Insurance Business TV presents an Elite Women special edition featuring this year’s standout leaders from across the global insurance sector, digging into the biggest forces reshaping careers, culture, and leadership at the top.
Joined by Fortegra EVP & COO Abbie Taylor, Markel Canada’s Dionne Bowers (also a co-founder and past Chair of the Canadian Association of Black Insurance Professionals), and Crawford & Company Australia’s Milia Xystros, the panel examines why progress into senior roles remains slow—and what has to change now.
From hybrid work and sponsorship to DEI accountability, and from AI fluency to the “broken rung” blocking advancement, this conversation connects the headlines to real-world actions leaders can take to build stronger, more resilient teams.
We've been talking about women being in senior roles quite literally for decades.
And I think we need to ask ourselves, why aren't we there yet?
Teams that incorporate diverse perspectives are consistently more
innovative and better equipped to navigate uncertainty.
With the increased female representation in executive roles,
we're going to see a multiplier effect on hiring and sponsorship.
Hello everyone, welcome to Insurance Business TV,
and welcome to an Elite Women special edition.
Yes, every year Insurance Business celebrates some of the leading women in the industry,
those that are in positions of leadership,
mentoring the next generation, or simply inspiring those around them.
And today we're joined by some of this year's Elite Women class from around the world
to talk about some of the biggest issues facing women in the sector.
I'm delighted to be joined by Abby Taylor,
Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of Fortegra in the USA.
Dionne Bowers, Co-Founder and Past Chair of the Canadian Association of Black Insurance
Professionals, also National Business Development Account Executive at Markel Canada.
And Milia Sistros, she is Head of TPA Claims at Crawford & Company in Australia.
So welcome everyone, and to get the ball rolling,
just tell me about the structural or cultural shifts,
whether they're positive or negative,
that you have observed for women working in insurance.
And indeed, which of these do you think will have the longest-term impact?
Milia, I'll start with you.
Thanks, Paul.
I think there's been a number of structural and cultural shifts
that have had long-term impact for women in senior leadership roles,
and indeed women in any role.
In particular, changes to working models with more flexible working options
and hybrid working models available,
certainly spurred forward by the global pandemic by COVID.
So it's something that's really happened to support women.
Society, I think still women provide the primary caregiving
and hybrid work models certainly help to support that type of culture.
There's certainly also been over a number of years now,
evolving perceptions in what it means to be a leader.
The days where the leader was the boss,
you know, the assertive, almost aggressive male
who made decisions on their own, gone.
And leadership now is really seen to be something
that is more focused on collaboration and diverse decision-making
to make the right decisions for a company.
And I think they tend to lend themselves better with women.
There are some risks though, I think,
coming from structural and cultural shifts,
and they include, as an example, AI and tech,
traditionally more male-dominated areas,
data-driven methodology and the like.
So I think there's a real opportunity for us to consider
what that impact will have long-term on women
who are in management and senior management roles
and what we can do to support and educate them to future-proof them.
Yeah, a lot of great points there from Amelia, Abi,
but particularly that one around AI.
I mean, that's just reshaping things across the board.
Absolutely. I think the most crucial shift
is the redefinition of core insurance expertise going forward.
As an operations and technology executive,
I see areas like AI and data analytics reshaping the industry,
and therefore the profile of future leaders will evolve as well.
And the long-term impact for women will really hinge
on whether they're able to gain early and meaningful exposure
to technical and commercial roles
that define enterprise leadership in the future.
Another structural change I would just mention is,
I do think there's more visibility at the top to female leaders,
and that'll influence the pipeline below.
With the increased female representation in executive roles,
we're going to see a multiplier effect on hiring and sponsorship.
And I think female leaders can use their visibility
to deliberately build the next layer of enterprise-ready talent
that will shape the industry's long-term leadership composition.
Okay, so more female leaders at the top, more visible at least.
Dionne, is that helping with career paths?
