Around 1200 BC, the most sophisticated network of civilizations the ancient world had ever produced collapsed within a single generation.
Archaeologist Eric Cline has spent his career forensically reconstructing why, and the answer is far stranger and more unsettling than a single catastrophic event.
Dr. Eric H. Cline is Professor of Classics and Anthropology, the former Chair of the Department of Classical and Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations, and the current Director of the Capitol Archaeological Institute at The George Washington University, in Washington DC. He is a National Geographic Explorer, a Fulbright scholar, a Getty scholar, an NEH Public Scholar, and an award-winning teacher and author. He has degrees in archaeology and ancient history from Dartmouth, Yale, and the University of Pennsylvania; in May 2015, he was awarded an honorary doctoral degree (honoris causa) from Muhlenberg College.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Archaeologist Eric Klein analyzes the Late Bronze Age collapse to identify why certain civilizations perished while others endured. By examining the roles of geography, leadership, and social equity, he draws critical parallels between ancient systemic failures and modern vulnerabilities, offering a framework for building societal resilience against inevitable transformations.
I'm Eric Klein. I'm an archaeologist and an ancient historian. I'm also the author of 1177 BC
and its sequel after 1177 BC. The period that we're discussing today is incredibly important
in the history of humankind. It's the Late Bronze Age in particular, which goes from about 1700 to
1200 BCE, or BC if you prefer. This was a time where people were basically globalized around
the Mediterranean in a way that is not frequently seen, and so what happened to them back then
may have implications for us today. So it turns out to be a much more important period
to study than one might expect, even though it's more than 3,000 years ago.
Even though I think we can rank these societies as to how well they each did,
one of the difficulties is to try to figure out why they did. Like, why were the Cypriots
and the Phoenicians able to be that much more successful than the Hittites, for example?
So archaeologists and ancient historians are now starting to try and answer these questions,
to grapple with the concepts, and we're getting a couple of interesting things. For example,
it's now been suggested that maybe some of the societies were more fragile than they appear,
and that they might have been more vulnerable to the stresses than they appeared to outsiders.
Like the Mycenaeans, they had been overexploiting the lower classes, and those lower classes might
have been quite happy to see the palaces fall, and even cheered, and they may have been, you know,
part of the internal rebellions. So it may be that something that looked very strong, like the
Hittites, was actually weakened internally, and the first big gust of wind came and knocked that
tree over, and boom, no more Hittites. But it also might have just been the luck of the draw.
It might have been geographical luck. So I think that's where water comes into play,
because the Assyrians and the Babylonians are in my category too, and they're right by the Tigris
and Euphrates. And the Egyptians, of course, have the Nile. Now, those are three of the big four
in the ancient world. I mean, my poor Mycenaeans and Minoans, they're not quite up there with the
others. You know, the big two in the Late Bronze Age are the Egyptians and the Hittites, but then
Assyrians and Babylonians. So of those four, Egyptians, Hittites, Assyrians, Babylonians,
Assyrians and Babylonians have the Tigris and Euphrates. The Egyptians have the Nile.
The Hittites are the only one of those four without a major water source. They're also
the only one of those four that go down completely. I don't think that's a coincidence.
And in fact, in talking to various people, I've heard time and time again that wars over water
are gonna be what are fought in the coming century. And we can already see that in California
with water, with Colorado, with Mexico, and all of that. So I think in some ways the fact that
the Assyrians and the Babylonians were able to maintain their government and their religion and
their writing systems and all of that might have been just luck of the draw that they were so far
inland that the Sea Peoples didn't get to them and they were on the two rivers, Tigris and
Euphrates, so that the drought didn't impact them as badly as it did others. But having said that,
we have written texts from the Assyrians that do talk about period of drought. They are hit.
It's not that long though. It's like less than a century and it came well after everyone else
had been hit. So there is something there to be said for where you happen to be. So again,
I think this is where we're gonna be looking in the future is how did these people manage to
survive or why didn't they survive? Were they not aware that they were collapsing? And again,
we have to keep in mind, and I actually say this at the beginning of the sequel,
most of our records are from the 1%. They're from the elite. We know how the kings did
and the central authorities that were living high. We don't know as much about the 99%,
if you want to call them that, about the farmers and the peasants out in the fields in Messenia in
Greece or the hinterlands in Anatolia. We don't really know their story that well,
but we're learning it because archaeologists are now moving out and excavating the little villages,
the little towns that are inhabited across the divide, Bronze Age and Iron Age. And so we're
gonna get more evidence. We're gonna get more answers. And again, that's what I love about
archaeology. It's not cut and dried, and if you will pardon the pun, it's not set in stone,
right? It changes depending on the new discoveries. So everything you're reading in the books,
not just my books, but the history books and all that, it's gonna be different to a certain extent
within five years, 10 years, 50 years, right? I've already come out with the revised version
of my first book, and I have a folder in Dropbox of new articles that have already come out
since 2021 that I need to take into account if we're ever able to do a third edition, right?
