7 Scientific Reasons Why Darwinian Evolution Is a Myth

Decoding Life's Mysteries
11 followers
53 Video Views·Feb 28, 2025
In this video, we are joined by Dr. Marco Fasoli who holds a doctorate in biochemistry from the University of Cambridge. Using science, he exposes many of the flaws in Darwin's theory of evolution.
I want to understand if we can actually qualify evolution as a scientific theory.
Obviously we're speaking about macroevolution. Can this be qualified as a scientific theory?
Well, we could take Darwin's words himself to answer that question.
Darwin himself said that his ideas on evolution are entirely based and totally depends on Elias
geological speculations, which have since been disproved by cutting-edge sedimentology.
With regards to whether it's true science or not,
his theory, in a letter to Asa Gray, he wrote,
quote, I am quite conscious that my speculations run beyond the bounds of true science.
It is a mere rag of an hypothesis with as many flaws and holes as sound parts, close quotes.
At least he's honest.
Now, the speculative nature of evolution, obviously there's been about 150 to 200 years
of time since Darwin published The Origins of the Species,
and so we can also hear what others have had to say.
The fact of the matter is that there are, despite the very prevalent and dogmatic support
that theory of evolution commands today amongst the scientific community, there are
a leading and growing number of honest scientists that, following 150 years of
fruitless searches for evidence that would support the theory, has spoken about Darwin's theory.
We have Dr. Ernst Chain, Nobel Prize-winning biochemistry, who helped develop penicillin in
1972. He called the theory of evolution, quote, a very feeble attempt to understand the development
of life, close quote. In another statement he made, he said, quote, I would rather believe
in fairies than in such wild speculation as Darwinian evolution, close quote.
We have Louise Bonneret, professor of geology at the University of Strasbourg,
say, quote, evolutionism is a fairy tale for grown-ups. This theory has helped nothing in
the progress of science. It is useless, close quote. And we have Albert Fleischmann, German
professor of geology, say, quote, the Darwinian theory of descent has not a single fact to
confirm it in the realm of nature. It is not the result of scientific research, but purely the
product of imagination, close quote. Obviously, we don't want to appeal to authority in our
discussion, but I think it's important to give a perspective on the words that Darwin himself
used, but also the words of other scientists, eminent scientists, that have taken a dispassionate
view on the topic. And I think this is something that's so crucial to cover, because basically,
I mean, it's quite shocking, to be honest, because in most schools today in this country,
and even in, I mean, we have a brother here from India who was saying that in his
education, in his biology textbooks, evolution was all over, it was everywhere. So basically,
it's been proclaimed as a fact. It's proclaimed as a fact. And the thing that's quite shocking is
that, I mean, as these scientists have just said, there's not a single fact which backs it up.
So obviously, there's something quite strange going on behind the scenes here.
Anyway, so the question I have for you now is, regarding Darwin's theory, what are the biggest
problems that you see in his theory? There are so many problems. I will highlight just a few,
but we could have lots of talks about this. The whole thing is, as intimated by some of the
earlier quotes, is full of flaws. But the fundamental issues with it are, I'll just
list them quickly. First of all, evolution is not observed and is not happening today.
It has not been observed in the past. It presupposes but cannot account for the origin
of life. I'm talking primarily of biological evolution here. It violates an important
physical law, the second law of thermodynamics. Its proposed mechanism of natural selection and
mutation has been shown conclusively not to work. It fails to account for the irreducible complexity
that we observe in biological systems. It fails to account for the origin of specified information
in the biological systems, primarily the genetic code. It fails because it violates many first
principles in philosophy, which actually renders the very concept of evolution
metaphysically impossible and hence irrational. That's just a summary of the problems, but it's
more extensive. I'd just like to ask you, because obviously you're speaking to someone here who's
very, very bad at science. Biology is probably my worst subject. Could you please
expand on some of the things you said? Because to a lot of it, it's like you're speaking a
different language. Yes. The purpose of these points that I'm making is really to encourage
people to do their own research and to be with an open mind. It's all available. It's all out there.
It's not spoken about in textbooks, but with an open mind and some research,
all these can be found. I think it's important for people to also form their own opinion about this.
But I will just go through some of these points in a bit more detail.
So the first point was that Darwinian evolution is not observed and is not happening today.
So whenever experiments have been tried to reproduce or simulate the evolutionary process
in the laboratory, they've always failed to produce any new species. I'll give a quick
example. E. coli is a form of bacterium, very, very simple organism, that reproduces every 20
minutes. Because they reproduce every 20 minutes, they have analysed it over a period of decades now.
