00:00 Intro 02:07 Fraser learns a new word 06:33 Earth is special 19:50 Habitability of Venus and Mars 24:58 Implications for exoplanets 33:57 Current obsessions 50:11 Final thoughts
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
The habitable zone is a region in a solar system where liquid water can appear on the
surface of a terrestrial world.
But it is a very rough approximation, like it is the bare minimum that there are probably
almost certainly a range of other factors that play into whether or not a planet is
going to be habitable or is inhabited.
And you're looking at the presence of a large moon, you're looking at the potential chemicals
that are present on the surface of that planet to be able to promote life.
Not enough of one chemical, maybe you can't get life.
But is the earth normal?
Like we clearly have life on our surface and we have these various chemicals.
We have phosphorus, nitrogen, carbon, sulfur, other chemicals that are absolutely required
for life.
But we also have oxygen, which is constantly trying to do chemistry on all of those chemicals
and in some ways can end up making these various minerals not available to potential biology.
So my guest today is Dr. Craig Walton, he's a junior research fellow at the University
of Cambridge, and he's written a new paper that looks at the formation history of Earth.
You know, we know that most of the Earth's phosphorus is actually down near the core.
And that when you consider the ratios of phosphorus to nitrogen, and then you consider what oxygen
is doing to them, then it is this sort of balancing point that Earth seems to be perfectly
stationed on.
And maybe is that the way you get life?
That if you have too much of one of those other chemicals, then life becomes not possible.
Now, this is a longer, more complicated interview than just this research, but if you're interested
in sort of what are the chances of life in the universe, then you'll enjoy this.
But then we have a fairly long, totally unexpected conversation about artificial intelligence,
as well as a sort of totally different conversation about how he has potentially reset the era
of the late heavy bombardment.
So I think if this sounds like a kind of dry topic, I promise you this is a very fascinating
interview and I think you're really going to enjoy it.
Craig, it's good to see you again.
Thanks very much for having me back.
It's great to be here.
So you taught me a new word that I had never learned.
Can you guess what the new word is that I had never seen before?
Fugacity?
Oh, gosh.
There we go.
That's a word and a half.
Yeah.
You may be relying on that word quite a bit in this conversation.
So I think you should provide a definition up front and then we can just use it naturally
in our speech the way we always do.
Oh, gosh.
Yeah.
So that is such a...
You go right for the jugular.
Fugacity is a word that is an absolute nightmare for all who use it.
And you're putting me on the spot here.
Yeah.
So geologists have all sorts of terms which come about through quirks of history.
Like, for example, the naming convention in mineralogy.
Lots of minerals are named after people rather than for any logical reason.
And fugacity is a complex term.
Basically, it refers to the expected partial pressure of a gas in a system, right?
And it may not actually happen.
This is where it gets immediately confusing.
It may not actually happen that way, but you can compute theoretically that something should
be there based on a whole bunch of chemical reactions which are intersecting.
And then it allows you to put yourself, relatively speaking, in a parameter space.
So for example, fugacity in the context of the paper, we're talking about oxygen.
We're talking about oxygen fugacity.
And we're defining it with respect to whether or not we would have some amount of molecular
oxygen in the system if you're partitioning it amongst all these other elements that it
could be bonded to and reacted to.
And you can have this massive parameter space, right the way from having an atmosphere with
lots of oxygen around, a very oxidizing system where the oxygen is O2, and what's called
a really reducing system where the oxygen fugacity is incredibly low.
And almost anywhere you look, there's no oxygen.
Things are just in like native metal.
They've not been oxidized.
And the equilibrium of the reactions would give you a tiny, tiny, tiny trivial amount
of molecular oxygen in that system.
And then you have different reactions which are controlling how much oxygen you would
get.
And the reason we use this complex term is because when you're trying to figure out your
say an experimental system to model nature and geology, you can measure specific reactions
and how they've landed and then compare that to a calculation.
So for example, you've got something called the iron-wustite buffer, this reaction of
the speciation of iron and how it's reacting with oxygen.
And then you can look at the minerals that result from that and figure out where you
are in this chemical parameter space because you can't measure the oxygen directly.
And that's just how people have done it through the years and it's become the standard.
And then I hate that it's a standard because then anybody who tries to explain it finds
it very difficult.
Right.
But so my impression is that if you are in a certain kind of condition, you would expect
the partial pressure of various gases to be at a certain level and that it's just dependent
on what kinds of reactions are going on.
And so here we are.
And so if I come on the surface of Titan and I'm wondering how much nitrogen there is in
the atmosphere, I would be sort of predicting its fugacity.
Precisely.
Great.
Well, it just has an extended use where you can talk about this and get a general sense
of the system.
So as I say, if you're in a really reducing system where oxygen fugacity is low, you can
extend from that a whole bunch of expectations for the chemical nature of the system and
for lots of other elements, even if there's almost no oxygen there at all.
And that's just, that's how it works.
Okay.
Well, so there we go.
So now we can freely use this term throughout the rest of this interview and the audience
will hear it and not go, wait a minute, what?
I recommend using Wikipedia for afterwards and you can see for yourself the challenge
I have here.
I like to assume the audience is fairly knowledgeable about various terms in science and chemistry
and especially the ones in astronomy and astrophysics, we'll just zip right past them.
There's no need to explain what a supermassive black hole is.
But in this case, you know, chemistry is, is, you know, that's a bridge too far.
Come on.
Um, I'm not a monster.
So let's, so let's talk about your new paper.
So the, the, the gist here is, uh, it turns out earth is special.
Why is there a special?
Hmm.
Well, we already knew earth was special to some degree because we have, you know, we,
we can see some planets around us and now we're beginning to see hundreds and thousands
of exoplanets and we've yet to see anything which you could actually call an earth twin.
