Layout Planning Part 2 - Track Planning And Benchwork

Toy Train Tips And Tricks
93 followers
1 Video View·Mar 3, 2026
Episode 67: Continuing the series on how I designed and built my new FUN Lines layout, we look at the process of track planning in this episode.
What are your "Gotta Have's" and your "Wanna Have's"? Find out why answering those questions first will help create a more satisfying railroad in the end.
The FUN Lines was designed using SCARM: https://www.scarm.info/index.php
Hello again, this is Mike from Toy Train Tips and Tricks, and today we are continuing our
series on planning a layout. Step one was to evaluate your space to realistically look
at how much space you have. Part two, keeping that information in mind, translating that
into a track plan and benchmark. Keeping in mind that everyone's layout is going to
be different. Everyone has different needs and different wants and what they're looking
for in a layout. I'm going to walk you through the steps that I did to work on my new layout,
which is now about a year old. And in the steps that I took, and so you can apply those
to planning your own layout, whether it's your first layout or whether it's expansion
of your current layout. So keeping in mind what I learned in step one, my obstacles
were first of all, a need for storage. We moved into a much smaller house with much
less storage space. Our previous house had a large two-car garage and a large outdoor
shed and a much bigger basement. This house, smaller basement, no garage, no outdoor storage.
We needed to find a place for more of our stuff inside. So the layout room, in addition
to being for the trains, also has to double as a storage space. I also have some obstacles
in the room to work around. I have an electric meter, an electric panel. I have a door that
I need to have access to, to the furnace in case of repairs or replacement. And I have
some built-in shelves that I need to work around. So all of these play into my track
plan and my plan for my bench work for this layout. So when you start this idea of track
planning and bench work, you need to break down, make a list of what I call your gotta
haves and your wanna haves. The gotta haves are the things I absolutely need to have my
layout do this, this, and this in order for me to enjoy the layout. And then the wanna
haves are, well, I'd like to have this, but I can live without it if I have to. So for
me, and again, this is going to be different for everybody, the gotta haves for my plan
were, first of all, I needed space. I needed storage space incorporated into the train
room. Secondly, I'm on a cheap budget. So I'm working with things that I already have,
inexpensive building materials, cutting corners, not so much on quality, but using as much
of the existing items that I already have. I've got to work, as I already said, with
storage. I've got to work within my existing space. But what I want to have, I gotta have
at least two main lines. I want to see at least, have the capacity to run at least two
trains at the same time. On my wanna haves, well, we always want the longest possible
run for our trains. Running around in a circle doesn't entertain us very long. So the biggest
main line is possible. I really want a multi-track yard with a yard meet if possible. That allows
you to do switching without interfering with the trains on the main line. I really wanted
to incorporate my number 2317 drawbridge. This was a key element of my previous layout.
It was a really neat feature, drew a lot of attention and kept operators occupied. I really
want to incorporate that into the new layout. I also wanted to incorporate my Carrera Go
set, the kids slot cars, were also an integral part of the previous layout. It made a nice
scenic effect in using both the trains and the cars in the same layout. It really generated
a lot of interest. So I wanted to have that if possible. Also, my gotta haves, I've got
to have an independent track where the fat wheel Marx locomotives that I have could operate.
This is less of a problem now as I have found a way to make the Marx turnouts compatible
with more modern equipment, as you see in a previous video, but that was a concern.
I needed the space for operating accessories. I have a Rhino milk car, a cattle car, some
dump cars, a mail car. I wanted places where these operating cars could work. And I wanted
it to be fast and easy to build. I wanted to get the trains running quickly. So with
these considerations in mind, I moved forward into the track planning aspect. And to help
me do this, I used a tool, a track planning tool called SCARM, Simple Computer Assisted
Railroad Modeler. This program is a free download. I'll include the link in the description
of this video. After a really quick tutorial, it's pretty easy to use. It includes a library
of both Lionel and Marx track, which is useful for me, not only for the turnouts, but I like
to use Marx 034 curves as well as Lionel 027 and 042. So having that option made it easier
to do the track planning, and it has a nice 3D modeling feature where you can, you know,
look at, you know, a kind of a 3D idea of what the layout will look like. And that led
me to my first plan. Now this first plan was a simple 4x8. My idea was to avoid all of
the problems with the outside of the room by putting a 4x8 in the center of the room.
And so let's look at the plan, and let's change the view here. Add some scenery. There we go.