So you have effectively, you can recreate in the lab, you can speed up evolution,
which is according to the evolutionary theory can take over hundreds of millions of years,
and kind of recreate it by looking at these organisms that reproduce very quickly,
generation after generation, you can recreate it in the lab. And the bottom line is that,
notwithstanding decades of these small bacteria called Escherichia coli,
reproducing under very favourable conditions, every 20 minutes, lots of generation, recreating
effectively the process of evolution, they still are bacteria. They haven't become
sponges, cats or frogs, and so on. A lot of work has been done by a scientist called Lenski
on this topic. Fruit flies, they've been irradiated with UV light to try and get
mutations to change their form. And all that happens is that they just get deformed and die,
they do not devolve. And we have simulations in the IT world. So the idea was, if any scientific
theory, empirical scientific theory, in the modern sense of the word, should be able to be
recreated through simulation, for example, in the cosmological field or the physical sciences,
this is a very common thing. But it has never been able to be successfully recreated through
simulations in computer science and IT. And the only way to make it work is, if you
introduce ad hoc interventions, meaning that you have to kind of fix the parameters in order to get
the answer that you want. But that is not how evolution in terms of the theory of evolution
is meant to work, which is meant to be a blind process with no guiding force and no intervention.
So it's not happening today. It has not been observed and is not happening in the past.
And that's the second point I was making. And here we have to look at the fossil record.
In The Origin of Species, Darwin himself made these comments, which are very significant.
He wrote, quote, as by this theory, innumerable transitional forms must have existed. Why do we
not find them embedded in countless numbers in the crust of the earth? Close quote. He himself
described the lack of transitional fossils as, quote, the most obvious and gravest objection
which can be urged against my theory. Close quote. Now, at the time, people were saying,
oh, we haven't looked around enough. We will find these fossils. Okay, so we wind the clock forward
100 years of hundreds of millions of dollars of investment to try and support and buttress
the theory of evolution. And atheist paleontologist Niles Erich, a very famous
paleontologist in the 1970s, acknowledged that despite massive efforts, nothing has changed.
Quote, it is a simple, ineluctable truth that virtually all members of a biota, which
basically means a species or a category of beings, of living beings, remain basically stable
with minor fluctuations during their duration, meaning that there is no new forms that can be
observed. The reality is that no meaningful fossils of the intermediate forms that are required
by Darwinian evolution has been found to date. Despite the existence of billions of fossils,
such a large number, incidentally, argues for a catastrophic event like the global flood. But
the fact that these transitional forms, as you evolved over time from the simplest organism all
the way through ultimately to man, you would expect a lot of intermediate forms, but they just
don't exist. They haven't been found. As evolutionary atheist biologist Jeffrey H.
Schwartz admitted, quote, instead of filling the gaps in the fossil record with so-called
missing links, most paleontologists found themselves facing a situation in which there
were only gaps in the fossil record, with no evidence of transformational intermediates
between documented fossil species. Close quote. These are scientists themselves saying this.
What we see instead is the same living forms persisting over supposedly hundreds of millions
of years of supposed evolution. There are fossils of squids that are supposed to be hundreds of
millions of years old that look indistinguishable from the squids of today. Bugs stay bugs,
as David Belinsky famously said. There's no evidence in the past that evolution has happened.
Evolution presupposes but cannot account for the origin of life.
Scientists have never been able to generate even the very basic constituents of life from
simple chemicals, despite decades of research and hundreds of millions of dollars of investment.
For example, there's no assembly of amino acids, which are the constituent blocks of proteins,
into proteins under abiotic conditions. The work of James Ture,
who's one of the most credentialed origin of life scientists in the world, with 800 research
publications, over 130 granted patents, and over 100 pending patents, he basically indicates that
there are insurmountable technical difficulties of generating even the simplest of biological
molecules, let alone any kind of simple organism. Experimentally, it's impossible.
This primordial soup model that you often see in many of the biological textbooks is just a
fairy tale. It's a fable. It violates the second law of thermodynamics. This is a physical law
that basically says that everything tends from an ordered state to a disordered state.
All the experience that we have is that all natural and physical processes,
for example, solar radiation, but also rain, wind, etc., are processes of decay that eventually
disintegrate all complex systems. Things will fall apart over time. That's the basic law.
It's called the second law of thermodynamics. They can vary the existing parameters of a system. For
example, iron can rust, but it cannot innovate the system and cannot change one thing into another,
particularly something that is more complex and more ordered. Yet, we believe that you can get
through these processes, these same processes, from molecules to man, as long as we have billions
and billions of years of time. The bottom line is you cannot get order and complexity from disorder.
