Some links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The speaker argues against the common assumption that photographers should always buy the fastest (f/2.8) zoom lenses. Instead, they suggest evaluating specific needs based on subject movement, lighting, and the desired role of each lens in a kit to avoid carrying unnecessary weight and spending excessive money.
Do you really need an f2.8 zoom
because if I was building my kit again today
I actually wouldn't give you the same answer for every single lens.
I'd want a 24-70 f2.8
but I'd be perfectly happy with an f4 wide angle zoom and I could
quite easily choose the 70-200 f4 as well
and I used to shoot weddings so this isn't because
I think f2.8 doesn't matter.
It absolutely can matter. There are situations
where I'd very definitely want it.
I just don't think the answer is buy the fastest zoom you can
afford and everything will be okay
because I think the thing that people are actually worried about
is regret. You spend quite a lot of money on the f4
and then six months later you're thinking I
knew it I should have bought the f 2.8
so eventually you buy that one as well
which is a very expensive way
of discovering what you wanted in the first place.
But you can regret things the other way around too.
You could buy the f2.8 because it feels like the proper one,
the professional lens.
Then every time you pack your camera bag you look
at this great lump of glass and you think
do I actually need to bring that with me?
And that's really what I want to work out in this video.
It's not whether f2.8 is technically better,
it's when does it actually make enough
of a difference that you'd pay for it
and actually bother carrying it.
The first place where I genuinely care about F2.8
isn't simply low light.
It's low light when something is moving,
and that is quite an important distinction.
So if you think about people playing basketball
in the school hall or a wedding reception,
Some sort of performance somewhere the light isn't great
and the person isn't going to politely stop
moving whilst you take the picture that's when I'm looking for an f2.8.
When I used to photograph
weddings I used both f2.8 and f4 telephoto zooms
and I was perfectly happy using a 70-200 f4 in a
church and churches can be pretty dark even in summer
but once the ceremony starts generally
Generally speaking, the people
aren't sprinting around the building,
well I hope they're not anyway, so I could let my shutter speed
come right down and I actually could make
perfectly good photographs inside a quite
dark church with an f4 lens.
Would I make the same choice for children running around
in a dark wedding reception?
No probably not because now I've lost my easy escape route.
I can't just keep making the shutter speed slower
and slower because the people that I'm trying to
photograph eventually become sort
of blurry apparition moving through the photograph.
At some point I've already got a high ISO
and I'm already at the slowest shutter speed that
I'm willing to trust and the subject is still moving
and that is when an f2.8 becomes valuable.
At the same ISO opening from f4 to f2.8 gives me
an option of a faster shutter speed where I can
keep the shutter speed exactly where it is and just use a lower ISO.
So this is probably the
the first question I'd ask before buying either lens.
When I'm in bad light,
Do I need to stop something from moving?
Because if the answer is yes, I take the f2.8 very seriously.
But now let's change one thing.
Let's say I'm photographing landscape at dusk.
Suddenly I don't care nearly as much.
So the mountains hopefully are not going anywhere.
I can put the camera on a tripod.
I can use stabilization if I'm hand holding.
And I can let my shutter speed come down as much as I like.
And quite likely I want to be shooting at f8 or f11 anyway
because I want some depth of field.
Now I'm carrying a bigger lens to solve a problem.
The photography isn't actually giving me,
and that's why I'm not particularly keen on the advice to just buy
the F2.8 lenses just in case, but just in case of what?
Because if the sort of photography you do regularly puts you
into that situation where you need that, absolutely.
But if you are mainly photographing things
that sit there rather obediently whilst you're
photographing them, F4 can suddenly start to make a lot of sense.
And actually let me know in the comments which way have you gone.
If you had to choose today, would you go for F2.8 or F4?
And I'm particularly interested if you've bought one
and then wished you'd bought the
other.
But unfortunately portraits ruin my nice simple answer.
I sometimes want F2.8 when I have absolutely loads of light.
So we've already broken my first rule.
On a mid-range zoom, like something like a 24-70,
I personally prefer f2.8 for outdoor portraits.
Sometimes that's because it's lower lighting
conditions, but quite often I just prefer
the extra control it gives me over the background.
Because if I'm photographing somebody
in fairly tight urban locations, I've
got walls and cars and railings and things in the background.
I can't always move my subject 10 meters forward
and politely ask London to move backwards.
So having 2.8 gives me another option.
If the background is closer than I'd like,
I can soften it a bit.
And for me, that's useful often enough.
But I will pay for it.
But F4 doesn't suddenly make bad portraits.
I've got loads of photographs shot
at F4 where there's plenty of background blur
and the subject still separates really nicely from the background.
Because aperture isn't the only thing doing this.
If I can get some distance between the person and the background,
that background is going to get softer anyway.
And sometimes I don't actually want it completely gone.
If I've taken someone to an interesting location,
turning the whole location into colored soup
isn't automatically an improvement.
I quite like being able to tell where they are.
So I wouldn't sit there with two photographs
at 200% magnification asking,
can I see a difference between f2.8 and f4...
Of course you can. I'd ask myself,
Does the difference make the photographs I like taking better?
For me on a 24-70 the answer is
yes and that's often enough that I'd buy the f2.8
but now the answer changes again.
I don't feel the same about the 70-200.
In fact I'll go backwards and forwards a little bit on
this. I've happily used 70-200 f4 lenses professionally
at those longer focal lengths.
With the way that I position people I can already get plenty
of subject separation
and that's why I don't think you should build
an entire lens kit around an aperture number.
The wide zoom makes this even more obvious
so for me I have almost no use personally
for an f2.8 on a wide angle zoom.
If I've got a 16 to 35 or something that's around that range
I'm using it because I want the scene.
I want the landscape, the architecture.
You know, maybe it's for travel.
I'm not putting it on the camera
because I desperately want to obliterate
the background and quite often I'm stopped down anyway.
So why would I automatically buy the bigger, heavier version?
This is where I think the question gets much more useful.
It's not which lens is better,
but what job does this lens have in my bag?
Because then you actually have to carry the thing.
So weight is one of those specifications
that seems incredibly boring
until you've been walking around for five hours.
But if you put those all into a backpack
and add a camera,
maybe a couple of prime lenses,
some water and everything else,
you've somehow persuaded yourself that was essential.
And the engineering masterpiece
has become a small punishment
that you have to wear on your shoulders
everywhere that you go.
So, what if?
Questions are incredibly persuasive.
What if it's really dark?
What if I need that extra stop?
What if I find the one background in Britain
that absolutely demands F2.8?
Right, fine.
But how often does that actually happen?
And then Prime's changed the decision again.
If I've got an 85 millimeter 1.4 in the bag,
Suddenly, my 70-200 doesn't necessarily need to be
my really fast, shallow depth of field lens as well.
The 85mm can do that job.
The 70-200 can become the lens I use when I need reach.
The lenses can all work together.
Every lens doesn't need to win the same competition.
So before you watch 15 reviews on different lenses,
I'd do something much more useful.
Look backwards, think about your last few proper photo shoots.
When did your current lens actually stop you?
But if the only situation you can come up
with is some horrible dark wedding you might
photograph one day, I wouldn't build my entire camera bag around that.
That's really the distinction.
I wouldn't buy an f2.8 zoom just to stop worrying about the f4.
I'd buy it because I could tell you exactly.
Where I'm going to use F2.8 and what problems it's going to remove.