the grasslands
of the steppes of what is now Russia.
They were not averse to robbing, raiding and extortion
to supplement their wandering lifestyle.
They were also superb horsemen, fearless and hardy.
Their heavily armoured cavalry
would break through any battle line.
Wearing conical segmented iron helms,
their bodies protected by suits of scale armour,
their principal weapon was a six-foot long lance
held double-handed,
though they had great two-handed swords for close combat.
For 3rd century cavalry,
they would not have looked entirely out of place
at the Battle of Hastings.
Understandably, many scholars see in them
the prototype for the medieval knight.
Basically, what Arthur inherited was a Dark Age SAS.
These people were efficient.
They were mobile.
They were self-reliant.
They would fight on horseback.
They would use a lance.
There was evidence of bow use.
They could also be used as infantry.
They were used to working together.
They could scout.
They could be used as heavy shock troops.
They could go in and pick at you
and snipe at you with javelins and bows.
These were highly trained professional troops
that had been practising it for generations.
The skills were passed on.
The armour was adapted, used.
They would be covered in chain mail or scale mail.
They were heavily armoured.
And because of the reflective ability and everything,
all this armour would glitter in the sun.
The thing about Romanisation was
the Romans believed if you got it, flaunt it.
And it came out in their weapons and in their armour.
It was practical, but it was also showing.
It is quite feasible that heraldry
might have developed from the Sarmatian custom
of attaching pictorial flags and banners
to their lances before they charged.
Known as tamgas, these banners bore strange designs,
neither picture nor word.
They were like property or tribal marks,
pre-Christian and mysterious in origin.
By far the most striking of these banners
was the type known as the draco.
This was a hollow, open-jawed dragon's head,
usually of bronze, joined to a long windsock
of fine material, usually in red,
and mounted on a long pole.
A standard is necessary in cavalry.
It gives you a focus point.
It can give you directions.
You follow the standard.
The Sarmatians who came over with the Roman army,
the Roman army also adopted it,
was the dragon standard.
The windsock, the hollow head,
the tail billowing out behind
with the movement of the horses.
It would be funnelled through the mouth
and the tail would wave.
It was visible.
It was quite scary as well.
You've seen this giant standard waving around
on top of a load of armoured horsemen.
It wouldn't be a pleasant sight.
So Arthur, if he was related to the Roman cavalry,
the Sarmatians,
the dragon standard would already be there.
So they would just take it on board.
It would become Romano-British again,
but not realising probably where it came from,
it was always there.
It was always used.
It was their standard.
By the 4th century,
all the legionary cohorts,
cavalry and infantry,
carried the dragon standard.
It came to represent the might of the Roman army,
just as the eagle had done.
So it would have been the most natural thing in the world
for the dispossessed ex-Roman citizens of Britain
to rally to the red dragon.
Those knights who patrolled Hadrian's Wall
would mix into the Celtic culture
and would mix into the ancient British culture
and the post-Roman Britain
and would fight alongside the Celts
and the natives against any proposed invaders
such as the Irish raiders or the Saxons.
So you could actually end up with Sarmatian cavalry,
with Asian cavalry,
being at home in England
and training Romano-British.
Well, they would become nationalised.
They would be Britons as far as they were concerned.
Two or three generations on,
they would have almost forgotten their roots.
They would be British,
but they would be trained in the ways of their old country.
So they are heavily cavalry-oriented,
which is what the Romans were building up to.
The horsemen of the red dragon
became the knights of King Arthur.
Their draco turned into the Welsh draig,
a thing of bronze, wood and silk
at the head of a cavalry charge,
changed into the guardian and protector
of a people's identity.
We know instinctively that legend works like that.
At turning points in history,
significant connections are made by eyewitnesses to those events.
But time is a distorting lens,
and to us, the connections may no longer be visible.
This is never more true than in the world of Arthur,
because, strangely,
there seems to be another link between his legend
and the Sarmatian cavalrymen.
The most sacred emblem of the Sarmatians
was the image of a naked sword thrust into the ground.
This is what Ammianus Marcellinus,
the 4th century historian, has to say.
In their country is neither temple nor shrine,
nor even thatched hut,
only a naked sword stuck into the soil,
which they worship with due reverence.
Such is the war god who presides over the lands on which they wander.
Blade worship is actually quite common to an awful lot of cultures.
The blade does represent the ultimate injustice.
It is only possessed by the rich.
People spend months and months making this.
It is also the highest technology that that civilisation is capable of.
But it has mystical qualities.
