If you like this video, you'll LOVE Fitness-Tip Friday! My extremely popular FREE weekly e-mail newsletter that is always short, significant, and science-based! 👉 https://www.dr-gains.com/fitness-tip-friday
Be sure to subscribe before you go! 👉 youtube.com/drgains
Key Timestamps: 0:00 Intro 0:35 Error #1 - Shoulder Flexion (Pull-Downs Don’t Work It!) 0:53 How to REALLY Work the Biceps at the Shoulder 1:33 Position vs Resistance Examples 3:15 What About the Eccentric Phase? 4:51 Why Should You Believe Me? 6:13 Error #2 - Active Insufficiency 6:53 Error #3 - Supination 8:42 Intro to Regional Hypertrophy 9:42 Biceps Regional Hypertrophy - Key #1 (Biarticular Effect) 10:31 Biceps Regional Hypertrophy - Key #2 (Supination) 11:31 Specialized Supplements You’re Not Taking 12:13 ProHealth Longevity & the Importance of Personalized Nutrition 13:58 Fitness-Tip Friday Newsletter
===
Athlean-X recently quoted a bodybuilder named Mike Mentzer in saying that “the close-grip palms-up pull-down is the best BICEPS exercise in the world, better than any curl you can do.” He even called the chin-up, which is the same underhand pull movement, one of the only 2 bicep exercises you need. Because, according to him “It applies the stress to the biceps from both ends because we’re going into that flexed shoulder and bent elbow position.”
Error #1 - The pull-down and chin-up do NOT work the biceps at the shoulder! It’s physically impossible.
The biceps perform elbow flexion at the bottom, and shoulder flexion at the top, and it is essential to work them at both ends, because that has regional hypertrophy effects on the biceps. Working them at the elbow preferentially works the LOWER biceps, while working it at the shoulder work the UPPER biceps more.
But a pull-down or chin-up combines elbow flexion with shoulder EXTENSION!! The exact opposite of what the bicep does!
To work the biceps at the shoulder, you need resistance against shoulder flexion. Here that’s the dumbbell pushing down on the upper arm, forcing the shoulder flexors like the upper biceps and front deltoid to work against it.
During a pull-down the shoulder’s in a flexed position, which may trick you into thinking you’re working shoulder flexion, but there’s nothing pushing down on the arm! The resistance - which is what matters - is the cable pulling up on the arm, forcing the shoulder extensors, like the lats and long head of the triceps, to work against it.
This can be confusing, because the shoulder IS in a flexed position. But the position itself doesn’t tell you anything about what muscles are being worked in any exercise. It depends 100% on where the resistance is coming from!
What about the eccentric phase? The shoulder is being flexed then, right? Yes, but it’s passive shoulder flexion because there’s still no resistance against it. Think of it this way, does the eccentric phase of a push-up work your back because your arms are pulling being retracted? Nope. Still works the chest, just concentrically then eccentrically.
The fact is that if you’re doing a pull-down or chin-up, nothing you can do, whether its overloading eccentrics, adjusting the angle of your elbow, or how far back you lean… nothing, can change that fact that you’re working shoulder extension. Not flexion.
Error #2 - Having the shoulders flexed and elbows bent at the same time - like they are at the bottom of a pull-down or top of a chin-up - actually puts the biceps into active insufficiency. So at this point of the exercise, even the elbow flexion aspect works the brachialis far more than the over-shortened biceps.
Error #3 - Having the forearms in a supinated position and working supination itself are two completely different things!
In order to work the biceps more than the other elbow flexors during a curl, there has to be ROTATIONAL resistance against supination! That’s what it does that the other flexors don’t. A pull-down or chin-up doesn’t provide that.
The YouTuber AthleanX recently quoted a bodybuilder named Mike Menser in saying that
The closed grip palms up pulldown is the best bicep exercise in the world.
Better than any curl you could do. He even called the chin-up,
which is the same underhand pull movement, one of only two bicep exercises you need.