But the problem is, um, when you've got so many planets out there, we still have this
question of how likely is it that there should be another earth somewhere that you'd have
to scan through a lot along a lot of earth like planets before you can say there's definitely
no, um, life out there.
And that statistically we shouldn't expect there to be civilizations.
And so really that's the question is like, you're working with very small numbers where
if the probability gets so low, you can begin to have a resolution to the Fermi paradox,
which I'm sure your viewers have heard of where the answer is simply that, yeah, we
are just really rare.
Life is rare.
Civilization is rare.
And we're not just about to go extinct, um, which would, if life is common, you know,
and we're about to colonize the galaxy, then you, you instead need to have a great filter
explanation.
Right.
Yeah.
That's kind of the most horrifying realization about the Fermi paradox.
If life is common, we're doomed.
If life is rare, everything's great.
Well, that's why, so maybe this paper, we have a lot to talk about here because this
fascinating subject in terms of the societal implications for how we think about our place
in the universe, I think.
And, but I'm adding a bit of extra rarity to the earth, which is good news for humanity
and bad news for finding life maybe.
So we'll see.
But that, so, so are you asking then, like, what am I, what am I adding?
Yeah.
So, so, I mean, your, your paper is talking about, you know, a lot of complex chemistry,
but essentially, you know, how the earth worked with its original phosphorus and, and
was it phosphorus and potassium?
No.
Nitrogen.
Nitrogen, phosphorus, nitrogen, and sort of how available those were to the planet at
various times.
And that would sort of describe whether or not we could get access, life could, could
arise if it would have the kinds of chemicals that it needed.
So, but, but you sort of found this sort of interesting chemistry that is probably going
on on planet earth that makes us a good place for life.
Yeah, exactly.
So we know that we need certain elements for life or at least for earth-like life.
I mean, once you expand the definition to non-earth-like life, all bets are off, but
working within the assumption that life is going to look like us, we know we need carbon,
nitrogen, phosphorus, and sulfur.
And we know these things because we've never found an example of life where those aren't
present and they're playing fundamental roles.
So for example, phosphorus, you've got it in your cell walls, you've got it in the
backbone of DNA, stopping hydrolysis from breaking down your genetic material.
And it plays an absolutely critical role in metabolism.
So like those three huge things that you just cannot do without.
Both of, we're today, we're both going to eat something and we'll be taking a lot of
phosphorus and the food that was grown and was fertilized with phosphorus.
Then for nitrogen, it plays an absolutely vital role in proteins.
So amino acids are defined by the presence of nitrogen heterocycles, and they are almost
definitionally what terrestrial biology is all about, is enzymes, because we're accelerating
reactions which wouldn't happen outside of biology.
So you can't do without phosphorus or nitrogen.
We know the earth has enough because we're here.
And the question is, is that anomalous?
You know, if we look at these other planets, even if we have the idea of the Goldilocks
zone or the habitable zone around a star where you have liquid water, which is what we'd
be thinking of, it's like, oh, water, habitable.
Does it have enough phosphorus and nitrogen?
You know, so is earth typical or atypical in that regard?
And that was the question on my mind.
And what we looked at with this paper was the formation process that you alluded to,
which determines how much of these two elements you actually have on a planet's surface for
life to work with.
And the reason it was on my mind is because I know for a fact that most of earth's phosphorus
is in the core, actually.
Something like 99% of it has, during the planet's early formation, when you segregated into
the core and the mantle and the crust, most of the phosphorus ended up in the core.
And phosphorus is one of the rarest bioessential elements on earth today.
So that's why I mentioned if you go and fertilize a piece of land with phosphorus, you get more
life.
If you go to the desert and add phosphorus, you get more life.
If you go to the ocean, sprinkle some on, you get a bloom of cyanobacteria.
So it's limiting.
So we're right on the edge.
So that's like a key element for us to cover.
And nitrogen is the same.
If you change the amount of carbon in the atmosphere, there are some effects, but it's
nitrogen and phosphorus that are really crucial.
And so if planets deviate in that regard, that's a big deal.
And that process of extracting phosphorus to the core depends on oxygen.
So we mentioned the other star, oxygen, fugacity, the prevalence effectively of oxygen.
If that changes in the initial conditions of forming a planet, core formation will proceed
differently.
That was the hypothesis we were testing.
You'll extract either more or less phosphorus and change the habitability of the planet
drastically.
And so basically what we did is we built a model for core formation where we just explored
this.
We took all the experiments people have done where they change the oxygen fugacity in the
system and see how phosphorus partitions into iron.
So then you can build a model of, as this iron is segregating, how much phosphorus goes
with it.
And it turns out there's this vast parameter space where the conditions would leave behind
no phosphorus at all.
You'd have a trace, trace, trace amount nowhere near enough to sustain life, nowhere near
enough to sustain a civilization as we know it today.
And that happens really easily.
So if you just change the formation conditions a little bit, you are suddenly in territory
which is uninhabitable.
And Earth occupies what I'm calling the chemical habitable zone, where it sits right on the
line where all the conditions have lined up.
And not only do you have water, but you also have the key elements that you need for life.
Right.
You said it was 99% of the phosphorus is down in the core.
It could just as easily have been 100%.
Yeah.
Or 99.999999.
Exactly.
Right.
Yeah.
That's the idea.
And so what made Earth special?
What made?
Well, okay, now we're getting to a really interesting point.
It turns out that Earth is special by being typical.
Let me just talk you through this.
I've just described the effects of phosphorus as a result of oxygen.
Nitrogen does the opposite behavior.
So when people have done these experiments and they're changing the oxygen fugacity and
they see, okay, I've decreased the oxygen fugacity and there are more phosphoruses in
the metal, which means more phosphorus will end up in the core.
