How to Think About God's Existence

Decoding Life's Mysteries
11 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 30, 2026
God exists? God does not exist? I find flaws and fallacies in both sides. So I step away from "arguments" about God and ask how to approach God's existence. What's the process? Featuring interviews with Philip Clayton, Victor Stenger, Robert Russell, Michael Shermer, David Shatz, and Peter van Inwagen.
All my life, I've wondered whether God exists.
Not with occasional interest, but with constant concern.
Even now, after struggling through five decades of hope and doubt,
all I know for sure is that most people claim to know whether God exists, but I do not.
I do know all the arguments.
I've heard the best from both sides.
God exists.
God does not exist.
And I find flaws and fallacies in both sides.
So now I step away from arguments about God, and I focus on method and process.
How to approach God's existence.
How to think about God's existence.
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn, and Closer to Truth is my journey to find out how.
I'm looking for new ways to think about God.
So I begin in Cambridge, Massachusetts at the Harvard Divinity School
with philosopher-theologian Philip Clayton.
Phil's new thinking in religion is grounded on the bedrock of science,
and he's not afraid to challenge tradition.
Philip, I am deeply interested in the question, does God exist?
If I come to you as a philosopher asking you,
how should I think about this question, what's your advice?
I suppose I have an answer that will seem surprising for a philosopher who is also a theist.
I'd approach the question from the probability that there is no God.
I don't have to say too much about that for people in a scientific age.
There seem to be many reasons to doubt that we could know there's a God.
There's a problem of evil, which makes us wonder how all the evil and suffering in the world
is compatible with the existence of God.
Yet, as humans, we seem to be preoccupied with this notion,
a God, a highest reality, Brahman in the Hindu tradition, consciousness.
Maybe the idea of God exists just because it serves a function.
It expresses the ideal of moral perfection, perhaps.
It expresses the idea of the completion of reason.
All these functions that the notion God might have.
And then, at the very end of the day, I would say,
hmm, is it possible that this idea of God is something more than merely functional idea?
Could it be that under this world as we find it, there's some sort of deeper reality?
We seem to be an animal that's preoccupied with this possibility.
We think about life, we think about questions of death and significance
and moral striving and so forth.
And I think it's our fate, our heritage, and our great privilege
as Homo sapiens to raise this question.
And so, actually, I don't think that philosophy is a technical discipline at all.
I think every animal that knows it will die,
every one of us, he or she, is a philosopher
and raises this question.
Could there be a deeper dimension of reality?
So, you're saying that it's the awareness of death, potentially,
that is the key energizer in the human longings
to ask the God question.
Question. How, if at all, we can now make the step
from the longing to the assessment.
Is there any progress that can be made?
And for me, the interesting debate about the question of God
would be to take all the dimensions of human experience
and to ask one by one, do we see in this dimension
any, let's call it, intimations of transcendence,
science, morality, but also aesthetics,
the history of art and culture.
It's a fantastic quest.
And I think it is so deeply integrated with our humanity
that I can't imagine being fully human
without raising this question,
which I would call the question of God.
Phil's new thinking about God rejects God
in order to find God afresh.
He does this by exploring human existence,
the certainty of death, hints of transcendence.
He then seeks God as the ground of that transcendence.
Phil is criticized by both sides.
Theologians claim he's too deferential to science.
Scientists claim he's wasting his time with religion.
Phil, good for you.
But why do most scientists dismiss all religious ramblings?
It's too soft and too credulous, they say.
They demand evidence, hard and sure.
That's their method.
I like evidence.
So I visit atheistic physicist Victor Stenger,
who has made it his mission to deny and disprove
the existence of God.
Well, first of all, as a scientist,
I have to look at the evidence.
The only really serious way that we've been able to discover
throughout human history of getting at knowledge,
information about reality is by observation,
by the observations of our own two eyes
and also by the observations we make
with our scientific instruments.
And if God is the central figure of all existence
that many believers think he is,
then you would imagine that you could find
observational evidence for his existence.
Is it natural to subject something that,
by definition, is immaterial
to the techniques and methodology of science
which is focused on the material world?
Yeah, I think so, because basically what you're doing
is you're still looking at material things.