No matter how many billions of years you're waiting, a pile of building materials will not
become a house, no matter how long you wait, just by waiting for the rain and the solar radiation
to make it happen. It's just not going to happen. In fact, over time, the building materials
themselves will crumble and disappear. Sure. You might get onto this later, but an interesting
thing that I heard in a talk by Father Rippiger is that he basically said, pertaining to this,
he said you can't give what you don't have. A piece of bacteria can't give the complexity
that a human being has. It's impossible. Basically, the cause has to be greater than
the effect. You can't create something that you don't have. I can't make you rich if I don't have
five dollars. It's like that kind of thing. Sorry to interrupt. We also have the proposed mechanism
of biological evolution that just doesn't work. It's called genetic entropy. A lot of very good
work has been done by Dr. Jan Sanford of Cornell. What he did is he measured the accumulation of
human mutations at around 100 new mutations per generation. Most mutations have a near-neutral
effect, are slightly deleterious, slightly negative. Beneficial mutation, things that
will give an improvement, are so rare that they're not even considered, essentially.
The bottom line is this. Every single mutation in the genetic code, over time,
will either have no effect or degrade functionality. They will degrade.
They do not add functionality. It's a bit like if you have a piece of software
and you have a bug, a software bug, you're not going to get anything,
an improvement in your software. It's going to degrade and probably stop working.
What Jan Sanford demonstrated through his work is that we, as humans, are actually degrading.
We're actually becoming dumber. We're not evolving. Interestingly, the rate of mutation
tallies with the biblical chronology. That's one of the reasons why the patriarchs lived for so
long because they were closest to the perfect prototype of Adam. That's very interesting.
Over time, all these mutations started to accumulate.
That's why lifespan decreased very significantly. We are getting a slight uplift recently,
but that's nothing to do with the genetic situation. It's some improvement of sanitation
and medical care. In terms of our genetic patrimony, we are degrading.
That's very helpful to note. It offers a good explanation to,
as you said, why the patriarchs lived for so long.
The bottom line is that genetic entropy has now conclusively shown that the fundamental
mechanism of biological evolution, which is the genetic mutation, the idea that through genetic
mutation and natural selection, you can get increased functionality, increased order,
increased complexity, you can go from a molecule to a man, ultimately,
just doesn't work. The mechanism doesn't work. We have irreducible complexity in all biological
systems that is, again, refuting Darwinian evolution according to Darwin's own criteria.
In The Origin of the Species, Darwin said, quote,
if anyone would prove the existence of a complex organ that absolutely could not have come
from a large number of consecutive changes, then my theory would completely collapse.
At the time of Darwin, cells were thought to be very simple blobs of goo.
But since then, we've had electron microscopy that has shown that cells are very, very highly
complex, what we call nanomachinery, like machines on a very, very small scale.
And they all have to be, all the functioning parts have to be present at the same time for
the cell to exist and survive. Cells are literally complex cities, which within the
interdependent factories and systems like a headquarter, the nucleus, the transport system,
the assembly system, manufacturing, energy production, storage, waste disposal,
very intricate systems all need to be together, otherwise the cell will just die.
So this is a classic example of irreducible complexity, a bit like the mousetrap.
All the components of the mousetrap need to be there at the same time and have evolved,
quote unquote, evolved at the same time in order for the mousetrap to exist and to be working.
This is not how evolution is supposed to work. But if you have examples like a mousetrap,
Darwin himself said, then my theory is false. Well, what we found throughout the biological
world is massive amounts of these, quote unquote, mousetraps, these machines that
need all of the parts to be there at the same time for them to work. Examples of
irreducible complexity. So by Darwin's own criteria, his theory fails. An example I'll
do very, very quickly is the cellular flagellum, which is used by bacteria for motion. It's like a
tail. It's like a tail. You think of it as a tail. It's made up of about 30 proteins
with a filament, a hook, and a rotor. So they're very sophisticated on a microscopic scale.
The rotor itself can operate at 6,000 to 17,000 revolutions per minute,
although with the filament, it's constrained. So the speed of rotation is down to about 200
to 1,000 revolution per minute. It's still pretty impressive. But it fails to assemble
and to therefore be functioning if only one of the 35 genes required to produce the 30
proteins is knocked out. This is an example of irreducible complexity that has been studied by
Michael Behe in particular and other scientists that conclusively show that we have these
highly sophisticated machines, which Darwin couldn't observe because the techniques weren't
available, but which refute his theory very clearly based on his own criteria.
So just to put this in layman's terms, just to make sure I've understood correctly,
we're saying that basically this flagellum only works if all of the parts are together. So it's
impossible that gradually over time each part came because it never would have worked.
Correct.
Okay, that's very helpful. Yeah, thank you.
It also cannot account for the origin of specified information evolution in biological system. What
do we mean by specified information? What we're referring to really is the DNA and the genetic
code. What we have found is that genetic code codes for information. It's like a manual,
instruction manual, for the production of all the materials and the overseeing of all the activities
of the cells. It's incredibly complex, it's massive, and it's made up of, so we're talking
about DNA, of a very sophisticated chemical and physical language that carries meaning.