I would say that career pathing at this point,
and what I've noticed is that it has flattened,
which has created early roadblocks for women.
So if we look at the broken rung theory,
where the substantial barrier women encounter
during their initial advancement,
from entry-level roles to managerial roles,
it continues, it persists.
So when we look at organizations that are creating pathways,
I think it's really important that we emphasis
a trajectory that helps women progress.
So things like access to sponsorship is very key.
We talk about mentorship as being one piece of the puzzle,
but sponsorship being the point that is required for women to excel
and transition into leadership roles.
So making sure that they have access to high-visibility assignments
that allow women to demonstrate their capabilities,
because that, I find, is diminishing.
So when we have a strong male-dominated appearance
within the industry,
it's now saying, well, as a sponsor,
what can I get this individual to profile them
when they're not in the room?
So as formal development support declines
and promotion opportunities narrow,
the long-term consequences is a weakened leadership pipeline.
That ultimately constrains senior-level representation.
I want to talk a little bit more about leadership styles, if I can,
because the industry is facing a host of major forces right now,
whether that's AI adoption, which we've already talked upon,
climate risk, market volatility.
So Abby, where do you see women's perspectives
or leadership styles adding particular value
when it comes to navigating these challenges?
I think there are a number of different powerful leadership styles
that women tend to excel and bring to bear.
I'd really talk probably about three different ones.
One is just cross-functional collaboration.
The second is disciplined execution
amongst a number of different priorities.
And the third is just leading with empathy.
The first I mentioned, just cross-functional collaboration.
This is one of the defining capabilities
of effective leadership in our industry.
Insurance is inherently complex.
And so the ability to work across silos
and work together with actuarial, underwriting, technology,
the operations team around a shared goal is really important.
And I think that will be important as we build organizations
that are adaptive and resilient
to environments that are shifting in the future.
The second, just disciplined execution I mentioned.
In fast-moving environments,
organizations that win are the ones that follow through
with rigor and consistency.
And women are often very skilled in working in environments
with lots of different priorities,
not just from a work perspective,
but all the demands on their lives.
And I really see women often excelling
and delivering with focused execution.
And then the last thing is leading with empathy,
particularly in periods of significant change.
And that can be whether it's acquisition
or technology transformation or market disruptions.
Uncertainty is created in these environments
and leaders who take the time to communicate
with transparencies and transparency
and bring their teams along
will be really valued in the future.
And what are your thoughts on those characteristics
that Abby's raised, Dionne,
or indeed, do you have any characteristics
that you would highlight?
Well, when we talk about technological advancement,
the industry's growing with complexity.
So women's leadership perspectives bring
distinctive value to the insurance sector.
So as AI becomes central to decision-making
and operational transformation,
inclusive leadership plays a critical role
in ensuring that technology is deployed
responsibly and equitably.
When women are actively encouraged
to develop AI fluency and contribute to strategy,
organizations are better positioned
to mitigate bias.
They're able to reflect diverse customer needs
and harness innovation more effectively.
So expanding access,
again, there's that word access,
sponsorship and voice in digital initiatives
strengthens both talent readiness
and enterprise outcomes.
Now, when it comes to the industry's exposure
to climate risk, regulatory complexity,
market volatility,
these are demands.
These are the threats that our industry is faced with.
So when it comes to that demands,
it demands all of that demand, sorry,
resilient and well-rounded decision-making,
leadership styles often associated with women
to Abby's point is collaboration,
holistic thinking, thoughtful risk assessment,
which complement traditional analytical approaches
and enhance strategic planning.
So the reality is that teams
that incorporate diverse perspectives
are consistently more innovative
and better equipped to navigate uncertainty,
which I think is an advantage
that is particularly relevant
in today's risk environment.
I just want to pick up on a word
that Dion mentioned, Amelia,
with you, if I can,
and that's the word collaboration.
Do you think that women are perhaps
better suited to collaborative leadership?