That's bad for life.
As you do that, you end up with more nitrogen left behind in the mantle and the crust.
And if you increase the oxygen fugacity, you get more phosphorus and less nitrogen.
So there's actually these two intersecting curves and Earth sits right on the point where
you have a bit of both.
So if you draw a histogram, Earth is in the most likely position on the histogram, but
almost all the other planets fall outside of the middle of the histogram.
Do you see what I mean?
Like a bell curve.
Yeah.
Exactly.
Seven is the most common thing you're going to roll on the dice, but it's not 50% of the
time you're rolling seven.
Exactly.
A huge parameter space for all these planets don't have one or the other thing that you
need.
And Earth is right on the dot in the intersection of these two things where you have a bit of
both, which is, I think that makes a lot of sense, right?
It's like I just said, phosphorus and nitrogen are limiting, right?
So we know right now we're right on this incredibly delicate balance point where if I add a bit
of phosphorus, you get more life.
If you add a bit of nitrogen, you get more life.
And if we had a bit less of either, you'd be really struggling to sustain a biosphere.
But why can't you get both at the same time?
Why couldn't we just, why couldn't we add like so much phosphorus and so much nitrogen
that, or of either or both, they no longer become a limiting factor, then maybe it's
the oxygen that becomes limiting.
Oh, well that, or carbon or sulfur.
Carbon.
Yeah.
Imagine a contrived scenario where this happens somehow, but it's just difficult, right?
Because the point is the oxygen fugacity is driving in opposite directions.
So trying to find a place in the parameter space where you have both is quite tricky.
So you could imagine a planet, say, that's very oxidizing, which leaves behind lots of
phosphorus, even though most of the nitrogen hasn't outgassed, it's gone into the core,
it's not forming a nitrogen-rich atmosphere.
And then you deliver the things that you're lacking through meteorites or something, right?
So maybe there's some planet out there where, we talked about cosmic dust in a previous
episode.
There may be some worlds, very rare, where external supply just delivers a huge amount
of the thing that you're missing.
But what's really hard is to balance bioavailable forms of these elements at the surface of
a planet.
Based on what I've done, it seems that Earth has done about the best that you can do, and
you still don't have very much.
Okay, so I guess what you're saying then is that if you're just considering the raw
materials for what goes into the planet, you're going to get a certain amount of nitrogen,
a certain amount of phosphorus, and then you're going to have the oxygen, which is
going to be doing the oxidizing reactions on all of the material that's on the surface
of the planet, and that if you have too much of one, then you're going to have a discrepancy
of the other.
It's only when those two are sort of in that sweet spot will you get that balance where
you have a lot of bioavailable chemistry.
Exactly, and it probably hasn't been a second layer to this, which I think would be a great
follow-up paper that I have in my mind, because the paper was written purely from the perspective
of assuming that you have life, like what nutrients does it need?
But there's another layer to this, which is the chemistry needed to begin life in the
first place, and that does not happen under oxidizing conditions.
So if I wiped out all our life on Earth today by some mechanism and just left it sterile
and said, right, let's have abiotic chemistry start, and it's already oxidizing because
we have this history of life producing all this oxygen, none of the chemical reactions
that we found in the lab to produce proteins or DNA or lipids or sugars will happen, right?
None of that.
You need reducing conditions, you need a low oxygen fugacity, or at least a medium somewhere
right in the middle, something like where Earth formed.
It makes sense that the formation conditions must have been right for origin of life chemistry,
but if you go to this scenario where you're way too oxidizing, you're way too reducing,
you probably can't begin life either.
And we don't know quite how narrow that is, but it's probably also a narrow window where
you've optimized everything.
Now, you're considering only two of those four essential atoms, the other two, the carbon
and the sulfur.
Do you think that they're sort of similar?
I mean, obviously we have carbon dioxide, you know, we have oxygen has a special relationship
with carbon, sulfur dioxide, sulfur oxide, same thing.
So do you think that this is actually like a four part interaction and not just a two
part?
No, you're right on there.
And I almost made the paper about all four.
And when I first started, it was a bit too much work.
And there's in some cases more experiments needed, but there's almost certainly going
to be more intersecting curves for the availability of carbon and sulfur.
As you change the oxygen fugacity, you'll change how much carbon you have at the surface
and what chemical form it's in, how much sulfur.
And we need both of those as well.
So it is possible that as you add in more and more of these intersecting curves, that
the zone where you have everything you need just gets smaller and smaller.
Earth's always going to lie on it, but it may get smaller and smaller.
And the problem you see is that you need to know that the experiments you're using to
inform the model are accurate and have explored the parameter space properly.
And that can be quite hard to do with these volatile elements like carbon and sulfur.
Basically, the only reason I was able to make this paper happen at all is because people
had cared so much about figuring out how Earth formed that they had explored a huge parameter
space for these experiments about core formation and then said, oh, Earth lies here.
And then I just looked at that and said, oh, well, that also allows me to explore exoplanets
and see how different they would look.
And so people have to do more experiments.
And I'm not an experimentalist on that.
For my master's thesis, I tried my hand at that type of experiment.
And it's really hard.
You're basically working with, you either have a piston cylinder experiment or a diamond
anvil, which are exactly what they sound like.
You get these forces and you put them on a tiny little experiment.
And then nine times out of 10, the experiment just breaks.
And you've wasted 10 grand.
So that wasn't for me.
The amount of effort going into this is substantial because it turns out, as you can see from
this conversation, that it's not enough just to observe exoplanets, that you need to have
an understanding of the fundamental thermodynamics and chemical reactions that will shape those
planets and have some way to infer what they'll be like.
And that's essentially what the paper is doing.
It's not just placing Earth in context.
It's a tool for us.