Because, according to him, I know that it does exactly what Mike was talking about
on that exercise. It applies the stress to the biceps from both ends because we're going into
that flexed shoulder position and bent elbow. Guys, there are three huge errors here.
First, the pulldown and chin-up do not work the biceps at the shoulder. It's physically impossible.
The biceps do perform elbow flexion at the bottom and shoulder flexion at the top,
and it is essential to work them at both ends. But this is what combining those two movements
actually looks like. A pulldown or chin-up combines elbow flexion with shoulder extension,
the exact opposite of what the bicep does. To work the biceps at the shoulder,
you need resistance against shoulder flexion. Here, that's the dumbbell pushing down on the
upper arm, forcing the shoulder flexors, like the upper biceps and front delt, to work against it.
Here, the shoulder's in a flexed position, which may trick you into thinking you're
working shoulder flexion, but you're not, because there's nothing pushing down on the arm.
The resistance, which is what matters, is the cable pulling up on the arm,
forcing the shoulder extensors, like the lats and long head of the triceps, to work against it.
Now, I know this can be confusing. It even threw off AthleanX. Because again, the shoulder is
in a flexed position. But what you need to understand is that the position itself doesn't
tell you anything about what muscles are being worked. It depends 100% on where the resistance
is coming from, in any exercise. For example, if we look at the top of a tricep extension exercise,
the elbow is in a flexed position. Does that mean I'm working the biceps here, via elbow flexion?
No, because there's no resistance against elbow flexion. The opposite is true. The cable is
pulling up on my forearm, creating resistance against elbow extension, thus working the triceps.
So, even though you get into a flexed elbow position at the top, you're still not working
the elbow flexor muscles at any point. On the flip side, if we look at the bottom of a bicep curl,
the elbow is in an extended position. Does that mean I'm working the triceps here,
via elbow extension? No, because there's no resistance against elbow extension. It's against
elbow flexion, the opposite movement, via the dumbbell pushing down on my forearm, thus working
the biceps. So, although you get into an extended elbow position at the bottom, you're not working
the elbow extensor muscles at any point. We could do this with any exercise. Here, the shoulder is
in an adducted position, but the resistance is against the abductors. Here, the shoulder is in
an internally rotated position, but the load is on the external rotators. You get the point. So,
now that this concept is clear, let's apply it back to shoulder flexion. If, during an exercise,
my shoulder is flexed like this, what's being worked? Say it with me. It depends. If the
resistance is down, shoulder flexion is being worked. If the resistance is up, shoulder
extension is being worked. And with a pull-down or chin-up, the resistance is pulling up,
thus working shoulder extension. Now, some of you may be thinking, what about the eccentric phase?
The shoulder is being flexed then, right? Yes, but it's passive flexion, because there's still
no resistance against it. Think of it this way. Does the eccentric phase of a push-up work your
back because your arms are being retracted? Nope. Still works the chest, just concentrically,
then eccentrically. Same here. Negatives still work the shoulder extensors,
just eccentrically. The fact is, guys, that if you are doing a palms-up pull-down or a chin-up,
nothing you can do, whether it's overloading eccentrics, adjusting the angle of your elbow,
or how far back you lean, nothing at all can change the fact that you're working shoulder
extension, not flexion. Shoulder flexion, shoulder extension. Upper and lower biceps,
only lower biceps. End of story, bye-bye, see you later.