Yeah, definitely.
And indeed, I echo all comments
made by both Dion and Abby
in terms of collaboration, empathy,
inclusive decision-making and the like.
Whether it's nature or nurture,
I think women can be more empathetic
and collaborative and mindful
of the broader teams
and even the broader society around them.
We talk a little bit about climate change,
but for me, insurance in particular,
we talk about it as a financial product,
but it's really a social product as well.
And bearing in mind things like
the impact that climate change
will have on vulnerable customers
and the broader community at large
and how that can be considered.
You know, Dion mentioned AI
and increasing our capability
and understanding in relation to AI,
but also the impact
that that will have on our people.
I know, I'm sure you ladies
have also already had people
coming up to you saying,
will my job be impacted by AI?
What will happen to me?
And just really providing that support,
that empathy and engaging and transparency
with your people,
I think will make businesses a success.
From that market volatility
point of view also,
you know, I think when people see diverse,
and it's not just women,
it's diverse boards,
it gives a level of comfort
around ethical decision-making
as well as the efficiencies
that the businesses actually
has well-structured
succession planning in place.
And there's not a narrow view
of what success looks like
in the business,
but a broader understanding
of what is happening
around them in society
and adopting an empathetic approach
and a collaborative approach
to decisions.
So I think overall, yeah,
I think there's some value there.
Yeah, well, let's talk a little bit more
about how society is changing
because attitudes without a doubt
have changed somewhat
towards diversity, equity
and inclusion initiatives recently.
John, just tell me,
how has that conversation
played out in insurance?
And indeed, what should
companies be doing now
to ensure that progress doesn't stall?
Well, across the insurance industry
in Canada,
the conversation around diversity,
equity and inclusion has,
it has evolved slowly
where there appears to be
few organisations shifting
from aspiration to accountability.
So when we look at
leading organisations,
they're beginning to recognise
that DEI is not simply
a values-based initiative.
It is a business imperative
that directly influences
things like talent retention,
innovation, risk assessment
and ultimately client trust.
Now, when you have
diverse teams in place,
they make better decisions
and are also well equipped
to serve an increasingly complex
and global marketplace.
When I was reading
the EY Women in Insurance Study 2025,
it specifically concentrated
its efforts on
the Canadian marketplace.
The survey that was done
was conducted in partnership
with the Insurance Supper Club,
which ISC Global Group.
And for the Canadian marketplace,
women occupy 66% of general roles
within the sector,
the insurance sector.
However, their representation
declined sharply.
And we know this
when we get to senior levels
with women holding
only 25% of vice president positions
and 18% of senior vice president roles.
So when we get to
the highest executive tier,
I mean, they referenced
publicly traded companies,
whether or not
that's insurance specific,
but it's looking at Canada's
100 largest publicly traded companies
and seven of them
have female CEOs, right?
So we're talking
about sustained progress
and that requires more
than performative statements.
DEI has to be embedded
into the organization structure
with clear metrics
for representation,
advancement and pay equity.
And that needs to be tied
to leadership performance.
So when we look at that,
we're looking or we're calling
for action for formal sponsorship
and development programs
that open, again,
those career pathways
to senior roles,
consistent, inclusive practices
in hiring and promotion,
transparent communication
about progress and gaps
and recognizing that collaboration
with internal stakeholders,
such as your employee resource groups
and maybe some external associations
with relevant expertise
will be essential.
Yeah, some fantastic points there.
And Amelia, I guess,
at the crux of it all,
is there a difference
that we're seeing
in the insurance sector
between words and action?
Yeah, exactly.
And picking up on some of the things
that Dion mentioned as well,
words to me are important,
but actions, of course,
speak louder than words.
And why I say that is,
we do need to be mindful
of the language that we use
around diversity, equity
and inclusion
and how it is supporting
or hindering the progress
of diverse promotions
within a business.