Think of our language, only orders of magnitude more sophisticated. The words, I'll use simple
language. You have genes, you have codons, and so on, but the concept is this. This manual is
made up of millions of words. Each word carries a particular instruction or has meanings, has a
particular meaning, but the words are so sophisticated, in fact, that if you read the
word in one way, you get one instruction. If you read it in the opposite way, you get a different
instruction. You have mechanisms that translate those words into a different language, which
then can be read to deliver other instructions. If you read the third letter of those words,
of multiple words, you get a further instruction. What we are seeing is a level of complexity and
sophistication which dwarfs our own human language. Imagine, just as an exercise, creating,
say, trying to find a word of 12 letters that gives you one meaning if you read it one way,
another meaning if you read it another way, another meaning if you only read the third
letters of that word, and another meaning if you translate that letter into a new language.
It's just unfathomable, it's impossible. Yet this is what the DNA that we have in each of the
cells of the body and that every organism has, can do. So where does that come from?
Where does that come from? The mind of God. So any evolution tree cannot count the origin of
the specified information, even though they presuppose it in a sense, because without
that first replicating organism, there will be no evolution according to them.
And lastly, I would say that evolution breaches a number of self-evident first philosophical
principles. And I think you were referring to some of those earlier. But these philosophical
first principles are principles that do not depend on other principles to exist. They are self-evident.
They cannot be proved but are intuitively true. And our intelligence, our intellect,
gives instant assent to them when they're presented to the intellect. For example,
the principle of identity. A thing is what it is, or the principle of non-contradiction. A thing
cannot be in the same place and with the same respect to another thing at the same time and
in the same place. Something can't be, for example, here and there at the same time,
in the same formality. Yeah, correct. So if Darwinian evolution has to be true, it has to
adhere to first principles. And if it doesn't, because first principles reflect the objective
order of things, they reflect the fundamental structure of reality of the created world.
So if Darwinian evolution fails to adhere to those first principles, then by definition it
can't be a valid theory. But the problem is we find that Darwinian evolution violates many first
principles, which follows that it must be false in whole or in part. And what are those first
principles? You mentioned one of them, the principle of sufficient reason. Either the
existence of a thing is inaccountable either in itself or in another. You can't get what you don't
have. If I don't have a million dollars, I can't give you a million dollars. If I don't have eyeballs
as an organism, I can't give them to the one that is more sophisticated to me, the next one up the
ladder. And the primordial soup doesn't have eyeballs. The primordial soup doesn't have
eyeballs. Nor does the first amoeba, to be fair. But the primordial soup doesn't have lots of stuff
that the first amoeba has. So the first microorganism. The principle of proportional
causality. No effect is greater than the cause. You mentioned that earlier. But here we have a
systematic violation of this in Darwinian evolution. Life coming from non-life, multi-celled life
coming from unicellular life, swimmers from non-swimmers, walkers from non-walkers, flyers
from walkers, and so on. It's a constant violation. Principle of resemblance or continuity of nature.
Like begets like. All life comes from life. So a dog is going to beget a dog. It's not going to
beget a cat or an ape. If I plant my tulips, put some seeds, or I plant a flower, I'm going to get
the flower that I know I planted, not some other flower. Yeah, sure. That's the thing. It's actually
quite useful, I think. I was thinking about this the other day. If you actually think logically
about how things reproduce, this is a helpful way to basically dispel this concept of evolution.
If you're within a species, you have a dog, and you follow the genealogy of the dog,
let's say over a thousand years. How on earth are you going to get a cat? Do you see what I mean?
Because it's just going to stay within the same species. The dog breeds with another dog and gives
you a dog, which breeds with another dog and gives you a dog. How on earth do you eventually get a
whale? It's just a completely different species. It's a different essence. So that's something that's
very simple. What they do is they use time. They basically say, well, over billions and billions
and billions of years, you are going to get a little change here and there. And it's going to
suddenly, a fin is going to come out. I see. And that's the use of time. But the problem is that
that fails in all sorts of different dimensions. And we're not going to go into too much detail,
but all these other things I mentioned. And then the last one, I would just say the logical
principles. So far, we've talked about real principles, which have to do with the being
itself, or the being of a thing. Logical principle, which have to do with how we know about
something. And this is the principle of evidence that is refuted. And basically an explanation or
hypothesis must take into account all of the evidence. And a single piece of evidence that
is contrary to or cannot be accounted for by the theory renders the theory false in whole or in
part. And we have seen lots of them already. And there are many more that we can't really explore
in this talk. But evolution is not observed, absence of fossil intermediates, irreducible
complexity, and genetic entropy. Those facts taken singly alone suggest, according to the
principle of evidence, that the theories are either false either in its entirety or in part.
And here we have lots of them.
