British Cavalry Swords: The 1853 And 1864 Patterns In Context

Rune Slicer
2 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 7, 2026
The British 1864 pattern cavalry sword replaced the 1853 pattern... Or did it? In this video I examine the mystery of where all the 1864 patterns have gone and whether the 1864 pattern really replaced the 1853 pattern in general use.
Hey folks, Matt Eaton here, Scholar Gladiatoria. So let's talk a little bit about British military
swords, which obviously something I talk about a lot on this channel, and specifically talking
about the move from the 1853 pattern cavalry sword to the 1864 pattern cavalry sword. Now
those of you who have an interest in this topic, and incidentally if you're not specifically into
this topic, I'm also going to touch on certain aspects of hand protection and things which
pertain generally to swords, but particularly to military sabres from all nations. Now the 1853
pattern, I'm not going to go in depth into the introduction of that, but essentially it was the
product of Charles Reeves of Birmingham. Charles Reeves was a very good sword maker. I have
several, more than several, many examples of his work in my own collection. And certainly Reeves,
to some extent, was a, if not a rival exactly of Wilkinson, was certainly on a par in terms of
quality with Wilkinson. The difference really, let's say in the year 1850 between Charles Reeves
and Henry Wilkinson, was that Reeves was really focusing on manufacturing for government procurement
contracts, although he did also produce officer swords as well, whereas Wilkinson were really just
at that point just focusing on private purchase swords for officers, and guns it has to be said.
For anyone who doesn't know incidentally, Henry Wilkinson, Wilkinson Swords, the famous sword
makers, actually grew out of Henry Knock's gun making business. So if I remember correctly Henry
Wilkinson was the son-in-law of Henry Knock. So they were connected businesses and they really,
Knock and Wilkinson really kind of aimed most of their business, certainly Wilkinson aimed most of
his business, in the early days towards officers and private purchase rather than mass manufacturing
factory produced goods like cavalry swords and bayonets and cutlasses for the military and navy.
Whereas Charles Reeves being based in Birmingham, so Henry Wilkinson was based in London,
Reeves was based in Birmingham and Birmingham at that time, and in fact for a long time afterwards
and until the modern day really, has been a mass manufacturing centre, so it was a place where
factories grew up. So Birmingham was really built up on industry and you know famously later on they
built rifles for the military companies like BSA and then they went on to produce things like
motorbikes and stuff as well. So in many ways Birmingham was on a par with places like Sheffield.
Right so the 1853 Patton sword was really Charles Reeves's design, he promoted it and
proposed it as a new cavalry sword to the British government, it was accepted in 1853.
Now if you study books on British military swords, so if you look at Brian Robson's
Swords of the British Army for example, then you might be of the impression that the 1853 Patton
sword was replaced quite cleanly in 1864 by the 1864 Patton sword, but it wasn't quite as simple
as that and so a major misconception is that when patterns come in the former pattern disappears
and it often just doesn't work like that. Now I often talk about officers swords on this channel
and many of you will know that in many cases officers weren't obliged to update their sword
to the new pattern when a new one came in, so for example in 1892 a new pattern of thrusting
blade came out, the narrow straight thrusting blade for officers swords, but many officers
continued carrying their previous 1845 Patton blades and indeed when the new hilt came in in
1895, because that's more of a visible difference on the sword, many officers upgraded their 1845
Patton swords to the new 1895 Patton hilt, but many kept the 1845 style cut and thrust saber blade
instead of improving or rather replacing the whole sword to the new 1892 Patton blade with
1895 Patton hilt, which is commonly known as the 1895 Patton sword. It gets confusing, and that
was to some extent true in regiments as well, so theoretically in 1796 when the 1796 light and heavy
patterns of cavalry sword came in, theoretically all cavalry regiments were supposed to update
their swords to the new patterns, the 1796 patterns, but they didn't. We know that the 1788
patterns, heavy and light, continued in use for several years and in many cases it wasn't even
possible for regiments to get their hands on the new pattern, either because not enough had been
produced yet or they put an order in and then it didn't arrive for a few years because whoever the
maker was, and there were many different makers in Britain, there wasn't one or one or two central
factories like there were in France with Châtellerault and Klingenthal and Saint Etienne as well to some
extent, in Britain there were many many different makers and different makers took on contracts
on smaller amounts, so in the Napoleonic period for example there were, I don't even know, maybe 20
different makers making 1796 Patton swords, and so your regiment, say you were in the 10th
Hussars, you might put an order in for the new light cavalry saber, but you might not get them
for two years because that maker might quickly have to ramp up to speed, get the designs in place,
get the prototypes made, make sure they're tested and everything, and then start going into production
and by the time they've actually manufactured enough to deliver to the regiment
it might be two years might have passed, so it might be 1798 or 99, during which time they're still
using the 1788 Patton swords that had been in use for many years prior to that, since 1788.