I was reading an article recently
which talked about how
women are often described
in senior roles
by their personality traits
and more people-orientated words
like being too ambitious
or not ambitious enough,
whereas men are really discussed
in terms of their tasks
and their actual achievements.
So just being mindful of what we use.
But ultimately, as I mentioned,
our actions speak louder than words.
So thinking about what we can do
to support a more diverse,
equitable and inclusive environment,
looking at things like Dion said,
equitable pay
and actually looking at it
and ensuring that there is equitable pay
for people performing
on an equitable basis.
Looking at things like unconscious bias,
are we providing as organisations
training on unconscious bias?
Should we be looking at
our recruitment processes,
potentially de-identifying CVs
so that you can't be influenced
by whether a person is a male,
a female, their race
or any assumptions
or unconscious biases
we might have based on a CV.
Looking also at things like parental leave.
I know, you know, in Australia,
the government provides
some financial parental leave,
but Crawford, where I work,
provides actually more parental leave.
But we also encourage men
to have parental leave too.
Actual co-parenting and supporting,
again, more diverse cultures
and so that we still continue
to push forward
and not stalling in our drive
for a diverse working environment.
Flexible work arrangements
I've spoken about before.
They cut both ways for me,
I'll be honest with you.
I do think there's a lot of merit
with people working in the office,
that tacit learning
rather than that more hardwired,
you know, data, factual learning
is certainly beneficial.
But having some flexibility
and supporting others
who can't always come to an office
for whatever they might be,
their reasons,
I think really has added
a lot of value to our businesses
in the last few years.
So I think there's a lot
we can do to ensure
that we don't stall in our fight
for diversity and inclusion.
Some great tips there.
And Abby, just to pick that up with you,
do you think enough is being done
to perhaps advocate
for high performing women?
I think that's absolutely a place
we can and should be focused, Paul.
If I look across the geographies
that we're representing here,
certainly the data is very similar.
Women are making, in the U.S.,
women make up, you know,
around 60% of entry level
or mid-level roles in insurance,
and yet less than 20%
of more senior leadership positions.
And so to me, access to opportunity
is where we can focus.
And Dion touched on this before.
The companies making real progress
are ensuring broad participation
in cross-functional projects
or high visibility strategic initiatives.
And senior leaders,
whether men or women,
can actively advocate
for high performing
and high potential women
and thoughtfully assign
different stretch assignments
to build their experience base
required for enterprise leadership.
And this is a place
we're really focused on
bringing these principles into practice.
And to me, being intentional
about who is in the room
when strategic decisions are being made
and ensuring that women in our business
have visibility to senior leadership
and are given these
meaningful development opportunities
is really critical going forward.
Well, we're talking about
getting women to the upper ranks
of the insurance sector,
but let's talk about getting them
in the industry in the first place.
Of course, talent attraction
and retention are pressing issues
across the sector.
So Amelia, what barriers
still exist for women
entering or indeed
advancing in the profession
and what practical changes
do you think would make
the biggest difference today?
I think we've already mentioned
a few already,
including cultural barriers.
It's a fact that women
still do tend to be
the primary caregivers
for children at home.
And so how we can support
that potentially with continuing
flexible and hybrid
working relationships,
as I mentioned earlier,
can cut both ways.
But I do think there's
definitely a place for that.
And I do know more and more businesses
are sort of pushing
for more time in the office.
So just making sure
we find that balanced approach.
Again, referencing unconscious bias
being a barrier and what we can do
around ensuring that we are,
you know, getting the right talent
and then retaining them,
even considering things
around networking events.
When do they happen?
Are they open to all?
Are we only doing them at night times
when people may have other commitments?
You know, I'm pleased to see
that in this day and age,
we do have networking events
and opportunities to meet
and advance careers
at different times of the day and night,
which I think is really beneficial
for all people in networking career.
But also, I think for a lot of women,
the barrier is intrinsic
within themselves
and there's a lack of confidence.