All right, so we have an outside loop that is 042 track that's here on the bottom.
Let me get rid of this. There we go. So you can see it. There's the 042 loop around the
outside. So that takes care of one of my one-and-a-halves. Here on the inside, this loop has some 027
turnouts and a combination of 027 and 034 curves. So it's not super, super tight with all 027.
It has some 034s here and here. So there's my second loop. I now have two main lines.
Do I have places for my operating accessories? Yes. I have a spot for a dump bin up here for
the operating dump cars. I have this for the operating cattle car. And I have this platform
for the operating mail car, milk car, things like that. I've got a switch tower. I've got
places for a passenger platform. And I've got this elevated section up here where I could put some
buildings, a little bit of scenery up here. And I have an upper loop that would be all with marks
turnouts. Or actually, I considered using Sakai turnouts here. They're kind of unusual, but they
work the same way, allowing fat wheel operation. I was going to use that for a third train.
So here in a 4x8 space, I have a plan that gives me some limited switching options and
sacrifices space for action, giving me three train operations in a small space.
But what it doesn't do is, let's take a look at our wanna-haves and our gotta-haves.
On the gotta-haves, it fits in the space. Yes. Cheap budget, 4x8, easy to build. Here's the
problem. It doesn't address my storage. In order to have access to all areas of the 4x8, both sides,
again, I like to have a 30-inch minimum aisle for access. So having my 4 feet plus 30 inches on each
side only left me about 18 inches for shelves on either side. And that was just not going to be
enough. I did have my two main line minimum. I actually had three main lines. I didn't get
any of my wanna-haves. There's no bridge. It's not a very long run. I don't have a yard.
I don't have a place for the career I go. I did have a place for the fat wheel track. I did have
a space for the operating accessories, and it would be fast and easy. And I had a 042. But the main
problem was I did not have space for the storage. So not meeting that basic design problem of
storage space, I moved on to plan B. The second plan was to build an around-the-wall layout.
The table would be built above the built-in shelving, but below the electrical boxes,
there was room to fit it. I was going to make individual 30-inch wide by tables no more than
68 inches long, some of them shorter, bolted together, six tables in total, but they were
bolted together to be easily removed in case of maintenance or remodeling or anything I needed
to do in that space. This would allow me to put a 30-inch wide storage shelf under each layout
section. So each table would have both the layout top and a 30-inch wide shelf and storage on the
floor underneath. And I would access the interior of the layout through a drop gate. So this
around-the-walls idea led me to this plan. And let's change the view here so you can see some
scenery. And what we came up with this time is I have a large 042 mainline around the outside.
I have a large 027 and 034 track around the inside. So there's my two-train operation.
I have a multi-track yard. I was not able to get that yard lead in here. I tried to switch
it several different ways to make the yard lead fit, but I do have my multi-track yard,
which also serves as a place for my operating accessories. I have a place for my 2317 drawbridge.
It's not on a mainline, it's on a siding, but still there's some operating possibilities
with that over here. Most importantly, I have my storage underneath all of these sections.
And there we go. And I access the interior through this drop lead. So this plan is what I went with.
I made some minor changes along the way. First of all, note over here in the yard, while the track
geometry in the SCARM is right for the track itself, for the turnouts, it does not make a
combination for the bases and the switch motors. And so using the stock line-out or mark's turnout,
you can't quite get them as close together as it's shown here. I needed to add footer sections,
small straights in between each one, which changed the geometry over here a little bit. It made me
move this to actually on the drop lead section. So it changed the geometry over here, and it
significantly changed the geometry over here. With where this is located, this swings much
farther out. The drawbridge is over here with the trestle, and I was able to add a hidden track
under here as well. After I built the layout, I did have this siding in for a while. I later took
this out, allowing me to take out this 027 section, making a nice wider curve along here,
which gives me not only a wider curve, but allows me to put a passenger station in here with an
unobstructed view. It makes this kind of a focal point scenically when the layout is finished right
here. And I added another siding right here as well, since this track was moved farther back.
So how does this plan work with my gotta-haves and wanna-haves? Well, on the gotta-haves,
it fits in my space. The budget is still cheap because it uses materials that I already have.
It meets the storage requirement, unlike the first plan. I still have my two mainline minimum
to good all over here. On my wanna-haves, I have a considerably longer run.
