Game of Thrones season 5: In defence of the Unsullied

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
80 Video Views·Aug 14, 2025
Hi folks, Matt Easton here of Scholar Gladiatoria.
So something I've heard in the last week, well first of all I have to say
spoilers coming for Game of Thrones so for those of you who are not up to date
in Game of Thrones you should probably stop watching now. They're not huge
spoilers but something I've heard in the last
week since the last episode which was episode 9 of season 5
is a lot of people complaining about how easily the Unsullied
are dying. I must admit this has crossed my mind as I've been watching
season 5. The Unsullied are supposed to be the
ultimate kind of uber army guys, castrated and trained since
childhood to be mega hard. I suppose they're sort of
supposed to be inspired by people like the Spartans for example
and a lot of people are complaining about the fact that
they're getting taken out by the sons of the harpy
these guys who essentially, or people who are essentially civilians
with a mask on with usually kind of like
kitchen knives or sticks or fairly you know whatever weapons they can lay their
hands on. Very occasionally they have a sword or
a spear but usually they've just got kind of something that can
easily be concealed, a dagger or just a normal
you know civilian knife and they are being
killed by these harpy dudes and dudettes and let's have a look at
the Unsullied for a start. They've got a
long spear which is what their primary weapon
they have a shield not dissimilar to what I'm holding here except it's metal
and then they have a short what looks like bronze a short sword or a large
dagger. Now if you actually think about this it
kind of doesn't matter and this is the point of the video really
it doesn't matter how tough a fighter is if they're trained for one type of
combat then often they're not going to be so
effective in a different type of combat. Now first of all
the Unsullied are trained primarily as battlefield troops they're not
trained as riot control police you know streets of urban enforcers, law enforcers
so they're not used to fighting in this kind of environment necessarily
but also their weapons aren't set up for it they're using
a spear and a shield predominantly. Now a spear is a fantastic weapon in an open
space but it's a really rubbish weapon in a
confined space. Yes they do have their short swords as a
backup however if they're initially going
around with their spear and their shield
they're probably not the way they've been trained they're probably not
initially just going to instantly drop the spear because that's what they've
trained to fight with and in fact this is what we see
in the series I don't know how true it is to the books but certainly in the
series we see that they try to fight with
their spears as much as possible and this is actually doing them a
disservice because fighting against one spear against multiple opponents
not just we're not just talking about two or three people but we're talking
about whole crowds of people who might be all around not just coming
from one direction trying to use a spear in that scenario
is not really a good idea. Spears are great against one or two opponents
and of course they're great when you're en masse and you're standing shield to
shield and you've all got your spears but if
you're trying to fight against multiple
multiple opponents and you don't have your comrades right next to you with your
shields protecting each other then they don't
work very well anymore and they become more of a liability and this is why
spearmen throughout history have carried daggers, swords,
axes, things like this as a backup weapon because in
a close press or in a confined space you need to be able to grab your short
weapon like the boar hammer there for example
and start fighting all around more dexterously and easily in a
confined space which you can't really do with a spear
so I would argue cut the unsolid a bit of
slack first of all they're not really trained for this type of fighting
secondly it doesn't matter how tough you are
if you're outnumbered you're kind of screwed usually
okay for any of you out there who ever do multiple opponent sparring in whatever
martial arts you do or even if it's reenactment or laugh or anything like
that you will know that if you're ganged up
on by more than two people you know sometimes you can hold your own
against two people especially if you're good
and they're their moves then often you can take out two new people however
if you get more than two people against you especially if they manage to
triangulate on you so they're not just all standing in front of you
but maybe one's there one's there and one's creeping around the back
it's incredibly difficult and shields are very effective but they're generally
only working in one or maximum two directions at once
so if I'm fighting someone over here I might have my shield there and I might
be trying to hold them off with the shield
I'm fighting someone over here but I'm essentially uncovered here and I'm
certainly uncovered there and I'm actually uncovered over here as
well so cut the unsullied some slack basically
they are good battlefield troops or they're
supposed to be and that's what they've been represented as in the series
however law enforcement urban fighting is not their thing
they don't really have the right weapons for it they're not heavily armoured
and essentially it doesn't matter how good a fighter soldier you are if you're
ganged up on by a bunch of civilians with knives
you're in kind of deep trouble and we see that even today in war zones
so cheers guys click subscribe now and also follow us on facebook