And I feel that often
that lack of confidence
is fuelled by the fact
that there is fewer women
in more senior positions.
You know, both the ladies
have referenced some statistics
around, you know, 20 to 30 percent
of boards or senior roles
are still only women.
So having that, you know,
referencing the Cinderella syndrome
where I sit back
and I wait to be noticed,
you know, really women
needing to put themselves forward,
advocating for themselves,
having that confidence to do so.
But ensuring that the business
is also structured in a way
that it supports visibility
of both competence and independence
and supports women
in their path of advancement
in their career.
And there's something
of a perception issue as well,
isn't there, Abby?
Across the insurance sector,
for men or women,
it's just not seen as sexy enough.
Absolutely.
I think the talent barrier
does start with the perception
of the industry.
For those of us
that have been in the industry,
we know that insurance
is one of the most
intellectually demanding
and rapidly evolving industries
in the global economy.
And yet it's consistently undersold.
There's different areas
that we're focused on,
managing climate risk at scale,
deploying AI across underrating
and claims,
just to name a few examples.
And this should be compelling work.
And we need to say so loudly
and early to potential talent
to join the industry,
whether that's in universities
or career development programs
and just how we talk
about the industry publicly,
because we often see that
when somebody joins this industry,
they stay.
So focusing on the perception,
I think, and bringing in talent
is a first step for us.
When you ask about retention,
I think another challenge we face
is we all know that
a significant portion
of the industry's senior talent
is set to retire over the next decade.
And this is not a distant problem for us.
Decisions being made right now
with how we fill our talent pipelines
are really critical
to make sure that we have the talent
as these roles are vacated.
Imagining, Dionne, as well,
that some of these issues
are just further exacerbated
for non-white leaders.
Is that correct?
It is.
I give massive kudos
to Abby and Amelia's responses,
because within that conscious
or unconscious bias,
we're looking at the influence
that it has on recruitment,
promotion, and everyday decision making.
And oftentimes,
it's reinforced by outdated perceptions
of leadership style.
So how a leader should act
or communicate, that has changed.
The risk appetite,
so the leader's willingness to take risks,
that has also changed,
as well as the executive presence.
So the image of what a leader looks like,
we're shifting away
from the traditional suit and tie
in a lot of spaces.
The confidence or the behavior
that is expected
of someone who holds a top role.
So I think we need to really reframe
the definition of what a leader looks like.
Amelia touched on the external pressures
of caregiving.
We've talked about access
to influential sponsorship,
because that to me still remains uneven.
And to your point, Paul,
it's looking at the underrepresentation
of non-white leaders at senior levels.
So that limits visible pathways
for advancement and signals
that the opportunities
to young people or career changers
coming into the industry
that were not yet
equitably distributed.
And so when I go back
to the EY report,
it's called Breaking Barriers,
Advancing Women in Insurance.
The research that was done
within that research,
there was a survey
done by the American Society
for training and development.
And they revealed that 75%
of executives credit career
development to mentoring.
But with most people
aligning themselves with mentors
who share similar backgrounds,
have same gendered proteges,
it goes on to address that
while this outcome
is not inherently harmful,
the fact that 72%
of senior vice presidents
in the Canadian insurance industry
are men, which means women
have fewer opportunities
to find mentors
who can support
their career advancement.
So this factor contributes
to their underrepresentation
in executive roles
and helps perpetuate
the glass ceiling phenomenon
when it comes to white women
and the concrete ceiling
for black women, right?
It's very different between the two.
So addressing these challenges
requires deliberate action,
embedding flexibility
as a standard
practice at all levels,
shifting from mentorship
to true intentional sponsorship
will help increasing
the transparency around
promotion and pay,
strengthening early access
to things like technical
and leadership development,
and ultimately holding
leaders accountable
through measurable
diversity outcomes
that are tied to performance.
It's paramount at this point.
Yeah, and you've all been
very, very generous with your time.