When we find a planet that's a candidate for having life, we can put it in context.
Right.
But I guess what I'm what I'm driving at is, is that, you know, if we if we think about
the about the Earth and let's say it had just a mountain of sulfur compared to the other
the other elements, would that also decrease the amounts of all of the other elements of
it?
And so if you have like too little of one, too much of any of them, then you're going
to end up with with a surface that is inhospitable to biological chemistry as we as we know it.
You know, we can go look at, say, Venus.
And obviously, Venus is a runaway greenhouse effect, but plenty of carbon.
There's like twice as much nitrogen in the atmosphere of Venus as there is on Earth.
They got lots of nitrogen.
There's lots of carbon, sulfuric acid in the right.
But how's their how's their phosphorus?
You know, Venus is such a frustrating planet because it's crazy that we don't have better
measurements of the surface chemistry.
I mean, we've sent the Russians sent that one thing there, which was impressive at the
time.
But it's a big sort of void in our understanding of Earth-like planets, because I would love
to know how different the biocentral elements look in the rocks properly, like genuinely.
We have the atmospheric chemistry.
We don't really know what happened with core formation or mantle chemistry or crustal
chemistry on Venus.
Not really.
So it's an important question.
I think it should be a total top priority because until we can properly explain the
massively divergent histories of Earth, Venus and Mars, what hope do we have of understanding
some dot on the telescope that's light years away?
We can't even know our closest planet.
So that's a huge gaping hole.
But what I will just mention is that during the process of writing the paper, we knew
we have to make sure this model can explain what we do understand, which is Mars, right?
And so we just took the model I made and put in the expected formation conditions for Mars
and predicted the phosphorus content in the crust there.
And then compare it to the rover measurements and it gets the answer right.
So it's good for Mars.
So that's at least that's something.
Right.
And so how is the habitability of Mars?
Mars is fascinating.
Mars has, it's more oxidizing than Earth.
It has a higher oxygen fugacity during formation.
It's further out from the sun.
So you expect that.
You've got more water condensing during planet formation.
And then that's full of oxygen.
So you're oxidizing things, basically.
And that means you should expect more phosphorus.
And Mars has around 5 to 10 times more phosphorus in the crust and the mantle than Earth.
So I've been saying to other people who I've been speaking to about this,
if Elon Musk tries to set up shop there, he won't be lacking for phosphorus,
but he'll probably be lacking for other things.
I mean, you look at the atmospheric composition on Mars and there's not very much nitrogen.
Right.
You're mostly CO2.
So that will be the problem there.
But then what do you think about the past habitability of Mars,
like 4 billion years ago, 3.5 billion years ago?
Well, I am going to put my neck on the line on that and say that there's no life on Mars
and never was, even if it had water, because I think it was too oxidizing.
Right.
And so it feels like if you're right, then you can start to make predictions about,
if you know sort of, because the composition of the planet's chemistry
doesn't change over geologic timescales.
You kind of just have this roll of the dice of what you're going to get with your planet.
And then you could be thinking about habitability
500 million years after the planet formed.
You could think about habitability today with the presence of liquid water.
You're always going to have that.
You've only got that raw chemical mix to deal with.
Right.
So there is some scope for change, just to touch on that.
The fundamental ingredients and the initial conditions, you can't change that.
So you're going to have a total inventory of phosphorus,
and the core formation will proceed however it's going to proceed.
And then that sets the boundary conditions.
But at the very surface, you can play with things to a surprising degree.
For example, some people have speculated that maybe the surface of these planets briefly
was very reducing, like very low oxygen fugacity.
If you, for example, deliver a massive iron impactor to the surface,
it can evaporate a lot of the water, reduce the water, react it away,
and reduce basically the effective abundance of oxidizing power.
And that would temporarily give you this anomalous conditions
under which maybe origin of life chemistry can happen.
The problem is we just don't know the exact conditions we're looking for.
But just to point out that, yes, you can't change the fundamental abundance
of phosphorus versus nitrogen in the mantle.
But at the very surface, you could maybe change the chemical conditions
and react those differently.
So people are working with this, but it does feel a bit contrived to me.
I have to say, it feels a bit like you're looking at something
which isn't any good and thinking,
oh, maybe somehow we could make it work with some external effect.
But it's speculative.
So yeah, I think that once you stray from the formation conditions of Earth,
I think you probably end up with something that just isn't right anymore.
Right.
So then obviously, this is a theoretically powerful tool for us to evaluate exoplanets
and try to figure out whether or not they not just have any life on them,
but at least do they have the potential for life.
So the best that we can do right now is evaluate the atmosphere of exoplanets.
And right now, James Webb can do gas giants and hot Jupiters
and theoretically can do planets orbiting around M dwarfs.
But we're still a ways away from having a telescope that can evaluate
another Earth orbiting around another sun-like star.
So can you get at this sort of relationship between these various chemicals
purely through studying the atmosphere?
Okay, so that's a really good point about how do we apply this.
And the right answer, I'm going to say,
is that what this type of work allows you to do is set expectations
and check for self-consistencies.
Because you're right, we'll be seeing the atmosphere
and maybe you see something that you think is a biosignature
and you can infer from that, okay, that would mean under these conditions,
the biosphere would have to be this big
and it would need to be supported by a certain amount of phosphorus and nitrogen.
And then you can run the planet formation model
based on where you see the planet, the composition of the star,
because that's what determines, for example, the oxygen fugacity,
the chemistry of the whole star and where you're forming this planet.
And then you can make a prediction.
And if you have this wild mismatch where it's like,
okay, in order to interpret this atmospheric signature as a biosignature,
we're saying there's going to be plenty of phosphorus at the surface to sustain that,
but the core formation conditions say there should be none.
Then suddenly you have a problem.
