Thinking about buying a home in Phoenix right now? Before you do anything, you need to see the latest data — because the math has shifted, and it might change your decision. In this week's Phoenix metro market update, I break down a brand new Realtor.com report showing that renting is now more affordable than buying across all 50 major U.S. metros — including right here in Phoenix-Mesa-Chandler. I'll show you exactly how much you could save per month by renting vs. buying in Phoenix, and more importantly, when it still makes sense to buy. I'm also covering: ✅ The rent vs. buy gap in Phoenix (the number might surprise you) ✅ Why Phoenix is officially a buyer's market right now — and which cities aren't ✅ How sellers outnumber buyers by 43% nationally (near a record high) ✅ The Cromford Market Index and contract ratios for the Phoenix metro ✅ Why this spring selling season feels unseasonably slow ✅ Where mortgage rates are sitting this week ✅ Where Phoenix home prices are likely heading next Whether you're a buyer trying to time the market, a seller wondering if spring is still your best shot, or just trying to understand what's really happening in the Valley — this update gives you the real numbers without the hype.
I may be a real estate agent, but I am telling you right now, do not buy a home in Phoenix
before you get this information because it just might not be the right decision for you.
We are also going to talk about how much buyers outweigh sellers in the Phoenix market and how
we are having an unseasonably slow spring selling market. So let's get into it. Thanks for joining
me. You guys, this new realtor.com report says that renting is more affordable than buying across
all 50 major U.S. metros. Now this has shifted over time. We've had buying being more affordable
than renting for a while. And then we saw an increase in mortgage rates in combination with
an increase in pricing that had happened over the previous years during that COVID time.
And it has now shifted to where renting is more affordable than buying. We see this in certain
areas, but this is I think the first time where it's been this way across all 50 major U.S. metros
and Phoenix does make that list. So they've got the list of some of these major metros,
Austin being at the very top of this list, Seattle, and then we have Phoenix, Mesa, Chandler,
Arizona, median rent $14.35 a month, monthly buy cost $26.27 a month. The difference between buy
and rent $11.92 a month, 83%. Obviously you're going to save a ton of money over a year's time
if you are saving $1,100, almost $1,200 a month. Now, aside from just looking at the numbers,
there's obviously pros and cons with both. And it really depends on your situation and your
lifestyle and where you're at financially. I think there's a benefit to buying if you plan
on being in the home 10 years or longer. If you're financially stable, where you can afford a
mortgage rate and not be concerned about paying your mortgage month to month. If you can afford
to put a down payment on a home and not have that drain your entire savings. If you buy a home more
than likely the price of the home goes up over time if you plan to hold it at least 10 years or
longer, and you will get some return on your investment. With renting, you have nothing to
show for it, but in the short term, you're saving money on an annual basis. So it really depends on
your lifestyle, your future plans, and your stability in your financial situation. That said,
I think it's important to point out that renting is cheaper than buying right now. And so if that
suits your lifestyle, then that might be the path that you want to go forward on. Now, I share all
of that. And I also want you to know that home buyers hold the negotiating power in 38 major
metros up from 29 major metros last year. And Phoenix does make the list on this as well. So
in my opinion, another thing to consider when you're thinking about buying a home or renting
a home is the market conditions. Because you can certainly save money when you are in a buyer's
market and buying a home. There's more negotiating power, the likelihood of bringing the price down,
getting concessions, getting repairs done by the sellers, all of those types of things are much
more likely when you are buying a home in a buyer's market. So this is something to keep in
mind. Nationally, sellers outnumber buyers by 43%, just shy of the largest gap in records dating
back to 2013. When sellers outnumber buyers, the buyers who are in the market have the bargaining
power. 38 of the most populous metro areas were buyers markets in March, up from 29 last year,
just five were sellers markets down from nine in 2025. So looking nationally, they say there
were an estimated 43.1% more home sellers than buyers in the US housing market in March.
That's just shy of the largest gap in records dating back to 2013. So this is what I'm talking
about. If you are considering buying, this is one of those scenarios where of course,
you're looking at affordability, but you're also looking at what is your advantage in the market.