It just keeps coming. It doesn't stop, and that is what is absolutely wonderful about it.
In addition to all the other factors, whether it was luck of the draw, where you were situated,
or anything like that, the other factor to bring into account is how good were your leaders?
That is, were they able to lead you through this time of turbulence and catastrophe? Did you have
the right people in the right place at the right time or not? I suspect that contributed a lot to
this as well. So for example, when Egypt had three or even four people all saying that they were the
pharaoh at the same time in different parts of the country, that's not good leadership, right?
That's not how you're gonna get through this. Similarly, the Hittite royal family had a schism
at exactly this time and parted the ways. That was exactly the wrong time to do that. You needed a
strong leader in place at that time. Now, the one or the two societies that do seem to have had
the right people at the right place at the right time are the Assyrians and the Babylonians.
The Neo-Assyrian rulers and the Neo-Babylonian rulers seem to have been the ones that got their
societies through this. In fact, a couple of fairly well-known scholars, Assyriologists, have said
that that is why the Neo-Assyrians and the Neo-Babylonians held on for about 100 years
before everybody else, before they were impacted to a certain extent by the collapse. They said it
was because they had strong rulers in place that they were able to stave this off for a couple of
decades or a century at most. So, I do think that leadership is incredibly important because, in
part, that leadership will determine how well you respond. Having studied all of this, what happens
in the aftermath and all of that, I was, again, wondering what lessons could be learned from
the late Bronze Age collapse and the aftermath. Was there anything that is of use to us today?
And I did come up with seven things that I think are kind of common sense, if I may, that are things
to remember, things to live by, things that will help us if we're ever going down that same path.
So, I think the first one is pretty obvious, that you need to have redundant systems in place,
right? We talk about that all the time today, but I think it's incredibly important. You need
to have a plan A, and if that somehow doesn't work, you need a plan B, and if that doesn't work,
you need a plan C, right? It's kind of like having a generator in place in case your electricity
goes out, but I would say not just a plan A, B, and C. You need a D, E, and F as well. You need
multiple redundancies in place and plans that you can go to if all of your major ones fail. Now,
I think that is something that they needed to do back then and that we would still need to do
today. The next couple I would say are, again, common sense. Be strong enough to resist invasion
if you can. Know who your friends are and who they aren't, and also be resilient enough to go with
the flow as you need to be. Don't be rigid. Don't be just, you know, no, this is how we've always
done it, but be prepared in case you're invaded. Be prepared to reach out to allies, and in that
same tone, try and be as self-sufficient as you can, but not to the detriment of alienating your
allies, I would say, because you're going to need each other. So, if you're going to make it through
this crisis, it's going to be because you're leaning on each other. The other lesson that I
from the Iron Age, and I will deliberately call it the Iron Age rather than the Dark Age,
is to be innovative and inventive, right? The fact that in the aftermath of the Late Bronze Age,
they were innovative and inventive with iron and the alphabet, I think is precisely what we would
need to be again here today. So, we're talking in part, this is what evolutionary biologists and
others would talk about in terms of the adaptive cycle, that when you have a crash in one area,
you then have an immediate era afterward where you are innovative and inventive. It's basically
the rise and fall of empires, but here we've got a Mobius strip on its side, I would say,
and I think that's where this would come into place. If you are crashing, if your society is
coming down, one of the ways you can best be resilient is to be innovative, is to be inventive.
So, back in the Iron Age, what they did was turn to iron when they were having trouble making
bronze. That actually, tin back then has been compared to oil today, petroleum, gasoline,
and their need for tin back then is much like our oil today, but I actually think it's changing now.
So, just like in the Iron Age, they changed to iron. So, what we need to be more worried about,
I think, in this day and age are rare earths like lithium that are used in chips, in computers,
and cars, and microwaves, and everything else. If something happens to the supply chain,
and we are not able to get that, I mean, and remember what happened during the pandemic,
during COVID, which wasn't that long ago, that we had such supply chain issues,
and all of a sudden there was problems getting everything from computers to cars.
We need to be innovative and inventive. We need to be looking already for substitutes that can
take the place of lithium or whatever. This needs to be not another Dark Age. When we go down,
if we go down, and I actually think it's going to be when we go down,
we need to be prepared to turn on a dime and be innovative and see what we come up with next
if we're going to survive the collapse of our society, which I do think is coming. I don't know
when, but I don't think it's, are we going to collapse? I think it's, when are we going to
collapse? And in this case, we're going to need to be innovative and inventive.
