Who is buying these cameras

Photo Camera Landscape Expert
201 followers
#PhotoCamera, #LandscapePhotography, #PhotographyExpert, #NatureShots, #ScenicViews, #OutdoorPhotography, #CameraGear, #LandscapeExpert, #TravelPhotography, #WideAngleShots, #PhotographySkills, #NaturalBeauty, #CameraTips, #PhotographyMastery, #LandscapeLovers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe reviewer compares the Sony RX1R III ($5,000) and the Leica Q3 ($7,000), two high-end compact cameras with fixed prime lenses. Despite their impressive sensors and build quality, the reviewer finds them overpriced and ergonomically lacking, concluding that they are luxury toys rather than practical tools for most photographers.
Today I'm reviewing and comparing two of the strangest, potentially most overpriced cameras
of all time. This is the $5,000 Sony RX1R III, and this is the $7,000 Leica Q3. These cameras
are absurdly expensive, and they are whatever the opposite of feature-rich is. Maybe they are
feature-poor cameras. I've never understood the draw to this genre or type of camera before.
However, I'm the first to admit that I've never given them a try myself, so I should do that
first. And I have been using these for three weeks now. Have they won me over? Let's find out.
First of all, let's talk about what makes these cameras so unique to everything else that's on
the market, and what makes these two cameras so similar to each other. The Sony has a full-frame
61-megapixel sensor inside. The Leica has a 60-megapixel sensor inside, and most people
believe that it's actually been made by Sony. These cameras are obviously very compact and
small. They're supposed to be travel cameras, maybe street photography cameras. They're supposed
to be unassuming. Now, the most difficult thing for me to wrap my mind around is that both of
these cameras have fixed lenses. And I don't just mean they are prime lenses. They are prime lenses,
but they are fixed in place. So you are literally stuck with the lens that comes on each one of
these cameras, and they do not zoom. The Sony lens is a 35-millimeter f2, and the Leica comes with a
28-millimeter f1.7. Photography purists might argue that around 30 millimeters is what the
human eye can naturally see, and so that's what they have permanently put on each one of these
cameras. And if you want to zoom, you simply zoom with your feet. For me personally, I'm not a fan
of 30-millimeter lenses. I know when I was shooting weddings and portraits, the only time I would zoom
out this wide is if I was shooting a group of people. Other than that, I was always zooming in.
If I could, I'd probably take every picture beyond 100 millimeters, which is literally the
opposite of what these two cameras can do. One thing I do appreciate is that both of these lenses
have a macro setting. They're not going to be a world-class macro lens at 30 millimeters, but if
you want to get close to subjects, if you want to take a picture of a bug or a flower, something
like that, both of these cameras are going to be able to do it. Now, because these cameras are so
small, you're going to have to give up a ton of different features that come on basically every
other camera, half the price of these. For example, almost every professional Sony camera comes with
in-body stabilization. This camera doesn't have it. The Leica, though, does have optical
stabilization built in. Both cameras can shoot video. However, there's obviously not room for
an HDMI port on either camera, and the Leica doesn't even have an audio input jack. So,
if you want to use an external shotgun or wireless microphone, it's not going to work.
One of my favorite, most used features of almost every modern camera are the new flippy screens
that can flip out to the side and rotate forward if you want to film yourself. The Leica screen can
only tilt up and down, which is frustrating, but not nearly as frustrating as the completely fixed
in place screen the Sony has. I can't tell you how frustrating it is to go back to a camera that
doesn't have any sort of flippy screen. I was always trying to take pictures at low angles or
high angles, and I just couldn't see what I was doing at all. Now, the first time I went out to
take pictures with both of these cameras, I was very frustrated by that 30mm semi-wide angle field
of view. I just don't really like taking pictures like that, and so I'm just taking all of these
really crappy looking photos, and I'm just thinking, who wants to take pictures at 30mm? I
hate this. But once I started taking pictures of people, it started to make more sense to me.
There is something unique and intimate about taking portraits at 30mm. Now, when it comes to
actually using these cameras, there are pros and cons here, because obviously these cameras are
smaller than my other pro cameras, but they're also so small that they don't comfortably fit
in my hand at all. The build quality of the Leica camera is incredible, and I can see why people
fall in love with this camera just as, like, a work of art and craftsmanship. But when I actually
have to use it and feel the ergonomics of holding this thing, I do not find it comfortable. And
maybe it would be fine if I was just using this occasionally to take pictures while I was on
vacation, but if I was trying to shoot an entire wedding with this, I think my hand would turn into
a claw. This is just not comfortable for me to hold at all. The Sony might feel even worse simply
because it's just that much smaller. There is almost nothing for me to hold onto here, and so
I actually found myself taking more pictures with my thumb like this, which is just ridiculous. The
other ironic thing is that these cameras were made to be small and compact and convenient, but
they're so well made, especially the Leica, this thing is heavy. It feels like it's the same weight
as my pro camera with a way larger lens on it. So if I was looking for something easy to travel
with, I'm not sure it would be something like this. Now, even though these cameras are a little
bit too small for my big hands, my five-year-old loved these cameras. These are the first cameras
I've ever tested that he could comfortably hold and take pictures with. Which one of these two
do you like the most? Okay, why do you like that one the most? Because it's more smaller. I mean, I would
say your hand does fit pretty good there, and then press that shutter button. Let me see how that works.