You're still using what's called methodological naturalism
without assuming an ontological naturalism,
without assuming that the reality behind it
is necessarily materialistic in nature.
And the most common argument that you hear
for the existence of God is that
you can't see how all of this could have happened naturally,
so therefore it must be supernatural.
And that's a God-of-the-gaps argument,
the argument that science doesn't know everything
and here's this particular gap in scientific knowledge,
so therefore we could fit God in there.
It's kind of an argument from ignorance, namely,
just because I don't understand
how to explain some phenomenon naturally,
that doesn't mean that science might someday
not be able to explain it.
Right down the list you can find examples
of where gaps in scientific knowledge have existed
and at the time were plausible sources of God's intervention
and time and time again they've been closed
by people like Darwin.
We don't believe in Bigfoot,
just because Bigfoot's possible,
we don't believe in him because there's no evidence for him,
Loch Ness Monster and so on.
Why is God any different?
Victor is a scientist.
A scientist requires evidence.
And as for God, Vic says,
all the apparent evidence has vanished or will vanish.
I cannot disagree.
What used to pass for proving God has been proven wrong.
So why then can't I leap to the logic of,
therefore, God doesn't exist?
Something's missing, I sense.
I'm not alone.
Many scientists believe in God.
Why? What's their method?
To find out, I go to Berkeley
to ask Robert John Russell,
a minister with a doctorate in physics.
Bob, what are some of the sophisticated philosophers,
theologians who believe in God,
what are the kinds of arguments they're using today?
In some ways they're using the traditional arguments
you've thought about.
The existence of the universe itself is the best evidence for God.
A lot of them are using science to say,
look, science demonstrates conclusively
the rationality and intelligibility of the universe.
It isn't just that it exists,
but it exists in a way where we can know it.
And that itself is an astonishing fact.
So let's explore that,
and why that would prove that God exists.
I mean, it is almost a tautology, as we might say,
to say that we understand it, therefore, God exists.
This is not a proof,
but it's a kind of argument for inference
towards the best possible explanation.
In other words, you can make a case
that the best possible explanation
of any universe existing is God.
We have no eyewitness to God's existence.
We have character witnesses.
If the universe looks like the kind of thing
that God would have created,
then it's a reason for tipping towards God
versus away from that.
It sounds like we're making a presupposition
that God exists,
and then looking around to see things
that confirm that presupposition,
as opposed to starting with a blank slate
and seeing what does the evidence entail.
Right.
Well, first of all, the blank set idea
is a kind of modern view,
where you start with blank slates.
You always start with presuppositions.
You begin with a faith assumption,
a presupposition, God exists or God doesn't exist,
and then you look to see how much of the world,
as you know it through experience and history
and life and science,
tends to provide confirming or supportive evidence,
how much goes against that.
So, again, not just that the universe exists,
but it's fine-tuned and it's intelligible,
are arguments people typically bring about
in the sense of inference to the best explanation.
One of the counter-arguments
is the presence of evil and suffering
and why bad things, terrible things,
happen to decent people
and why good things happen to terrible people.
And so there's a strong body of evidence.
It's not evidence for atheism
in some conclusive sense,
but it certainly is counter-meaning evidence
against the goodness of the universe
and its being here.
And that's always a problem for theists.
I wanted to go to an argument
that John Hick, a distinguished philosopher,
has written about.
He calls it epistemic distance.
His argument is that
the world has to be finely balanced.
You walk out in the playing field
and there's no direct evidence for or against God.
It's got to be a world with randomness.
Good things happening to good and bad people.
The world we're exposed to.
That that actually is the world you need
because it's the only world
in which you could really grow and mature
as a person of conviction,
whether the conviction is God or not God.
Otherwise, you'd be a puppet.
I mean, if God were so self-evidently in existence,
there'd be no relation of love,
of covenant, of choice.
It wouldn't be free.
It'd be forced.
Even if you were literally free
to do what you wanted,
but God was so obvious
that you kind of couldn't do anything else.
Exactly.
So what Hick is saying is that
this world is actually
just about what you'd expect
to see if it were a world
in which God created it
with this ambiguity,
but because God wants us
to have the opportunity,
the challenge to morally grow,
to spiritually grow.
And you call this epistemic distance.
Right, because there's a disconnect.
