Did This MYSTERIOUS Shield Actually Exist the Boeotian shield debate

Shielded Dynasty Network
2 followers
8 Video Views·Feb 2, 2026
In this video we delve into the subject of the Boeotian shield and whether or not it truly existed. Is it merely artistic license, or was it a real shield in use at this time?
Everybody knows that the Hoplites wielded the aspis as a shield, the shield that gave birth to
the phalanx style of warfare and categorically made the Hoplite the heavy infantry of the ancient
Greek battlefield. However, there is another style of shield which seems to be far more mysterious
and has a lot of questions about it that we see, that being the so-called Boeotian shield
or the diaplon. This shield is really an interesting style of shield as it is actually
quite different to the aspis and we know that a shield like this was used in the Bronze Age,
the diaplon, the original one, which was likely made of wicker and other organic materials.
What makes this shield particularly interesting is that this is well after the Bronze Age and
this is when we typically use the name Boeotian shield. We see this style of shield depicted
in artwork from the Archaic Period, not really in the classical except for on Theban coins,
which is why it gets the name Boeotian shield, as because Thebes is of course in Boeotia.
And this shield has quite a large debate about its authenticity. Is it really a style of shield
that still exists and was used into the Archaic Period or is it an artistic throwback to Homeric
era heroes and never actually existed? Today we're going to talk a little bit about this
forgotten and mysterious ancient Greek shield and give some points for and against the idea
of its use in the Archaic battlefield. So first I think what's important to outline is that this
specific shield that I have made here is a very circular diaplon, essentially an aspis with
cutouts. This is a style of aspis, I suppose, that we see depicted in Archaic era artwork.
However, it is very much unclear whether this actually existed or if this is an artist essentially
trying to depict a heroic diaplon shield in an Archaic context. The sort of true Boeotian shield
is actually more of an oval shape. Fundamentally as well, the shield is held differently to the
Whereas an aspis you typically hold your shield arm bent, the diaplon or Boeotian style shields
feature a straight grip. We also very much see this pose depicted when we see it in art.
So the arm is outstretched which then makes this blazon upright and it's held like that,
which is similar to how you typically hold an aspis in one-on-one combat as well.
We also interestingly often see Boeotian shields depicted with having a scaled front,
and I believe that this is quite possibly a wicker shield, which we know existed many earlier
shields and even classical shields, some of which were made of wicker, with a perhaps leather coating
and actually has scales stitched on as a means of giving it a bronze facing without having to use
very large sheets. This is a theory at the end of the day, but so much of ancient Greek history is,
especially when it comes to warfare, but I think it makes quite a lot of sense. We know that many
of these shields were organic, we know they were wicker, they were very very light. To stitch
scales essentially the same way that you did to armour to a shield facing is a time-consuming
but realistic way of giving a shield a bronze coating without having to have a dish and shape
massive sheets of bronze like we do also see. But that doesn't answer the question, was this
shield still in use at the time of the archaic period? And in short, we can't say, and I have
very mixed feelings about this. The archaic period does seem to be a period of warfare which sees far
more open styles of combat, which means that a shield that is held and used differently to an
aspis isn't necessarily a problem when it comes to more individualistic fighting. In fact, this
stance is very much ideal for an individual style of combat. It is widely depicted in this period as
well, however often in a very obscure way. It is essentially depicted as an aspis with the whole
internal fittings the same as an aspis with cutouts, some of which again circular like this one.
This could quite possibly be an artist who has never really seen a daplon shield trying to
depict one in art and basically messing it up and making an aspis with cutouts. Or this is a real
shield that existed for a brief period of time that was essentially an aspis with beautine shield
cutouts. For me I don't think that we should completely reject that as a possibility. I often
think people are very very quick to throw down unusual things as artistic license which quite
possibly weren't artistic license. I could see certain individuals wanting to have a
more Homeric appearance by basically having an aspis with cutouts and I could still see
an ancestor of that daplon shield still being in use for the early archaic period. I don't think it
was particularly common but equally it could very much be artistic license and a throwback. We often
see that especially in the archaic period Homeric era heroes depicted in archaic panoply. It is
highly possible and I think highly likely that we would have also seen Homeric era items
used in an archaic context in the artistic world. It is certainly a very interesting shield and a
interesting question that unfortunately as with much of the ancient Greek period we really just
can't answer. So those who have asked me about the beautine shield that is sort of the debate.
Did it exist? Maybe. Was it the same as the daplon shield? Probably not. It is highly possible
that it is an artistic throwback to Homeric era heroes depicted in archaic artwork. We can't prove
that. We can't disprove that really either. For me personally I think just the sheer amount of
artistic depictions of the shield existing I think it's highly possible that there was a shield that
was highly resemblance of the daplon shield or the beautine shield that was still used in the
archaic period. But again it might not be. Was it essentially an aspis made in the way of a
shield? That's also possible. Maybe there is again basically emulating your own heroes. Some
hoplites of the archaic period wanting their aspis to resemble more Homeric shields but equally as
well the fact that we see aspides depicted like beautine shields could indicate an artist that
has heard of a beautine shield and doesn't really know what it is. So again could indicate the fact
that it is an artistic throwback. So maybe a bit of a lackluster answer for you there of
we don't know. Maybe you can make your own opinions and tell me what you think in the
comments as well. I'm personally very much in the middle when it comes to this debate. I think you
can equally argue both sides and I don't think we really ever know. Maybe I'm leaning a little
bit more on the side that I think we shouldn't toss the artistic evidence aside that this wasn't
a real shield that was used. We see it in all forms of mediums. We see it in sculptural and
vase depictions. We have no archaeological remains of them but we don't have many archaeological
remains of aspides in general and if it existed in any era of sort of hoplite warfare the early
archaic period I think makes the most sense. We know it was still used around the geometric period
of course into the bronze age. We see very very similar shields. So I think it's highly possible
but I also do think it's very much possible that it is an artistic throwback to past heroes. What
do you think? Let me know down below and a special thanks to our channel members for supporting the
channel. If you yourself would like to support the channel more so than you already do just by
watching the videos then checking out our channel memberships can be a great help.
Also sharing the video around to try and help these very niche topics reach the people that
might find them interesting. Thank you very much for watching this video and I'll hopefully see
you in the next one.
