Honshu Historic Forge 15th Century Italian Longsword Review

Rune Slicer
2 followers
26 Video Views·Feb 24, 2025
Today we take a look at a very interesting piece. This is the Honshu Historic Forge Italian Longsword. Formally known as the Balaur Arms Italian Longsword.
Welcome everyone to Unchie's Sword Reviews. I'm Vic. And I'm John. And today we're here to review
the Honshu Historic Forge 15th Century Italian Longsword made by OTC. Indeed. So this is a very
interesting sword because lots of people have taken a crack at it. This is Baylor Arms who is
Cult of Athena's house brand, essentially first run at this sword. As some of you may know,
Cult of Athena has a house brand called Baylor Arms, but they don't actually forge anything.
They just sort of hire out other forges to make their stuff. So they've done some work with
Windlass. They've done some work with Honshu Historic Forge. They're now working with LK Chen.
And so many of the swords that they make have several versions. This is one of those swords
that has several versions that's been made by several forges under the Baylor Arms name.
So this is the same sword that was made under the Baylor Arms name,
except now being marketed as the Honshu Historic Forge slash OTC 15th Century Italian Longsword.
Correct. And so you can find this sword on a couple of different websites here in the U.S.
and I think you can find it like overseas as well. And it's interesting, this sword,
before we actually start talking about what's in front of us, kind of got to dive into a little
bit of history here. So OTC, the forge that was originally contracted with Cult of Athena,
had a falling out with Cult of Athena over one, the steel quality was being misrepresented. It
was 1560 as opposed to 5160 as they were advertising. And there were some other
issues that Cult of Athena didn't say. I can speculate, but I'm not gonna. But anyway,
so they left. And since then, you've been able to find, they essentially took the designs and
the models that Cult of Athena had and just recreated them. They created a new company,
I guess, named Eric Steelcrafts, where they have all of the original Beller Arms models
and some newer ones that look very suspiciously similar to some other high-end swords. Cold Steel
popped out with a couple of swords that were originally going to be Beller Arms swords for
Cult of Athena. And now you can buy the Honshu Historic version. So the new company, Eric
Steelcrafts, is still the original forge OTC. And they have a really, really not positive
reputation online. Yeah, if you go to the SPG forum, if you go to Facebook, there's lots of
mention on him essentially doing shady business practices that we're not going to get into.
And the reason we decided to review this sword is because it is a product that's available.
Regardless of what you think about the shady business practices, regardless of what you think
about this company, it's a product that's available. And at $279, it is a very affordable
option. And I think you get a lot for the money. So I think it's worth talking about because
regardless, people are probably going to buy these swords. Agreed. Agreed. So yeah, and you
of course get to decide how you want to spend your money. And if you're the sort of person that
doesn't want to endorse a company by spending money on it, even if it's a good deal, I would
understand that for sure. But it is, again, like Vic said, it's a sword that's out there and we
wanted to review it so people would know what they're getting. And not just this specific
model, but there's lots of swords that they make in the historic forge line that look really good.
You know what I mean? There's the Gladius looks really good. There's some armor swords that look
really good. And so they're enticing for people that don't want to spend a thousand dollars on
the sword. Exactly. So all that said though, how did they do? $279 budget, like hard budget for
a medieval sword. What do you think fit and finish? For a hard budget sword, I think they
did really, really well. There are definitely complaints that I have about the fit and finish
on this sword. I think that the one complaint I have in particular that I think they should
have caught even at this price point is on the peen block. There's a fairly serious sort of
chunk out of it that you can get your thumb in. And it strikes me that that was a very serious
quality control miss that they probably should have caught and probably should have fixed.
But then again, can you catch everything like that at a $279 price point on this sword?
I'm hunching probably not. So, you know, with a few exceptions like that in general,
I have very few complaints about the fit and finish for this price point. I think it's excellent.
What do you think, Vic? Yeah, so I agree. The chip that's in the peen block, that's substantial
enough to me that if this were, say, a Cult of Athena sword, I would expect it to be like a
munitions grade or a blemish grade, something. I wouldn't expect it at full price for that.
See, blemished, I would say definitely because it's still functional. It's not going to impact
the use of the sword. It's not like a warped blade or something, which I feel like it would
be munitions grade. But yeah, no, I agree with you. It should be sold at a discount. It should
not be sold at the price of the sword. Right. However, the rest of the sword actually looks
pretty good, especially considering the price points. I think the grip is fairly well done.
The seam is pretty tight and straight. You really can't feel it that much. The central riser looks
really good. The cross guard and like the shapes of the fittings. So, this specific sword,
the Italian long sword that this is based off of, is loosely based off the Brescia Spadona.