So the 1853 Patton didn't simply get replaced in 1864 by the 1864 Patton, and I will talk more
about the 1864 Patton in a minute, that's the first thing to acknowledge. The second thing to
acknowledge is that in some cases I am now 98% certain some regiments I believe never got the
1864 Patton sword. Now we do have records, and Robson quotes them, we do have records for the
number of 1864 Patton swords that were made, however we've also got other records which in
many cases photographs, as well as written records, showing what certain regiments were using
sometime as late as the end of the 1870s, the Zulu Wars, and into the 1880s.
And I know for a fact that even in the 1880s some regiments still had the 1853 Patton,
so the question has to be why didn't they have the 1864 Patton? Why wasn't the 1864 Patton
prevalent everywhere? Now I'll just shoot off at a slight tangent for a second, an interesting
anecdote or piece of subjective evidence for modern sword collectors like me and dealers like
me is that you don't see an awful lot of 1864 Patton swords. In fact they're really rather rare,
they're one of the rarest Patton swords for British military Pattons, especially considering
in theory, at least if you read Robson's book or any of the standard guides on British Patton
swords, you would believe that there should be thousands of these things in circulation,
as many as the 1853 at least, because in theory the 1864 Patton sword was the regulation sword
for British cavalry between 1864, or by the time it got rolled out, 65-66, and in theory about 1885.
Yes indeed there was an 1880 Patton, Pattons, and 82 Pattons that were supposedly modifications of
the 64 Patton, but the first big production, the first next big Patton production was in 1885.
So in theory for 20 years the 1864 Patton was in use. So where are all the 1864 Pattons?
I have owned two in my life, and the one I have here isn't strictly speaking an 1864 Patton,
although for the purposes of this video it's representing an 1864 Patton, I will talk more
about this sword in a minute. I have owned two plus that one, which is not a standard one.
They're rare, they're really hard to get hold of, and therefore of course they're relatively
expensive as well, and yet 1853 Pattons I've owned maybe 30? There are loads of them around,
there are loads of 1853 Pattons, but on paper if we just go by the dates of the Pattons,
this was only in use from 1853 to 1864, 11 years, whereas the 1864 Patton was supposedly in use for
20 years. Well the problem is I call BS, because the 1864 Patton I am now strongly strongly
convinced, unfortunately the records are somewhat lacking to be able to say exactly who was sent 1864
Pattons and when they were sent them, but I am now fairly certain that lots of regiments,
lots of cavalry regiments never ever got the 1864 Patton. I think that they were produced in
relatively, to other patterns, relatively small numbers, or for some reason just never got to the
regiments, or perhaps some did get to the regiments and people didn't like them, or people didn't
adopt them, or maybe they were put into storage and the 53 Pattons kept being used because these
were only 11 years old, or maybe by the time the 64s arrived maybe 13 years old, and so people
thought well we'll keep using these, these are fine. Who knows? There are lots of unknowns,
always with the study of militaria and antique military history there are always unknowns.
But the 1853 Patton we know was still in use in the 1880s, and I have had one example
that was literally dated 1883 I think it was, it was 1880 something, early 80s. So even in the
1880s these were still being made. Another piece of evidence is if we look at Alfred Hutton's
The Cavalry Swordsman, which he wrote in 1864, he actually talks about the design of cavalry swords
and he describes the universal pattern of cavalry sword, and he describes this in 1864, well bear
in mind, in 1867 sorry, in 1864 a new pattern of sword was supposed to come out for all cavalry
regiments, and yet here we have Captain Alfred Hutton, I think he was then in the King's Dragoon
Guards, writing about the regulation cavalry sword and it's this, it's the 1853 pattern.
He was writing about cavalry swordsmanship and cavalry swords, talking about cavalry sword
design, and he'd never even heard of the 1864 pattern. How's that possible? And he was in an
illustrious cavalry regiment as well, this wasn't some, you know, these weren't some backwater
light dragoon unit who were posted out in India or somewhere, these were the King's Dragoon Guards.
If anyone should have known about the latest developments in cavalry swords it was Captain
Alfred Hutton in 1867, and yet he'd never even heard of the 1864 pattern cavalry sword. So
let's now put a cap on that and have a look at this 1864 pattern sword and what the difference was.
I should just mention a couple of stats about this sword, it has a 35 and a half inch blade,
okay, so it's a fairly big sword. This is the 1853 pattern and it has a three bar hilt, this is the
sword that Alfred Hutton describes in 1867 in the Cavalry Swordsman as the regulation cavalry sword.
