Life after death is explored in the context of diverse theories of consciousness, from strict Materialism/Physicalism to those of ancient wisdom traditions. We explore the view that the haunting and deeply personal question of life after death relates to theories of consciousness.
Judith Wolfe is Professor of Philosophical Theology at the University of St. Andrews, and editor of the Oxford Studies in Philosophical Theology. She researches and teaches in systematic and philosophical theology, as well as in theology and the arts. Her overarching research interest is in eschatology, i.e. the study of the “last things,” and its significance within theology, as well as within epistemology, anthropology, and ontology more generally.
Closer To Truth, hosted by Robert Lawrence Kuhn and directed by Peter Getzels, presents the world’s greatest thinkers exploring humanity’s deepest questions. Discover fundamental issues of existence. Engage new and diverse ways of thinking. Appreciate intense debates. Share your own opinions. Seek your own answers.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Judith, you're an expert in philosophical theology
with a particular specialty in eschatology,
study of ultimate things.
And those ultimate things affect individual consciousness,
because that's what happens ultimately to a consciousness.
And so that's the normal assumption that you make
is that human consciousness exists
and all the things that may or may not happen to it
in an ultimate future.
What I want to try to do is leverage your expertise,
but in the reverse arrow of causation.
All right.
And say, let's assume the eschatology
that you believe in and you study is real.
What would that say then about consciousness?
What can we infer from the eschatological ultimate reality?
What can we then infer about the nature of consciousness?
Is that fair?
Go for it.
I guess so, yes.
Go for it.
Okay, well, it probably sounds a bit wacky
because it's such a specifically theological claim.
But if we take seriously
the Christian eschatological vision
of what we call a beatific vision of God,
then that runs something like the following.
That God, well, no,
then that runs something like the following.
In the New Testament, there are several passages
that seem to suggest that the kind of consciousness
that is characteristic of the eschaton of the final state,
whether that of resurrection
or an immortal soul after death,
Christians are somewhat divided on that,
is a vision of God face to face.
So Paul says in 1 Corinthians 13,
now I see as in a mirror darkly,
but then I shall see face to face.
Now I know in part,
but then I shall know even as I am fully known.
And the first letter of John says,
beloved, we do not yet know who we are,
but we know that when he appears,
we will be like him for we will see him as he is.
So there's this sort of claim in the New Testament
that our true mode of knowing
in the eschatological state
will be one of face to face vision of God.
And the implication is twofold.
One, that because we are made in the image of God,
we will only know and be ourselves truly
when we see God face to face.
In other words, the claim here is that
the mode of consciousness that is most natural
and most basic to us here in this life,
namely a sort of self consciousness,
is in a sense a pre-ultimate kind of consciousness
which compares to eschatological consciousness
in the way that seeing in a mirror darkly
compares to seeing face to face.
Okay, but the kind of consciousness
that we would have now is not some total transformation.
In other words, we'll still have
certainly the Abrahamic religions in a resurrection.
In all three Abrahamic religions,
Judaism, Christianity, and Islam,
you maintain your individual personality.
You don't lose that.
You may be glorified, you may be incorruptible, whatever.
Sounds good, you know, both sound good.
But you don't lose that personal touch that you have.
You'll still know that I am me.
You won't be absorbed into the great ocean
of cosmic consciousness as a drop.
Right, yes, and that's important.
That's characteristic of those religions, yeah.
What does that say about our current consciousness,
the nature of it?
Well, I think the basic ontological claim
underlying the eschatological claim,
in Christianity at least, is that the act of creation
is an act of love by a triune God
who is always already in himself a triunity of persons
related to each other in love.
And the creation of the world is out of that love
as an expression of that love
and for the purpose of drawing the creation into that love.
And so individuality or personality is not an illusion.
It's not any pre-ultimate reality that will disappear.
It's something that's already there on a different level
in an analogous sense in God
and therefore also something
that is characteristic of the eschaton
where all people will be drawn into
this life of mutual love, which is also a way of knowing.
So to know oneself in the eschaton
is to see God face-to-face,
but therefore also to be known by God
and to be revealed through that face-to-face vision.
And I think many modern theologians would add
that the continuation of personality
means that forever each person
is able to have a face-to-face encounter
and see God in a way that is individual and personal,
which they can then also reflect to everybody else
such that community remains an essential aspect
just as it is in the life of God.
And so to make that a coherent story,
theologians talk about between where we are now
and in the eschaton, both continuity and discontinuity.
The discontinuity is obvious to go from corruptible
to incorruptible, mortal to immortal.
I mean, that alone is pretty significant, a discontinuity.
But I'm looking for the continuity and how it works.
In other words, we agree that there is a continuity
in the Abrahamic religions.
So is there any sense that we can make a little bit
of a progress further to say,
well, then how does that happen?
It happens through our consciousness, the continuity.
I think so.
So I think the earthly, sort of the day-to-day experience,
which makes this entire claim of a consciousness
that is no longer primarily consciousness of self,
but rather a consciousness of self
through a face-to-face vision of God
more plausible or less crazy-seeming
is the experience that I think we all have
that sometimes we only know ourselves are right
by being seen by another person.
In other words, that the way I know and experience myself,
that I'm conscious of myself is often much more closed in
than to be open to other people in love
and to allow them to see and witness us to ourselves.
And so I think that this sort of flow of consciousness
as not something self-enclosed,
but rather something that we owe to each other
is already often a very precious feature of life,
which Christians believe will flower in the eschaton.