It's a really, really famous sword in the museum in Brescia, Italy. Other makers make that sword.
Albion makes one. Lockwood makes one. Very, very high in stuff. So, like, the look of that sword
is pretty iconic. A lot of people in the community like it. So, again, why this is an enticing
option? Because you kind of get the aesthetic of that hilt in an affordable package. Right, exactly.
And in terms of that, I think it looks really good. I think the guard and the pommel are maybe
a little bit too big. Like, they don't have as much dimension and stuff as I would like,
but I would want that on a more expensive sword. Right. For this price point, I think it looks
really, really good. Agreed. And one thing I neglected to mention that I wanted to mention,
which is probably my favorite part about this sword, is the way that the blade looks.
Because it is a diamond cross section, but it's got a hollow grind on it that is just,
will knock your socks off. Right. Like, it catches the light. We'll show you some
video of moving it in the light. It catches the light beautifully.
It makes this deep sort of sinister whoosh when you swing it. It is a good looking blade. This
is a good looking blade if this was a $700 sword. Yeah. It's a great looking blade at $279. It
really blows my mind. So, I'll agree with you that the hollow grind and the look of the blade,
that's really good. And I would be fine with that if it were a $700 sword. I wouldn't be
fine with the super crazy secondary example. Agreed. Absolutely. Just the hollow grind.
Okay. My bad. Yeah. Just the hollow grind. But even with that, like, even if this were
a more expensive sword, I probably would be fine with it. Like, it's not that bad. Like,
the gap in the cross guard, it's big and, you know, it's not the most symmetrical, but again,
whatever. Like, sub 300 bucks, I am not going to harp on that too much. But to get a hollow grind
and like a really good looking hollow grind for under $300, like, that's what really makes this
sword stand out. You know what I mean? Agreed. And it just, it was a weird juxtaposition for
me that they have a sword with a hollow grind that's this good and that peen block that's
that bad. It was just like, one of these things is not like the other. You know what I mean? It
was kind of weird. Well, and that's part of that also plays into OTC's reputation. A huge part of
that reputation was quality control. This should have been caught, I think, personally. Yeah. And
it wasn't, or it was overlooked is my suspicion. My hunch is they're like,
good enough. Yeah, literally. Yeah, mediocrities, you know? But again, you're paying less than $300
US dollars. So what can you expect for that fit and finish? And like, I have seen personally,
so the quality control is one thing, but like the grip quality and all that is way better than I
would expect for this price point. I completely agree. It feels really good in the hand. It's
very well balanced. It's very quick. This is the sort of long sword that you hand to people.
If they've never held a long sword before, and they fall victim to the myth of, you know, Katana,
a car, an ass, long sword club, you know, that whole thing. You hand them this and they're like,
oh, okay, well, that's interesting. So yeah, no, it's a good representation of what a long
sword can feel like, I think. Agreed. And worth mentioning real quick that this sword was bought
at BDK, and you can also find it on True Swords if you want, if you live in the US.
Both of those sites have the weight listed at 2.65 pounds. This one came in, we weighed it on
our scale at three pounds, two ounces. So at least a half pound heavier than what they're
advertising. I don't know if they just made a revision and haven't updated the sites or
there's wild inconsistencies between the quality control. Not sure. On that note though, handling,
you said you could put this in the hand of somebody who thinks that medieval swords,
European swords are heavy crowbars. Yes. This is not the case with us, right? It is not the
case with this at all. So it's got a point of balance at about 2.9 inches out. We did not list
the distal taper on this, but we will link that in the description, but it's got a fairly
substantial distal taper. So it is very, very wieldable, very maneuverable. It feels really
excellent in the hand. I like it. I really, really like it a lot. Another person that we are friends
with that we've done some reviews with in the past, Kane Shen did a review where he talked about
the blade harmonics and where the vibration nodes are and pointed out quite accurately that
they're not perfect in this and that the vibration node is closer into the handle than it should be,
which again, for $279, that's going to, you know, you're going to have to make sacrifices like that.