Early on in man's history,
the ability to smelt iron and forge metal
bestowed an almost magical advantage
on the tribe or people who possessed that secret knowledge.
In fact, the metalworkers and alchemists
who drew out the iron from ore or stone
often had to hide from the society they served
to protect their secrets.
Deep in forests and mountain refuges,
their seclusion gave rise to the tale of dwarves and wizards legend.
The blade, you must remember, they believed in only four elements.
There was earth, wind, fire and water.
All these are used in the smelting process of iron
and even more so in the forge for producing the blade.
So this blade has been endowed
with all the mystical qualities from the four elements.
So the spirits of all those four elements
are trapped in the blade and imposed in that blade.
So the blade has a mystical quality.
It is magical.
So removing it from a stone is the iron being removed from the ore.
Moving it from an anvil, as it is later in some of the later history,
is just relating how all these mystical qualities
have been imposed into the blade in the blacksmith's forge.
That is one way to understand the story of the sword in the stone.
But on another level, perhaps the Sarmatian's most secret image really
was just handed down through successive Roman cavalry regiments
until Arthur, commander-in-chief of a newly forged Roman cavalry force, inherited it.
Even as a Christian, he would have understood the need to clothe himself
in the traditions of the Roman cavalry
to emphasize his continuity with that glorious past.
Like a giant golden sun,
he has always exerted a strong gravitational pull on myths and characters,
even from outside the legend.
The Celtic peoples of the island of Britain
had always practised the ritual of sacrificing precious offerings,
like jewellery and weapons,
by throwing them into lakes, rivers and wells dedicated to the old gods.
There is a strong echo of this in Arthur's sword Excalibur.
It was given to him by the lady of the lake.
He made sure it was returned to her as he lay dying.
Three times he asked the knight Sir Bedivere to throw it into the lake nearby,
but only on the third time of asking could Bedivere bring himself to obey.
As Excalibur whirled through the air, glittering in the moonlight,
a hand came up out of the water and caught it,
brandishing it three times in homage to the dying king.
Then it was drawn down under the pale silver waters and was gone forever.
If there is anything really, really authentic in the entire Arthurian legend
that links to actual practice,
it's that heart-stopping moment when Sir Bedivere chucks the sword back into the lake.
Because when rivers are dredged in many parts of England,
you find Iron Age swords, often the most exquisite workpersonship,
deposited there.
And since many of these places are deep pools, they're not river crossings,
the chances that these things are just lost,
that somebody was boating across and lost his sword are virtually nil.
These are sacred offerings put in there probably as gifts to deities
and as part of a great tradition of putting hefty metalwork in sacred water,
which goes on for a thousand years.
There is one final strange twist to the story of Arthur's sword
and, once more, the summations are involved.
One of the tribes of this barbarian people was the Alans.
Their only descendants, the Ossetis, still inhabit the steppes of Russia to this day
and they have a story about one of their heroes,
Batrads, who was fatally wounded
and told two of his companions to throw his sword into the water.
Twice, they pretended they had done it.
But when they finally threw in the sword,
the water turned blood red and turbulent.
Did this story come to Britain with the Sarmatian horsemen
along with the red dragon and the sword in the stone?
Personally, I don't believe a word of this theory.
First of all, the legend of throwing a sword into a lake,
returning it to the maiden who lives at the bottom of the lake,
is certainly not confined to the Sarmatians
and far more likely to have existed among the Britons already.
Secondly, there's a common mistake of thinking that
because these Sarmatians happen to be a unit of heavy cavalry,
immediately the mind leaps to Arthur and his knights.
But there's actually no evidence of any sort to suggest
that the Arthur of history was particularly renowned for using cavalry.
So the story, this theory to me, seems completely fanciful.
The main problem with Arthur is it is Dark Ages.
The reason why they're called the Dark Ages
is we virtually know nothing about them.
Our history is dark.
Arthur keeps most historians going in their afterlife arguing about him.
He is immortal just through the arguments,
let alone the legends.
History is a confusion.
And we've really got problems, haven't we,
when we're trying to work out who on earth was Shakespeare.
You know, there's a rumour that he really didn't exist.
He was someone else.
So if you've got problems with defining who Shakespeare is,
it's the same problem with Arthur.
It seems that with Arthur, anything is possible.
It is a natural human instinct to prefer the miraculous to the commonplace.
If we could find comprehensive answers to the enigma of Arthur,
to pin him down for once and for all,
we would be the poorer for it.
As things stand, we can still choose to believe
that he waits for the time of his people's greatest need
and that he will return to help us.
Rex Quondam et Rex Futuris.