How I've always made French Onion Soup - Classic

More Than Recipes
100 followers
221 Video Views·Mar 2, 2026
Possibly the original hug in a bowl, cheesy, beefy oniony goodness. This is how to make french onion soup.
French Onion Soup (Gruyere Croutes)
8 italian white onions, peeled and sliced
125g butter, diced
25ml sherry vinegar
200g madeira
3ltrs beef stock
-
Heat a wide based pan, melt butter and cook sliced onions slowly until deep golden and sweet. Deglaze with sherry vinegar, reduce, then madeira, reduce again. Add beef stock and simmer 20 minutes. Correct seasoning if needed.
Fill ovenproof bowls halfway with soup. Slice and cut bread with cutter, then fry in melted butter until crisp. When cool – top with grated gruyère. Bake at 200 °C until bubbling and gratinated. Finish with thyme.
Audio tracks for some languages were automatically generated.
AI Generated·May contain errors
This is one of my absolute favourite things to make, French onion soup made proper. This is a
soup that's got layering and layering and layering and detail but the result is indulgent and
absolutely unique. A beautiful soup done proper. Okay for French onion soup we need a few things,
we need lots of onions. I use white onions, these are Italian white onions, lots of those peeled.
We need some Gruyere cheese, a little bit of bread for a crouton, that's thyme, fresh thyme rolled up
in a muslin, salted French butter, that's sherry vinegar, that's Madeira and this is very critical
to this is beef stock, that's French onion soup. Okay let's move all this out the way for the
minute we just need to concentrate at the moment on our onions. So vinegar, Madeira,
these look at those Sam, I bought those in an antique market in France, they are lion head
bowls with a difference, see how they come into play later on. That's the beef stock we made last
night and there's my onion. So we need to slice these, I like to slice onions with a nice thin
bladed knife, I don't know if that's technically right but ultimately it gives me a really fine
controlled version. When we're slicing onions we need to take off the root, cut it straight in half
through the root. These are just peeled so that you don't have to stand here and watch and film me
or watch me peeling onions which is not a fun thing to do. So just straight through the root
and then I cut a little v that side and a little v that side and line them all up and this is a lot
of onions because that's what French onion soup takes, absolutely tons of onions and when people
make it on an industrial scale they often use a Robocoup slicer or a big machine to do it with but
cutting them by hand is actually better because the onion will stay together, they're nicely cut
with a sharp knife, they give you a much better finish that we can use for stocks and sauces.
Right now I've got all my onions there all lined up, all topped and tailed. Now very importantly
there's two ways to slice an onion, if you go this way what you create is an onion that will
basically fall apart, you see that, they break at the sort of little junction, they just break,
they fall to pieces, don't cut them like that. You want to cut a sliced onion with the way that
the grain runs like that, use a claw method, nice sharp knife, I use a thin knife for this.
You don't actually need these onions to be really really fine and you see now because of all the
already cut, they're already v-shaped, both of them, they've got no root in them, they're nice
and even and I can just sit here and go straight through them. You could use a chopping knife
in a kind of rocker motion which would look a bit like this, which is more traditional I guess,
so using a claw method and sort of rocking through but for me that is not as efficient
as what I'm doing, I find it more efficient to work like this, I can just chop straight down
and end up with a bigger pile of onions in a quicker fashion. Let's put a nice pan on,
you need a pan, heavy base pan, really structured, you want to hold the heat,
retain the heat in that pan, so you use a really good pan, nice salted french butter,
plenty of butter in there, that is a, that's going to be all those onions you saw, so lots of butter
goes in there, get that butter down, no need to melt the butter now but we can start to build up
the onions in there. Another thing that's important as well is that the onions aren't
too long, you know when you go in, think about the end user, when you go in with your spoon,
if the onions are very big onions and you cut them the wrong way, the pieces can be kind of
that long, they will then sit, they'll just fall over the spoon so you can't actually eat it,
you've got to think about things like that, all the devils in the detail Sam. I'm going to season
this now, this is Maldon sea salt, okay that's all my onion slice, it looks like an awful lot of
onions, that's about eight onions, quite small white onions, that's going to be enough for about
four or five portions of french onion soup, believe it or not these onions are going to
disappear into nothing by the time they roast down. We'll put some nice black pepper in there
as well, that's why it doesn't work, nice black pepper, in that goes and we just keep that going
down, I'm keeping the heat pretty strong there, I'm not turning this down to absolute minimum,
you see that, can you see there all the water that's coming out, that's the salt that's make
that happen, so the salt's drawing all the moisture out of the onions, give that a really good stir
and just let that melt down now, this will take about 40 minutes, 30 to 40 minutes to get these
onions to where we want them before we can start adding the Madeira or the vinegar, so just be
patient, get that on there, no cartouche, no lid, let all that evaporation happen, that's really
important, you can smell those onions and often sometimes onions they can make you cry as well,
best thing I know for that is dip your fingers in cold water, takes the crying thing away,
the enzyme away that makes you cry. Okay so these onions, believe it or not, that's exactly 30
minutes to get that massive pan of onions all the way down to there, where they've still got
structure, that's really important, soft, short, cooked, sweet onions, nice and brown, not dark, not burnt,
that's really important and they're not caught on the bottom and that's because the pan's great
quality as well. Right now a few things need to happen at this point, this is a great place to get
to and now we've got a good four or five portions of French onion soup, that there is a little bag
of fresh thyme, beautiful, that's going in there now, didn't go in the beginning because I think
it will just overcook and you'll get all the tannins from the thyme out there, you don't want
that, I want it at this stage. There's a single bay leaf that's going in there now at this stage
and that's probably different to what some other people do but I don't really care. That is a little
bit of sherry vinegar, that's to sort of cut through all the richness of the onions and the fat
and the beef stock. With anything like this, very important that the richest, the most acidic thing
goes in first. So if you're doing armagnac and then port and then red wine, it has to be
armagnac first, then port, then red wine, we've done this before on the channel.
