USA Bow Vs. China Bow Vs. Inspected Bow

Shatterproof Archery
117 followers
Which bow is the best value?
USA Bow: https://www.shatterproofarchery.com/products/the-bob-garner-usa-made-takedown-recurve-bow
China Bow: https://amzn.to/47VFgSV
Inspected Bow: https://www.shatterproofarchery.com/products/the-inspected-black-hunter-recurve-bow-mk2
We are for you - Stay Shatterproof!
Archery Questions? We would love to help: [email protected]
https://www.shatterproofarchery.com/
Shatterproof Archery is a small company located in Colorado Springs CO.
We are dedicated to helping more people enjoy more archery.
#shatterproof
#bowmaking
#traditionalarchery
Affiliate Links were used in this description
A couple months ago I made a video called we set out to beat the Black Hunter USA made
bow.
And now the obvious question hangs in the air.
Did we do it?
Did we beat the Black Hunter?
We're going to answer that question today by comparing the Black Hunter to the bow that
we were building to set out to beat the Black Hunter, the Bob Garner recurve.
Now there are two ways we could do this.
One way would be to compare the Bob Garner to a Black Hunter off of Amazon.
The other way would be to compare the Bob Garner to an inspected Black Hunter, a Black
Hunter that we buy, inspect, upgrade with our string and accessories and resell.
And I've gone back and forth between what we should do in this.
So what we're going to do today is just compare all three.
I got a Black Hunter from Amazon.
I got an inspected Black Hunter and I got a Bob Garner bow.
We're going to compare all three.
And now I know what you're thinking.
You're thinking this cannot possibly be an honest review because you sell two of these
three products and you are absolutely right.
So we're just going to do the best we can.
I will do my best to present the facts and let you guys make the conclusions.
We're going to be inspecting these bows, checking them out on five different criteria, specs,
speed, smoothness, snag ability, and sacrifice.
Let's get into the specs.
This is going to be our score sheet or what would usually be our score sheet.
Now, usually I'd score these on a scale of one to 10.
But today, because of my bias, I'm just going to state the facts.
So on specs, the draw weight's off.
I'm just going to put how much of the draw weight's off, all that.
I'll let you guys score it on your own at the end.
That way I can just try and be as unbiased as possible.
So on the specs, there's really three things that I care about.
Number one is the draw weight.
If the draw weight is way off, it can be really annoying, especially in a couple of scenarios.
If you're a beginner and you get like, let's say a 30-pound bow and it comes in as a 40-pound bow,
that can be really annoying because you can't pull back the bow.
You can't even use it.
Or if you're a hunter, you order a 40-pound bow.
It comes in at 35.
Depending on what state you're in, you could be illegal
in your hunting bow when you thought you were legal.
So we're going to check the draw weight first thing.
Second thing, brace height.
Now, brace height is important because it makes the bow shoot smooth.
When you get a good brace height, it shoots smooth.
It doesn't slap your wrist, that sort of stuff.
So I want to check the brace height because sometimes if the string that comes with the bow
doesn't give the brace height range that it's supposed to give, that can be really annoying.
And number three is just what's included with the bow.
Does it come with everything that it says it comes with?
So let's check out the specs.
We're going to start with the Amazon bow, then do the inspected, then the Bob Garner.
All right, so far it looks like everything that was supposed to come with this bow
came with this bow and some.
It didn't say that it came with string silencers, but it comes with string silencers.
And then it also didn't say that it came with limb silencers,
but there's a pack of limb silencers as well as already cut to size arrow rest.
All that it said it came with was this square.
And so it came with everything it said it was supposed to plus some.
Let's check the draw weight now.
All right, this is supposed to be a 40-pound bow.
All three of these bows we're checking out are all supposed to be 40-pound bows.
40.24, 40.2.
All right, the draw weight was 40.23, which is dead on.
It's supposed to be 40 pounds within 0.2 pounds.
Anything within 2.5 pounds, I count as correct specs
because usually people are listing bows in every five-pound draw weights, 35, 40, 45.
So if you're within two and a half, you selected the correct variant there.
So they nailed it on this draw weight.
Brace height, 6.8 to 7.8 inches.
Max draw length, 28 inches.
Just over seven and a quarter.
So that's right in the middle of the range that they said it was going to be.
As far as specs go on the Amazon Black Hunter, they nailed it.
They included everything they said they were going to include,
nailed the draw weight, nailed the brace height,
and great rule of thumb is to under promise, over deliver.
They actually included some things that they didn't say they were going to include.
String silencers, limb silencers, and already cut-to-size arrow rests.
So they did a great job on the specs of this bow.
Now let's unbox this inspected Black Hunter.
Is everything here that's supposed to be here?
Yes, there is.
You got the bow, limbs, limb bolts, flemish twist bow string,
beaver string silencers, and a trim-to-size arrow rest.
Now there's one thing, or a couple things here,
that the manufacturer doesn't say on the listing that isn't here,
which is the factory bow string and limb silencers are also included that are extra.
There's also QR codes to how to set up the bow,
how to shoot your first arrow, and FAQs, as well as the specs on the back.