You have this wild...
But on the contrary, if the two things line up and you say,
actually, yeah, this looks like it should be much like Earth,
that gives you a really big boost to say that, yeah, this is all adding up.
So that's how it gives you that bottom-up context for informing
models that are interpreting the atmospheric chemistry.
And I hope that answered the question.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I mean, I think the point being that you look at the planet in context
with the rest of the system,
ideally other planets in the system and especially the star,
that will to some degree give you the metallicity
and some of the composition of the star,
although stars also will absorb their chemicals
and not necessarily reveal all of their metals at the upper atmosphere.
But you then are able to say, yeah, in context,
kind of like how a geologist will do this, right?
Yeah, yeah.
They're going to look at the planet and they're going to look at the environment
around the planet, try and get a sense of what it was and where it came from.
Then you could say, okay, great.
That I'm seeing these chemicals in the atmosphere of the planet.
And I know in context that that is the kind of,
of, you know, chemical abundance that could support life.
Therefore, we should, we should,
if we have a limited number of planets we can look at,
this would be one of the good ones.
While if you look at another one and you're like,
we're seeing all these potential biosignatures,
but there's no way based on the star and maybe even other planets in the system.
Like, did it borrow this planet?
Is it an adopted planet or is it just false signals?
Maybe we put that one lower down on the priority list.
Yeah, exactly.
And there'll be many, many more ways to do this.
It's not just, you know, what I've done here.
And for example, liquid water and radiation, right?
So people see what they think is a biosignature.
And then you say, but hang on, the planet should be a million degrees
with a massive atmosphere and a horrible bathing sea of UV radiation,
which should sterilize everything.
So there'll be a whole bunch of factors and it's just a question of probabilities
because we're not going to be able to go there and just see the aliens, right?
So, but if everything's lining up, then you begin to,
it's going to be a question of just seeing if we can rule it out
or if we have reasons to think that it's unlikely.
And if everything's lining up and you start to think
this is actually very much plausible for life,
then you start to get excited.
But you can see how difficult it is because as I mentioned before, Venus,
I don't know if you know, you probably do,
but there was this whole drama with Venus.
With phosphine.
With phosphine. It's phosphorus, in fact.
And still there's no clarity on whether or not
there was any phosphorus there at all, by the way.
Well, and I always use this as an example of how difficult
this whole process of searching for biosignatures is going to be
because Venus is right over there.
It's right there.
You know, we can send spacecraft.
We don't, but we should and could send more spacecraft to Venus
to analyze the atmosphere and literally fly around and float about
in that atmosphere to get to the bottom of this mystery.
And there are astronomers who will argue
viscerously either way about this.
Just imagine the arguments that are going to happen
when they start to think about exoplanets.
But I want to go back to this idea of sort of,
because it really looks like now the traditional idea
of searching for biosignatures has failed, that, you know,
in the past, if you talk to researchers 20 years ago,
they say, well, you look for oxygen, you look for ozone,
you look for maybe nitrogen, you look for various chemicals,
and that will tell you that there's life on that planet.
And now scientists have found abiotic ways of producing
literally every single chemical we can think of
short of chlorofluorocarbons, right?
So then just finding the presence of some chemical
in the atmosphere of that planet, even phosphine,
because you can find phosphine in the atmosphere of Jupiter,
that doesn't help you.
And now it looks like it's about the interactions
between molecules that you're seeing.
Are you seeing methane rise in the spring?
Are you seeing carbon dioxide cycling versus oxygen versus whatever?
And so do you think that you can kind of take it
one step more simple and just see the interactions
between, say, phosphorus and nitrogen and sulfur and carbon
in the atmosphere of the world to give you a sense
of its habitability or its inhabitedness?
Is there life there?
Yeah, I think I like the way you're going with this.
If I understand you correctly,
you're basically broadening the thought process
away from a smoking gun where it's like,
we found this molecule, we have found life,
towards does the entire system make sense
that it would be inhabited?
You know, you've got a whole bunch of molecules
which life could be producing.
Maybe they're in a disequilibrium like methane and O2, right?
Which if there wasn't a constant production of both,
they'd just react and you wouldn't really have either.
And does the star and the formation condition of the planet
suggest that it would have liquid water
and sufficient phosphorus and nitrogen, carbon and sulfur
and the UV radiation isn't...
I think that the way in which we're searching for life
is becoming more realistic.
And I think that's a positive thing
because I don't think the previous approach
could ever have worked unless it was always a fool's errand.
Whereas now, as you say, we're bringing in geology
and it could never have just been an astronomy
and a biology approach to this
because planets are rocks fundamentally.
And they're big rocks and geology is fundamental to life
and controlling everything about how life then behaves on that planet.
So yeah, I think we're moving in a good direction.
The only problem we have in terms of the chances of finding it
are that every time we find out a new geological
or astronomical variable that affects habitability,
it narrows the parameter space
under which you would expect to find life.
So, you know, at this point,
I'm not surprised that the search so far has failed
because it's like throwing a dart at a cosmic-sized dartboard,
you know, and hitting the bullseye.
It's really hard, which as we talked about,
it's good for, you know, our chances of being,
you know, rare and the Fermi paradox and surviving.
But it's going to be tricky, I think.
Another thing, by the way, just to comment on that as well,
is that previously people were using how Earth is now
as an assumption of what we should look for.
And I quite like the idea of using terrestrial life
as a general assumption.
I know n equals one,
but I think there's lots of chemical reasons to think
that this is like, this makes sense
for how biology would come about in general.
But now, like today,
is not representative of most of the history of the Earth.
For most of the history of the Earth was anoxic.
No ozone, no O2, no oxygenic photosynthesis
that would have been detectable from a distance, certainly.