With acidity like this, always high vinegar first, then into your alcohol. So let's get that
vinegar burnt away, having its effect on those onions, softening the onions even more, balancing
out all of the richness of the onions and the butter and the beef stock. Get that cooked away,
can't see anymore, great, in with the Madeira. So this is layering, sweetness and depth.
A nice Madeira, you don't need to go with a crazy expensive 20 year old Madeira or something,
just a very standard Madeira is absolutely fine. You're looking for those sherry notes,
the sweetness, the nutty notes that Madeira brings. I really love Madeira in a French
onion soup. Get that in and bring that down on a rapid heat and then it's going to be time for
the beef stock. Very simple, but the ratio of beef stock is very important. God, you can smell
that Madeira. When are we going to get our viewers being able to smell things as well, Sam? That's
the key, eh? Right, that Madeira's gone now, see that? Right, here's that beautiful rich beef
stock and I will do something on this this year on stocks, I think, because it's really nice.
That's just fat on the top there, I'm going to scoop that away, you see that?
Just use a ladle. A ladle works because you push the bell of the ladle into the stock
and then you can swoop around and you can lose that, you see? All right, in goes the beef stock.
If you use too much beef stock, you're just going to end up with a very diluted
French onion soup, which you don't want. So be cautious when you add in, you can't take back out.
So make sure when it goes in, you've got the right amount and that can take a little bit more.
There we go, that looks about right to me. I want a nice ratio of beef stock to onions and I want
that thyme in there and I want the bay leaf and all I'm going to do now is simmer that for about
10 minutes just to get the whole thing amalgamated, get the thyme permeated through, get the bay leaf
in there, let that all happen together and then we're going to move on to the finishing. So if
come over here, we're just going to make a little garnish for our French onion soup, a very
classical garnish. So all we're going to do is create a float on the top. I'm going to do three
actually. Al, have you got a round cutter for me, please? Okay, so Sam's asked a very good question.
When you're adding that stock in, I'm just doing that naturally to eye, but ultimately how do you
know when that's enough? So simply if you lift that up, what's that feel like when you lift it
up? Does that feel like French onion soup? For me, that immediately identifies as French onion soup.
That means that the ratio is absolutely spot on. I don't want tons and tons of onions. It's not
a bowl of onions that are slightly moist with beef stock. It's about a 50-50 ratio.
So I feel like when I'm doing that, I'm obviously doing it by eye, but I feel like that's enough.
Right, we're just going to make a couple of croutons out of this bread, which are going to be the
piece de resistance in our finishing of our French onion soup. That's enough now.
We'll pull our soup off for a moment and just let that infuse. Go back on with a little frying pan,
take a little bit of olive oil, and all we want to do is basically crisp up these croutons
so they don't just completely disappear and dissolve. While they are frying, I think
Gruyere cheese is the one. It's the only one really you need to use. For me, it gives that melt,
gives that slight acidity as well. I think it's really lovely. It's a great cheese.
What you're looking for is the cheese to kind of melt into the soup and give you that overall
feeling where you've got crispy bread, you've got sweet onion texture, and you've got rich beef
stock. A hint of Madeira, we've got a bit of acidity. It's an absolute, it's the ultimate
hug in a bowl is a French onion soup. We love it. Right, so let's get that lovely soup,
take out our bay and our thyme, that's done its job, and our soup goes in to our bowls.
What's interesting is, I was actually slightly wrong. It does happen. All those onions I made
were literally just three portions. So it's quite important that you understand how little comes
out of those onions once you've finished cooking them. So you start with a lot of onions and you
just end up with three portions of soup. Right, onto that crouton goes the Gruyere.
On top it goes like that. It needs to be a slightly obscene amount of cheese.
I think that's quite important and it needs to float on top like that. Okay,
that's now going to see my oven for about six minutes. Beautiful. Be good. Okay,
that's had about 10 minutes in there. Nice and golden brown that's going on the top there.
Bubbling, bubbling, bubbling hot soup. That should come with a health warning, that one Sam.
That's a serious bowl of cheesy onion, beefy goodness. There we go. That is my version
of that brilliant classic French onion soup. Fantastic thing. It looked like a lot of cheese
but actually once it melts in, I think that's the right ratio of onion as well.
I think it's the right ratio of onion. I think it's the right ratio of sweetness.
I think it's hotter than the sun. Oh, that is fantastic. Adam, come and try this. It's so good.
Because Trinity is what it is, we don't serve a bowl of French onion soup. We do in some of
the other restaurants but it's just not something we serve very often. It's great to be reminded of
how bloody good that is. There we go. That's my absolute favourite soup with many different
guises. This is a French onion soup. We don't make it to Trinity very often but I think this
is one of the most indulgent soups. It just needs a few of those little details to make
that absolutely right. White onions are the key. A little bit of sherry vinegar, a little bit of
Madeira. Be generous with the cheese. Cook the onions enough. Put it in a nice pot. You can
make this the day before. That's really important. You've just got this absolutely indulgent, cheesy,
oniony, beefy soup to die for. Oh, that's hot.