This is not designed by Angus Trim, right? But yeah, I have no complaints about the handling
whatsoever. It is a very serviceable, very fun backyard cutter. And honestly, it's one of those
kinds of swords that does some of the work for you. It actually makes you feel a little bit better
than you are. And I think in general, 18Bs tend to feel that way to me. And I think this is a good
representation of an 18B in that way. What do you think, Vic? I agree with pretty much everything
you said. Yeah. The center of percussion being lower than it should be is something you kind
of only will notice if you've handled swords that have correct center of percussions. So going back
to our whole putting this in the hand of someone who's never swung a sword before, they're not
going to notice that. They're just going to think it's an agile, lively sword that can move and has
authority to it. The blade maintains a really, really good width up at the foible, which really
helps you in cutting. Like this is the kind of sword that you could really just throw forward
and it will do the work for you. It's actually a really good cutter. And like for the budget price,
for a budget backyard cutter, like holy crap, this is fun. It's easy to wield in one hand,
two hand. You could do all kinds of different cuts with it. It's sharp as hell. Again, ugly
secondary bevel. Not a historic though in some cases, but sharp, like really sharp. Sharp out
the box to do whatever you want with it. 100% agree. And again, I find myself almost being too
harsh with this sword because it's so good that I start comparing it to mid-range swords. Right.
And then I realized, wait a minute, but no, it only costs $279. Right. So I think that's, it
almost tricks me into being harsher on it than I ought to be. So, but no, I, yeah, it handled
beautifully. It's yeah. Another quick thing, and this is going back to the aesthetics of the sword
is the central Ridge really kind of waivers to the right at the tip and is nowhere near centered.
Um, again, that's an aesthetic thing. I don't think that affects the sword very much. And you
expect some, even in high-end swords, there's not perfect symmetry and perfect crispness in lines,
but this is really like off to the, off to the right. This is if it was an Albion, you'd send
it back. Yes, for sure. However, it is not an Albion. It's not an Albion, nor is it claimed
to be, nor is it priced as such. So yeah. So on that note, $279. I can't recommend this sort
enough, which it concerns me somewhat because of the sort of gray area that it's in as regards
intellectual property. Um, I'm not, I'm not well-versed enough on it to know for sure,
but I know there is, there is, there's a little bit of a smell test issue here.
Um, so that concerns me, but I think, you know, if you are looking to get into collecting swords
and you have a choice between this and a $200 Katana, there's just absolutely no, no,
no decision in my mind. You should get this. Like this is a really, really, really good sword. It
feels like it's firmly in the middle of the mid range. I can't like, it's a great, it's a great
value. Even with the quality control issues that it has, even with, you know, some of the issues
in terms of fit and finish, I I'd say go for it. I think it's worth rolling it ice. Yeah, I agree.
Um, if you are in the budget range and you want a nice long sword that looks good, that has
striking features to it, and that handles really well and is fun, I'd be hard pressed to find a
better sub $300 option. Yeah. You know what I mean? Like comparing it to 200 Katanas, $200 Katanas,
that's a fair comparison. But if you're the kind of person that doesn't want a Katana,
you want a long sword, it's harder to get something that good quality. That's a solid
This, however, is really, really fun and will do the work for you in a way that like more expensive
swords sometimes don't even in the same typology. So issues aside, I think it's worth checking out.
Um, and when, when I was making that comparison to a $200 Katana, my point was that if you're
just looking for a functional backyard cutter of any type that you can go hang out with your
friends, drink some beers and cut things in half with, um, I think this is at the top of the pile
range. That makes more sense. That's kind of what I'm, what I meant to say. So, but, um, yeah,
in general, I can't recommend it enough. I think it's a very, very good price at this price point.
And you know, if you just turn off all the worrying about anything that might be nefarious
about their business practices, it's, it's a great deal. Oh, also should be mentioned comes with a
scabbard too. $279. I'd have been happy with that, but this is actually not a bad scabbard. It really
is not a bad scabbard at all. I think it's much nicer than you would expect it to have, like you
would expect it to have. Um, it's got a stainless steel shape at the bottom or at least, at least
chromed anyway. I don't know if it's stainless or what it is, but it doesn't rust and it won't
take bluing. I can tell you that much. Sounds like he's tried. So, uh, yeah. Um, in general,
it's, it's a nice scabbard. It's got rain flaps or, you know, it's really nice. It's, it's again,
nicer than it needs to be for this price point. Oh, great. At $279, I'll be fine with just the
sword, but like that's, or a cheap leather flimsy sheath and a good, good scabbard. So yeah,
I think it's worth it. I can't recommend it enough. Go check it out. Links in the description.
Yeah. So we want to say thank you very much for watching. Um, if you enjoyed this video,
you would like to subscribe. We would very much appreciate that. Also, uh, if you stay tuned to
the channel, there are some videos coming up that might interest you, especially if you found this
one interesting, there's going to be a comparison between this and a very similar sword and some
discussions about the pros and cons, as well as some reviews of, uh, some interesting and
popular arming swords that are hot in the market right now. So, uh, please hit the subscribe
button so you don't miss any of that. And thank you very much for watching. Peace.