And so I think there's also been a change
with astronomers working with the geologists
to set our expectations as,
you know, what would Earth look like most of the time?
Any planet we find as life,
it's more likely to look like what Earth looked like
for most of its history, not the last 500 million years.
Craig, what are you obsessed with right now?
Oh, several things.
I think I'm very obsessed with AI
because AI actually has Fermi paradox scale implications.
So I might write something on this.
I mean, it's a bit outside of what I would normally research.
But if you think about it,
if we are, as many people say we are,
on the verge of making intelligent,
self-replicating machines,
it kind of compounds the urgency of the Fermi paradox drastically
because this stuff, as soon as it's out of our control,
it doesn't even have biological constraints on it anymore.
You can rephrase the Fermi paradox
from where are the organic aliens
to where are the intelligent machines?
Yeah, I did a whole video called Where Are All The Robots?
Oh, I should watch that.
That sounds awesome.
Yeah, I did it like 10 years ago.
Oh, 10 years ago?
Oh good, you were a road man.
Maybe.
I mean, the point is that, I mean, this is,
von Neumann was the one who was ahead of the curve, right?
Yes, yes, yes.
But Neumann said, you know,
that you should be able to build a self-replicating machine.
And so you send out the von Neumann probes,
they go to other star systems,
they make copies of themselves.
Yeah, and so people always say,
well, maybe robots are the answer to the Fermi paradox.
And I say, absolutely not, because robots love to go to space.
So in other words, we should be expecting to see the board.
We should be expecting to see civilizations,
ever-growing civilizations filled with robots,
and we don't see that.
Therefore, you know, it makes the problem more complicated,
because that's the thing we should see.
We shouldn't see, you know, the greys showing up.
We should see their robots.
It then makes you think either the great filter
is us making these robots,
and we should take the extinctionists very seriously
when they say that AI can do everything.
But then we would see the robots, right?
So it can't be the great filter,
because then we would see the robots,
but we don't see the robots.
Exactly.
It would mean that the great filter scenario is narrow,
where the robots exist enough to kill everybody,
but then they don't expand.
And I actually, I don't think that's plausible.
Some people have suggested it, but I completely agree with you.
I think it just means it's more likely
that we're not going to die,
that robots won't just flow out through the universe uncontrolled
and without us being involved.
I think we might be the first to reach this point.
I'm an optimist.
You're an optimist that we're alone in the universe.
I think so.
I think so, too.
So, yeah, don't, you know, it's okay.
This is a safe space.
At least as an intelligent.
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, I think that it feels like developing
a technological intelligence
is a thing that humanity has been trying to do.
And it feels like it's a natural thing
that other civilizations are going to attempt as well.
And so we would expect to see the horrifying results
of that experiment run at a grand scale,
like it should be Borgs everywhere.
And we don't.
And so either other civilizations wisely always go,
whoa, whoa, whoa, robot's bad.
Or they just, that this experiment has only been run once
and it's us and we're the ones that are,
we stand at the precipice of this.
We stand at the precipice.
It doesn't mean that we don't know
what the answer would be.
Like, it's possible that like, once we've done this,
the universe will be full of Borgs,
but there just won't be anyone to observe it.
So we just need to be careful.
Yeah.
What do you think?
Is it going to be fine?
No, no, no, my, no, my PDoom is 50%.
Yeah, yeah.
I've actually gone on a, on an AI sort of podcast,
which is sort of trying to raise awareness
on the threats of artificial.
Yeah, with Shapiro.
Yeah.
On doom debates.
And so we talked and he, you know,
I was there to talk about the Fermi paradox
and sort of pushing back on Robin Hanson's
grabby alien hypothesis and sort of talking about that
and sort of explaining that.
But, you know, we've got to get to, you know,
what my PDoom is and yeah, my PDoom is kind of 50%.
I, that even if we end up wrapping our,
like, even if the large AI companies get,
get under control and they, they proceed very carefully
and safety is a concern that algorithmic improvement,
technological improvement puts the power of these things
into the hands of less and less people
until eventually some script kitty
with a desktop AI computer can destroy the universe.
And it just, it just sort of proceeds along.
And there's, how do you stop the competing wishes
of 8 billion people?
Some of whom should not be given the power,
that level of, of power.
So yeah, I, I, I am definitely concerned.
Well, I guess that's like a whole other conversation.
The only thing I would push back on,
it's just to say that in all arms races
across all of evolution, once a predator evolves
and defences evolve in response just as quickly.
So I think it's unlikely given that these things
will only scale up if they're commercially useful
and that we won't see any warning signs
that then require us to get better defences and so on.
Like if it can't be regulated now,
it won't be regulated ever.
I think there's a little bit of hope
just from the sense that.
Yeah. If we have time, if we take it seriously,
if we, if we take a hundred years to slowly
and inexorably work through all of these issues,
then we will probably figure this out.
But we're not in that land.
We are in YOLO.
We are in, you know, let's just run these things
as agents on our laptops.
Let's have them have full access to the internet.
Have them just go crazy.
Yeah. And give her.
So that's a Canadian term.
I apologise.
But hopefully people can understand what that means.
Yeah. Yeah.
So that's, that's my, that's my perspective.
And so, and so, in fact, my sort of,
my feeling about this inexorability of
the development of artificial intelligence
is one of the big reasons why I feel like
we're alone in the universe
is just because we don't see the robots.
We're the Borg.
Yeah. I might be doing this probably lower than 50,
depending on the timescale.
Because I would also include us
no longer existing as humans to be extinction
in its own way.
So I think it's very likely that the technology
will allow us to engineer ourselves
into completely different species.
And I think that's likely as well.
Yeah. As long as we get to, on our schedule,
on our, on our directive,
we get to maintain who we are and what we want to be.
Like if it's up to us, then that is not doom.