I have my multi-track yard. I didn't get my yard lead,
but I have the multi-track yard. The drawbridge is incorporated, although not as part of a
mainline as it is on a siding, but it's still there. The Carrera Go didn't really fit on the
main part of the layout. My plans were to eventually build an upper level on this side,
as you can see here. It's all under tunnel. And I was going to put the Carrera Go on this
upper level with a small piece of track as well. I ended up scrapping that idea because I was
running out of time, really. It was taking me too long. So I moved the Carrera Go set to one
of the storage shelves below the layout. So it's not really incorporated in the layout. It's in
the same space, but the cars and the trains do not interact with one another. I think the kids
are starting to outgrow the slot cars anyway, so this may not be a huge problem. The Gotta-Haves
that works with my fat wheel track, my inner loop, was all set up with Mark's turnouts.
I have space for the operating accessories in the yard. It was going to be a fast and easy build.
Put up the tables, put up the loops of track, and then add more stuff later. And one of my main
lines is 0.42 or larger. The outside loop is all 0.40, 0.42 track, except for the switch turnout.
The main line itself is 0.42. So building this with my bench work, I used the tabletop design,
really no elevation changes except for the trestle going to the drawbridge,
so I could build a flat tabletop design. I used 5.8 inch MDF board because I found a bunch of
this at my local Habitat for Humanity restore for really inexpensive. This is the kind of stuff
that is underlayment for kitchen countertops. So it is thick, it is strong, and in my case,
it was great because it was cheap. My basic tabletop height is 42 inches. That puts it
above the built-in shelves but underneath my electrical boxes. That also allows me to
put shelves underneath with plenty of clearance for 18x30 storage bins. I use 2x3s for the outside
frames and legs, and I also use 2x3s for the lateral braces that are a maximum of 15 inches
apart, sometimes closer depending on the length of the table. You can probably get by with 1x3s,
but the COVID lockdown had already started, and I couldn't find any 1x3s. As a matter of fact,
I ended up clearing two of our local hardware stores out of all of the 2x3s that they had,
and I couldn't find 1x3s anywhere. So it's a little overbuilt with 2x3 braces.
The lower shelf provides the leg support because it's identical in dimensions to the top,
but it is 21 inches from the shelf top to the tabletop, which gives plenty of clearance
not only for the 2x3s, but for up to 18 inches of storage bin on the shelves,
and then also storage underneath. And the six tables are bolted together for easy removal
for maintenance issues that may pop up in the basement as we go along.
There are other popular options for how to build benchwork. One would be an open grid design.
Using this, you generally use a 1x4 frame. You could use 2x4s, but 1x4 is generally strong enough
around the outside perimeter. Make a rectangle, then put 1x4 braces across the rectangle every
12 to 15 inches, depending on how strong you want the top to be, and then use 1x4 risers
to connect this frame to the underside of your track roadbed, which typically would be plywood
that is cut to the shape of the track. This allows for easier elevation changes. You basically
lay the track out on your plywood, trace the shape of it, and cut out that shape,
and then use 1x4s to adjust the height of the track at different places.
So again, the open grid design is very useful for layouts with when you have multiple elevations of
track. It just makes it easier to accommodate those. And another popular benchwork design
for model railroaders is the tried-and-true L girder option. Similar in concept to the open
frame, but instead of having the outside rectangular frame, you build L girders. You
take two 1x4s, put them at 90 degrees in the shape of an L, and connect them that way,
making a single girder. Put two of those across, usually at around 30 to 36 inches,
depending on how wide the area is that you're framing in. Then lay 1x4 braces across the top
of these girders, every 12 to 15 inches, depending on how much strength you want.
And then again, using 1x4 risers to go up to your cookie cutter roadbed, just like the open grid
framework. And again, 2x4 legs. And this allows not only for easier elevation changes, but also
if you, instead of having the tabletop look of rectangles, if you have more curves and other
cutouts in the perimeter of your layout, the L girder, by allowing you to change the length of
the cross braces and how far out they overhang, makes it easier to get those nice gentle curves.
So that is also a popular option among model railroaders.
So that's how we did, how I did my track planning and how I did my bench work for my layout.
In part three, we're going to cover some of the basics of wiring and electrical.
We'll talk about command control versus conventional control, tab control versus
block control, and a few other tidbits about wiring up your basic layout options that you have
for wiring and operating your layout. So again, thanks for watching. I hope you found this
informative. Like it, share it, subscribe, tell your friends and tell your neighbors,
and keep those trains running. We'll see you in the next episode here on Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