Now Phoenix does make the list of one of these metros that is having a buyer's market and that
kind of balance of power. So if we look at Phoenix, they're saying that sellers outnumber buyers by
79.1%. So when you have more sellers in the market and fewer buyers, obviously buyers have
the advantage, they have the leverage, they have more options to choose from, they have the
negotiating power. And when we look at the Cromford report, that's looking specifically at the Phoenix
metro area, we see that the CMI or the Cromford market index is 82.8. According to the Cromford
market index, anything below 90 is considered a buyer's market. So we are reflecting the same
thing here as what this national reporting is saying from realtor.com. However, I think
Cromford is always so much more specific and accurate than something on realtor.com and kind
of a broad brush sweep of the nation. But this is reflecting the same thing. Demand is at 88.8,
so that's 12% below normal. Supply is at 107.2, that's 7.2% above normal. So we have more supply
than we have demand and therefore buyers have choices, they have negotiating power, they have
options. Now, as I've shared every single week, this environment varies city to city,
but we do have a number of cities that are still in a buyer's market here. If you look at anything
from Goodyear down to Buckeye, all considered buyer's markets. Peoria is kind of right on the
cusp there in a balanced market as well as Cave Creek. And then we have a number of seller's
markets. So you're reading this realtor.com article and you're saying, oh my gosh, Phoenix
is in a buyer's market. I'm going to take advantage of this. And then you go and write
an offer and you find out that there are multiple offers on the same property. That's because there
are some cities in the Phoenix metro area that are seeing a lot of competition, multiple offers,
and they actually don't have that glut of inventory that other areas of the market do.
Whether that be because there's not a lot of new construction or maybe just fewer homes come up
sale in those areas and it's a very desirable area for buyers, you will see more of a seller's
market environment. I was just speaking with someone the other day who was asking about
when a seller's market is going to come back to Phoenix. And I was like, we have one. It just
depends on what area you're looking in. So you can see that Fountain Hills all the way down to
Avondale is technically in a seller's market because anything over 110 is considered a
market on the CMI. I always like to look at the contract ratio because I think this is just a
little bit easier to understand what's going on in the environment. And the contract ratio right now
for the overall Phoenix metro market is saying 36.9. And if we look at the key for what that
means, anywhere between 30 to 60 is considered a balanced and warm market. But we've got areas of
the metro area that are a little bit hotter than others. Some of these yellow and red zip codes
here are seeing more heat in their area because they have fewer homes for sale and more of those
homes actually going under contract from interested buyers. So this is what you need to know when
you're thinking about buying because yes, it might be a buyer's market environment in some areas,
but not all. And keeping in mind that you could rent for cheaper than you could buy, but it
depends on your long-term goals. So if this information is helpful for you as a buyer,
considering getting into the market and you want to know the contract ratio in a specific zip code,
check the description below to request that information. We can get that to you. We can
also set up a discovery call with you if you'd like to talk more about your situation and point
you in the right direction. So let's talk a little bit about sellers out there because this is our
season, the spring selling season. This is always the time you want your home on the market because
you get the most offers, the most interest, the most buyer activity, and technically should allow
you to get the highest price, right? Well, bad news, late April is the best time to list a home for sale,
but also the spring housing market is unseasonably slow as Iran war high-cost curb demand. Okay, so
two headlines. Let's break these down. Redfin is saying late April is the best time to list a home.
And this is, of course, you know, a very broad statement, but I will say for the Phoenix metro
area, this is true. This is when we see the most contract activity. We see the most buyers in town
for the spring season, although it's been hot as heck here. So no one's really been enjoying our
spring quote unquote, but regardless, we are still in this springtime where we tend to see a lot more
buyers. They say this is a sweet spot for sellers listed homes listed during this period have the
highest chance of selling fast and fetching more than the asking price. The best time to sell
varies by region, but the swings are bigger in some parts of the U S than others. Um, the picture
is more complex for buyers. House hunters have the most homes to choose from in late April, but
they get the best deals in July. I would say for Phoenix buyers do have the most homes to choose
from in April or the spring season. They get the best deals in December when people are distracted
with the holidays and just ready to get their homes sold. So regionally, it always depends,
right? But long story short, now is the time to have your home on the market. If you were trying
to get the most eyes on your property, but is this year the same as all years? No, because the housing
market is unseasonably slow as the war and high cost curb demand. I will agree with this. This is
one of the slowest spring seasons that I've experienced since I've been an agent in the
metro area. Now I I've heard from many agents that they are seeing a lot of activity out there.