And if it's up to something else, then that is doom.
But we'll, we'll have to see.
I know it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a funny time.
And I, and I think that for a lot of people,
they're sort of watching this conversation from afar.
But if you've like really enmeshed yourself
in the technology and, and played around with it,
David Kipping recently had a, a great sort of
story on his YouTube channel talking about,
he was at a, at MIT and, and watching how
they're using artificial intelligence tools,
specifically things like cloud code
in this kind of agentic way that it's
taking over their computers and doing whatever,
run, running roughshod over their computers.
And they're just, and they are, they,
they no longer are working on the code.
They're just saying like, you know,
solve this math problem for me.
And it's coming back with the solutions.
He said it was like nothing he'd ever seen.
And that's my experience as well.
I, you know, I have 20, you know,
my degrees in computer science.
I have 25 years of product development experience
in computer science, computer software.
And it, the three months ago, everything changed.
Yeah.
And I can't believe what this feels like.
This feels like we're now
on the on-ramp to the singularity.
And I think it's literally like living
in a wild science fiction, totally realistic scenario.
And I agree with you.
I'm using it now, literally in the last few weeks,
I've started incorporating it properly
into my science where I realized that
I was going to be left behind if I didn't.
Where like, why is everybody else's productivity
is going to skyrocket?
And then I'm there watching it manually.
Like, no.
So yeah.
Yeah.
And like, just watch for hallucinations.
Watch for it to do a good, like,
like I think the pushback you're going to get
from people is it, it's probably,
it's probably hallucinating.
It's probably lying.
It's probably doing this wrong.
But if you can, by the way, so what people,
what sort of people that them, the, those people,
the other people, the people who,
who are, aren't convinced yet.
So, and the, and the, the way you do this
is if you're a scientist is you just have someone
who understands how to make cloud code, for example,
do this kind of thing for you,
give it a problem that you just worked your way through.
See if it gives you the answer that you got.
If it did, then you should be somewhat intrigued.
Like, don't be convinced.
Don't be completely pushed over to the other side,
but at least be open to the possibility
that this is a powerful tool that can assist you
in your research.
And at the same time, be appropriately horrified
at the fact that your, your computer is now doing
some degree of science for you under your control.
But, but what comes next?
Look, it's crazy.
The next years are going to be insane
because it is, it is existential,
even at a lower level, just for like all sorts of fields.
I mean, science is one of them
where like that's going to change drastically,
but also the arts.
So I also write science books.
It's like a fun hobby of mine.
I publish them and I'm like,
I'm not going to be able to compete with this thing
because it's going to be able to draw on
every science fiction author ever.
Like it's, it's, oh my god.
Yeah, that one I'm less concerned with.
And maybe that's just me, you know,
as a person who writes and creates content,
you know, la la la, I'm not listening.
But, but I think it's, it's a garbage writer.
Like it's, it writes trite.
It takes, it writes the average.
It doesn't come up with interesting turns of phrase.
It just isn't fun to read.
And it isn't fun for now, yes.
But I think that making it fun to read
is always pushing back against the,
like, like it's always moving away from innovation,
from ingenuity, from coming up with new ideas
and trying to push back towards the mean and the median.
And, and so as long as those are the forces
that are making AI very successful,
then it's going to make the kind of content
that it produces very bland and mediocre
and less interesting to most of an audience.
But, but I could be, I could be super wrong about that.
And I think where it gets kind of scary
for content creators is when you have a person
who knows what they're doing.
You have a very skilled producer or director
or a screenwriter who is directing the AI,
but they're the ones providing the ideas.
And then they're looking,
they're using it to execute their ideas more quickly.
I can see a writer no longer,
like creating a movie without a movie production company.
So those are the kinds of things where I think
we have that kind of short-term scariness.
But I, I personally, I don't feel
that it's going to be a better interviewer than me
for a while, right?
The cool thing about what you're doing,
I think maybe you might be the model for going forwards
is that you, you are on camera
with a platform engaging with people, right?
And so it is literally, you are the product
like in many ways.
And so it's very human.
Whereas the concern I have with say, writing a book, right?
Like lots of books are actually quite formulaic.
And so maybe nothing of value has been lost.
But if you look at, for example, like romance books,
people go into them and they don't expect to be surprised.
It's completely, they know what they're going to get.
It's predictable.
It's not about innovation.
It is actually about mastering the meme.
And, and they will just be completely, I can.
They are.
Yeah.
I mean, like, like there's, there are people who are teaching people
how to write romance novels with Claude.
You can write a book in 45 minutes.
They're, they're pumping out thousands of them.
Amazon is choking under the strain of these things.
And, and I think, and I think you're, you know,
you do have to have that kind of question.
Like was, is that okay?
Is that, does it matter?
Is that all right?
Like if I'm looking for something genuine and interesting,
you know, if I'm just looking to fill my time,
it's funny, you listen to people like the, the AI music industry is,
is having this big issue right now.
And a lot of musicians are saying like,
what is the point of being a musician?
If you can just write down a bunch of prompts and,
and obviously the point is that you're, you're making this stuff.
You're using your voice.
You're creating something that is of interest to you.
But what's interesting is,
is that the kind of people who are using the, the AI music apps,
you ask them who their favorite musicians are,
who their influences are.
And they say, it's me.
I like my music.
I like the music I'm making with the AI better than I like
to listen to anybody else's music.
And so you can imagine that same thing being applied.
I'm going to read books.
I like the books that I read because they fit my exact interests.
I like to watch the TV shows that I'm creating with my AI
because they fit my exact interests.
I like the movies that I'm watching.
And so we're all siloing into this sort of personal mediascape.
And we no longer have this shared collective hang around the water cooler
talking about last night's episode of fallout.