Yeah, your hand does fit good there. How does that one feel? A little too heavy. A little too heavy. So I
gave my wife a heart attack by giving my five-year-old $12,000 in camera gear to play with,
and we've been having a great time going out, and we take pictures together. We take pictures of the
same stuff. We take pictures of each other, and this is the first time we've ever gotten to do
something like that. Nolan, do you know how expensive that camera is? No. You've got to be more careful with
this camera than any toy you've ever had, okay? That's why I want you to keep this strap on. Yeah.
And somehow you have a Cheerio on the microphone. How did you do that? How did you do that? I ate.
You ate Cheerios? Okay. Yeah. I wonder if I could take a picture of that bird right there. Okay, go try.
I see a guana here. The autofocus on the Leica is honestly better than I expected it to be.
They have subject detect autofocus, and it will lock on to human eyes and stuff, and it does a
pretty good job, just not nearly as good of a job as the Sony. I think portraits looked great out of
both of these cameras, but I was getting significantly more sharp images out of the Sony.
The Leica easily missed focus, especially with moving subjects. Now, I actually released this
for a few minutes and realized I had made a massive mistake in that first video when I said
that the Leica camera doesn't have any video function at all. I was incredibly wrong because
not only does this camera shoot video, it can shoot 8K video. Now, I've been trying to figure
out how I could have made such a mistake. Why was I so confident that this camera couldn't
shoot video? And I think what happened was I was preparing to review another Leica camera
that couldn't shoot video, and I just had it in my mind that this camera can't shoot video,
and then at the last second, I decided to compare these two cameras. I switched to the Q3 because
it had similar specs, and without checking all the details, I never realized that this camera
can, in fact, shoot video and impressive video at 8K. Now, as I mentioned earlier, the Leica does
not have an audio input jack, which is a huge deal breaker for me personally that's always using
wireless microphones. The Sony, though, does have that feature if you want to use it.
Now, I use professional Sony cameras on a daily basis, and it was kind of a trip to use this
little guy here because everything about the menu and the way this camera works and the way
the autofocus works feels exactly like my much larger cameras. I have to admit, while taking
pictures with this little camera, a few times I started to fall in love with it, and I started
to tell myself, you know, maybe it's not a big deal that I can't really hold it comfortably.
Maybe taking pictures with your thumb is just what you have to do from now on, Lee. This camera
might actually be worth it, and then I had to remind myself, no, it's not. This camera costs
$5,000, and you can't swap the lens out. There's no way I'm buying this camera. Now, this is my
first time using a Leica camera, and I assumed one of the things that would set this camera apart
are the unique color profiles. I am ashamed to admit how long I have been trying to get
Leica color profiles in Adobe Lightroom, and I believe you simply can't do it. You can change
color profiles in this camera, but that only affects JPEGs, but you probably want to shoot
RAW, and you want to get those color profiles on your RAW shots. As far as I can tell, the only way
to do this is with the Leica iPhone app. This is just so strange to me. I thought professional
photographers shoot RAW, and only the finest professional photographers would shoot with Leica
cameras, but they expect you to do all of your editing on an iPhone app? I thought, surely,
if they have an iPhone app, they also have some sort of standalone app for macOS or Windows.
They don't. The only way to edit these photos and get their color profiles baked in a RAW file
is with a smartphone app, and here you can see a JPEG with Leica's standard color profile built in,
and here you can see that exact same RAW file exported in Adobe Lightroom. Now, I actually
prefer Adobe's colors in this example here, but it's still interesting how different these two
pictures look. Now, I also had IDR turned on, which I believe is Intelligent Dynamic Range turned
on that was set to auto on the Leica, and you can see here, when you compare the JPEG with it turned
on, and then the RAW file straight out of Lightroom, I think this feature is way too heavy-handed, and
when I compare both of those shots to an image straight out of the Sony camera, I'm preferring
the images out of Sony almost every time. So, I went into this review with an open mind. I was
honestly hoping that I would fall in love with both of these cameras, but I have
ended this exactly where I started. I simply do not understand why somebody would choose to spend
$5,000 or $7,000 for either of these cameras, and if you're screaming at your screen right now,
Lee, it's because we want a compact camera with a 30mm fixed lens. There are so many better
and cheaper options. You can get the Sony A7CR. This is their ultra-compact camera with the exact
same 61-megapixel sensor. It currently costs $3,400. It has every single feature that these
cameras have, plus way more in-body stabilization, way better battery life, flippy screen that comes
all the way out to the side, and most importantly, it has interchangeable lenses. Here's a Sony
28mm f2 lens for just $500, and guess what? That camera and lens weighs less than the Leica. I
can't imagine that either of these cameras are anyone's only camera. These are incredibly
specialized luxury items for photographers that probably own many other cameras, and they just
want another high-end toy to play with. Probably the best comparison to this is the luxury watch
market. Digital watches obviously tell the time better. Smart watches have tons of different
features, but of course, the luxury mechanical watch market is alive and well today, but I don't
own one of those watches, and I also probably won't own one of these cameras. We need to review
this camera, right? So other people are watching this video. They're trying to decide should they
buy this camera. What do you think? Yes. The problem is this camera is very expensive. What
are your thoughts on the expense of the camera? I don't know. One of your Hot Wheels costs $1.
This camera costs $5,000, so you could have 5,000 Hot Wheels, or you could have one of these
cameras. Which one would you choose? Cars. Cars? Okay, I think that's the right choice. Yeah,
because cars are more better.