And, believe it or not, there are actually two more big, fundamental errors here. Here's the
rest of that clip, where that Mike Mencer guy explains why he says the close grip underhand
pull-down is the best biceps exercise in the world. Here's why. When you do a curl, whether
it's a barbell curl, a nautilus curl, a dumbbell curl, whatever, you're working this muscle around
the single joint axis, the elbow, which is why the stress is limited exclusively to the lower
bicep, if you've noticed. When doing a close grip palms-up pull-down, on the other hand,
you're working the bicep around the joint, the elbow joint, and the shoulder. The muscle is
contracting more uniformly from both ends. Now, before I get into the other two reasons why that
is straight up wrong, some of you may be thinking, but Michael, their biceps are bigger than yours,
so why should I listen to you over them? Their biceps are indeed bigger, or at least used to be,
so why should you listen to me? Well, for one, my biceps happen to be the exact size and shape I
want them to be, and two, I achieve those results without having ever taken any steroids, anabolics,
or hormone boosters of any kind, so my results are from pure technique. Three, the foundations for
what I teach comes from my training at the top-ranked medical institution in the world,
the Mayo Clinic. Four, the pull-down isn't the only exercise those two did to get their biceps
so they wouldn't look the way they do. And finally, none of that even matters, because guys,
the size of their biceps doesn't change physics or human anatomy. A pull-down works shoulder
extension, not flexion. This isn't my opinion, it's an objective physiological fact. They've both
conflated having a flexed shoulder position with working shoulder flexion itself, so in this case,
they're just flat-out wrong, big biceps and all. However, there is one thing Mike Mansur said there
that is true, and it's that elbow flexion preferentially works the lower biceps region,
and shoulder flexion the upper region. That's due to an extremely important principle called
regional hypertrophy, and I'll go over more techniques for regional biceps training here
towards the end of this video. But first, I told you there are two additional issues here.
The second is that having the shoulders flexed and elbows bent at the same time, like they are at the
moment, puts the biceps into active insufficiency, which I've gone over multiple times in the past,
but if you're not familiar with it, check out the links I put in the video description below.
So at this point of the exercise, even the elbow flexion aspect works the brachialis
far more than the overshortened biceps. If you look back at my combo flexion technique,
you'll notice that the elbow and shoulder flexion occur in two phases, precisely to avoid active
insufficiency. When the elbows are flexed, the shoulders are straight, and when the shoulders
are flexed, the elbows are straight. So the biceps are at full capacity at both ends the
entire time. And here's the third issue. The full reason ATHLEANX gives for calling the chin-up one
of only two biceps exercises you need is this. Because I realized it allowed me to do something
very important that you might be missing right now, and that is to get all three of those functions
of the bicep hit in one shot. Getting elbow flexion, getting supination, or in a supinated
position, and also getting that shoulder flexion with our arm up high. If you understood the
shoulder flexion mistake, you may have already caught the third mistake here. In fact, he kind
of captures it himself. Getting supination, or in a supinated position... Once again,
having the forearms in a supinated position and working supination itself are two completely
different things. Most people don't know it, but the brachialis is actually the strongest elbow
flexor if the forearms stay fixed in a supinated position. In order to work the biceps more than
the other elbow flexors during a curl, there has to be rotational resistance against supination.
That's what the biceps do that the other muscles don't. And I gave you guys nine different techniques
you can use to effectively do that in a previous video that I'll link below. But I'll give you
another one now that you can use to actually work supination in a pull-down movement. Using a rope
attachment or something similar, we'll start with a pronated grip, then supinate your forearm while
you do the pull-down. This supinating pull-down will provide rotational resistance against supination
and will work the biceps far better than a supinated pull-down. I'm currently developing
an attachment called the Gains Hammer that will work far better for this, but until it's ready,
a rope will work. Let me be clear here, this isn't meant as an attack on AthleanX. I rarely watch
other fitness YouTubers, but from what I've seen, his content is normally spot on. Everybody makes
mistakes, but this pull-down business is a big one, and one that I finally had to address because I
have heard it from so many people. Another reason why it's essential to work supination itself
is because it has regional effects on bicep growth, which brings us back to the all-important
principle of regional hypertrophy. Contrary to popular belief, muscle activation and growth
never happens uniformly or equally across the full length of a muscle. Rather, in any exercise,
certain regions of a muscle will always be activated more than others, and there are
dozens of different factors you can control to determine what that regional growth looks like,
if you know how, because many of those factors are very muscle-specific. Regional training of the