This was brought in just on the eve of the Crimean, obviously just a year before the Crimean War.
Some of these were used in the Crimean War and some regiments, again to illustrate my earlier
point, hadn't yet received this new sword and were still using the older 1821 pattern sword,
which if you read many books on the Crimean War they will state how that was a greatly inferior
sword and this was a great leap forward. Well that's BS, that's written by people who don't
know anything about swords and probably never even held any of these examples themselves. The
fact is that the only real difference between the 1853 pattern and the earlier 1821 pattern
is the construction of the grip. This has a full width tang built like a mesa grip or a knife grip
so you can see the tang on front and back. So it's simply, it is a stronger tang construction method
and that was Charles Reeves' patent, that was his gift to the world was the full width tang which
I've spoken about in previous videos and if you look at eastern antique arms you can find articles
about this by me. The 1821 pattern sword is not a bad sword, it's the same size as this, it's a 35
and a half inch blade, it's the same width of this, it's a similar curvature to this, it's got a spear
tip like this, it's got a single fuller like this, it's got a three bar hilt like this. So the 1821
pattern sword is very similar to the 1853 pattern sword, really it's just the hilt construction is
the only difference. And do you really need a full width tang? Well I would argue probably not.
If we look at officer's swords, officer's swords for the most part didn't adopt the full width tang,
they kept the normal tang, through tang going through, peened at the end or screwed at the end
and they never had any problems with those. So anyway, so the 1853 pattern sword was replaced
in theory in 1864 by the 1864 pattern sword, however as I've just hopefully illustrated it
wasn't. Many regiments kept these, most regiments I believe kept these until the 1880s when they were
replaced by the 1885 pattern and I believe that some regiments, possibly even more than half
regiments, never had any sword that came between the 1853 pattern sword and the 1885 pattern sword.
I believe that a lot of regiments just moved from 1853 pattern to 1885 pattern and in my view this
is a better sword than the 1885 pattern. So what changed on paper in theory in 1864? What was the 1864
pattern sword? Well quite simply it was this sword with a different guard, that was all it was. So you
will notice this has a three bar hilt and as many of you will notice there are gaps in here. Now
whilst the three bar hilt remained popular with some regiments and with most officers
and with the Royal Artillery this was seen as adequate for most people in most circumstances
but it has to be said that it is not a perfect guard, it is not symmetrical so it's slightly
more balanced to one side than the other and of course it does have these holes through the bars
where theoretically a cut or a thrust could pass. So the obvious modification to make this
into the ultimate cavalry sword is to put a form of bowl guard or shell guard onto here that doesn't
have those imperfections and so that's what we have here. It's a symmetrical guard which is good
for balance, rotational balance and it has a bowl guard which only has perforations at the very front
of it, the so-called Maltese cross and this is the very first form of guard to have this Maltese
cross on it. Why are those perforations there? Well partly probably because they look nice
at least to them and secondly because a point can't get through here, certainly a sabre point
couldn't get through there, maybe a small sword could, but it makes the guard lighter. So any
perforations and you'll see the same thing with Austrian swords for example, often if you look
at Austrian swords you'll notice there's a lot of common ground right from before the Napoleonic
period right the way through to the end of the 19th century there's a lot of commonalities between
British military swords and Austrian military swords. There seem to have been some close, that's
a topic for another video, but some close relationships there. So this model of guard, bowl guard here
and one just minor detail is the 1864 guard has these sword knot option up here instead of the
normal sword knot option there which it also has, it gives you an option to have the sword knot
attached at the back of the wrist rather than the bottom of the wrist. So the 1864 in theory
is basically just an improved guard on the 1853, the blade is the same, the hilt construction is
the same, blah blah blah. Now this, I said this isn't really an 1864 pattern sword, this isn't
and that's because this is a private purchase one. Now I don't, I've never seen another one like this
ever. I searched, I tried to find a comparison for this sword online and looking in auction
catalogues and I found this sword. So I actually found, I found what I thought was another example
of this sword and it was just this sword that had been sold previously in auction prior to the time
that I bought it in an auction. So this happens with antiques, if you're an antique dealer or an
antique collector sometimes you see literally the same sword come around a few times, maybe you sell
it and then a few years later you see someone else selling it or maybe you see it in auction or
whatever. This happens and I've actually, currently I own one sword in my collection now which I had
previously owned and sold, regretted selling and then bought back from the person I sold it to
into your course. So that happens, there are only a finite number of antiques in the world at the end
of the day. So this is pretty much the regulation guard as we find on the 1864 pattern but you'll
notice it has one difference, it has these incised lines around the edging, so both around the
perforations and around the edge around here. That points to it being an officer's weapon.