Now this arrow rest that comes with the bow is absolute trash.
You might be able to get it to work,
but it doesn't even come with the sticky on it already.
And that's the factory arrow rest, so we include our own arrow rest.
All right, let's check the draw weight on this inspected Black Hunter.
It's supposed to be a 40, stamped right down here.
Now one little secret on these inspected bows is that we write on the box the actual draw weight.
So this one is supposed to be a 38.3.
We list it as a 40 because that's the nearest 5.
So that'd be what I'd guess it'd be.
And that's one thing to keep in mind is that if you're looking for a specific draw weight
at 28 inches or a different draw length, you can let us know what draw weight you want
and we can get as close as we can based on what we have in stock.
37.7.
So it's about 0.5 off of what the box said.
37.7 is 2.3 off from a 40-pound bow.
Check the brace height on this guy.
According to the pamphlet, it's supposed to be 7 1⁄4 to 7 3⁄4.
Right at 7 1⁄2, so right on.
All right, specs on this inspected Black Hunter.
Very similar to the Amazon one.
The draw weight was more off than the Amazon one.
That was 0.2.
This was 2.2, I think, 2.3 off from 40 pounds.
They both came with everything they said they were going to come with,
as well as some extra stuff.
So this inspected one came with an extra,
I actually don't know if it's Dacron or D97 string,
but factory string, and then it also came with limb silencers as well.
Part of storytelling is telling the truth,
and the truth can often be hard to tell because,
well, for a lot of reasons.
Sometimes you don't want to, you don't want to be vulnerable,
you don't want to be honest.
And so this is something that I'm going to make myself do right now.
This bow right here is a shop bow that we use at the shop,
and so I packaged it up as if we'd send it out.
And as I'm looking through the specs, I forgot an allen key.
Now I wanted to just add an allen key in off video,
and then there'd be an allen key, but that wouldn't be telling the truth.
And so as far as specs go, this is missing allen key.
So what would be the case if you receive this,
you would either need to, if you had one, you'd be fine,
or you'd have to reach out to us to get an allen key
so that you could tighten down the limbs all the way.
I guess technically we don't say that there's an allen key included,
but there should be, and we should add that.
All right, let's check the draw weight on this.
Another thing to note, this is a custom bow.
So this is made to order.
So if you're looking for a 37 pound at 26 inches,
that can be done for you as well.
This one's marked 40 pounds, it's at 28 inches.
36.7, that's tough.
36.7, so this one would be marked wrong
unless the customer wanted a specific draw weight when we built it.
Man, telling the truth is hard, 36.7.
Because this was a return from someone who didn't want it.
And so we use it as a shop bow now.
If we could figure out which bow it was
to see if we measured the draw weight wrong,
if our scale's off, or if he wanted something specific
and that's why it's marked that way.
All right, good news for Shadowproof Archery at least.
I found the email thread with the guy who ordered this bow originally.
The guy ordering it said,
I ordered 40, but can you please make sure it comes in lighter?
I have a 27 inch draw and really need the bow to come in lighter than 40 pounds.
So we emailed back saying we can definitely do that.
I said also with a 27 inch draw,
you'll be pulling a couple pounds less than 40.
Do you want it lighter at 28 inches or lighter at 27 inches?
He never responded.
So I'm guessing what we did is at 28 inches,
we made it a couple pounds lighter than 40,
which is why it was 36.7, I think,
and listed as a 40 because that's what he ordered.
The other thing that could be going on here is Quinn's been using this bow.
He's been shooting it.
And so it's been strung up on the wall for a couple of months.
Yeah, at least a month now.
And leaving the bow strung over time can also reduce the draw weight.
So I'm guessing it was probably around 37, 37 and a half
because he wanted a couple pounds less than 40.
And we left it strung on the wall.
And now we've got a 36 point, whatever it was.
I could just not post this, but I'm going to anyways,
because telling the truth is more important than...
Hey, that's how we start the video, right?
You know, could be bias or I could tell the truth.
Here we are.
Now we don't look as good.
Well, at least we're honest.
Oh, man.
Yep, exactly.
30 or 40 miles.
It's like his own peninsula in the middle of the state.
So it's only a 36.7, I think.
So it might be a little slower than the others.
We'll see.
160.
Might be faster for an identical draw weight though.
All right, so we got the noise results.
We got the speed results.
One thing is that I did not install silencers on any of these strings.
And that will affect the speed and the noise.
So now I'm going to do the test again with the silencers provided for that bow installed
to see what's the quietest, what's the fastest on those levels.
And then we can analyze all of that information.
Okay, ready for the speed, smoothness and snaggability data.
Here it is.
This was measured taking five shots with each bow without silencers.
And then with silencers, we measured the speed, five shots, then smoothness, five shots.
And then we added the silencers, speed, five shots, smoothness, five shots.
Here's the results.
I'll put this up on the screen so that you can see the results as well.
Without silencers, the fastest was the Amazon bow.
And that is probably because it was a 40 pound bow.
So I did the speed divided by the draw weight to get feet per second per pound of bow.
And it actually flipped the script where the fastest was the Bob Garner.
And then it was the inspected.
And then it was the Amazon.