The knowledge of God's existence
is disconnected from the knowledge
we have of the world.
It's very subtle.
Now, I tend to say that's why science exists.
Science is possible in a world
with epistemic distance.
For spiritual reasons,
with epistemic distance.
But that also gives you
the possibility of science,
because science is based on
methodological naturalism,
which means you can study the world
without appealing to God.
So if the world is epistemically distant,
that is, if it's this ambiguous playing field,
it's also one of which
you can learn about the world
through science,
and science does not presuppose
God is an actor in the world.
As a scientist who believes in God,
Bob sees science
as a path to God,
not a way.
Not as proof of God's existence,
but as corroboration
or confirmation.
That's the process Bob follows.
Emotionally,
personally,
I'm with Bob.
Analytically,
rationally,
help, I need a skeptic.
One of my favorites
is Michael Shermer,
editor-in-chief of Skeptic Magazine,
with a doctorate
in history of science.
What I like about Michael
is that he works to understand
the methods and process
of religious believers.
Our position is the null hypothesis
that there is no God,
and the burden is on the believer
to present evidence
for the existence of God.
And so our position
is how do you engage in the debate?
I think there's two approaches.
One, you tell me
what your specific claims are
and the evidences for them
and the best arguments you have,
and then I will respond to those.
Two, I think there is
positive evidence
in support of the idea
that humans constructed God
and religion, not vice versa.
And so what are those evidences?
And I point to the sociology of religion,
the anthropology of religion,
and the fact that, you know,
historically we've constructed
all sorts of religions and gods,
and to me there's positive evidence
in favor of that
as opposed to the existence
of an actual being.
Historically, theologians
and philosophers of theology
have put forth a series of arguments.
Would you like any of them?
If you already believe,
they're reasonable arguments.
If you don't, they're not.
And they're just interesting
because they're big enough
to contemplate and ask,
but not big enough to answer.
So, your own view
sounds to me
more agnostic
than affirmatively atheistic.
In this sense,
I'm agnostic as Huxley meant it,
that God's existence
is not a soluble problem
by science.
Science cannot adjudicate
the God question
on the terms of existence.
Is that your base in society?
Oh sure, personally I think
everyone must confront
the ultimate sort of state of being,
why am I here,
what's it all mean,
that sort of thing.
Everybody, any thoughtful person
should at least think about those things,
but also read what all the great minds
have said about it.
And when you do that,
to me it seems like,
wow, no one's got the answer.
There's just a whole bunch
of scientific method
or set of logical arguments.
But in reality,
there is one truth.
Yeah.
I would be surprised at this point
in my life if there was a God.
So, I assume that there isn't.
I'm a non-theist.
I would be shocked, in fact,
if when I died,
there it was, the gates,
the pearly gates,
the guy with the beard.
I'd be, oh my God,
that's so anthropocentric,
it's such a human story
that the chances of that being the case
are, I don't think, too good.
Michael and I think so much alike,
he would almost convert me.
Yet I cannot rid myself
of an intuitive sense
that there is something more to existence,
that God, or something like God,
may exist.
But in this ultimate high court,
is intuitive sense
admissible evidence?
That's a rabbinical question.
So I go to New York,
to Yeshiva University,
to meet David Schatz,
a rabbi and a philosopher.
If I remain rational,
I ask David,
can I believe in God?
There really are two kinds of rationality.
One is what you call cognitive rationality
or epistemic rationality,
where you base your beliefs
upon the evidence
that's available to you.
But there's also a different kind of rationality,
and that is pragmatic rationality.
What sorts of endeavors
will bring you the greatest rewards?
And that is to say
that the reasons to believe in religion
are partly about the evidence,
but it's also partly about the benefits
that that religion offers to you.
There's a powerful, powerful essay
by William James,
The Will to Believe,
which I think is really
a classic of philosophy.
James' argument is
that sometimes in life
you confront the following kind of situation.
You have to make a choice
between two belief systems.
It's a choice in which
there is some appeal
that both sides have to you,
and it's an option
that he calls forced,
in the sense that if you decide
to sit on the fence,
you're going to make a decision
that's going to be just the same
as if you had decided against it.
It's like you'll see somebody drowning
and say, you know what,
I can't decide whether to go in and save them.
Well, then obviously,
the person's going to drown.
