Today we are tackling a massive misconception in the hobby. You see, when most people think of 3 rail O gauge model trains, they assume they're a relic of the past. They think of the trains that Dad or Grandpa used to have, but they are completely unaware that brand new, cutting-edge O gauge trains are actively being made right now in 2026. If you are looking for a 3-rail O gauge starter set today there are two options, Lionel, the firm traditionally associated with O gauge toy and model trains, and the modern disruptor shaking up the market, Menards. If you’re looking to buy your very first set or want to expand your layout, which one should you choose? Let’s break it down!
00:00:00 Introduction 00:27:48 Starter Set Makers 00:52:58 Brief History of Lionel and Menards 04:09:54 Different Track Systems 05:02:47 Control Systems 06:13:38 Sound Systems 06:51:43 Couplers 07:11:40 Menards 275-9523 M&M's Train Set 07:50:54 Menards 275-9409 Burlington Northern Train Set 08:14:48 Menards 275-9040 Soo Line Set 08:22:00 Menards 275-9350 Tulsa Tank Train Set 08:39:40 Menards 275-9498 Dino Express Train Set 09:00:54 Lionel 2623080 Bethlehem Steel Mill Runner Set 09:42:49 Lionel 2623070 Frisco Shipping Service U36B Set 10:13:59 Lionel 2623110 Santa Fe Super Chief Set 10:31:51 Lionel 2623160 Union Pacific Flyer Set 10:50:49 Lionel 2623150 Pennsylvania Keystone Set 11:14:47 Lionel 2623130 Hogwart's Express Set 11:42:35 Lionel 2623050 Spirit Of Christmas Set 11:59:42 Lionel 2623120 The Polar Express with Skiing Hobo Set 12:28:41 Lionel 2623140 Winter Wonderland Set 12:49:48 Lionel 2623100 Christmas Light Express Set 13:18:39 Lionel 2723010 Lionel Lines 2-6-4 Postwar Set 13:44:42 Lionel 2723020 American Defense GP38 Set 14:10:37 Summary
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Hello again! This is Mike with another episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
Today, we're going to address one of the big misconceptions about three-rail O-gauge trains.
Most people, when they think of classic three-rail O-gauge trains...
Thinking of Lionel and Marks and others...
They think that they're just a relic of the past.
They think about the trains that Dad or Grandpa might have had.
And they're completely unaware that three-rail O-gauge model trains are still made today.
So, if you're looking for a three-rail O-gauge starter set today...
That would be everything you need to get started in one box...
You have a couple of options.
One is, of course, Lionel trains...
The name that everyone recognizes and everyone associates with these types of trains.
And the other option is the new upstart...
Menards.
Which option should you choose? Let's take a deeper look.
Now, before we look at the individual sets...
Let's break down the history of the two companies.
Because they come to us from two totally different places.
Lionel is the definition of toy train royalty.
Founded by Joshua Lionel Cohen in 1900...
Lionel practically invented the American toy train tradition.
By the 1950s, they were a household name...
Putting trains under millions of Christmas trees.
Despite ownership shifts over the decades...
They've remained the gold standard of O-gauge trains.
Menards, on the other hand, is a massive family-owned home improvement chain in the Midwest.
So, how did they get into trains?
Well, the company's owner, John Menard, is a passionate train hobbyist himself.
And around a decade ago, Menard started manufacturing highly detailed, affordable O-gauge freight cars.
Fast forward to today, and they are fully in the locomotive and starter set game...
Providing real competition to the old guard.
Lionel tends to focus on premium, licensed experiences.
They give you a highly detailed locomotive with freight or passenger cars...
A full loop of track, and a power supply.
These sets typically retail between $350 and $450...
Featuring themes like the Polar Express...
Christmas, or classic post-war inspired sets.
Menards focuses on value for your dollar.
Their starter sets usually retail between $200 and $300.
And they have a blast with their themes...
Offering everything from the whimsical Dino Express...
To the colorful new M&M set...
To prototypical freight sets, all featuring their sleek FP7 diesel locomotive...
Sometimes disguised as a dinosaur...
In road names like Burlington Northern, packed with two sturdy freight cars.
How easy is it to actually buy these sets?
Well, Lionel has global reach.
You could buy Lionel products at hobby shops, major online retailers...
And sometimes even in national big box stores during the holidays.
Menards is physically located in the American Midwest.
And if you're lucky enough to live in their service region...
