The Critical Thinking Crisis Nobody's Talking About

Charley’s Garage
78 followers
Critical thinking ability is at an all time low, teachers and parents need to step it up with this while the kids are young!
#diesel #training #automobile #mechanic #tech #basics #hydraulics #cummins #pumps #criticalthinking #teachers #parents
Hi everyone. There was a discussion I saw recently on LinkedIn and they were talking about whether
the perception of Gen Y as being lazy, unmotivated, and carefree, and not giving an F basically,
and whether or not that was true. And of course you had people who thought,
yeah there is some problem with that with this generation, and other people saying it's just
a difference in opinion, and if you give them certain info and facts that you wouldn't have
had to have done with other generations, they'll come around. And you know, I kind of agree with
that. I think describing everyone based off of when they were born is kind of unfair,
and you can speak in generalities all you want, but I've had, I deal with different types of
people every day. So at a school like this one here, you have all kinds of people that
are here for different reasons and different motivation levels. Some people come to this
school because they love being a mechanic, they love knowing how things work, and how to put them
together, how to take them apart, how to diagnose them, how they work together, and they pay
attention, they take notes, they ask questions, they do everything, right? But even, and then
you got the students that are, so example, some older people who are veterans are using their GI
bill. Some of those guys are here because they legitimately want to be a technician,
and they want to learn this stuff and go out there and have a good career post-military doing this,
and there's other veterans that come here and just do the bare minimum to get by because
they're just basically soaking up their benefits that they earn, they have a right to use them
however they want, and they're just kind of still trying to figure out what they want to do in life,
and they don't have a plan yet, and it doesn't necessarily mean they're going to be a diesel or
an auto tech when they finish this school. They might decide after this to go to a community
college and learn something else and be a legal aid for all I know, right? But for right now,
they're just kind of coasting through the process, and then I get the ones that mom and dad said,
you need to get out of our house and go find a job, and they said, what if I went to school,
and this was the conclusion. So they're the ones that miss as much time as they can down to the
wire and still pass who come to school and then disappear out of class and come back later and
don't pay attention, don't ask questions, and everything else. So like I said, the entire
spectrum of what you would expect at a school with the entire society coming to a school here.
So that's why I say I don't like to put generalizations on a generation because I've
got some Gen Y students that were super awesome, right? Some of them are some of the smartest
young people I've ever met that instinctively picked up on things, asked questions, and got
to what the point of this video is, is that the one thing I do see a weakness in across all that
spectrum and younger people, whether they're good at what they do in school or good at their job or
whatever, the common weakness I see in almost everybody below a certain age is critical
thinking skills. I can give a class full of entire people information where the answer
should be obvious, and they can't answer that question, right? I could tell them, you know,
I could tell them that A is 2 and B is 3 and C is, and they can't figure out that 2 plus 3 is 8,
or you know, they can't think critically enough to come up to an answer to a problem,
and that's a problem in the industry that I teach because you have to be a critical thinker.
You have to understand the relationship between complex components and how they behave together
and know things about both things and be able to come up with a third option, right?
My ABS light is on, and they, you know, can't come up with, well, ABS is controlled by wheel
speed sensors that connect with the computer that also can connect with the engine and do
torque adjustments, and they can't put all that information together and come up with thoughtful,
what could the problems be, right? I just went through an entire lecture the other day where I
talked about HPITP fuel systems and talked about how the plungers in the injector have a space
between an upper plunger and a timing plunger and that we put fuel in between those two to advance
and retard the timing. Basically makes it where the stroke squeezes the fuel faster or it takes
longer depending on how much fuel there is between the two, and then I immediately asked what kind
of problem would air in the fuel cause in relation to this, and I got 15 blank stares. Not a single
person, remember from previous classes or even in the classes that I've personally taught them,
that air is compressible and that if you put air in that gap, it's going to affect the timing.
Not a single person can come up with that, and it seems like you have to basically hand people
the answer on a platter and say, here you go, before they can come up with it on their own,
and part of that is not paying attention, so I would say probably half of that group wasn't
listening to what I was telling them, that's why they couldn't come up with the answer,
and the other half just don't have the experience and critical thinking of putting together pieces
of information to come up with an answer, and I blame parents and I blame public schools,
right? When I was a kid, I was taught by my teachers at school that, you know, this was this,
and this was this, and then I would see questions on tests and in papers or on whiteboards and
blackboards of why is this, and I would have to look back at my notes and go, okay, this is this,
if this is this and this is this, that causes that, and we learned that stuff, right? We had the,
if a train leaving San Francisco going to Chicago traveling this fast and this,
we had to figure out what that third piece of information was with the information given to us,
and if we got the answer wrong, yeah, sometimes the instructor would say, look, here's the answer
and here's why it's the answer, but they would follow that up with, here's another problem just
like that one with different numbers, now go figure it out, and eventually we would figure
that out. We've learned critical thinking that way. Our parents back in my time, they
also didn't necessarily give us something for nothing. I didn't get an allowance where my
parents would give me X amount of money every week. I had to, you know, do a chore, I get this
much money, you want to move along, I get this much money. If I didn't get enough money from
my parents for something I wanted, I was critical thinking that, hey, if they're not giving me
enough money, I need to go find out what other people need done to make money, and so I would go
to the local restaurants and say, hey, can I pick up the trash in your parking lot for five bucks?
You know, that's critical thinking. I wanted X, how do I get to X, come up with a solution?
So there's my plea for people, parents, teachers, make these people think when they're young for
themselves. Give them information and ask them to come up with solutions. They're never always
going to be right, and that's okay, but they're learning. They're learning the concept of
critical thinking. And so regardless of whether there's problems with laziness, attendance,
all this stuff, that is the one thing if I could fix, I would fix it. Because the other things,
those are personality traits for individuals, but critical thinking skills seems to encompass
everyone that's come up in the last 20 years or so. So let's concentrate on that. Teachers,
parents, educators, don't let people walk through life without teaching them the skills they need
to be successful. If I'm running a shop, and I get a tech that's been through school,
and I have a truck that's a crank no start, and this guy just sits there and stares at it for
eight hours because he doesn't know what the first step to take in troubleshooting that is because
he can't think critically, I don't need that person. And a lot of these young people are
going to run into that wall of not being needed because they can't think independently,
and creatively, and critically. So that's my two cents for that. I thank you all,
and I thank the students that have been through my program, who come to the schools, who ask
questions, who do things the right way. And for those of you who come to school and don't pay
attention, and don't spend the time learning the things that you're here to learn, I just
feel like you're going to get old one day and wish that you had those three
to four hours a day back that you wasted. So, bye.
