Neil deGrasse Tyson, world-renowned astrophysicist, says science hasn’t stalled at all — we’re just too close to the progress to notice it.
What you think is “no breakthrough” could actually be the fastest era of discovery in human history.
Neil deGrasse Tyson is an astrophysicist, author, and one of the most influential science communicators of our time. We cover: why people falsely believe science is stagnant, what’s actually changed since 1989, why AI already runs your daily life without you noticing, and the discoveries (from exoplanets to black holes) that quietly rewrote reality.
Science didn’t slow down — you just stopped paying attention.
This is a clip from a longer episode where Neil and I cover Mars, black holes, the multiverse, dark matter, and why most people get probability wrong: ▸ Watch the full conversation: https://youtu.be/aUnkkHuorto ———
🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
When they ask the kids, what do you want to be when you grow up?
And they say, I want to be a YouTube influencer.
They would have been slapped podcaster pod.
What's a pod.
Oh, it's an iPod thing.
That's up there lately that most, you know, annoys me is physics has not progressed.
Science has not progressed.
Science is static.
There's been no real progress, you know, because of things like
string theory and other things.
And you know, most of the progress in, in, in technology, if you were to
teleport somebody from 1989 to here to today in 2024, at the end of December,
they would say, wow, your TV sure got flat.
And that's about it.
You know, so in the last, you know, 35, 40 years, not much.
And then you look at this book and every chapter, there's been radical discoveries,
Nobel worthy discoveries ranging from exoplanets.
I mean, you talk about, is there life on other planets?
And at the time you didn't know.
I mean, we hadn't discovered the exoplanet count was zero and
now it's rising through 6,000.
People who say this, they've overvalued the interval of time over which they're
living, because they they're thinking to themselves, they look throughout history
and they sample, let's say 150 years since the second wave industrial revolution.
And they want all that to be happening in their lifetime.
Well, it's sort of is, but it happens smoothly and at a rate that you're
not even paying close attention to.
So if you go back, is it, is it 15 years?
Yeah.
Go back 15 years.
We'll go back to 2006.
Okay.
There is no smartphone.
YouTube doesn't exist yet.
Okay.
There are people who are YouTube influencers that are making more money
than their parents ever dreamt of.
And their parents surely would have said when they asked the kids, what do you
want to be when you grow up?
And they said, I want to be a YouTube influencer.
They would have been slapped.
Podcaster.
Pod.
What's a pod?
Oh, it's an iPod.
What that's where that comes from.
Of course.
What?
That's going to be a thing.
What?
They're going to be 8 million of those actively produced ever.
What?
And by the way, we have an SUV sized Rover on Mars right now
that brought a helicopter with it.
Excuse me.
We sent a spacecraft to Pluto.
We landed on one of Saturn's moons.
First time anybody's landed on a moon outside of the hour moon.
Okay.
You could walk down the street with your smartphone and talk to someone in Europe
and think nothing of it and not write home.
Guess what I did today?
I talked to that.
Meanwhile, it's in living memory, this.
Shoulder mounted cell phone that was wielded in 1987 by Gecko in the movie
wall street, as he was walking the beaches of the Hamptons.
And I remembered, I remembered in 1987, gee, I wish I was as rich as he was.
So I can have a phone like that and I can walk down the beach and talk to people
with this brick sized, cinder block size, shoulder mounted phone.
And now you look at that and say, geez, people actually use that.
And so I don't know what they're paying attention to.
Their head is in the sand.
I don't know what we have a telescope that can see the birth of galaxies.
Come on now.
What more?
Maybe they're worried that they want a new equals MC squared or some new
formula like that, that you can write on a small sheet of paper.
And is that what they're after?
You know, I don't know.
Is that what they would count as a discovery?
We're on the heels of quantum computing for goodness sake.
All right.
And AI, you know, you're in your car.
You push a button and the car tells you turn left here to avoid traffic
and save 10 minutes on your trip.
Who's the person inside the car?
Who's calculating that?
Nobody.
It's a computer.
It's a ******* eye.
Okay.
That is in our lives on a level that we're not even thinking about because
the goalposts for AI have been moved.
They're always getting moved ever since like the 1960s when the Turing
test was defeated with Eliza, the program, the computer therapist, where
you have a conversation with it and you don't know if it's a real person
or it's like you just didn't know.
And that fulfilled the Turing test.
Well, we keep moving the goalposts and now AI can compose your term paper.
And then all the liberal artists folks freaked out.
Meanwhile, automated robots replaced factory line workers and the liberal arts
folks, I didn't see any outpouring of sympathy from them at that time.
Oh, you just got to get used to it.
It's technology moving along.
And now all of a sudden AI is in everybody's lap and people are freaking out.
It's like, come on now.
And whoever is not paying attention to any of this, I don't
know, are they on an Island?
Are they like what?
In fact, in the other book, which you haven't mentioned yet, I spent an
entire chapter exploring the rate and pace of technology and what happens in
30 year increments from 1850 through 2020.
And I just review them and they're mind blowing, mind blowing.
You bring someone from 1990 into the present and you say, I got to
send this, this file to someone.
Do you have a fax machine?
No, I don't have a fax machine.
No.
Okay.
Where's your CD player?
CDs.
I don't even know what a CD and just, they would not know how to function in our world.
They'll get in the car and they won't know what button to push.
Yeah.
The backup camera.
Where, where's the backup camera into reverse?
Like it doesn't have a gear.
If it doesn't have a backup camera, kind of a chauvinism, right?
That we, we focus as a recency bias, whatever you want to say, aliens
are going to look like us.