You can find O-Gage trains on the shelves from October through January.
Oh, and another tip...
During the off-season months, some train items are still available upstairs...
In the off-season area of the store.
You can also have items delivered site to store year-round at no charge.
If you live outside their service region...
You can order directly from the Menards website...
And have your items shipped straight to your door in most of the lower 48 states.
However, there is a major catch for online buyers...
And that is that Menards does not ship to certain US states, including California...
Due to some specific state regulatory compliance issues.
So if you live out West, getting your hands on a Menards set can be a real challenge.
Also, the popular 11% rebate program through Menards is only available for in-store purchases.
Lionel starter sets include Fastrack...
A rigid track system with included plastic roadbed.
While Lionel Fastrack looks much more realistic...
And it's perfect for running on carpets because it keeps dust and carpet fibers out of the gears...
It can get pricey when you want to build a bigger layout.
Menards sets use classic tubular metal track.
It doesn't have a built-in roadbed...
Meaning you do need a hard surface like a plywood table or a hardwood floor to run it reliably.
However, traditional O-tubular track is significantly less expensive for expanding your empire.
And here's another great tip...
You don't actually have to choose one or the other.
Both manufacturers make special transition track sections...
That allow you to connect Fastrack and tubular track seamlessly together on the same layout.
And how do we control these trains?
After all, control systems have come a long way since Grandpa's massive ZW transformer.
Today, Lionel Trains has gone fully digital...
Featuring absolute train control using a free Bluetooth app...
To control the direction, speed, sounds and other features of the locomotives.
If you prefer to hold a physical remote in your hands to control your trains...
The Lion Chief Universal Remote Control is available for separate sale.
Menards, on the other hand, includes a remote control...
A physical remote control with every locomotive and train set.
This controls your direction, your speed, your sound functions...
Even the volume of the sounds themselves...
And it is all included right there in the box.
However, Menards trains are not compatible with Bluetooth control.
And for those with existing layouts...
Remember that even though both sets come with DC wall adapters...
Both Lionel and Menards locomotive control systems...
Can operate perfectly well on traditional AC transformers...
If you want to integrate them into an existing legacy layout.
Let's turn up the volume and talk about onboard sounds.
Both systems feature built-in audio...
But there is a quality difference.
Lionel has a massive advantage here with their Lion Chief sounds...
Giving you very realistic chuffing, diesel revs, crisp bells, whistles...
And even specialized crew talk announcements.
Menards also features basic onboard horn, bell and pre-programmed crew talk sounds...
And while they add plenty of fun to the play experience...
Their sounds are definitely more basic and toy-like...
Compared to Lionel's more realistic sound offerings.
And when it comes to switching cars and making up freight trains...
It's good news because both firms offer operating knuckle couplers...
That can be uncoupled remotely using special track sections.
And these couplers are fully compatible with regular Lionel knuckle couplers...
That have been made since 1945.
So, what starter sets are available in 2026?
Let's start with Menards.
As of the production of this video...
The most recent Menards starter set announcement is the M&M's Express...
Featuring a colorful licensed FP7 diesel...
A matching offset cupola caboose...
A gondola with five M&M figures...
Plus a 56 inch by 36 inch oval of track...
Power supply and wireless remote.
The listed price is $249...
But Menards often offers an 11% rebate program for in-store purchases.
For more realistic train operations...
Menards recently released the Burlington Northern freight set...
Featuring a Cascade Green Burlington Northern FP7 diesel...
With a gondola and a quad bay coal hopper.
Featuring the same track and control options...
This set is priced at $229 before rebates.
You may also be able to find previous releases of this set in different road names...
Such as Soo Line.
Also from previous years, but possibly still available...
Are the large Tulsa Tank Train set...
Featuring a powered Santa Fe FP7 with a matching non-powered unit...
Plus three modern tank cars.
This set is listed for $399.99 before rebates.
And the whimsical but fun-packed Dino Express set...
Featuring an FP7 disguised as a dinosaur...
Plus two gondolas with 15 total dinosaurs...
A Dino Kibble core car...
Plus a motorized Dino Chaser vehicle...
All for $299.99 before rebates.
Lionel's starter sets for 2026 feature lots of variety.
First up is the Bethlehem Steel Millrunner Lion Chief 040 set.
This set includes a classic Bethlehem Steel 040 steam switcher...
With sounds, headlight, smoke, and operating rear coupler...