Now, as far as noise goes, the quietest was without silencers was the inspected.
The second quietest was the Amazon bow.
And the third quietest was the Bob Garner.
Now, the reason for that, reason for the inspected bow being quieter than the Amazon bow is probably
the Flemish twist string.
The Amazon bow has a, I think it says it's the same material, a Dyneema string, but it's
a endless loop string, which means there's no twists in it.
And it's a little bit different style in the composition of the loops.
And it seems like Flemish twists shoot a little bit quieter than endless loop strings.
Now, with the silencers that change things around a bit, you can see on the Amazon string,
it has these really big silencers, which is going to slow it down more than smaller silencers
like this.
The question is, is it worth the loss in speed?
So let's see the results on that.
The fastest ended up being the Bob Garner, which is interesting because the draw weight
didn't change.
And so the fastest was the Bob Garner, could be in part because of the silencers.
But yeah, it actually, according to those 10 shots between with silencers and without
silencers, it got faster by 1.8 feet per second with the silencers.
So that's probably due to human error as I'm anchoring, probably anchoring at slightly
different points or have slightly different release to have different draw weights because
it wouldn't really make sense for it to get faster without adding the silencers.
Usually it'll get slower.
The second fastest was the Amazon bow and the slowest was the inspected bow.
Now, if you look at the feet per second per pound, again, fastest Bob Garner, second
fastest inspected, third fastest is the Amazon bow, which makes sense because the Amazon
bow has such big silencers.
Now let's look at the quietness.
And what to look at here is the difference between how quiet it was with silencers and
without.
So from the, with the Amazon bow, it went down 1.1 decibels, not bad.
With the inspected Black Hunter bow, it went down for 3.7 decibels.
That's crazy.
And with the Bob Garner bow, it went down 0.6 decibels.
So not near as much as the other two.
I don't know why the inspected Black Hunter would go down so much just by adding these
small silencers on the bow and that it'd be even more than the other.
I don't know if it's, I don't know, but that's what the test results show.
The speed, I'll leave it for you to decide.
The smoothness, that's why I measured noise for that.
They all feel similarly smooth.
The, it was interesting because the inspected one, not because of anything we've done, but
the inspected one seemed to be quieter and smoother, which that's what the test results
showed.
And then the Bob Garner seemed to be a bit more snappy out of the, on the shot.
I'm not sure what would cause that, could be the thinner limbs.
But it seemed to be a little bit more snappy than the Black Hunters on the shot, which
the speed would back up on that as well.
As far as snaggability goes, that's just how easy it is to pick up and shoot.
I would say all of these bows are pretty equal as far as snaggability goes.
They are all pretty, they're all similar.
They're all easy to pick up and to shoot.
They all are cut to center, point the arrow where you want it to go, and the arrow goes.
So as far as snaggability, I'd say they're all equal.
Now let's look at sacrifice.
The sacrifice for the Amazon Black Hunter is like $94 right now, and that can fluctuate
a little bit, but it tends to be, it tends to be around $90 to $109.
For this one, the brand I got is the Obert Black Hunter, and so that one costs around
$100.
The Inspected Black Hunter is $188, and then the Bob Garner is $499.
That is the facts.
That's the, no conclusion, but that is the facts.
Now I will do a moment to mention a couple of things that are unique about these different
bows, a couple factors that don't show up on these five scales, so let's check out a
couple of those.
All right, here's a side-by-side-by-side comparison of how the three bows sound when
they shoot.
This is the Amazon bow.
Inspected, Bob Garner.
Speed, this is the Amazon Black Hunter with silencers.
All right, this one's the Inspected with beaver string silencers.
All right, this is the Bob Garner with beaver string silencers.
Some extras.
The Amazon Black Hunter comes with an endless loop string.
Now, it's not a bad string, it's Dyneema.
The downside to it is that it doesn't have any twists in it, and that it's a little bit
more noisy.
The reason no twists are a downside is because if you wanted to adjust brace height, make
the brace height shorter, you can't do that.
The Inspected Black Hunter, one benefit with that is customer service.
So if you wanted a specific draw weight, you could reach out to us.
If you have any issues with it, you could reach out to us and we'd be happy to take
care of you.
And then the Bob Garner, obviously made in the USA, you got the customer service.
It is a custom bow, so you can ask for specific draw weights at specific draw lengths.
The Amazon Black Hunter does come with a bow stringer.
While the Bob Garner has an option for a bow stringer, but it costs $20 more.
And then if you got a bow stringer with the Inspected Black Hunter from our site, it'd
be like $25, I think.
Another nice thing about the Inspected Black Hunter is that you can add a knocking point
if you want for $15.
We can also tune the arrows for you for $30.
To answer the question at the beginning, we set out to beat the Black Hunter, did we?
I mean, you could say we're competing.
We didn't beat it in price.
Beat it in speed.
A little bit louder with this particular one, at least, in this comparison.
Made in the USA.
So did we beat it?
You tell me.
And you tell me what you think is the best option.
Yeah, that's the facts.
Unbiased.
You got anything to add, Quinn?
It's the truth.
And the truth is the hardest to tell.