Life has to be like us in order to matter, to give us a cosmic significance.
But yeah, maybe technology has to be exactly what we have now.
No problems with our current tech, but it has to be that much better.
Or we'll say that it's stagnant.
And as an experimentalist, look, I, I have sympathy for some of the, you
know, complaints about theorists that, that, you know, there, there has been
a sort of, there tends to be a type of group think that does occur.
It's normal.
I think it's natural.
And some fields have it.
And some fields sure as hell do not have it because some fields
of theory are incredibly active.
And, and we just have to look at observations and experiment to see
how active and how many discoveries.
I mean, basically every single, you know, four or five year period has seen
that Nobel worthy discoveries that weren't even conceivable 50 years ago.
Detection of gravitational waves, imaging of a black hole's event horizon.
I mean, incredible discoveries.
And I think
by the way, I only just learned this because I hung out with Kip Thorne just
recently for my own podcast, had a long interview with him about his life.
I did not know that in order to stabilize the detector system, because they're
trying to measure very small length changes between the two beams on the order
of a fraction of the diameter of a proton.
So you have to characterize the thermal movement of everything so that you know
what is a gravitational wave and what isn't.
And apparently he described this to me and I was in disbelief so that my brain
wasn't clicked in to even understand what he says, but I'll repeat it, but
I don't claim to understand it.
What he said was they took steps to bypass the Heisenberg uncertainty
principle to more precisely isolate the movement of the proton.
Yes.
It's all the squeeze states, right?
It's a, yeah.
Is that what it was?
Okay.
Thank you.
Exactly.
Quantum squeezing.
Yeah.
Basically.
Okay.
It was like, it was like magic to me, but oh my gosh.
And then you look at that and they, they invented active noise cancellation.
They, yeah.
Yeah.
And everyone just accepts that and presumes it was always there.
Yeah.
Just get out of my face.
You go back to 1990 and we'll see how easy life is for you with
your Walkman cassette player.
I could have afforded one back then.
I, I couldn't afford, I had to get one of these knockoffs.
And that was, they had the CD Walkman, which was bump resistant.
I don't know if you remember that.
Yeah.
Speaking of lasers and sound.
Yeah.
The problem with that one.
Yeah, exactly.
That was bulkier.
You usually things when the technology improves, it gets smaller, but the CD
player was bigger than the tape deck.
I remember the skinniest one I had my eyes on.
I could not afford until I was a postdoc probably.
But when we, when we think about these things, yeah, it's, it's, it's
always surprising to me that people are so pessimism biased.
You know, they say that, you know, optimist, you know, builds the
airplane, the, the, the pessimist builds the parachute, but it's
because I think people think they think they sound smart if they're
pessimistic, like if they're jaded, you know, it's the jaded tortured gene.
But I think you're a beautiful counterexample of that.
I think you have,
well, no, I'm not an optimist.
I think I'm a realist.
No, no, I'm a positive realist.
So I look at the fun things that can happen.
That can happen realistically.
And pragmatist.
Yeah, that's the word I meant to say pragmatist.
That's the only other is I'll admit to being other than a scientist.
I'd rather say I'm pragmatic.
Pragmatist implies there's some philosophy and a doctrine
and a leader and a cult.
No, no.
If the shoe fits where I think you have a, a nice, a nice cold fall.
You had a tweet recently that, you know, something playing, I've
been playing with similar ideas.
I actually talked about this with Steven Bartlett on his
podcast, diary of a CEO.
We're at the very end.
He gives me the highest compliment.
And he says, you and Neil deGrasse Tyson are very good at
explaining things to, to lay people.
So I took that as a great compliment, at least for one of us.
But the tweet that you had that reference, what he, he asked me to
basically, you know, see if I can debunk astrology and you put out this
tweet, you know, basically, which I've been saying to some of my friends
and my students, you know, if you were born in late November, you're
actually an Ophiuchus, which sounds dirty.
You know, it's like panspermia.
It's, it sounds dirty, but it's not, it's, it's actually fine.
It's, it's a perfectly legitimate scientific term.
And so Ophiuchus would have been the, so how does that, well, you know,
would you, a Libra, I'm a, I'm a Virgo, Libra, Libra, Libran, you know, just
if you properly do the word in the way, like, you know, Ophiuchus is the
constellation, and if you're of Ophiuchus, you'd be Ophiuchian, that's all.
Now, doesn't that just obliterate astrology right then and there?
I mean, they never knew about it, right?
They never talked about it and they never knew about it.
And if you tell them about it, they'll deny it.
They'll say it doesn't matter.
These are just arbitrary.
Oh, so it's just an arbitrary distinction.
What, what constellations the astronomers draw.
So why isn't it arbitrary what you astrologers draw from the place of the
sun on my mother's day of giving birth to me, and, and it's worse than that.
So let's, let's assume that Ophiuchus was just ignored from the original assessment
of the 12 constellations of the Zodiac.
I'm just highlighting it as a reality.
But if that reality doesn't matter, there's another reality that should.
And that's of course, that earth processes on its axis and the
alignment of the sun with the zodiacal constellation is shifted by an entire
month, so, and you can look this up yourself at any star chart, which shows
where the sun is at what time of year.
And it does not match up.
It just doesn't matter to astrologers.
So I've had people say, astrology can give you insight into a person's
personality and their traits and all these, and I, and they'll say, well,
what's your sign they've asked of me.
And I said, well, if astrology is that potent, you should be able to figure it
out, why should I have to tell you, you should just go walk down the street
and pick out everybody's star sign.