Plus a culvert gondola with load, a twin bay hopper car, and an illuminated porthole caboose...
Plus track and power supply.
The locomotive can be controlled with a smartphone using Lionel's Cab 3 app with voice control.
The suggested list price is $349.99...
But many retailers will offer significant discounts, especially as the holiday season approaches.
For diesel fans, the Frisco Shipping Service Lion Chief U36B set is available.
This set is led by a colorful Frisco U36B diesel with sound, headlight, and operating couplers...
Followed by a piggyback flat car with two trailers, a Frisco box car, and a modern extended vision caboose...
Plus track and power supply.
Control is again provided via the Lionel Cab 3 Bluetooth app.
The set has a list price of $399.99.
For passenger fans, the Santa Fe Super Chief Lion Chief set features a classic Santa Fe FT diesel...
With Bluetooth-controlled sounds, headlight, and operating couplers...
Plus two matching illuminated passenger cars, track, and a power supply for $399.99.
The Union Pacific Flyer Lion Chief set is led by a Bluetooth-controlled 080 steam locomotive...
With sounds, smoke, headlight, and operating couplers...
Plus a matching tank car, box car, and center cupola caboose.
Of course, track and a power supply are also included for $329.99.
The Pennsylvania Keystone Lion Chief set is available exclusively through Hobby Shops.
It features a Bluetooth-controlled Pennsylvania 080 steamer...
With smoke, sounds, headlight, and operating couplers...
Plus a box car, flat car with removable bridge, and a Pennsylvania N5C-type illuminated caboose...
Plus track and power supply for $359.99.
Fans of the Harry Potter film series may like the Hogwarts Express Lion Chief set...
Featuring a Bluetooth-controlled 460 steam locomotive similar to the one in the films...
With sounds, smoke, headlights, an operating coupler...
Plus two matching illuminated passenger cars, track, and power supply for $399.99.
The set is also available in a special Christmas edition for the same price.
If you like the European styling of the Harry Potter set, but not necessarily the films...
The Spirit of Christmas 460 passenger set includes all of the features of the Potter sets...
But is decorated in a Christmas theme for the same $399.99 price.
Speaking of Christmas, the Polar Express Lion Chief set with skiing hobo car is also available for 2026.
This set is led by a Bluetooth-controlled 284 steamer similar to the one in the films...
With sounds, smoke, headlight, and operating couplers...
An illuminated observation car with swinging skiing hobo and hero boy...
Plus an illuminated coach car, track, and power supply for $399.99.
Or choose the Winter Wonderland Lion Chief set...
Led by a festive Bluetooth-controlled 080 steam locomotive...
With sounds, smoke, headlight, and operating couplers...
Plus a matching box car, triple-dome tank car, and center cupola caboose...
Plus track and power supply for $329.99.
To really light up the season, try the Christmas Light Express Lion Chief set.
Led by a Bluetooth-controlled 284 steam locomotive with sounds, smoke, headlight, and an operating coupler...
The set also includes a festive Happy Holidays box car with LED lights and holiday carol sounds...
A Seasons Greetings box car with LED lights...
And an illuminated caboose, plus track and power supply for $469.99.
Late additions to the Lionel Starter Set lineup include the Lionel Lines 264 Post-War Inspired Freight Set...
Featuring a Bluetooth-controlled clone of the classic number 2035 Lionel steamer...
With sounds, smoke, headlight, and operating coupler...
Plus a box car, operating log dump car, an SP-type caboose, and track and power supply for $469.99.
And for lots of play value, there's the American Defense GP38 Freight Set...
Led by a Bluetooth-controlled GP38 diesel with sounds, headlight, and operating couplers...
Plus a flat car with missile load, a Minuteman missile launching car, and an illuminated security caboose with rotating searchlight.
The set also includes track and a power supply for $399.99.
So, which option will you choose?
If you're looking for state-of-the-art Bluetooth control...
Top-shelf sound systems and control...
Nationwide availability...
Well, then Lionel might be your better choice.
On the other hand, if you're on a budget...
If you're more interested in whimsy...
Don't mind the slightly lower level of sound system...
And you prefer a physical remote...
Then Menards might be your choice.
Which way are you leaning? Well, let us know in the comments.
And don't forget to hit that like button, subscribe to the channel, and share with a friend.
And most important of all, keep the trains running.
And we'll catch you next time with more toy train tips and tricks.