Um, and I, I'm not saying it's dead by any means, but there's usually just a little bit more pep in
the step it feels like, uh, in the spring. And, and I'm just, I'm not seeing that as much this
year. And they're saying us pending home sales fell 4.1% from a year earlier during the four
weeks ending April 12th, which is the biggest decline in over a year. Sales fell in all but
seven of the 50 biggest us metros. Um, and the biggest declines were in Providence, Rhode Island,
Houston, uh, New York, San Francisco, West Palm beach, and Miami home buying demand is unseasonably
unseasonably slow. Home touring activity is up just 11% since the start of the year compared
to a 40% increase over the same period last year. So that is a big indication when you don't have
people out there looking at homes and booking showings, then obviously that buying activity
is not going to follow because no one's actually looking at homes. And that's one of the things
I've noticed this spring where there will be like complete dead zones of not a lot of showings on
our listings. And then all of a sudden a huge spike of a bunch of showing activity and then
dead zone again. And it typically is a little bit more consistent this time of year where you get a
lot of showings, um, pretty consistently over, you know, through March and April. Uh, and I've
just noticed it kind of being like a spike and then a flat line. I'd be curious for any agents
watching this, if you've had the same experience or what has been going on with your listings this
year. So drop that in the comments, we would all love to kind of get the inside scoop on what
you're seeing. Now what's really interesting is that we are seeing our active listings
start to come into contact with 2025 active listings. So if you remember, we have been
seeing active listings increase above 2025 above all the previous years. Um, and every January,
this has been consistent. We start with more listings than we did the previous year. And that
has just increased as we get into the spring season. But we are now seeing, if I take off
these previous years, you can see it a lot better. We are now seeing kind of our listings,
our active listings this year, starting to combine with active listings last year on this tracker.
Um, they're not outpacing anymore. So is this flat lining in terms of our active listings?
Um, that is another interesting piece to this puzzle for our busy spring season. If we're not
seeing more active listings, then, um, that might stay on pace with lower buyer demand and
things will just stay steady Eddie at that point. Again, when demand is meeting supply,
then we're just in a balanced market and no one really has the upper hand.
Um, and we are in that space in a few areas, and then we've got a little bit of everything going
on in other areas. Now the listings under contract, which is showing our demand has been elevated
above 2025 and now is also coming back in line with 2025 just like those active listings are
doing. So we're kind of like both, both metrics are kind of settling into where we were at last
year. It'll be interesting to see what happens into the summer, which is usually a little bit
of a slower season for us. Um, tend to see active listings kind of stay elevated, but the demand
doesn't always meet that it's a slower time in terms of demand. We'll see what happens as we
continue on. All of these things, by the way, are indications of where prices are heading.
And when you aren't seeing a huge increase of supply and, uh, you know, very little demand,
then it's pretty reasonable to expect prices to stay stable. And that's the question that I get
all the time is like, where are prices heading? Should I wait to buy? Should I wait to sell?
Our price is going to go up down right now. Everything that we can see in terms of our
supply and demand is not giving us a big indication of a big change in pricing one way or the other.
Now, since everything has felt a little slow, I was like, well, let's see where we're at with
the number of sales per month, because that's going to show us if we're on track with previous
years. And wouldn't you know, here we are in 2026 number of sales per month is above 2025 and 2024.
So we are still getting things done around here. It is just feeling like everything takes a lot
longer, but we've got 7,731 sales that took place in March have yet to have the April data here.
If I were to guess, I still think it's going to be above 2025. So sales are still happening.
Buyers and sellers are out there making deals. It just feels like it's, you know, not that big
rush that we tend to see every spring. Now let's take a quick look at where we're at with mortgage
rates, because that is always something to keep an eye on both as a seller and a buyer to know
what's going on with the buyer sentiment out there. Many of them are basing it on rates and
their affordability. But we're at about 6.32, definitely has come down from the peak that we
saw back in the middle or end of March. And then we've jumped back up in the last few days around
6.32. Not terrible. It was great when we were hanging around closer to six, but it is what it
is. I would expect some volatility in this with everything going on economically and with Iran.
But for now, 6.3 ish, not terrible. Just keep an eye on that and get in touch with your lender if
you are considering buying a home and just kind of want to have a good idea of what you could
afford. Our team is always speaking with buyers and sellers in the Phoenix metro area, helping
them decide what the next move is and how we can support them in that. So if any of that is of
interest to you, check the description below to book a discovery call. You can also request the
contract ratio in a particular zip code to help you understand the data and know what your next
move is going to be. I will see you guys next week on my next market update. I appreciate you
joining me and have a great week. Transcribed by https://otter.ai