It's equivalent to you not going to save them.
And James says whenever you have
this combination,
live, meaning that the options
have some appeal,
momentous, important,
and forced,
between the scientist and the believer.
The scientist
is very afraid
of error.
He doesn't want to believe anything
for which he doesn't have sufficient evidence.
The believer
is full of hope,
and therefore the believer
will opt to believe in God.
The scientist will opt
to bet otherwise.
And what James is saying is
that both the scientist
and the believer
have a passion or a passional stance.
And as he puts it beautifully,
he says,
duperie for duperie,
what proof is there
that duperie through hope
is so much worse
than duperie through fear?
Both the scientist
and the religious person
are really acting on their emotions,
on their passions.
So what do you do?
I mean, what is he saying?
They're both legitimate?
in the cases of your own
pragmatic considerations.
But the believer is certainly
justified in moving ahead,
number one.
Number two, he does think
that the benefits that religion brings
are far greater
than the benefits that you get
if you don't involve yourself
with religion.
But isn't there a possibility
that's a combination
of wishful thinking,
sort of psychosomatic engendering
of emotional well-being,
and not tied
to some ultimate reality?
Right, right.
Some people have actually
called this about the will to wish.
There is a very difficult line
to draw between what's
wishful thinking,
what's legitimate thinking.
But it's a legitimate issue.
So is my intuitive sense
of God justified
or just rationalized?
I'm interested in fooling myself.
I fear fooling myself.
That's why I go to Notre Dame
to ask Peter van Inwagen,
a tough-minded
metaphysics philosopher,
who, even though a believer himself,
rejects arguments for God
that do not work.
How does Peter think
about God's existence?
So, why should I believe
that there is a God
when I look at the world?
And it doesn't force me.
I don't want to believe
that there is such a thing as God,
or it isn't obviously
the best explanation.
I would just have to ask
what the general epistemological
rule is here,
that you shouldn't believe
in something unless your experience
forces this hypothesis on you
as the only possible truth?
And I don't see why,
you know, if it's all right,
say, to believe that you
should vote for the candidate
that you believe in God
when it isn't forced on you
about your experience.
But isn't God's existence
something fundamentally different
than almost anything else
we can think about,
politics, art,
other kinds of things?
We're dealing with trying
to get to some fundamental reality,
not just an opinion
of what's good or best.
Something, some belief
that you have,
either there's a rule
that says you shouldn't believe
things that go beyond
the evidence you have available,
or there's a rule
that allows you to believe
in things that go beyond
the evidence.
So what follows from that?
What can we then infer
to the way to think about
whether God exists?
Well, I don't presume
to tell anybody
how to think about anything
that's weird.
That is, don't tell people
that it's wrong to have
religious beliefs
that go beyond the evidence,
but okay to have
scientific beliefs
or political beliefs
or philosophical beliefs
that go beyond the evidence.
Obviously, almost all beliefs
that my fellow philosophers
have must be beliefs
that go beyond the evidence
because they all disagree
with each other
and they all have access
to more or less
whatever evidence may be
in philosophy,
I guess, arguments,
pieces of philosophical text,
they almost go beyond it.
I don't see why that isn't
allowed to people
in religion as well.
You know, and I'm just saying
I don't want that license
or liberty to be denied
to people in the case
of religious beliefs alone.
It wasn't long
after my bar mitzvah,
the Jewish tradition
of becoming a responsible adult
at age 13,
that God got my attention.
Not as some religious experience,
mind you,
but as an intellectual search.
For decades,
I've enjoyed all the arguments
for and against God.
But after all my strivings,
I am feeling still at sea
with wobbly legs
on the battered boat
of my beliefs.
That's why I shift to
how to think about
God's existence.
But what I find
is discouraging.
Smart, sincere people
believe or disbelieve
unrelated to sound method
or clear process.
Rather,
they believe what they already
assumed to be true,
their pre-existing
belief systems.
So how do I
think about God's existence?
I do not fear
to hope beyond evidence.
But I dread
contorting evidence
into sustaining
false belief.
All I really know for sure
is that pursuing
God's existence relentlessly
is something
I cannot
not do.
Still for me,
that's closer to truth.
For complete interviews
and for further information
please visit
www.closertotruth.com