The other thing we need to do, and again, I think this is very relevant
to today, is to prepare for extreme weather conditions. Now, back then in the Late Bronze
Age, I was talking about a mega drought that lasted 150 to 300 years. That, I believe,
would qualify as an extreme weather event. Today, we are also having extreme weather events. We see
almost on a daily basis now. And what I would say here, my rule of thumb is, look, prepare for
extreme weather events because then if they come, like intense hurricanes, then you're prepared.
And if they don't come, what have you lost? Right? Not much. So I would say one of the big
lessons from antiquity is prepare for extreme weather conditions. And along those same lines,
I would say one of the other lessons is to really be careful of your water resources,
right? Be very careful of where your water is going to come from, whether it's from a river
or elsewhere. But we saw what happened in the Late Bronze Age, and we're seeing what's happening
today, where people are already fighting over water resources, and especially rivers. So I
would say that that's another takeaway from the Late Bronze Age collapse and its aftermath.
And then the last thing that I would add is keep the working class happy. I mean,
any historian from any period of history will tell you that that's essential. Keep the working
class happy or there will be consequences to pay. And I think we see this in the Late Bronze Age
collapse, especially if internal rebellions are a greater factor than we have thought even till
today. And even now, I would say we need to look around and ask, you know, are we keeping the
working class happy? And if not, what's going to happen, right? People point to all sorts of things
like the Russian Revolution and the French Revolution and all of that. We've seen what
happens if the working class is not happy. So I think that that is, again, that would be my last
of the common sense takeaways, but surely we can add to it. I mean, I think we could probably easily
get up to a top 10, but for right now, I've got a top 7. One of the things we need to be worried
about is the tipping point. When are we going to reach the point of no return for ourselves?
Are there warning signs? I do think there were warning signs back in the Late Bronze Age. We know
that the Egyptians, for example, were trying to crossbreed their cattle, their normal cattle,
with zebu or zebu cattle who thrive better in arid conditions. Is there anything we can do today
if we notice signs warning us that we may be approaching a societal collapse, that there
might be a tipping point coming up soon? I think we've already got some of the signs out there.
Not everybody believes them, but I do think they are there. I think the extreme climate,
the weather conditions, is one of the signs that we're approaching possibly a tipping point.
But we've also got other things that some may or may not remember. Back during the pandemic,
when we had all sorts of supply chain issues and had trouble getting toilet paper,
that was a systemic problem and, I think, kind of a warning of what might come.
The ship that got stuck in the Suez Canal for five or six days, that, I think, was also
a problem. And it really drove home the fact that one ship stuck in one canal can affect people
worldwide for a week or more. And imagine if you had that at the same time as some of the other
problems. We might have been looking at a systems collapse very quickly. And, in fact, one of the
things I am now wondering about, back in 2008, we had the Wall Street financial crisis. What if
that crisis had happened 10 years later or a dozen years later? What if we had had the Wall Street
financial problems at the same time that COVID was hitting or beginning to hit? What if they
both happened in about 2020? I'm not so sure that we would be sitting here today. I think we might
be scrambling in the ruins of our globalized network. I think we might have come this close
to our tipping point, and we're lucky that they were 10 or 12 years apart. So I don't think we're
out of the woods yet, and I really do think that when people say to me, oh, we can't collapse.
We're too big to collapse. We're too big to fail. And I answer, no, we're not. That's hubristic.
Every society in the history of humankind has either collapsed eventually completely or has
transformed so much that they're almost unrecognizable in their new form. And to say that
that's not going to happen to us, I think is just foolish. It's hubristic, for sure. So when people
say to me, are we going to collapse? I look at them and I say, yes, we are going to collapse.
The question is, when are we going to collapse? And for that, I don't have an answer. It could
be next week, could be next year, could be 10 years from now, could be 50 years from now,
but I am sure that at some point we are going to collapse or have to transform. I mean,
maybe AI is going to create it and cause it right now, but who knows? My big question to those that
are asking me is to ask them back, when we collapse, how are we going to deal with it?
Are we going to be fragile? Are we going to be vulnerable? Are we going to be anti-fragile?
In the aftermath of our society collapse, are we going to be Phoenicians or are we going to be
Mycenaeans? And I personally am a bit worried. As an archaeologist, I look back and I tell my
students that they're the next generation and they're going to be inheriting all of the problems
we've created. We know that. I'm not saying anything new, but this is where archaeology,
I think, can be of use, and especially archaeology when it's applied to ancient history.
Because if we're willing to listen and to learn from the past, then we can deal with
what's happening in the present and that will affect our future. Otherwise, we're just doomed
to repeat the past again and again and again. And personally, I think we're smarter than that.
But I may be wrong. Let's hope I'm right.
Want to support the channel?
Join the Big Think member's community where you get access to videos early, ad-free.