Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/knf775 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
If your private student loans are in default, you're not out of options.
Go to why refi.com slash Ramsey.
Yeah.
So the issue that I'm trying to sort through right now is my daughter
is heading off to college this year.
Um, I do have two other kids to follow behind her about four years
apart, which is a good thing.
Um, have a lot of debt, about $200,000 worth of credit card debt and, uh,
loans with personal loans and HELOC, which does not include the mortgage of
about, um, you know, I pay about $4,400 a month there.
So, you know, the issue that I'm having is that I make too much money that
we don't get, um, any financial aid.
We were fortunate enough that we got some merit aid.
Um, my daughter's going to be going to an sec school and, um, they're giving
us like in-state tuition, so that helps a lot, but we're still going to be
left with about 30 some thousand dollars after the fact, so I'm stuck with the
question, do I try to pay that in cash?
Because I can work extra that I could probably do that.
Do I take, uh, the $20,000 person, a parent plus loan out and make that, put
that extra money towards the debt that I have?
I just, I just don't know which way I go.
Um, my wife and I are, you know, we, not that we fight about it, but we argue
about, you know, what the heck we're going to do because we totally miscalculated.
And we were just, um, just didn't know.
We didn't know anything about paying for college.
I was still living in the eighties and nineties and, um, things have changed since then.
Yeah, for sure.
Yeah.
The affordability of college, um, is, is tough.
So we, you know, we find that, you know, we, we are not a, um, proponent of any
kind of debt, Joseph.
So no, we will say no to the parent plus loan.
And we're about going to a school that, um, that everyone can afford.
And it sounds like you guys can't afford this college.
So that puts a awkward conversation in the air, uh, with the 18 year old, because
it's May and I'm sure the acceptance has already happened and the plans have
already started rolling.
But the truth is, if you guys don't have the money to pay for this, you don't have
the money to pay for it.
So either your son or daughter, who's going off to college works and finds a job
and has a different looking college life than just sorority houses and frat parties
and football games.
Um, and you know, he or she will be working and, or they can't go to that school.
At least not right now.
Have they already like, have they have it in their heads?
They're going to this school.
Yeah.
How far are we?
Yeah, we, we, we already, uh, we already committed, got the t-shirt and everything.
Okay.
So let's talk through this.
How much money do you guys make a year?
Uh, combined income about $340,000.
Okay.
So help me understand how a family making $340,000 is $200,000 in consumer debt.
What happened?
So we have, um, a lot of credit cards.
Um, you know, we have, I took a HELOC loan out, uh, probably
about five or six years ago.
There's about $50,000 on that.
Um, we had a roof leak.
There was about $20,000 on that.
But what was, what was happening to the actual income you had coming in?
Cause this is all outside of your, you know, 15 or 20 grand take home every month.
Sure.
Where was that going?
Um, a lot of credit card misspending, bad, bad, bad decisions.
Bad decisions over a long period of time.
Yeah.
That when we bought our first home, uh, we were, which again, I, I'm financially
illiterate and we'll take the full blame on that when we, uh, when we bought our
first, um, when we bought our first home, um, our agent set us up with this
financial person and then we were making the minimum payment at the time, but I
didn't realize that despite me making the minimum payment, which I thought
was satisfying everything, it was borrowing against the principle of the
mortgage and my principle was actually going up.
So that put us in a hole there where we have since sold that house and have
moved on.
Um, I knew we couldn't afford the house that we lived in.
We had a couple of friends, a family, actually family to front us some money
so we could get the house right now.
Our mortgage is about 4,400.
And what's your take home pay every month?
What's coming into the bank between the two of you?
So my wife is about 6,000.
This is take home after taxes.
My wife is about 6,000.
I'm about eight, nine, roughly about 10,000.
That's before, before overtime and extra shifts.
Okay.
I can work pretty much as many extra shifts as I can.
And after taxes, I get about a thousand dollars per shift.
Okay.
After taxes.
Cool.
Well, the math should be pretty clear here on how we're going to cashflow this.
And if that means it slows down your debt payoff a little bit to get her through
this first year and buy you guys some time, that's what I would do.
Because I do think it's a great goal for her to go to school debt free, but I
think she needs to have some skin in the game versus dad just working his tail
off so she can go enjoy the frat parties and sorority parties.
So that would be the game plan.
And then the longterm, we need to clean up the $200,000 of
debt using the debt snowball.
So attacking the smallest one first, we need to rant, you know, really dial
down our lifestyle because my guess is your total expenses are close
to 16 K a month, if not more.
Yes, definitely.
What's coming out of the bank account every month?
Uh, mortgage.
I mean, is it more than 16 K or is there any money left?
No, no.
There's, um, I would say, you know, I was doing rough estimates
over the last week or two.
I would say it's roughly about the like 14, 15,000 that's coming out.
Okay.
And besides the more, cause you said 4,000 is the mortgage, right?
Right.
So you got 12,000 left.
How much are all the payments on all the debt, the
credit cards and everything?
Um, let me see.
We have, I just paid a car off.
We have two cars that are about $700 total between the two.
The HELOC is about, um, five, $500 a month.
Um, the credit cards are, um, at several thousand.
It's a couple of thousand a month.
Um, you know, it's like 30% interest, which is killing me.
Um, uh, I'm trying to think of what else.
Yeah.
Well, I mean, I'm at 7,000 right now.
I mean, it's just to the point.
Yes, that these are, and these things I don't, we don't
want you to get behind on.
Um, so yeah, so Joseph, I mean, I would sit down tonight and
we'll give you a, every dollar our budgeting app, we'll give
you a year subscription to it because I would want, I would
want, if I were you, you and your wife to sit down and list
out everything that we spend money on in the month.
And my, my hope is, and my sense is that you guys are gonna
look up and be like, oh crap, three to $4,000 is just getting
blown on subscriptions and how to eat and just whatever we,
whatever the flip we want to do.
And all of that has to be tightened up to not only pay off this debt,
but if you guys are serious about this college of starting to save
to cashflow and have to make payments for this college, um, forward
payments, not back payments of debt.
And so getting on a really strict budget, Joseph, I mean, even
looking at selling some of these cars, if you want, like whatever
you can do to get out of this as fast as possible is what you need to do.
Yeah.
I would not turn to any more debt.
That's what's got us here.
It's not going to get us out.
So no more parent plus loans.
No more just kind of phoning it in.
You guys make too much to be the credit cards.
Be done with them.
Why refi refinances defaulted private student loans for struggling borrowers.
Learn more at Y R E F Y.com slash Ramsey.