Chinese Traditional Story: The Consequences of Ignoring Advice

中國傳統故事 Chinese Traditional Stories
2.4K followers
200 Video Views·Apr 29, 2026
(1) The first story happened during the Western Zhou Dynasty, the tenth ruler, King Li of Zhou, ruled with coercive and tyrannical methods, ruthlessly plundering the people’s wealth, monopolizing social wealth and resources, intensifying the exploitation of the working people, and simultaneously stripping some nobles of their power.
(2)The second story took place during the Warring States period. On one occasion, the state of Qi was preparing to attack the state of Song. The King of Song sent someone to scout the enemy’s situation. The scout returned and reported, “The Qi army is very close to our borders, and the morale of our people is low, so everyone is very worried.”
Hello everyone, I would like to share two short stories today.
The first story happened during the Western Zhou Dynasty.
The 10th ruler, King Liu Zhou, ruled with coercive and tyrannical methods, ruthlessly
plundering the people's wealth, monopolizing social wealth and resources, intensifying
the exploitation of the working people, and simultaneously stripping some nobles of their
power.
Externally, the Zhou Dynasty waged war against the Jianqiu states to the south and defended
against nomadic tribes to the north, while also facing numerous conflicts with neighboring
ethnic minorities.
To surprise public discontent, King Liu Zhou enlisted a sorcerer from the state away to
monitor those who spoke out.
Whoever the sorcerer denounced, King Li had executed.
As a result, fewer and fewer people spoke out, and at the same time the feudal lords
stopped coming to pay their respects.
Eventually, none of the common people dared to speak up anymore.
When they met on the street, they could only exchange glances to communicate.
King Liu Zhou was overjoyed at this and said to Duke Mou Xiao,
I have silenced the people's criticism of me.
They were never there to complain again.
Duke Mou Xiao replied, You have merely stifled their voices.
Silencing the people is far more harmful than damning a river.
When water accumulates to a great extent, a single breach in the river will inevitably
cause great harm to many people.
The same principle applies when the people are silenced.
Therefore, those who manage waterways must stretch the river to ensure the water flows
freely.
Those who govern the people must allow free speech so that the people dare to speak their
minds.
King Liu Zhou refused to heed warnings, acting on his own whim and doing as he pleased.
From then on, the people dared not speak out.
Within a few years, the people had reached the limit of their endurance, rose up in revolt.
King Liu Zhou fled in panic and died in exile.
The second story took place during the Warring States period.
On one occasion, the state of Qi was preparing to attack the state of Song.
The king of Song sent someone to scout the enemy's situation.
The scout returned and reported, The Qi army is very close to our borders,
and the morale of our people is low, so everyone is very worried.
Those around the king also urged him, We must act quickly.
Upon hearing this, the king of Song became furious and had the scout executed.
Later, the king of Song sent another man to reconnoiter the enemy's position.
When this man returned, his report matched that of the first man.
The king of Song was furious and had him executed as well.
In this way, three men were sent out in total, and all three were killed for telling the truth.
For the fourth time, the king of Song sent another messenger to scout the enemy's situation.
The messenger saw that Qi army was about to invade Song,
and the morale among the people was low.
He intended to return and report this to the king of Song,
but he feared that he might meet the same fate as the previous three messengers.
So he asked his old brother,
The men who spoke the truth before were all killed by the king of Song.
If I tell the truth, the king of Song will surely kill me as well.
But if I don't tell the truth, and the truth comes out, I'm doomed either way.
What shall I do?
The man's old brother said, If you tell the truth, you will die before everyone else.
So the messenger returned and lied to the king of Song,
saying, We haven't seen any Qi troops anywhere.
Our people are living in peace.
Upon hearing this, the king of Song was overjoyed,
and his courtiers flattered him, saying,
Indeed, those three men were spreading a lot of rumors.
They deserve to die.
The king of Song then rewarded the man with a large sum of money.
Before long, the Qi army attacked.
The king of Song, enabled among the defense, fled in panic.
These two stories remind me of the famous scene by Duke Zhuang of Zheng
from the spring and autumn period.
Those who commit many acts of injustice will surely bring about their own downfall.
Just wait and see.
Conversely, they also remind me that the brilliant achievements
of Zhenguan era of the Tang dynasty were inseparable from Emperor Tang Taizong's
villainous to humbly heed his ministers' advice.
Thank you very much for listening to the story.
More touching stories will be ready for you if you just subscribe it.
Thank you again.