biceps is highly complex, so I won't be able to cover it all in this video. However, I'll give
you two keys to understanding the regional effects of an underhand pull-down now, and then if you
want to dive into the rest, you can find in-depth breakdowns for region-specific training of almost
every major muscle in the body, including everything on the biceps, in the new Regional
Hypertrophy Training section of my All Access Membership site, which I'll link in the video
description. Key number one, because the biceps are biarticular, meaning they cross two joints,
they undergo a specific type of biarticular regional hypertrophy we've already touched on,
where working it at the distal joint will preferentially build the lower biceps region,
and working it at the proximal joint will preferentially build the upper biceps region,
which makes perfect sense. Not all regional effects do. Now, there are many caveats and
exceptions to that. I told you it's complex. For example, using BFR cuffs during elbow flexion will
work the upper biceps regions just as much as the lower. But, in general, if you want even
development across the full length of your biceps, you need to work it at both the elbow and shoulder
joints, which was why it was so important to understand that the underhand pulldown or chinup
do not do that. Key number two, the reason it's important to work the full supination range of
motion is because the first half of the movement, from palms down pronation to just past neutral,
preferentially works the short head of the biceps, which makes up the inner biceps region,
including that coveted biceps bulge, while the second half of the motion, to a palms up position
and even past it, is performed by the long head of the biceps, which makes up the outer biceps
region, including the also coveted biceps peak. So, if you want even development across the full
width of your biceps, you need to work the full range of forearm supination. And as we've discussed,
a palms up pulldown doesn't work supination at all. Again, for more details and regional techniques
with links to the scientific research, check out the regional hypertrophy training platform. I'm
adding new content to it every day, but it's already the most comprehensive resource for
regional training that exists. And you can get access to it, along with the entire basic membership,
for less than 10 measly bucks a month. That's less than a Baconator. However, if you want optimal
training results, it's just as important to have the right nutritional supplementation as it is to
perform the right exercises. And not just your standard protein, but also lesser known yet equally
beneficial supplements, such as D-ribose and ATP boosters, which not only enhance your body's
natural energy production and metabolism up front, but also drastically accelerate muscle recovery
post-workout and prevent age-related muscle loss long term, along with even more benefits you can
read about below. And these are just two examples of the more specialized and newly developed
supplements that, until now, I didn't have a high quality resource for, but I was confident in
which is why I'm pumped to announce that I partnered with ProHealth Longevity.
As many of you know, I partnered with AminoCo to bring you by far the best pre-workout supplement
on the market, and with Legion Athletics to bring you the best post-workout supplement,
along with your standard high-quality whey and casein protein. And if you missed my explanations
for why those are the best, I'll put links to those YouTube clips in the video description below.
However, those supplements all have very short-term effects and don't carry many
benefits outside of muscle growth. ProHealth Longevity takes the longer view and does so for
the entire body and mind. For example, in addition to the energy and muscle-focused
supplements I mentioned, they have the only collagen supplement I've found that provides
all five of the most important collagen types. Most only have one or two tops.
They've also developed a form of curcumin, one of the few legitimate nootropics,
that's 285 times more effective than normal curcumin. And they're best known for their NAD
Plus Triple Boost, which might be the single most effective product on the market for slowing and
even reversing aspects of the aging process, including muscle loss. Along with dozens of
other uniquely effective products of all types, all based on rigorous scientific evidence,
third-party tested, and especially important if you're over 40. And now, you can use the link
I've put in the video description below, along with the code DRGAINS, for 15% off their entire
selection. And if you'd like, you can take advantage of their free concierge service,
where they'll actually work with you one-on-one to create a personalized supplement regimen.
And guys, that's more important than you'd think, because supplement needs can differ
drastically from person to person, based on everything from your age and diet to your DNA
and genetics. Finally, for more free top-tier health and fitness content, make sure to join
Fitness Tip Friday, my extremely popular weekly email newsletter that is always short,
significant, and science-based, and also includes exclusive deals and beta testing opportunities,
along with inspirational quotes and updates from me and my family. Guys, if you liked this video,
please let me know by hitting that like button, leaving me a comment below, and maybe even
sharing it with a friend. All of those things will help me and my channel out significantly.
And be sure you're subscribed and have hit that bell icon so that you don't miss any of my future
videos. Mahalo, my friends. Until next time.