Thank you very much.
It's been a fascinating discussion.
I just want to throw
one more question at each of you
if I can.
Just tell me
what are some of the pivotal moments
or trends that you think
leaders perhaps are
underestimating right now,
especially when it comes to
its impact on women in the industry.
Avi, anything that you would highlight?
Sure, and I think that Dion and Milia
and I have already
touched some on this,
but the pace of the shift
towards technical fluency
can't be underestimated.
I think as AI analytics
and automation reshape
underwriting and operations,
early exposure and experience
in these areas
is going to be critical for talent.
And the way I think about it
is you want to couple
domain knowledge with AI fluency,
and that combination
will be really powerful
for any talent in the future.
So providing access and training
will be important
and making sure that
women are part of that.
And then I'd say this,
the other big pivotal trend
is just faster decision cycles,
which are partly due
to the changing technology.
But that can potentially narrow
who gets a seat at the table.
And so in volatile markets
with compressed timelines,
it may mean fewer voices are consulted.
And so again, being intentional
about how we have
high potential talent,
having exposure
to these high stakes decisions
will be really important going forward.
Yeah, some great examples there.
And Dion, any trends
that stand out for you?
Well, understanding that
the industry is at a
structural turning point,
technologically, culturally
and competitively.
We need to look at
who is going to
be the next generation of leaders.
So hybrid working,
we've touched on that,
has increased flexibility,
but without clear guardrails,
it can create that visibility gap.
So proximity bias,
which is often unintentional,
can affect access
to stretch assignments,
sponsorship and promotions.
Because women are more likely
to use flexible arrangements,
poorly designed hybrid models
by organizations,
risk reinforcing
rather than reducing inequity.
So at the same time,
AI automation
and data-driven transformation
are reshaping core functions
and underwriting claims
and distribution.
So if women are not
intentionally included
in upskilling digital leadership
and innovation pathways,
they risk being concentrated
in roles most vulnerable
to disruption
while remaining underrepresented
in positions shaping
the industry's future.
So the choices we make today
around flexibility,
digital investment,
leadership criteria
and accountability
will shape the strength
of our future leadership pipeline.
Leaders who consider
these decisions through
the use of a gender lens,
for lack of a better term,
will build stronger,
more resilient organizations
while those who do not,
they risk reinforcing
outdated imbalances
at a time when diverse perspectives
are essential.
A great message
for any leaders watching out there.
Amelia, any final points from you?
I certainly echo the comments
made by Abby
in terms of AI fluency
and, you know,
how we might be underestimating
that in terms of supporting women
in more senior roles
and we can do that.
Most definitely support
Diane's comments
in relation to flexible
work arrangements
and being visible
and what impact that will have
not only for women,
but employees who are working
in more regional areas.
They can be your best employees,
but sometimes maybe
are being overlooked
because they're not visible
and there is a push
for organizations
to have more and more people
in the office.
What does that mean?
Are we considering
all our consequences of that?
But also for me,
a trend that we really need
to focus on
is the slow pace of change.
You know,
we've been talking about women
being in senior roles
quite literally for decades
and I think we need to ask ourselves,
why aren't we there yet?
What is it that is preventing us?
Because we're about to have
this next change now,
you know,
like how Dion described it
in terms of
we are at a change moment now
with flexible work arrangements,
AI,
there's a lot going on in the industry
that may push that movement back
for diversity and inclusion.
So why didn't we get there
and how can we continue
to constantly challenge ourselves
and progress
and really create
high performing teams
that support industries,
societies and their own families?
You know,
how can we continue to strive
and improve as businesses
and as a society?
I think there are things
we need to challenge ourselves about.
Well, fantastic thoughts from everybody
and indeed,
congratulations again to all of you
on being named among this year's
elite women class
across the insurance industry.
And remember,
for more from the sectors elite
from around the world,
well, keep it right here
on Insurance Business TV.