Because I'm playing video games that,
that are the perfect balance of the kinds of games that I'm most interested in.
I'm watching TV shows that, you know, I've,
I've adapted the stories that I wrote using the music that I wrote.
And when I say wrote, I mean, that's a terrible,
please, that is, I prompted this thing saying, you know,
write me an epic sci-fi that has really cool music
and has really amazing characters.
And I, and there's a video game that I can play.
Okay, ding, done.
Okay, great.
Now I watch it.
Right.
Look, I think, I think the most likely outcome is that both will happen
if there's a niche for it.
You know, I think that some people will enjoy that stuff
and it will have its place.
And maybe that's a good thing to have ultra personalized stuff.
Maybe that's good.
And then, but I also think there'll be a craving
for genuine talent in the real world,
going to see music live, all this stuff.
So hopefully, hopefully the future is bright
and these things just reorganize, you know, at least, you know,
maybe it won't be quite as dramatic as people think
in terms of everybody's just unemployed.
And because maybe there'll be demand for other stuff,
but it's really hard to call, man.
It's hard to call.
Yeah.
It is really hard to call.
Yeah.
I mean, I can feel as a product manager,
working with the technology to make things that,
that my, my someday maybe to-do list is just vaporizing.
Right.
I'm just like, you know, I'm like, here's this thing
that I wanted to do someday, but it's impossible.
I don't want to control my telescope remotely.
It's impossible.
Now, you know, I've now it's, I've got an interface
that lets me control my telescope remotely.
So, so these kinds of things are suddenly happening.
Yeah.
And so then the question is, is that just make it bottomless
for me to start developing things or do we reach this point
where I literally am out of projects?
So, yeah.
I will see, we will see.
Yeah.
I think both of us are in a, I'm just glad that I'm 30,
you know, and I've done some of the things I wanted to do.
Because if the future is that everything gets done by AI,
I wrote the book, I did the science, you know,
before the robots.
Yeah.
You retired at 35.
Yeah.
As the, as the, as the robotic, yeah.
As the, as the exoskeletons are crunching down on the skulls.
I would be so pissed just starting my PhD.
Yeah.
My kids are, my kids are that age and I, you know,
interested in helping them navigate careers that will,
will keep them in the, you know, employed.
But yeah, it's a funny time.
Who actually knows about this stuff to guide them.
So yeah.
Hopefully.
Yeah.
Or I could be doing a terrible job.
I don't know.
Craig, always a pleasure.
Thank you so much for taking the time to chat with me.
Good luck with your,
with all of the research that we talked about today,
as well as the research that we didn't even talk about today,
but that'll have to be next time.
Oh, fantastic.
I look forward to that.
Thanks for it.
Thank you.
All right.
Bye bye.
I hope you enjoyed that conversation with Dr.
Craig Walton.
Now we talked about this sort of bioavailability of phosphorus
and nitrogen on planets like the earth.
And then I switched gears and we have a much longer conversation
about another paper that Craig released within the last couple of weeks that says,
well, maybe the late heavy bombardment started much earlier,
like right at the beginning of the solar system,
which kind of makes sense that you had all of this,
these asteroids formed during the beginning of the solar system.
And they were constantly crashing into you.
Why would you get this spike about 700 million years after
the formation of the solar system?
That's weird.
Not expected.
So Craig has has sort of painstakingly gone through meteorites around the world
and built what he thinks is a more accurate picture of the early formation of the solar system.
So now, as always, that conversation is available over on Patreon.
Now, I've got to remind you, this is available free.
You can click this, go over there, just watch it.
There's no there's no gating.
You don't have to pay for anything.
You have to donate.
You can just watch it over on Patreon.
And that's because we think that Patreon is a much better experience.
That you can watch this stuff without any ads and and not be locked into the YouTube algorithm.
So definitely go and check that out.
I'll put a link down in the show notes.
And then just remember, everything we do.
We also do this over on Patreon completely for free.
And it's better.
We do it with additional content in everything that we produce.
So definitely go and check that out.
Now I'm going to give you some final thoughts.
But first, I'd like to thank our patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pedretti, Bear Lake Roofing, Brian Bowdy,
Kerwin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Baylock, Cy Nielsen, Darkfinger, David Gilson, David Matz,
Evan Dot Pro, Greg Feeley, James Clark, Jeremy Madden, Jim Burke, Jordan Young, Josh Schultz,
Marcel Smits, Michael Purcell, Nordspace, Onesetforanimals.org, Paul Buck, Ren Kaidu,
Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Stephen Fowler-Munley, Team 49, Telescopes Canada, Wolfgang Klotz,
and Zeldaboard Galactic Defender who support us at the Master of the Universe level.
And all our patrons.
All your support means the universe to us.
So if Craig seems familiar, this isn't the first time that I've talked to him.
I did an interview with him about two years ago or so and on a totally different subject,
which is that we talked about cosmic dust and that cosmic dust is constantly raining down
on the surface of a planet like the Earth left over from the formation of the solar system,
as well as just interstellar dust that is making its way.
And that it can both kind of locally change conditions on, say,
a snowball Earth to start the warming up process.
We get enough of this dust darkens the surface of the planet starts to melt.
And maybe that's what triggers the end of these snowball Earth cycles.
But also, you know, based on the conversation that you heard today that we talked about sort
of what's available to life on a planet during the formation process, that that doesn't include
this constant eject injection of, say, 100 tons a day of material from space.
That it's constantly layering down onto the surface of the planet and making it
have more chemicals available to life.
And that makes things more complicated.
So if you enjoyed this conversation with Craig, I know you're going to love the other conversation
with him that I had.
So I'll put a link of that in the show notes.
You can go and check that out.
All right.
I hope you enjoyed this conversation and we'll see you next time.