The other thing which points to it being an officer's weapon is this here, is the etched
panel which gives you Milan and Man of George Street in Edinburgh. So this was presumably
ordered as a private purchase by a Scottish cavalry officer and finally there is one other
big difference, the construction of the grip. Now I'll just grab the 1853 grip for a second,
so the normal 1864 has a grip constructed in the same method as the 1853 here, in other words the
hilt is leather, so it's leather slabs riveted by five rivets onto the full width tang and those
leather slabs are built up by layers of leather, a bit like a pyramid, stacked on top of each other
in lines and then over the top is a kind of final roll outer layer of leather. I know that because
I've seen these that have been constructed with age. So the typical 1864 pattern has the same
construction grip as this here, 1853. This one you can see doesn't, it actually has grips, it's still
got the full width tang, you can see front and back, but it has grips made of horn and it has
more rivet holes in it than the typical non-officers, the troopers version, the rank and file version.
So this is essentially, well essentially it is, an officer's private purchase version of the 1864.
That opens all sorts of questions because I've just explained to you that most cavalry regiments
retained this 1853 and most cavalry officers, I'll just grab a, most cavalry officers just simply had
a more fancy version with the old hilt construction style, so with a through tang instead of, with a
through tang instead of a full width tang and a back strap. So this is an officer's version and
you can see that obviously if your troopers, if your men have this three bar hilt and you have
the officer's version you look kind of similar to each other don't you? So if most of the troopers
retained the 1853 pattern then finding an officer's version of an 1864 is quite unusual, so presumably
whichever regiment this officer ordered this sword from, number one his regiment had received the
1864 pattern swords or possibly they still had the 1853 pattern swords but he knew about the new 1864
pattern and he wanted one of the newer more protective designs. And finally he elected through
his own decision to have a sword which was more similar to the trooper's sword rather than looking
like the typical officer's sword, which is quite a big leap in a way because most officers were about
almost distinguishing themselves from the men in terms of their uniform, the quality of all the
fittings, the quality of the sword, the decoration of the sword, you know the fact that officer's
swords have chagrin grips and this incised line decoration. So whilst this is officerised
from a distance it would probably look like a trooper's weapon, which is an interesting thing.
And as I say this isn't the standard 1864 pattern, yeah 1864 pattern, but it is of 1864
size so it still has a 55 and a half inch blade, it's still got the same fundamentally the same
design hilt but which is with a bit of added decoration on and it's still got the full width
tang but the grip scales instead of being made of leather in this case are made of horn and riveted
more times than the typical 1864. How does this feel in the hand? Feels absolutely lovely, it's
got amazing hand protection, very very strong, nothing to criticise about that hand protection
for a sabre really. The only way it could be improved is making it into a full basket hilt
with all of the disadvantages that a full basket hilt has in terms of wearing and versatility of
grip and weight and things like that. So it's a lovely lovely sword, I'm very lucky to have it,
I actually missed it, I saw it in the first auction it was in many many years ago or I was
outbid or whatever and then it came in up in another auction I managed to get at that time
so I'm very happy to have it in my collection. It will feature in my book when I eventually get
around to making it and there we go. That fundamentally is the difference between the
1864 and 1853 pattern, it's purely the guard, purely the protectiveness of the guard, the rest
of the construction of the 53 and the 64 are the same but the most important fact that I would like
to lay down in print or in video print is the fact that I strongly believe that the 1864 pattern
was never really rolled out to most regiments or perhaps not in enough numbers and we just don't
see many of them today so it is my strongly held belief based on written evidence, photographic
evidence and the number of antiques surviving that the and dated examples of the 1853 pattern with
1880s and 70s dates on them, it is my belief that the 1853 pattern remained the standard British
cavalry trooper's sword until the 1880s and some people will disagree with that but I'd like to see
their evidence to suggest that the 1864 pattern made it to many regiments and I'm always happy
to be corrected. Anyway I hope this has been interesting to some of you, I know it's very
specific and deep drilling into a minutiae of detail for British military swords but hopefully
it's interesting to some more of you as well anyway or gets you interested in this topic.
The two main books if you're if you want to learn more about British military swords are
Brian Robson's Swords of the British Army and Richard Deller's book which I believe is called
the British Cavalry Sword but in any case I will link both of these on Amazon below here
and thanks for watching give us a like and please subscribe if you haven't done already and click
that notification bell if you want to see more videos like this one see you really soon cheers
thanks for watching we've got extra videos on Patreon
please give our Facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
