Odd Edison Box Fan Motor Failure

TV Electric Fan
2 followers
9 Video Views·Feb 24, 2026
The rotor collides with the stater at certain parts in this motor. These were very cheap fans with poor manufacturing tolerances so it's not inconceivable that a defect like this would exist, but what makes this so odd is that the fan appears to have been used at some point. The rotor is clearly slightly oblong and I just don't see how this failure could develop over time.
Well, I'll explain what went on here ding so we have a situation as I said we have a situation
Did I bring
We have one more shell than we actually need so so we have a situation with this
thin and light pan
Where the road would be thick and heavy
That's interesting is it working perfectly now
So you know a car ride bumps to get all the car yeah, so the situation was here there is this one spotting
Plug that in I'll show you
We'll just hum
Yeah, there it is
Where the rotor gets stuck?
Air quality issues down here
That was a good lunch
That's it's locking up now because it relies on both shells be it doesn't really yeah
I never knew that it'll never work without the second shell in place
But I did have the second shell in place at one point
And I had to disassemble the whole darn thing again because ultimately what's happening now without the shell in places
It just pulls okay to the nearest pole, and then it locks up against the
It locks up against the state
So can we put the shell on yeah, I can see what's going on
Yeah, I do kind of feel that one spot. Yeah, it's it's it's getting stuff
if this does happen to be an issue with
The fit we could probably just shave down some part of this
Wherever it's hitting
Do you think the cause of that is a true manufacturing defect, or it would there be something mechanically that caused that I?
Would say it's probably a manufacturing defect it is a fairly precise fit
But this looks unusually close especially for a cheap motor
Yeah, this this is definitely a manufacturing defect as you can see
But
If you look here, this is practically touching mm-hmm
And then this is practically touching and then you have a fair bit of gap here
This amount of gap is probably around what's normal
So I I do think that there's a manufacturing defect of this motor
Because it is just not oh
I forgot we didn't have the other shell in place though
It still seems like this here here and here just seems very very close
Let's let's put the other show on and see I like to work with a plug in as well a man play
See these motors there's an error
these motors being that
Now I wouldn't call that
Press fit, but kind of like a press fitting. It's gonna be very difficult to align that properly
Is this is this on all the way?
No, it needs to be is that needs to be completely
Yeah place for this to even have a chance of working I
Don't like these motors
This is the part that's always tricky
Did you line it up correctly?
Believe I did
There it is. No, it's not like I'm working with Kevin
I don't think this is one correctly. That's
Is the back show
it is misaligned because
Can't get this
Yeah, it's totally misaligned. That's the problem. That's unfortunate
But these are pain
That motor is alignment nightmare. It is a nightmare. I
Do not enjoy working on those motors at all
in the world
It doesn't it does
as you know with these motors
It mounts into the guard so like it's a lot of alignment
You better hurry up to get that motor I don't turn this fan on
He's like there's no other fans
That'd be too easy, I'm gonna go out I get some more fans. Oh man, we ate the same thing
As
Well, you got to put the bolts in first and tighten it down
so this actually has to mount back into the
Well, aren't aren't there? There are bolts that go in and under nuts. I should say that go on this other side
Yeah
Well, how does the motor stay closed?
so
these just see like these just tighten into the into the shells and
Then they tighten down on the outside like
That one you can pull through but no there has to be nuts that go in the front there
You know, this is saying that this is threaded here
Because there's just nuts for the front of the guard in here. No this there definitely need to be um, they're neat
And that's it. We need to be a day
Nuts here on the front for sure
Just pull out what we got
These three funny-looking ones go to the front of the guard
washers
these go to the
Well, if that's the way it came that's why it doesn't work
No
There absolutely has to be nuts on the front of that motor that would be the problem
You're saying that those three aren't it?
No, because these three
So when this all those go in the back, yeah, well since it's the same thread we can use it just for testing purposes
You know, we have to find out what the um, the thread is on those and get some some more
Hopefully it's a fairly standard size
That would make a ton of sense
I've worked on enough of these to know that
We have to tighten it down and align it first
probably
stupid size
What a lousy welding shop. Yeah, really I've
Yeah, when I was this there was something off with this motor from the minute I took it apart. Well, this might be it
Might be missing some parts
And it does appear that it was tampered with because let's say a piece of the thrust
Thrust washer. Yeah, sure it is. Oh cool. So now it's gonna make some funny noises
Well now there's something else wrong with it because this is just totally locked
It's the same same problem. This was the problem that you would have
And it was like that way when I went to disassemble it
You see that's
Is that do you think where it's hanging up?
You can I can feel it. This is not a bearing issue
This is metal on metal and metal surfaces are not meant to be touching. No, they're not
This is this is going to be the rotor
This is going to be
And now it's free
yeah, so what's happening here is the
Rotor's touching the rotor is hitting the stator at some point
And that's that's why it's getting so stiff
most likely the
Rotor is so poorly made that it's it's just slightly oblong
So that's why we have a free spot here
And then it locks again, I bet this was this was a factory defect and it was like this from day one
It had to have been because there's no
When I disassembled it as I said, it seemed like it had like zero hours on it and that would
Line up offer an explanation. Yeah
so
Um, so let's see if we can tell where
It's hitting and maybe we can just shave that part down
It looks it looks okay on that side
I think it's going to be that pole. This is a really strange problem. It is i've never seen anything like it
The viewing angle is not good enough. It's very hard. I'm trying to see through the openings as well
It's very hard to see where the problem is taking place
Can we like take this outside of the box and sit on the table is there enough slack
can we um
Just remove this stuff
Yes
Just leaning over the box is not uh helping us
I like pizza
Maybe if we just remove this wire tie that'll make it. Yeah, that's yeah
I hate taking these out because they tend to snap when yeah, I wouldn't take that. Oh, yeah. Uh, do you have
Something to snip that with yes
Working upside down
ding
All right, you're free a lot of construction drivers crash around the side box
You know what it might be easier to look at it from
If we turn the shaft from the front and look at it from the back
It might also be that it's such a small difference we're not even going to be able to see it
I mean, it could be like a couple microns or something difference
Yeah, I I think it's right here, okay
We've got nothing to lose
It's not much to gain either just a cheap piece of junk box
Throw it out and buy alasko 3733
I bet the motor wouldn't have this problem
Yeah, I don't see any space between what we would even use to file this down
Yeah, i've never filed a rotor down before
This is such a bizarre issue to have
And you said that you tried other rotors in here
No, I didn't that was that was the one thing I didn't I I thought I had a spare rotor we we looked all over
Yeah, we did. Yeah
We just take a working one and put it in there to see what happens
Yeah, because then quickly you would know if it's the rotor or if it's the stator exactly
I mean, it obviously has to be an issue with this with the rotor not being perfectly circular, but
It could be that what's out of spec as though is the um
the stator
How does that happen coming off an assembly line when things are
Designed to be exactly the same
I guess there's a tolerance. I think that the tolerance on these is probably very very poor
Yeah, i'm going to say that it's it's it's happening
With this pole right here
It looks to me like it's practically touching
Or it probably is
I don't see any I mean, I don't see any gap in there at all. It's between that
Oh nose. Yeah, so I think that's where it's getting hung up
so
We now have to figure out
One is at the only spot
And number two, how do we shave it down?
But I I would want to try another rotor in here before we do it makes a lot of sense
Yeah, because if the rotor is I I think it's the stator that's out of spec. But if the rotor is out of spec
I mean you have to shave off so much. I don't know how you'd even do that. I would just
Get another rotor or find one
Okay
Very strange. Yeah, but I would say that's definitely some type of manufacturing defect. Yeah
To be continued
